Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register    
 
smk mk64 mksc mkdd mkds mkwii mk7 mk8
general   mafia   smk   mk64   mksc   mkdd   mkds   mkw   mk7   mk8   |   problems   |   discord   irc
 
  Home Search Members Login Register
 
Pages: 1 ... 5 6 7 8 
Send Topic Print
Low-Power Mafia Gamovr (Read 2026 times)
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



6446 days karting
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #150 - 08/02/10 at 16:16:09
 
Camster wrote on 08/01/10 at 08:55:02:
Matt - No readings on him, as he hasn't contributed at all. A couple superfluous posts at the beginning, and a random vote on Padz later on. I want to hear more from him, as his inactivity suggests mafia to me.

MVT - MVT is very focused on Brett. Check this out:

TellTale wrote on 07/31/10 at 09:53:55:
Edit - On the bright side if his claim is true we got rid of one of the most counterproductive players out there...ever

I could've sworn at least twice he's expressed this exact same sentiment against someone at the start of the game who did something stupid and ended up being town. MVT was also town both times I think, so that doesn't necessarily make him mafia. I think he should try to not focus so much on his gut reaction at the start of the game, as it's been wrong before. I want to know what MVT thinks of the rest of us, we all already know what he thinks of Brett. I'm undecided on MVT atm.


Camster wrote on 08/01/10 at 09:08:49:
Padz - Has only like three posts this entire game. What he's said so far is reasonable, but I'd like to here more from him. Undecided on Padz right now.

Web - I get a strong town vibe from Web, his posts seem very sincere. Not much else to go on here though.

Zwiebel - Hasn't contributed much, and his posts just seem like summary posts to me. Claims he has some thoughts that aren't based on logic so he's not gonna vote for now? I don't understand how that helps anyone, it seems like a cop out for not posting anything to me. I get a mafia vibe from Zwiebel, though it could just be inexperience since it's his first game.

Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
Web
NinjaWeb
*****
Offline

Expected MKSC
Comeback: 2016?!?!

ate 5795 donuts

Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #151 - 08/02/10 at 16:19:09
 
Of course its easy to say now that he's mafia. If I had posted the same thing before and he had come up mafia, then it wouldn't be a big deal, but since i wasn't on the computer due to being out to dinner and it lasted longer than I thought it would and I come back, suddenly it isn't good enough.

I can perfectly understand why this is questioned, but its something I can't help.....

@MVT of course.



Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



6446 days karting
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #152 - 08/02/10 at 16:21:43
 
Keep in mind my long post was made without any look at who's targeting who on D2.
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
Web
NinjaWeb
*****
Offline

Expected MKSC
Comeback: 2016?!?!

5795 days karting

Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #153 - 08/02/10 at 16:23:30
 
Oh btw MVT, Zwiebel was back and forth on his vote for the whole day, and Brett pretty much persuaded him after he voted Tom, then unvoted to MVT.

Brett told him to vote Tom. I thought Zwiebel was town but now I'm not sure since he was pretty much forced to vote Tom otherwise it would have seemed suspicious that he refused and then a few hours later Tom was mafia.

Anyway, I'll be back on again soon, busy with AP work atm.
Since Matt V finally decided to talk, I'll do this for the moment. We still have 43 hours left in the day so I'll vote later when there's more to go on.

Unvote
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



punched 6446 kiddies
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #154 - 08/02/10 at 16:24:20
 
Whatdya mean finally? I had to work haha.
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
MVT
Ex Member




Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #155 - 08/02/10 at 16:29:52
 
Matt V wrote on 08/02/10 at 16:15:28:
I know your votes on me were due to inactivity more so than mafia leans, so let's just do a big player breakdown.

MY PLAYER BREAKDOWNS

1. Brett - Brett is on the fence, he first says Tom is town, and speaks against MVT/Darius getting an "easy townie lynch" out of him.  He was under the radar by everyone, and nearly got lynched, but everyone seems to have forgotten that.  He also insta-jumped on the Tom voting bandwagon, for weak reasons (Tom not instantly saying he was town, and in hindsight, he was suspicious of a post saying Tom thoguht he was town....weird much?).  Brett is not one to play a shitty game I'd argue against that.  I think Brett and Zweib are town.  Could they be mafia, ya, but it's not likely.  but he has defended himself over the top, even though it was unnecessary (kind of like I did when I was mafia, althoguh I do suck at this game lol). The only thing speaking for Brett is that he recruited Zwiebel to vote for Tom, which he'd NEVER do if he was mafia.

3. Darius - Darius started the Tom lynch, and has provided alot in the game.  I 100% think he is town, and can be trusted. Ya I'd be quite floored if he was mafia unless the plan was to sacrifice Tom right away?  Possible, never say 100%.  I do lean town though.

