Robertvz wrote on 05/16/16 at 04:06:49:


I would feel a lot better if we had an know system we agreed on rather then everyone having their own interpretation. I mean when a person can speak, a lot can be interpreted wrong.

And how is finding a better way to talk with a blackmailed person not an issue?

We still have time, we should cover everything.

Again what is the downside of this system and what is a downside of having a system like that?. This won't hurt town, it can only help. It is pretty clear and we don't need a lot of discussion about it.

no control wrote on 05/16/16 at 04:21:53:


It's a non issue because it's something that can be thought up on the spur of the moment, if a person wants to say yes, they can vote themselves. If a person wants to say no, they can vote no lynch. Regardless of who dies at night, the person being spoken to and no lynch option are always in play so yeah. Nothing's gonna be perfect but if we can set up a simple yes/no and a way to see if a person wants to out night info that's good enough for me.

Awake and re-reading. That Walter post is abysmal. After missing 75% of the game so far there's no summary of the game so far, no leads, just "oh hey guys, looks like there's two choices so I'll pick the one that has more votes".

I still feel most confident in my current Yoshistar vote. He has been more responsive than J-Cop when the pressure has been put on him, though that may have more to do with his wagon having more votes than J-Cop's than alignment.

and I agree with Brett on eoJ's status. It doesn't make sense to lynch him when his claim could be verified. If we could grab a cleared town early in the game that would be helpful to draw mafia actions as well as learn information about posters.

So I also wouldn't vote eoJ today, I could be convinced to move to J-Cop if his wagon gets more traction but for now I'm sticking with my vote.

It does contribute to town. It's just not something you're naturally gonna get 100% of people to agree with and it's better to just do it when the time comes.

Also if 2 people on Yoshistar switch to J-Cop that forces a tie. Jon hasn't even been responsive to pressure, I think he's just given up.

Joe if you read this I have no idea how you can go through the whole day 1 and never place a vote down.

Zoran's posts so far are good, he's always questioning members on their statements (especially the definitive "this member is 100% town/mafia" ones), which shows me he doesn't want to sit back and accept others' opinions without digging for his own like others have this game.  

Also Zoran I do like your blackmailed code proposal but I don't see why we can't come up with something after the N1 events, it just seems like jumping the gun a bit. We don't know who is getting blackmailed yet so why not just discuss it fully once we know exactly who is blackmailed?

I think we should certainly discuss other suspects before D2 though.

LewisRichards wrote on 05/16/16 at 04:30:19:


It's becoming more and more likely that this is the case. But what do you make of the Walter vote? If YS gets lynched and flips mafia like you think, would that make Walter more likely to be town or mafia?

Putting the pressure on J-Cop would be interesting. I could switch if you guys want me to, but I still feel like YS is a good lynch.

Day ends in: 4 hours, 7 minutes (Immediately if/when vote majority is reached)
12 Effective Votes on one player (or No Lynch) for majority. Note that the votes shown here are total player votes, not necessarily equal to the total number of effective votes.

Updated to Reply #715
(This takes some time to figure out, so stuff has probably changed.... figure out the changes! Also, the program might be bugged, so please PM me if you see a mistake in your vote.)

0 - Timothy
9 - Yoshistar (TvK, Sam F, thewebinator, Racer727, J-Cop, Walter, DBMK64, theyounggun, Vinnie927)
5 - J-Cop (ALAKTORN, Brett, sportsguy001, Locky, fank009)
0 - TvK
0 - sportsguy001
0 - ALAKTORN
0 - Brett
0 - Vinnie927
0 - ラサヤ Ζα€
0 - Zarkov
0 - thewebinator
0 - Racer727
0 - Locky
0 - fank009
0 - Sam F
0 - no control
0 - DBMK64
0 - kyleb30
0 - theyounggun
2 - Walter (Yoshistar, no control)
0 - Lafungo
3 - eoJ (Zarkov, Zac, Timothy)
0 - No Lynch

Not Voting 3 – (eoJ, Lafungo, kyleb30)
Not Posting – N/A

Please make sure your vote was recorded accurately, at least up to the reply listed. I don't trust myself or the .cgi program 100%

Locky wrote on 05/16/16 at 04:55:29:


Ending it 4 hours early isn't too bad, it's 12+ where it gets to be troublesome.

no control wrote on 05/16/16 at 04:42:37:


I'm perfectly fine with whatever will be agreed on. Your proposal looks good to me.

It's an ok proposal, so how about if you want to talk to a blackmailed person you can use your own system and I'll do whatever I feel like works best for me? Let's agree to disagree here?