LewisRichards wrote on 05/14/16 at 18:10:32:

Locky wrote on 05/14/16 at 18:16:01:

Brett is taking a leadership role, which I feel could be coming from a mafia.
Web is a "terrible scum" according to Brett, and I agree with him. Due for reconsideration if Brett is actually mafia
Fank is always confusing to read, but that's his strategy. I've never played with him, but I felt like if I targeted him, his reaction would have cleared up any questions I had about him. I was wrong, so I'm leaving him for later reconsideration.
Dan is probably town, because he targeted me first. It makes sense, because my prior reputation had seemed a little naive (at least from the way I read the situation). I've now realized it's pointless to pursue any connections between him and Brett
Kyle is similar to Locky in that they're both exhibiting similar types of behaviour. I haven't been attempting to read him, but he's probably town.
I felt Locky is a mafia for the same reason he claims Kyle is a mafia. But I don't want to get rid of a helpful town, either. Locky could be making himself important so that others would be hesitant to lynch him.
no control is inexperienced, that is all. Daniel nailed him early on.
tyg might be an inexperienced mafia, from the way he seemed eager that I had dug myself into a deep hole.
I forgot eoj, Lafungo and Yoshistar were playing, I recommend that people use their night abilities on them.
Zac doesn't seem to understand the game very well. This could be a wise strategy, or mafia could be telling him to be quiet in the chat.
Racer seems to be pretty good, but he is pretty quiet as well. Could fall under the same category as Zac.
ALAKTORN, Zarkov, Sportsguy, Timothy, J-Cop, Walter and Sam F haven't done anything noteworthy.

Vinnie plz, I've always been eager on this forum. You don't even want to look at my posts on this forum from when I started....... *shivers*

I skimmed over those parts, I'll go reread them

Probably going to sleep, thanks for the discussion everyone that was around. Feel like it was very largely town. More people need to get discussing though.

Robertvz wrote on 05/14/16 at 18:43:39:

I agree, I got targeted for trying to carry the discussion

Vinnie927 wrote on 05/14/16 at 18:45:18:

You got targeted for coming up with some really far-fetched posts with not much analysis behind them, not for carrying the discussion.

Some of the strongest players are the most quiet so far which will hopefully reverse tomorrow, but I would be interested in hearing some reads from the players who have posted a few times but haven't said too much (like eoJ or ALAKTORN)

But if you say that, then mafia know not to kill Brett so that he becomes a target

Vinnie927 wrote on 05/14/16 at 18:55:20:


I was going to add this to my "book" but it's too tempting to discuss it now.

Brett is a strong game solvey player. they have two options. 1) keep him alive to lynch. 2) kill him early game.
If they keep him alive, he'll likely get town in a situation where they can solve the game. so there's that dilema

Fank, Sportsguy, Brett, and Locky are the best players, and are therefore the biggest targets. If one of them is killed, we can assume that the mafia are inexperienced players who are just killing the players that intimidate them.

Quick post before I go to bed.

Vinnie, Zac, and Racer look like deadweights to me. Vinnie seems town though, because I'd expect his mafia buddies to have shut him up by now if he were scum.

Town lean on Dan and Zoran.

I don't like Sportsguy's first post.

I'd like to know why Locky voted Timothy.

J-Cop should have been back by now, I want to hear from him.

I'd be disappointed if fank and/or Brett dies early, it would make the game a lot less interesting.

Read over and thoughts.

I don't know how to describe the start of the game? how do you describe people wanting to no lnych in a way that is not offensive?

Just seems to be poor thinking (or lack of experience) that results in these logical fallacies.

Vinnie for sure is the king of logical fallacies (first 2 shot down by brett already)
Vinnie927 wrote on 05/14/16 at 12:19:53:

Vinnie927 wrote on 05/14/16 at 12:31:59:

Vinnie927 wrote on 05/14/16 at 12:38:40:

If this was the only "???" post by Vinnie, I'd say this is a tier 1 maf play. (OK, you think I'm scum? You think fank's scum as well let's go for him)

Vinnie927 wrote on 05/14/16 at 18:29:52:

-Fank is Always confusing to read
-Never played with the guy
Granted I've had a few posts, but the first post indicates you at least know my posting style, (which would lead to a conflict of point no. 2

Vinnie's definetly coming off as somone who is at best confused when looking at it in some deep thoughts. Doesn't mean he's misdirecting, probably more going in the wrong direction. I somewhat don't like the idea that Vinnie's been picking up a bit of steam for these logical fallacies, and it makes me lean towards him being town.

He has so many "Ugh" moments though :/
Vinnie927 wrote on 05/14/16 at 17:57:59:

(While I was posting...)
Vinnie927 wrote on 05/14/16 at 18:45:18:

Vinnie927 wrote on 05/14/16 at 19:04:24:

I'm not going to, I'm not going to. I'll just leave it here.

There's a huge problem I have with vinnie and thats every 2nd post when reread in conjunction with other posts feels like it contains TMI


Brett's been having a good hardworking game as per usual.
Robertvz wrote on 05/14/16 at 18:16:39:

his content has been more or less on point as per usual, nothing indicative he has scum motives and worth to keep around for now.



LewisRichards wrote on 05/14/16 at 17:34:54:


This is a horrible post I've seen a lot of emotional maf in my time and I feel this is one of those moves, even if it was renegged, it doesn't put the genie in the bottle and it's posts like these that should die by fire.
LewisRichards wrote on 05/14/16 at 19:03:17:

more bad posts by TYG. This feels like either "guess you'll wonder" or its setting up to be a trap.
Did TYG get good at mafia over the past X amount of moons???


Racer727 wrote on 05/14/16 at 12:28:33:

Can we kill it with fire?
Racer727 wrote on 05/14/16 at 13:39:41:

Can we PLEASE kill it with fire???


No control
I think in my first post, there's something about him that strikes my eye, this may be his first game (here) but the "aura" I sense from him he's no slouch to mafia. Those tricks though I'll definetly be watching throughout the game.



Sportsguy001 wrote on 05/14/16 at 18:52:07:


I feel like thats been a thing in this game, where everyone states that they are suspicous of a person and then not really back anything up with their statements.
DBMK64's first post though...
DansGame wrote on 05/14/16 at 11:47:59:

Um, it feels so patronizing. it feels like something maf will come up with after the end of the night, and the fact the no lynch vote doesn't help anything.


Nothing else worthy of being in the book at this stage I feel.

Lafungo wrote on 05/14/16 at 19:10:40:


Was just a vote on an inactive in an attempt to pressure then but Brett pointed out how he'd probably be asleep given his time zone so lol me