6. MVT - Really went all-out against Brett, who seems suspicious to me, which gives a town lean. Also, Tom's final post was pegging MVT as town, which is something I doubt such an experienced person would do, to try and "protect" his partner.  Therefore I get a TOWN lean. Not much else to say, MVT is one of the best players when he is playing mafia, his posting style never deviates from game to game.
Good read, I'm town.
7. Padz - I put a vote on padz to get some defense out of him, he was just jumping onto the lynch Brett bandwagon, which I think could be staged to blend in.  He's also after Web, who I think is town, and myself, another town. Slight mafia lean.  I don't like padz style this game, but he seems to agree with what I say a lot so I'd rather keep him around.

8. Web - Hasn't done anything suspicious, just a few joke posts, and also keeps getting pushed by padz, who is a mafia lean to me.  I think Web is the most likely town left after Darius, and our man Cam thoguht the same before he was killed.  Well if Web does turn up mafia and there is one more maf left, you're screwed after this paragraph.  Definite linkage right there.  Kinda makes me a lot more sus of you to say he hasn't done anything suspicious even though he has contributed nothing and avoided Tom thoroughly.

9. Zwiebel - I can't get any read on Zwiebel.  First he goes for a mafia with the third vote on Tom, but then pulls a 180 and says that Tom needs to be rescued. Then Brett gets him to change his mind yet again.  His lack of experience is showing, but I'm not one to talk.  Again, no real lean here, althoguh maybe slightly town.  I think he is town just because he could have easily gotten rid of any number of people at the end of Day 1 and chose tom.  There was a reason I did not want to vote for anyone and that is way.  I wanted to see what someone would do when pressured into the big single decision making vote.  Zweib's action then shows he is likely town when you look back. Cool


So I may not look like I did much but every single move I made and post I said had a purpose.  2 things I did.

The Brett roasting day 1, (contrary to him thinking I hate him and I'm a terrible human being) actually were purposefully designed because I KNEW how combustible he is when put under and tiny bit of pressure.  Look how me roasting him almost proves he is town!

The end of day 1.  I didn't want my vote to be the decider or influence the outcome since it was very close or tied I believe.  I wanted to see someone step up and make the move of the killing vote.  I knew it would speak volumes about their position later in the game once the dead guy was revealed.  Zwieb stepped up and voted Tom when he could have voted out many others.  Tom turns up maf.  Zweib is likely town.  If he was mafia he would have chosen one of the other several options.  

I got a good game going so far. Shocked

Wink
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
MVT
Ex Member




Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #156 - 08/02/10 at 16:36:27
 
Game plan of attack

Matt V - Was inactive until now.  Avoided any tough decisions or pressuring anyone.  Claims Web is not at all suspicious.
|
connected
|
Web - Very suspect.  Avoided Tom like he was a hot potato.  

Padz - strange style.  Not choosing the correct people either to vote for.


Lynching Web tells us what side Matt V is on.  I'm always in favor of such situations.  I always try to get value for a lynch in any game.  In any game usually 2 for 1 situations arise and here is one very basic clear cut situation.  Matt V says Web is not at all suspicious.  If Web turns up maf, Matt V is very likely to also be maf.  If Web turns up town Matt V is also likely town.  



That is why the choice to kill Web today for me is so easy and obvious.

The logic is unavoidable and undebatable.

So Vote Web guys!   Smiley
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



ate 6446 donuts
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #157 - 08/02/10 at 16:38:40
 
Well with my town read I'm glad you analyzed my post.  I'll never pretend to be as good at this game as people like you and Cam, but those were my gut instincts.

Hindsight is always 20/20, and whoile I'm not flipping 180 degrees, Brett seems more town, due to the fact that his bad suspicions were so early in the game.  I didn't know he was always so defensive?

My Web/town read was based on my read of Padz being mafia, and of Cam's read, whose judgement I trust.

With Zwiebel I feel I agree with you, but for different reasons Mike.  Brett "convinced" (I doubt it was staged) him to put the vote on Tom.  If he were a more experienced player I'd be suspicious, but for now I lean slightly more towards town, but still not toally sure.
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



drank 6446 beers
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #158 - 08/02/10 at 16:41:23
 
If Web is mafia the game should be over, and whatever suspicions you have of us being linked will be disproved.

If he's mafia it also makes you probable mafia for gunning him so much, so it's also win-win for town.

Vote: Web

Even though I still think he's town, this could smoke out MVT.

I hope Darius gets on to post soon though, as the only for sure town.
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
MVT
Ex Member




Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #159 - 08/02/10 at 16:43:27
 
Matt V wrote on 08/02/10 at 16:41:23:
If Web is mafia the game should be over, and whatever suspicions you have of us being linked will be disproved.

If he's mafia it also makes you probable mafia for gunning him so much, so it's also win-win for town.

Vote: Web

Even though I still think he's town, this could smoke out MVT.

I hope Darius gets on to post soon though, as the only for sure town.


Wait what?  If I was mafia I would target my only buddy left in such a small field of players?  HUH?
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



6446 days karting
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #160 - 08/02/10 at 16:47:38
 
Sorry I meant town not mafia.

"If he's town it also makes you probable mafia for gunning him so much, so it's also win-win for town.

Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
MVT
Ex Member




Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #161 - 08/02/10 at 16:50:03
 
Matt V wrote on 08/02/10 at 16:47:38:
Sorry I meant town not mafia.

