Locky wrote on 03/18/14 at 21:39:25:I like both Flo and Zwiebel's entrances. Although his point about Kmacc is silly he seem relatively composed. Zwiebel came in strong and brought up some good points on TvK.
I like J-Cop's posts through, especially the TvK/Zwiebel/Shock scumlist post, he seems genuine in his posts even though he's picking at dirt a bit in the post.
Unvote for now
First finding, likes J-Cop's post.
Timothy wrote on 03/20/14 at 10:18:42:J-Cop wrote on 03/20/14 at 09:26:46:Sportsguy001 wrote on 03/20/14 at 04:43:31:Voting was tied between the two guys and then it went basically all to TVK led by Flo coincidence?
It was actually led mostly by Zwiebel. He had a rather lengthy post focusing on TvK and if you look back to the end of the day, he had four different posts urging people to vote TvK before we ran out of time.
It makes him look suspicious to me. I mentioned TvK in a post saying I thought he could be mafia. When Zwiebel showed up, he really pushed hard for a lynch on TvK using some of the same reasons I gave. At first it made me think I was on to something with TvK because someone else was agreeing with it, but now it just looks bad. He targeted someone very heavily on day one that someone else was already suspicious of, and that person ended up being town.
He also called Flo a retard and that was funny.
Ok but yeah you can always interpret things in two ways which is why this is so difficult... Was Timur a) pushing so hard from the side of the town because he was trying to stimulate discussion and/or apply pressure to someone with what seemed like good reason?
b) pushing so hard from the side of the mafia because he could paint a good picture of suspicion in a relatively innocuous situation and not feel he'd be incriminated if that person was lynched and turned up as town?
But I agree with him that aggression is a better strategy, I was hoping the game would have sped up by this point, esp after such a bad day 1 result.
Maybe it's your strategy or whatever but you come across to me like the "innocent bystander" who doesn't want to get his hands dirty, so why should I not vote for you?
Vote: JCopPlease post more people... I'm still unsure on Flo, but I do think Silver is more likely town than mafia.
Pressure on J-Cop from Timothy.
J-Cop wrote on 03/20/14 at 14:44:32:Zwiebel, I didn't know that you typically play aggressively like that, I'm not sure I've played in the same game as you before. Timothy confirmed that aggression is the better strategy, though, so I guess leading the charge to a town lynch is understandable.
Blahpy comes across to me as clueless town, not mafia. He's probably not posting much because he doesn't want to accidentally say something stupid and get himself killed. Rather than sniff out mafia, he's just trying to keep himself alive. It doesn't help anybody, but it doesn't look suspicious to me. Right now I'd put him and Silver in the same category, inexperienced town who are too scared to speak up.
Yesterday, Shock went heavy on Silver. Today, he's going heavy on Blahpy. That looks bad to me.
It also looks bad that Lafungo has followed Shock's opinions without really contributing anything. When Shock went after Brett day 1, Lafungo's very next post was a vote for Brett. Shock goes after Blahpy now and Lafungo immediately votes for him. He hasn't contributed anything, and for the most part his posts have only consisted of voting for the people Shock mentioned. Could be a link between these 2.
Timoth confirmed something for J-Cop? Meh
Timothy wrote on 03/20/14 at 16:44:44:J-Cop wrote on 03/20/14 at 14:44:32:Zwiebel, I didn't know that you typically play aggressively like that, I'm not sure I've played in the same game as you before. Timothy confirmed that aggression is the better strategy, though, so I guess leading the charge to a town lynch is understandable.
Yeah but just to clarify (even if obvious) we're talking about directed (not blind) aggression, otherwise we're just flipping coins. Day 1 was just a bit of a mess because there wasn't much to go by and it all got out of hand towards the deadline.
J-Cop wrote on 03/20/14 at 14:44:32:Blahpy comes across to me as clueless town, not mafia. He's probably not posting much because he doesn't want to accidentally say something stupid and get himself killed. Rather than sniff out mafia, he's just trying to keep himself alive. It doesn't help anybody, but it doesn't look suspicious to me. Right now I'd put him and Silver in the same category, inexperienced town who are too scared to speak up.
Yesterday, Shock went heavy on Silver. Today, he's going heavy on Blahpy. That looks bad to me.
It only looks bad to you because you think Blahpy is more likely "clueless town", but that doesn't make it a bad strategy and I'd rather see quiet players called out than left to rot.
Timothy wrote on 03/22/14 at 02:45:59:I don't like that it's become strictly a Lafungo/Sportsguy race. JCop never even addressed my vote on him earlier in the day.
Unvote
As Zwiebel says, Sportsguy is only a useful lynch if we're extremely confident of his alignment. If he turns up town then we get almost nothing - the only links would be with Flo and possibly Silver but again that doesn't necessarily incriminate them as his thought processes have been pretty illogical. I'm more inclined to believe his claim for the time being.
Out of these two I think Lafungo is more likely scum, as I and others have said it looks like he's been trying to cover his tracks.
Vote: Lafungo
I don't like this situation at all, I believe it's tied 5-5? If that's the case, if no one posts in the next 15 minutes I'll unvote to break the tie. A no lynch is obviously dreadful.
Timothy was trying to get attention on J-Cop, trying to get another Townie lynched or diccoc? Can't tell yet.
Locky wrote on 03/26/14 at 02:41:48:No use staying on Blahpy any longer...
Why are you voting Brett here Flo? Timothy has been online and hasn't posted anything. If he were town, surely he would've claimed (or at least posted something) by now.
Vote: Timothy
One of the (maybe most) telling things. At that time it was 3 votes on Brett and 2 votes on Timothy. Lock comes in before EOD and votes Timothy to get 3-3 and a no lynch. Would he do that if Brett was Town? He would've probably just let him die.
I think Brett is more likely Maf than J-Cop just for this sole reason. Maybe you can find more in the timothy/J-Cop interaction, I for myself can't tell if it's dissoc or something else. I'd rather rely on this Lock vote which seems really telling. Why would he no lynch otherwise?
Pages: 
