sportsman!!

salutations sir!!!

Quote:


that was sarcasm in response to dan, pointing out "oh hey here's a trait of someone else on the forum, does that make me them??" to highlight the flaw in Sir Danskiy's logic.

ALSO, your reads thus far?

that's all I got for you for now, thanks!!!!! <3

John

In 1st 10 posts, John shares his opinion on YS role situation. He also provided reasoning about certain situations, but nothing that would indicate what he thinks of others (with exception of saying Leone might be jester). He also hasn't done any scumhunting.

johnboy81918 wrote on 08/22/17 at 18:03:15:


This is where he mentions a lynch for the 1st time. He is not calling for it, but this is a 1st mention of something useful.

Then more talk with Dan about YS role and Leone and then this:

johnboy81918 wrote on 08/22/17 at 18:49:55:


This time having a more clear attitude on Leone lynch

johnboy81918 wrote on 08/22/17 at 19:13:56:


Finally some opinions about other players then Leone and asking some questions.

Then comes another post about Dan and Leone, asking Leone about PAF vote.

and then he posted a list and that is the action which i always support 137

Nothing unusual except 1 error:

johnboy81918 wrote on 08/22/17 at 20:42:06:


Orange never voted for TvK. Could be a mistake, hard to tell.

Then he goes to sleep.

The 2nd day (real life) he started with answering some questions and stating some opinions 207

johnboy81918 wrote on 08/23/17 at 10:49:16:


I agree on that one.

He is making himself present, but except a few good posts, didn't do too much scumhunting. I consider that list he made his best post. I have nothing solid to believe he is scum at this point.

Btw i'll make 1 post with all my short reads once i'm done with my analysis of each player. This will be no later then 6-7 hours before eod.

Quote:


Paf sir, why wouldnt he go for an immediate busing strat?!?!?! worked last game!!!!1 Also yeah his arguments do kinda look sheeped from others, but again the logic follows... eh, what's yer read on 'im??

nvm paf you said your read on 'im in the quote i quoted

im a retard, gg selves

Sportsguy001 wrote on 08/23/17 at 14:31:16:


Normally I would agree that high postcount is most of the times an indicator for Town, however 90% of his posts were "jesterhunting"(or call it whatever u want)if anything so I will not accept this argument for him this game.

@sportsd00d

yeah that's a weak/scummy argument to make even if you've not read a whole lot, TvK and Timur both pulled off high-post maf games and Dan would know high-posters look more inno, perhaps yet ANOTHER potential goal could be inflating his count by tunneling me??????

also why do you disagree so strongly with dan's conviction that me=jester?? elaboration would be nice, sire!!!!!

Leone wrote on 08/23/17 at 14:44:33:


I said "in general" higher posters are town.  I'm not giving anyone an all clear day 1.  

Not sure i really disagree that you are JESTER per se. Just that you probably would have changed your posting after he went on the tangent of you being 100 percent being YS JESTER if you really were.  You haven't changed anything about your posting.  I made a comment earlier somewhat about this. If that makes sense.

Fine, Leone. I can see your point. You may actually be scumhunting, but you're doing it such as you're actually finding details which may look like contradictions but likely aren't. I referenced how TvK seemed to scum hunt hard in previous games when he was actually trying to frame noobs such as myself. (and the way you ask it makes it even more annoying).
But eh, you may actually be legit. I can't see you scum with Dan, and there's no 2nd maf group in this game. You're still really confusing to me, though.

Ya know, I can try to contribute while having TvK/Zoran suspect of me, it's not like I have a choice anyway. You're saying I'm not scum hunting? It's true, I don't ask question as much as those previous two, I can't think of which questions to ask so easily. But that's not the only thing a townie can do ya know?

I'm actually at a mario kart tourney in NY right now and haven't read most of the thread today. I do want to point out again that I think Leone is much more likely angel than jester.

Trying to read back a bit now before the karting starts. Zoran I think John can be forgiven for thinking Orange voted TvK considering Orange opened up with a post hard on TvK.

P.A.F.625 wrote on 08/23/17 at 13:27:14:


One of the things about Leone that I considered and brought up very early is that he might have some kind of posting restriction due to not ending literally a single sentence with a solitary period. After I brought this up, he continued posting in that confusing way but made a point to end some sentences with solitary periods, as if to show he didn't have such a restriction and that his confusing posts were just being made because he was choosing to. I do believe that this behavior is indicative of someone trying to get themselves lynched.

Timur #248:
Zwiebel wrote on 08/23/17 at 12:05:37:

Why do town and maf both want to get rid of the jester? Nobody wants to kill him during the day to give him his win (in any event, town would rather lynch scum, scum would rather lead town to a mislynch of a townie). And if the jester's identity is known who will waste a night kill on him? Any townie with a night kill (if we even have one) would be better off hunting scum. By the same token, scum would rather kill a townie.

I've never played with a jester role before, so I'm curious what I'm missing?

P.A.F.625 wrote on 08/23/17 at 15:04:13:


Because I didn't see it in the rules and in my experience, about 85% of all mafia games have only 2 factions without any other roles.