Mario Kart MB - TIME TO DEBATE

Hugo

Legend

Offline

3670 days karting
France
Gender: male

TIME TO DEBATE
11/22/15 at 04:58:40

Until now, ERWAN.s wasn't a problem, when we discovered him, he only had an european top 10 on TC... But he quickly managed to improve most of his times and even get a WW top 10 on TC, while unveiling another one on rLR. After showing a 1'59"849 on RRM, he eventually improved it to reach the WR. There have been some questions, but we finally accepted each of his PRs, including his WR.

But today, he finally joined the french TT site, mktrial. We finally discovered his full timesheet (http://mktrial.fr/stats.php?m=2790) but not only: a few minutes later, someone called "Esteban R." also joined the site, submitting times like 1'13"154 on rRR as you can see here: http://mktrial.fr/stats.php?m=2791

After asking proofs, he told us he was ERWAN.s' friend. Possible, but really doubtful.

That's why I'd like to hear your opinions, since I own the european and french top 10's threads.

Back to top

IP Logged

Dos Santos Ex Member	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #1 - 11/22/15 at 05:20:50 well then he's about to prove he's some dirty cheater needing to be banned unless he miraculously owns a capture card and streams ????? or live with hands like most people do when they feel like proving their potential
Back to top	IP Logged

Hugo Legend Offline 3670 days karting France Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #2 - 11/22/15 at 05:28:58 How could we know if Esteban isn't Erwan and if Erwan isn't somebody else? And should they be legit?
Back to top	IP Logged

Samuel

King

Offline

All my friends are
dead.

fell 3717 times for marty
Atlanta, Georgia
Gender: male

Re: TIME TO DEBATE
Reply #3 - 11/22/15 at 05:50:42

Hugo wrote on 11/22/15 at 04:58:40:

But today, he finally joined the french TT site, mktrial. We finally discovered his full timesheet (http://mktrial.fr/stats.php?m=2790) but not only: a few minutes later, someone called "Esteban R." also joined the site, submitting times like 1'13"154 on rRR as you can see here: http://mktrial.fr/stats.php?m=2791

After asking proofs, he told us he was ERWAN.s' friend. Possible, but really doubtful.

That's why I'd like to hear your opinions, since I own the european and french top 10's threads.

I have many opinions and questions about "Erwan s.", but I'm just going to try to keep it factual. Although idk if you have to have proof to join mktrials, but if everyone else does, then Esteban should have to show proof no matter whose friend he is. Until such time, don't allow him on that site and certainly not on the French + European top 10s of this site. I think Erwan should be allowed however, he has Miiverse and video proof, which is more than many people can say for themselves, and although he is suspicious and I don't feel right about him, that's not a reason to count him as a cheater. I might change my opinion given how this situation progresses...

Back to top

My Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC__pSKc-FkNiRdN_I9A0Swg
MK7 WR Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLyR_OwCutT9INmnjGSisLUd5BpzE1hbLK

IP Logged

Frederiek

Legend

Offline

Revenge of the
Goomba. No more
jumping on my head!

3964 sex records
Belgium
Gender: male

Re: TIME TO DEBATE
Reply #4 - 11/22/15 at 09:30:55

If you want my opinion:

If someone has doubts about your times, it's in your own interest to prove them. The easiest way is by making a timescroll. I don't think Erwan is a cheater. But he would be more appreciated if he made a timescroll too.
I don't know Esteban. He should definitely prove all his times. If you doubt that Esteban could be Erwan, you can ask them to identify themselves. I'm not in favour of making their identities public, but they could show/send them in private to someone who is trusted in the community. This is also an opportunity to find out if Erwan is or is not an alt after all. Timescrolls should be public.
And does Erwan say he knows Esteban?

Back to top

Use this tool for MK7 time submissions:

http://www.mariokart64.com/mk7/submit

IP Logged

Hugo

Legend

Offline

3670 days karting
France
Gender: male

Re: TIME TO DEBATE
Reply #5 - 11/22/15 at 09:37:11

Frederiek wrote on 11/22/15 at 09:30:55:

If you want my opinion:

If someone has doubts about your times, it's in your own interest to prove them. The easiest way is by making a timescroll. I don't think Erwan is a cheater. But he would be more appreciated if he made a timescroll too.
I don't know Esteban. He should definitely prove all his times. If you doubt that Esteban could be Erwan, you can ask them to identify themselves. I'm not in favour of making their identities public, but they could show/send them in private to someone who is trusted in the community. This is also an opportunity to find out if Erwan is or is not an alt after all. Timescrolls should be public.
And does Erwan say he knows Esteban?