"If he's town it also makes you probable mafia for gunning him so much, so it's also win-win for town.



I guess that makes sense.   Huh  edit - you changed it from town town to town maf.  Now I finally understand what you mean in theory.  Except for the fact I'm town.

I also don't like how you keep saying Darius is for sure town.  Maybe it's just inexperience but there is no such thing as a sure thing.  Tom and Darius are both wise players.  If they wanted to think of a plan where one starts a lynch bandwagon against the other to make one look very innocent, they could have easily worked that out.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



6446 sex records
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #162 - 08/02/10 at 16:51:16
 
Fine, Darius is 98% town.
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



helped 6446 people
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #163 - 08/02/10 at 16:52:42
 
Also, I'm sure Darius will come in and start a brigade against someone, and he wouldn't do that if he was mafia.  You just wait and see.  Grin
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
MVT
Ex Member




Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #164 - 08/02/10 at 16:52:48
 
If web flips maf I will focus day 3 on you Matt.  If web flips town I will focus on padz day 3.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



6446 sex records
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #165 - 08/02/10 at 16:54:02
 
Unless there is VERY STRONG evidence that surfaces of MVT being mafia, I'll keep my vote on Web, no matter what.  I want this kid off my ass, and onto an actual mafia.
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



6446 days karting
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #166 - 08/02/10 at 16:54:50
 
Like I said before there is prob only two mafia, so either we will win or we will move onto another sus person.
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
Honko
NinjaHonk
*****
Offline

Toad Runner 24: Honk
Another Day

7550 toadgasms
California
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #167 - 08/02/10 at 16:56:26
 
Votals
[3] Web - MVT, Darius, Matt
[1] Matt - (Darius), Brett, (Web)
[1] Padz - Zwiebel
[1] Zwiebel - Padz

Day ends in 42 hours or when someone reaches 4 votes.
Back to top
 
 

<Roy> this theme plays while honko tells "more like" jokes
<Roy> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOIjzmMZi_s

VAJ wrote on 12/11/09 at 06:26:06:
Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Shocked
View Profile   IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



6446 days karting
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #168 - 08/02/10 at 17:01:02
 
BRETT STOP LURKING I SEE YOU ONLINE
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
Brett
Ex Member




Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #169 - 08/02/10 at 17:09:50
 
I just freaking got here, calm down.

Anyway Matt, I have no idea how I could be on the fence in your eyes considering I pretty much with the help of Darius led the Tom lynch. Zwiebel was certainly capable of whacking a townie and forcing a tie vote but no, instead I focus him on a mafia player.

I don't know what to do. I want to vote Web but I won't end the day with 42 hours left. Lets give Web a chance to defend himself and hopefully provide more to the table than arbitrary lists of who seems town and excuses.

@MVT:  I'm confused. You pushed hard against me knowing I'd break down and reveal what side of the playing field I am on?
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Matt V
Legend
*****
Offline



6446 holabolas
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #170 - 08/02/10 at 17:13:07
 
lol caps lock fail by me >.>

I'm going out with friends, may or may not be back on before bed, so if I'm not on for the next 15 hours don't harass me.
Back to top
 
 

View Profile Matt V   IP Logged
padz
King
****
Offline



ate 5818 donuts

Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #171 - 08/02/10 at 18:26:09
 
i don't see how zwiebel being pressured into bussing tom would make him look town. it's happened plenty of times and the lack of confidence in his own opinion says a lot about him trying to make sure he doesnt make any waves w/ anyone. maybe you guys are right about it being just a first-timer thing.

reason i didn't vote web is that i figured i'd at least give him a chance to fuck up a bit more but all he's done is spout what he said yesterday so that kind of flopped

unvote

vote Web
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Honko
NinjaHonk
*****
Offline

Toad Runner 24: Honk
Another Day

7550 toadgasms
California
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #172 - 08/02/10 at 18:27:32
 
Quickest game ever.
Back to top
 
 

<Roy> this theme plays while honko tells "more like" jokes
<Roy> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOIjzmMZi_s

VAJ wrote on 12/11/09 at 06:26:06:
Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Shocked
View Profile   IP Logged
Honko
NinjaHonk
*****
Offline

Toad Runner 24: Honk
Another Day

7550 toadgasms
California
Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Day 2
Reply #173 - 08/02/10 at 18:28:18
 
Web was mafia, game is over.

Time to celebrate!
Back to top
 
 

<Roy> this theme plays while honko tells "more like" jokes
<Roy> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOIjzmMZi_s

VAJ wrote on 12/11/09 at 06:26:06:
Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Shocked
View Profile   IP Logged
padz
King
****
Offline



drank 5818 beers

Gender: male
Re: Low-Power Mafia Gamovr
Reply #174 - 08/02/10 at 18:32:49
 
looks like darius got his grueling lowpower game eh Smiley

honko more like dane coonko
Back to top
 
« Last Edit: 08/04/10 at 14:07:35 by padz »  
View Profile   IP Logged
Pages: 1 ... 5 6 7 8 
Send Topic Print