i actually just realized

goose killed me.

if he hadnt pretended to have scanned tom i wouldnt have convinced myself he wasnt granny

damn

e: fab wouldve died if he didnt bail at the last second though

I played a pretty bad game, but it was my first one on Mario Kart Boards, so maybe I'll get better lol. It's always harder to be mafia IMO.

Amazing game by Jack though, as well as Matthew, they helped the mafia greatly

Kmacc got owned :'( sucked that he could never post.

Goose giving up and outing townies as mafia was really stupid.  Fred/Howes giving up was dumb as well.

Mafia was destined to win from the start with all the roles they had.  They almost bungled it though.

If you guys haven't looked, there's already a healthy discussion going on in the Results thread on the other board, might be worth checking out for those of you who played.

any and all results are over on scotts board.  as well as thoughts from other players.

i'll go ahead and say a few things here though.

game should not have been hosted at all due to my lack of time to do so properly.  made a lot of mistakes this game that could've been avoided if i had the time to actually pay attention to it plus just lack of stupidity for next time i host.  apparently a lot of people didnt like the different board idea either, but oh well.

thanx everyone for playing, despite all the flaws.  i wont be hosting for a long time, so bug honko in the future if you want another one.  

Probably not, but I won't be hosting at all until at least mid-July so it's a bit early to decide.

I think I played quite well. I read the other board and people (koops) seemed to think that I didn't understand my role. lol. I fully understood my role, everything i wrote was ambiguous, vague and misleading on purpose. I hinted that there was complexity in my role by suggesting that i couldn't talk to much about it. I also insinuated that i was bulletproof for most of the match and seems like they didn't know for sure

The bullet proof rolecall was quite cunning and kept me in the game up to the end. Near the end I wanted to be scanned so that they would kill me, however someone blocked the scan... muppet. If you re-read my posts i'm baiting the mafia to scan me, check me, check me, check me i was saying as night fell but they (credit where its due) were smart. So it was a trade off, claim bullet proof for most of the game but also bring in the scanning element. I then brought in the bullshit about 2nd scans etc so that people if they had scanned me before (mafia might assume town had scanned me or that they'd had a scan blocked) would scan me again and die. There wasn't any scanners left though.

Jack was mvp for me. He played well, so did Moe imo but at the end he flopped.

Dwight also needed to show more when it was critical.

It was a good game. Wish I had one more day, I had so many mafia pegged by the end of my last day.

because i thought he could've been roleblocked.

Scum MVP was either Jack or Fred. They both did an excellent job of messing up Town.

Matthew played good at the beginning of the game. He had me fooled on Day 2. If I was alive on Day 3 he would have been toast though.

Moe played good but he was left in the hopeless situation of "everyone left in this game is a retard and/or mafia." He knew what was going on but couldn't keep people active or get them to listen to reason at the end.

Silencers are dumb and I regret ever using one in a game. They encourage bad play and just make the game less fun. There were also way too many bulletproofs and way too many killing roles, and no those do not balance each other out.

So yeah not a fan of the anonymous forum, not a fan of a lot of the roles, and not a fan of big 20+ player games where we have so many inactives and so many bad players. But in the end mafia is mafia, I enjoyed it while I was in. Thanks for hosting Koopz.

You didn't even make it past day 1   whoops haha. Maybe you're just the new Flo.

KoopZ wrote on 05/04/10 at 06:58:30:

Thanks Koopz.
That's too bad Honko got killed on first night. We would have had more chances to win.

Quote:

I don't think Moe played that well... Ok, he was helping by rereading all posts but most of the time, his votes were wrong.
Sword played well imo, just like Alvaro and Couscous. ^^
Chris and I got lucky to lynch both during the day and that they finally appeared mafia... Mostly for Alvaro (Michael) imo. He hadn't done so many mistakes in the game but we stayed on our plan to lynch Michael if Couscous was mafia. And we were right.
That's why I think Sword might have been a bit scared of me and Kevin after that so he prefered to kill me that night.
Then, kill Kevin the next night...

also, why does MVT have a Stanley Cup Playoffs avatar?  What team are you cheering for?