J-Cop wrote on 05/31/16 at 23:17:38:

I think it's possible Darius just said that for town cred, but I'm not sure because that's a very risky play for a mafia member to make if it's against a fellow mafia.

At this point there are four possible role combinations for Zarkov/Sam/Racer.  In what light do people's EoD actions make the most sense?

Zarkov - mafia
Sam F - town
Racer - town (to me this makes the most sense given what happened at the end of the day)

Zarkov - town
Sam F - town
Racer - town (can anyone make a reasonable case for this scenario?  I feel like the jump on Racer at the end of the day and the ensuing chaos makes this unlikely, as does the fact that the Zarkov wagon by Shock didn't gain any initial traction)

Zarkov - town
Sam F - mafia
Racer - town (again I think this scenario is unlikely because of the fact that the Zarkov wagon by Shock didn't gain any initial traction and that all the craziness only happened once it did)

Zarkov - mafia
Sam F - mafia
Racer - town (I think it's unlikely because of the way Zarkov has been treating Sam)

Does anyone debate that if we lynched Zarkov and he turned up mafia that it would pretty much clear Yoshistar and cast a very suspicious light on people like Kyle?

This post looks bad to me:

Honko wrote on 05/31/16 at 20:39:21:

The "let's lynch Yoshitstar instead" part sounds scummy.  Why not lynch Sam?  Why not lynch Zarkov?  They've both looked bad throughout the entire game.  What reason do you have for not wanting one of them dead?  You even said yourself that they both look scummy.   I understand that other players may also look like worthy lynches, but why talk people out of lynching Sam or Zarkov?



Zoran's reply sums up my thoughts pretty well:
no control wrote on 05/31/16 at 23:08:15:

Particularly the highlighted part.  Why don't you trust the lynches?

My first suspect to who I think is a mafia

Bradon's Case

Bradon wrote on 05/28/16 at 18:18:53:


I'm not sure whether he's just pissing around in this one or if there's a secret message hidden if you analyse it with a keen eye. Firstly, in the post he's quoting it says Lapungos, which is supposed to be Lafungo (well obviously). Then in his quote he replies by voting "Laugh-on-go", which to me is suggesting that him and Lafungo are both mafia as they are having a good "Laugh-on" at watching us fellow town's trying to figure out who is a scum and who isn't. What's even more curious is that straight after he voted for Lafungo in that post he unvotes him

Bradon wrote on 05/28/16 at 18:19:40:


I believe that this is because he knows that Lafungo is mafia, (as all mafia know who each of them are) and voted for him as a joke then unvoted as he didn't want him to actually get lynched


Please not that this may not be accurate now as all evidence I have gathered was from page 6

DansGame wrote on 05/31/16 at 16:22:39:


My problem with your vote is the timing. It was perfect. You gave an explanation, but still.

I'm playing a scenario here that you are mafia. If that is the case, i assume that you were here all the time and your story is made up. in that scenario you vote for random because as mafia, you would be aware of the situation. I know it is a small time window, but good mafia would be ready for this. And you are a good player.

At this point you have to jump somewhere. If sam f and racer are both town, your jump on racer is the last nail and you will for 100% be a suspect.

If you put it to random with sam vote there is a 50% chance sam will be lynched and you are a suspect then. This is where i get my 50% chance of you being a suspect.

I would like to repeat that this is a scenario in my head, nothing more.

Orange Slices wrote on 06/01/16 at 00:49:17:


Reading a bit too deep into that, if you look further there may be something on brandon though

J-Cop wrote on 05/31/16 at 23:49:41:

So I brought up a post of yours and all of a sudden you decide to vote on me? And you explain this after you've been asked why? This makes me think you're staying low to not draw attention, until someone says you look scummy and goes defensive by voting on that person who accused him.

no control wrote on 06/01/16 at 01:08:56:

I mean if I really needed to I could probably prove that I was at a Memorial Day parade - I'm the assistant band director and at around 10:20 Eastern the marching band I teach started marching the parade and ended around 11:40 or so. It was a total shock to me when I jumped in right after that that the choice was between Racer and Sam suddenly and if you look at the timing of my posts you can understand why I got the 40 seconds error message.

Anyway did you read my long post about what a Zarkov mafia Sam town situation would mean? Can you and more people go back and read that? I want to hear more people discuss my Zarkov - mafia Sam - town theory.

Orange Slices wrote on 06/01/16 at 03:39:04:


Wasn't Racer talking in the Mafia perspective? Or am I just missing something here?

Off topic, but nice new Mafia section. The description is accurate  

Case #3

Suspect - Sam F

Reason: Suspiciously low post count and exaggerative behaviour

Evidence

TvK wrote on 05/30/16 at 04:08:30:


First off, he doesn't put any thought into why I made the joke in the post he's referring to

Yoshistar™ wrote on 05/30/16 at 03:58:06:


Orange Slices wrote on 05/30/16 at 04:01:30:



He's just being plain rude. Especially seeing that he didn't mind the "Lafluffgo" and "Laugh-on-go" jokes.

He also states that what I am doing is "not town behaviour", probably assuming that it will make others think that I'm a maf, when it is evident that I am not.

Oh hey, it's Sam not responding to me. I'll repeat: what about those posts of Shock's you listed made you think Shock was cop and not just town?

Orange: your Kyle case is a case on Racer, who is already dead. Can you try to read a little more closely?

Darius wrote on 06/01/16 at 04:06:08:


The fact that he was breaking down every small detail, far more than the others which makes the impression that he was Cop to me, and I have no idea why Shock would lie being a cop if he was a Town Vanilla, that could make him look real scummy if someone else claimed Cop. I don't agree with revealing  that early, but you know it was his decision.

Orange Slices wrote on 06/01/16 at 04:03:17:

Don't vote who has the most votes. Vote who you think is more likely to be scum.

Orange Slices wrote on 06/01/16 at 04:03:17:


That is just really, really poor reasoning.

What do you think of the wagons being tied yesterday?

&b wrote on 06/01/16 at 04:12:16:


Okie dokie. I'll check into Zarkov and see why 3 people have voted for him. At the end of the day, my vote comes down to how obvious it is that that person is maf. It doesn't necesarily mean that my final vote is you