I actually took the time to take a look at the new replies this morning and I have a few things to comment on...
FirstKmacc wrote on 03/18/14 at 13:00:08:Fant0m wrote on 03/18/14 at 12:41:02:Nope, no claims for me, yet, I'm just analyzing people's reactions on the very first day.
I can notice Fank is playing the usual way so I can't tell if he's mafia or town yet.
People unvoting and voting for me right away, all in a row, just to lynch someone always seems very scum to me. It's as if they knew he was innocent but still wanted to kill him and try to make everyone else join their thoughts. What's even the point of wagoning for someone who hasn't even posted yet...?
Ftm, I'm expecting people like TVK, blahpy and Kmacc to be mafia.
Also, I find it funny how Brett started the wagon but then says later on it was a joke, without unvoting...
Shock is actually trying to participate a lot in this game so far.
Timothy and Kmacc voting for each other, then unvoting ... What's the point?
Also, I looked at Timothy's posts but didn't see anywhere he had unvoted Kmacc...
However, in Kmacc's votes update post, it seems like he stroke Timothy's vote on his name...
This means he probably expected Timothy to post an "unvote" somewhere as if it was obvious he wouldn't vote for Kmacc in the end... As if they were in the same team...
That makes 2 wrong points for Kmacc.
Vote : Kmacc
My apologies, Tim never did unvote me, you're right. But like I said, I tallied that up quick, and I really only did it because it hadn't been done yet. I even admitted it might be wrong. If you'd like, you can assume counting the votes, since you seem to have an eye for it.
As for voting for you, at least I substantiated that I wanted you to get more involved, unlike others who voted for you on the first day just because. I think that's how others felt though anyway regardless, hence why Brett unvoted for you now that you've finally posted. I hope you also realize that by the time you want to post tomorrow morning, the day will literally be almost over, so putting it off until then is basically saying you're not going to participate for the rest of day one, no? And nobody even tried to convince others to strictly vote toward you. People were voting toward dead weight players, and you happened to be one of them.
Me and Tim always used to vote for each other at the beginning of these games, so it was kind of tradition. This always happens at the beginning of mafia games, you should know this from playing in more than a few.
I totally understood why you voted for each other at the begining, it just made me laugh. The thing I find curious is that you stroke Timothy's name before he even unvoted you, as if you
knew he wasn't going to vote for you in the end. You can defend yourself by saying it was just a joke and a ritual between you 2, but I have a feeling it goes way beyond than that and you two probably are in the same team . I have no other proof of this yet unfortunately...
SecondFank seems to play like the "manager" of the game...
Fank009 wrote on 03/18/14 at 14:07:45:Fant0m wrote on 03/18/14 at 12:41:02:...
(shortened cause I don't want all the quote cause it's irrelevant and making my post closer to a novel)
Hi Flo, Don't worry, you still have 3 posts to convince me of what side you are on.
As if we had to convince you and not the opposite... Remember you need to convince us that you are town too because for the moment you're not proving anything...
FinallyDJT wrote on 03/18/14 at 17:31:14:Zwiebel wrote on 03/18/14 at 16:55:51: Silver, do you understand why rolefishing was bad in that situation? Do you still think it was good to propose that? I would like to hear clarification about that...and please a bit more than one sentence.
I don't really see how it was wrong, think of it this way: if he claims a power role, a cop or investigator could investigate him and/or a doctor could protect him. I'll admit it's a bit risky in this game since we don't know how many mafia and power roles there are - works better in games where we know the numbers. That way we can weigh out the advantages or disadvantages of asking for a claim or claiming it yourself. But it could still work out.
Hell, I'll even claim what I am right now:
vanilla townie.
Ok, I'll probably do something stupid here but I can't keep looking at this post without doing anything and I'm even surprised that none that could notice it before me didn't react to this at all before I did...
Silver, being mafia or town, either way you are amazingly stupid. Role claiming is already a dumb thing to do on day1 I agree, but here, you've reached an other level of stupidity. I'll explain myself.
A role claim implies you to reveal the role
the way Tom wrote it for you
The fact that you said you are "vanilla townie" implies that either you're a dumb townie for not revealing your role properly, or you are faking it. Indeed, Tom was smart enough to not write "vanilla townie" in the roles. Also it is very easy for mafia to claim they are "vanilla townies".
So until you give me the real term(s) for "vanilla townie", I will think you just shot yourself in the foot with your mafia role.
unvote
vote : Silver.
Also, I'd like to hear more of TVK and blahpy because they haven't really helped for anything in the game ftm.