I just read through the whole thing...haven't played a game with Goose yet, but I heard that you play pretty good no matter which role, so I guess I'll keep neutral about you know until a later point in the game. If I had to put a lean, I'd say Town because it seems like a honest effort, but I won't decide for now.
Zark is just playing his normal D1 of posting nothing at all so we can't read much of that either.
I don't see why you call NStrides first posts ok Goose, care to explain it for me? Not like they contain much of a value to judge yet, right?
Also, it appears strange to me that so many people use Toad to mention their first MK character, that's very suspicious. I will rather chose
Peach.
About Fank, I'd rather think about him being n00b town. At least he is posting, I'd rather keep alive a "possible" N00b Town which is posting than a "possible" N00b Town player that is not posting at all.
I already forgot who else posted so I'll look through everything again