Yeah, good ideas. And nope, we didn't ask Erwan yet

Back to top

IP Logged

Zepple King Offline rMG4life 4596 sex records France Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #6 - 11/22/15 at 10:12:10 What does a timescrool prove though? Nothing says he hasn't cheated by any possible way to get the times shown on the 3DS. Imo, a live run would be better.
Back to top	#19 MK7 IP Logged

Karmakas Elite Offline missed 3861 mts France Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #7 - 11/22/15 at 11:54:27 This is the end...
Back to top	IP Logged

WillD King Offline TrackMania, F-Zero, and Mario Kart. 4853 days karting Virginia, USA Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #8 - 11/22/15 at 20:32:38 The 1'13"154 on rRR isn't showing up on his profile anymore. He does have a 1'50"960 on rDDJ listed, which would be 9th worldwide.
Back to top	WR History Updater \| Former rDDD WR AlexPenev wrote on 08/08/12 at 03:51:30: Did you try doing a mini turbo? That could change everything. IP Logged

Zepple King Offline rMG4life drank 4596 beers France Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #9 - 11/24/15 at 11:04:01 As he isn't proving his times, I have to keep deleting them on the French site, so you won't see them.
Back to top	#19 MK7 IP Logged

WillD King Offline TrackMania, F-Zero, and Mario Kart. 4853 sex records Virginia, USA Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #10 - 11/24/15 at 13:11:05 Zepple wrote on 11/24/15 at 11:04:01: As he isn't proving his times, I have to keep deleting them on the French site, so you won't see them. Can you ask Erwan to prove his 1:12.000 rBC1 No-Glitch?
Back to top	WR History Updater \| Former rDDD WR AlexPenev wrote on 08/08/12 at 03:51:30: Did you try doing a mini turbo? That could change everything. IP Logged

Hugo Legend Offline 3670 days karting France Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #11 - 11/25/15 at 05:20:05 WillD wrote on 11/24/15 at 13:11:05: Zepple wrote on 11/24/15 at 11:04:01: As he isn't proving his times, I have to keep deleting them on the French site, so you won't see them. Can you ask Erwan to prove his 1:12.000 rBC1 No-Glitch? That was maybe a typo, if you don't enter the thousandths your time appears as a .000
Back to top	IP Logged

Zepple King Offline rMG4life 4596 holabolas France Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #12 - 11/26/15 at 09:55:20 Maybe yes, I asked him for a proof anyway.
Back to top	#19 MK7 IP Logged

Hugo Legend Offline 3670 days karting France Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #13 - 11/28/15 at 05:27:08 https://miiverse.nintendo.net/replies/AYQHAAABAACNUKFLrvqz5g Which means Esteban R. is a fake EDIT: https://miiverse.nintendo.net/posts/AYQHAAABAAAtVHhocZbsfQ he says he's gonna play WWs, I guess it'll prove he doesn't TAAAAAS
Back to top	« Last Edit: 11/28/15 at 09:24:43 by Hugo » IP Logged

WillD King Offline TrackMania, F-Zero, and Mario Kart. drank 4853 beers Virginia, USA Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #14 - 11/28/15 at 11:53:48 In that case, I'm removing Esteban R.'s rDDJ time from the Pending list of times. Good to see Erwan is finally playing online!
Back to top	WR History Updater \| Former rDDD WR AlexPenev wrote on 08/08/12 at 03:51:30: Did you try doing a mini turbo? That could change everything. IP Logged

Raγ

King

Offline

fell 4409 times for marty
NL, Canada
Gender: male

Re: TIME TO DEBATE
Reply #15 - 12/27/15 at 07:00:01

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUtoudSVWEpx8gCHDRK6zxA

Sorry for bumping, just figured I'd leave this here in case no one knows about it. The channel was made Dec 2013 and it has some MK7 vids on it from the same month and year with him giving commentary, so imo it's safe to say that he's been around for a while and he's most likely not an alt. Just felt like clearing up any suspicions that may still be around Tongue

