ALAKTORN wrote on 05/15/16 at 04:34:59:Shock wrote on 05/14/16 at 20:24:58:- As indicated in the role PMs in the OPs, Mafia may only post on their forum during Night phases. Otherwise, they may only view their forum.
Doesn’t this confirm that the claims of “mafia would’ve shut Vinnie up” are without foundation? If they can’t post in the forum until the day is over, how would they shut him up?
Yes, this was a mistake on my part. I assumed mafia could discuss during the day, I've never played in a game where mafia could only talk privately at night. While it does invalidate the argument I used in my last post, I still find it unlikely that Vinnie is mafia at this point, because it's unusual for a newbie to post so much as mafia.
As for lynching Vinnie to get info on Brett, that's a bad idea considering there are much better ways to get info on Brett given this game's setup.
ALAKTORN wrote on 05/15/16 at 04:34:59:Also I was thinking– if we lynch someone on day 1, that would mean they won’t get to act at night, right…? And this game is filled with power roles. I can see no lynching being a good idea to let the night play out, since town doesn’t have a single vanilla going by the mod’s posts (neither does mafia I guess). At first I thought lynching every day would be simple game theory, but I wasn’t thinking about roles. With these many roles I don’t see why not lynching is as bad of an idea as others have made it out to be.
Because the game is filled with power roles, it doesn't matter as much if one of them gets lynched D1. The information gained from a lynch, combined with the possibility of hitting a mafia, is more valuable than potentially losing a town power role.
ALAKTORN wrote on 05/15/16 at 04:34:59:Fank hasn’t really done anything to clear my suspicion of him yet.
Why is Fank suspicious?
LewisRichards wrote on 05/15/16 at 05:11:42:Hey, I'm online quick before I go to chess. There still seems to be that negative vibe going towards me, but I'm pretty sure that I have already explained my innocence decently well in that I saw a lot of people making random accusations because it was funny, so I did the same. I litterally said in the same post that there was a high chance of a mislynch... the "obviously fucking mafia" thing just sounded funny to me lol and I picked Vinnie because he seemed the most like mafia to me. I'm not sure about him now.
On the one hand, you're saying that your first post was a "random accusation", but on the other you're saying Vinnie "seemed the most mafia". Which one was it?
LewisRichards wrote on 05/15/16 at 05:24:04:Sportsguy was giving me a large mafia vibe too. Judging by his posts it seems like he and Brett could be in together, although I haven't gotten a strong mafia vibe from Brett yet.
Why do you think Sportsguy and Brett "could be in together"?
Pages: 
