Robertvz wrote on 07/22/11 at 04:00:20:RVZ wrote on 07/22/11 at 02:04:45:What do you think about Gaff, Brett? He's not really a big poster too imo. All he said basicly is nothing worthly for town.
Webinator is nightkilled. I'll have a closer look into his posts and his opinions.
Tom doesn't seem bad. He's posting his usual ways. I lean towards town on him, he hasn't given me really any proof that he is mafia. He's been trying to help a lot. I don't get how you say he has said a whole lot of nothing. I can look back as maybe my memories of him are a bit askew. I know he's been asking a lot of questions and trying to get into a lot of buddy to buddy conversations along the way but I'm not so sure if he's doing this because he's mafia and "knows" that who he is allying with is town or because he's town and going on gut feeling.Also Flo how could Tom and Clark BOTH BE MAFIA? If Clark was mafia you realize how bad that would make you look? I guess one could be mafia but if both of them are mafia then they deserve to win.
Clark's reasoning for roleclaiming is understandable, although I still don't like it. With 4 claimed powerless townies (2 of which are dead), the chance of a maf kill hitting a power at night goes up a lot. You're not helping by just claiming Vanilla. It's just easier for mafia to nail whatever few powers we might have. Look what happened with Web.
Oh yeah, and RVZ, Zwiebel's post against you makes you look terrible. I can't believe I didn't notice it earlier. If you were sure they both weren't good lynches why didn't you focus your attentions elsewhere and try to lynch someone you thought was more likely to be mafia? If you brought up good points someone else coulda been lynched instead of useless Silver.
Still waiting on you to come back online and finish making your post about Web's D1 play.
Oh look, Brett's defending Tom's playstyle. Also:
The Gaff wrote on 07/22/11 at 05:32:41:Clark, i'll try to be more to the point then.
At the moment these are my thoughts;
brett - town lean, contributing alot, helping and pretty much leading this game for town.
Zyklon - maf lean, hasn't contributed anything for town yet.
Zwiebel - undecided
Zarkov - hasn't dont that much apart from vote for silver but in fairness he wasn't alone in that
F@nt0m@s - still not convinced. I think, if he is mafia, then his mafia friends would've been trying to get him out of that day 1 sticky situation. I'm going to re-read D1 and see who was pushing the silver vote over flo again.
rvz - mafia lean, normally he is really analytical but in this game he seems to be keeping a low profile. If he's not mafia then he probably has a pr. Sorry if that baits you out.
el nino - mafia lean, probably just trying to keep quiet so he can escape being rumbled.
i've just put some heat out there so i'm expecting to get some grief back. Alternatively i'm not expecting anyone to really justify what i've written. Would like more thoughts from the quiet players though.
Funny that Tom thought Brett was the most Townish player, but jumped immediately on the RVZ claim without hearing on to Brett's explanation. As A Townie, I would expect that from you if you thought so hard he was Town.
I'm fairly sure Tom/Zark is remaining Maf. Still looking back for some good quotes.
Pages: 