Back to top

IP Logged

Hugo

Legend

Offline

3670 days karting
France
Gender: male

Re: TIME TO DEBATE
Reply #16 - 12/27/15 at 09:03:01

Raγ wrote on 12/27/15 at 07:00:01:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUtoudSVWEpx8gCHDRK6zxA

Sorry for bumping, just figured I'd leave this here in case no one knows about it. The channel was made Dec 2013 and it has some MK7 vids on it from the same month and year with him giving commentary, so imo it's safe to say that he's been around for a while and he's most likely not an alt. Just felt like clearing up any suspicions that may still be around Tongue

Some people think that the 1'58"948 RRM ERWAN.s (who appeared when Leo was looking for him) was somebody else who impersonated him and created the Miiverse account... (weird though)

But I just noticed one thing: he's speaking on most of his videos, we could ask him to do the same on his new channel to see if it looks the same Cheesy

Back to top

IP Logged

L e o King Offline missed 3505 mts Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #17 - 12/27/15 at 09:28:45 Erwan.s is talking in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0tpeCmoeuZU
Back to top	#8th Mario Kart 7 #135th Mario Kart DS #318th Mario Kart Wii Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_--qU1dVfLwtqblCRHVRJg IP Logged

Frederiek Legend Offline Revenge of the Goomba. No more jumping on my head! drank 3964 beers Belgium Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #18 - 12/27/15 at 13:20:17 lol this post https://miiverse.nintendo.net/posts/AYQHAAABAACXVHhomkN1yA
Back to top	Use this tool for MK7 time submissions: http://www.mariokart64.com/mk7/submit IP Logged

Hugo Legend Offline 3670 days karting France Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #19 - 12/27/15 at 13:34:01 L e o wrote on 12/27/15 at 09:28:45: Erwan.s is talking in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0tpeCmoeuZU Well, we already knew that he was legit but now I'm almost sure that ERWAN.s is ERWAN.s
Back to top	IP Logged

Hugo

Legend

Offline

3670 holabolas
France
Gender: male

Re: TIME TO DEBATE
Reply #20 - 03/06/16 at 02:41:22

Raγ wrote on 12/27/15 at 07:00:01:

Sorry for bumping

but

Raγ wrote on 12/27/15 at 07:00:01:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUtoudSVWEpx8gCHDRK6zxA

According to this channel (which is the old one), ERWAN.s' name must be Erwan Sellier, right? However he said a few days ago it was Erwan Sirote in the comments of one of his latest videos (in his new channel) so... Huh

Back to top

IP Logged

Karmakas Elite Offline seen 3861 mj vids France Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #21 - 03/06/16 at 05:18:24 Maître gims
Back to top	IP Logged

MK7Jack King Offline worships 3313 kartgods	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #22 - 04/03/16 at 08:42:35 Erwan.S has TT proofs here: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7nMe3wsdhI8 skip video to about 12:00 and it's a timescroll
Back to top	#32 PP MK7 IP Logged

WillD King Offline TrackMania, F-Zero, and Mario Kart. 4853 days karting Virginia, USA Gender:	Re: TIME TO DEBATE Reply #23 - 04/03/16 at 14:17:11 MK7Jack wrote on 04/03/16 at 08:42:35: Erwan.S has TT proofs here: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7nMe3wsdhI8 skip video to about 12:00 and it's a timescroll He has a 1'11"986 time on rBC1. Unclear if he used the glitch or not, and I'm not sure whether this supersedes the 1'12"000 time on the pending list.
Back to top	WR History Updater \| Former rDDD WR AlexPenev wrote on 08/08/12 at 03:51:30: Did you try doing a mini turbo? That could change everything. IP Logged

Hugo

Legend

Offline

punched 3670 kiddies
France
Gender: male

Re: TIME TO DEBATE
Reply #24 - 04/03/16 at 20:30:39

WillD wrote on 04/03/16 at 14:17:11:

MK7Jack wrote on 04/03/16 at 08:42:35:

Erwan.S has TT proofs here: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7nMe3wsdhI8 skip video to about 12:00 and it's a timescroll

He has a 1'11"986 time on rBC1. Unclear if he used the glitch or not, and I'm not sure whether this supersedes the 1'12"000 time on the pending list.

It doesn't, he sent it on the french site as his glitch time so yes, this means his glitch time is only .014 better than is no glitch one...

Back to top

IP Logged