Joe Reinreb wrote on 12/21/09 at 12:56:05:I sat back on Day 2, and I understand that it looks really bad. I honestly didn't know what to say about the Howes lynch. In past games, I have always taken what Kmacc, Etch, Karterfreak, and Cooper said to be trustworthy, and in this particular game, I saw Kmacc's post and felt like I would just be piling onto what he was saying. I don't like posting for the sake of posting, so when I feel like I have nothing more to add, I just sit back.
I understand that in a mafia game, EVERY post matters, but sometimes when you post just for the hell of it, it comes off as a "mafia tactic." I obviously don't want that happening...
That being said...
This is the most important day of the game. It is absolutely necessary to kill a mafia member tonight, otherwise the game could essentially be over. We need to have EVERYONE talking in this day. No more sitting back and playing it cool (*raises hand*), and no more lack of posting (*raises hand again*)...
Dave and Tom, you guys (along with me) really need to step it up today.
Tom- in past games, you've always had a strong mafia radar, and yes, I always think that eventually you're going to be mafia, so I throw some heat on you early on, but you're always able to back out of it. This game is going astronomically different. Care to explain?
Dave- I think your quietness is hurting us the most. As a self-proclaimed "Greatest Mafia Player EVER!" you really need to prove it. I want to hear your plan for today...
Let's not get too lynch happy too soon (like we already seem to be doing). We need to think this through and nail a mafia member for sure. There is no question...
Going back and reading the entire thread. One thing stands out with Joe. He hasnt voted for anyone yet...considering there would be no trail to follow when someone dies this way, it seems rather suspicious to me.
Quote:This is the most important day of the game. It is absolutely necessary to kill a mafia member tonight, otherwise the game could essentially be over. We need to have EVERYONE talking in this day. No more sitting back and playing it cool (*raises hand*), and no more lack of posting (*raises hand again*)...
I agree. And yet you still havent followed up with your promise of talking or contributing more. We've got a few votes on Dave and Tom at the moment, but we still need more information. I'm gonna switch my vote to you.
UNVOTE
VOTE: Joe-Clay