Joe Reinreb wrote on 03/25/12 at 17:29:02:I just wanted to see more out of Brett other than a list of posts defending himself. I am in no way suggesting that you're mafia, I just wanted to read something other than the obligatory "I'm town!" post...
And I haven't played mafia in a long time, but I've always been rather quiet through the first couple of pages because I like to read the field before I post anything about anyone.
The bogus roleclaim went over my head. Apologies for that...
As soft as it is, I do feel that it's ridiculously easy to bandwagon on him for this reason alone. This is what I'm worried about. Joe's alignment can be confirmed later and I don't think he's too much of a hinder to keep around since he's not damaging town, unlike Brett who has completely taken control of the day because of a simple grudge vote which he could have easily chosen to avoid responding to.
I also agree with him and expected more out of Brett, but all he's really done is try his hardest to divert attention from himself, give poor justifications as his answers and to randomly buss people to try and get a lynch (he never explained why Web would be a good lynch and he said I would be a good candidate but did not explain why. . . ?)
Joe Reinreb wrote on 03/26/12 at 06:37:31:While I still don't understand why there was heat on Brett at the very beginning of the game, he doesn't apear to be mafia in my book. It seemed like someone had it out for him and a couple others just ran with it and voted was too quickly.
I think a lot of people are jumping the gun and wildly voting. I mean, people are spite voting because of personal issues outside of the game. Why did Clark vote for Tom? Spite. Why did Tom vote for Clark? Retaliation and spite. This is no way to play the game, and it makes it harder for me to read into your posts.
I know that there's only 20 or so hours left in the day, but I still can't vote unless I'm prettt confident with my choice.
I can see why people think this is mafia. He's definitely tip toeing as if he's walking on glass, and stating what is easy to see. Although I am a bit concerned on why he doesn't think Brett is maf. His reasoning behind that is terrible. What he said was true and that's how it started out, but more has been said and put above the surface. Keep in mind I don't think he's read that part yet (especially the discourse between Brett and me) so I'll wait for him to come on and read through that before I make any rash decisions.
It's Day 1 also, so I honestly don't think anyone can be 100% confident in their choice since the information to go off of is limited. His paragraph about retaliation seems like a reasonably fluff paragraph as well.
I don't know. Joe just seems like the easiest lynch for mafia to pull off. That's why I'm not so sure on lynching him. Plus I want to hear what he has to say.
My top 3 for today as of now are Webinator (has contributed little and is severely under the radar) Brett (caused nothing but confusion and has made countless bold statements with absolutely no backing) and then Joe would be last due to his risk-free posts, but he has played like this so often I'm finding it difficult as to whether he's being sincere.
Also you can blow me padz for posting jack shit on Page 6 you dumb fuck
Pages: 
