Lynching me was incredibly dumb on the mafia's part.  I'm always going to be the most suspicious, wanted player... keeping me alive gives someone to blame for being mafia.  Getting Howes and Matt lynched even if I was mafia wouldn't be beyond me.  I can do anything, I should always be kept alive as long as possible if my side wants to win.

I'm going to post now to say that I think it's insane that Town kept killing Mafias over and over again.

Scott it wasnt really luck.  It had a lot to do with the fact that the masons were able to all KNOW 100% as a fact that eachother were town.  We all were able to share our roles and plan out night actions just like the mafia could do.  So it was often a no brainer to put our votes together and lynch off someone who wasn't one of us.

People being 99.9999% sure that I was town is exactly why the mafia should have kept me around.  I'm that 0.00001% and they could easily have made a case for it.

the town had MVT as recruiter, and he got etch and pobre right away.  thats what won it for us in the end.  about the only thing you can brag about is that you got howes, who you didnt know was godfather until after he died.  

I had karterfreak and cam pegged from very early on.  Darius and sportsguy I would not have guessed without help.  I was actually very close I think it was night 3 to trying to recruit sportsguy into the mason.  Good thing I chose etch  

There were many moments where the town could have easily lost this game.  It was not as in-hand as it looked.  Momentum shifted in the mafia's favor several times and we were put back on our heels.

Night 2 was a complete mess.  I lost my mason, who happened to be town mayor, a very strong role that could have been used in numerous circumstances.  We lost the Lenny the tracker which hurt us badly too since the cop was also dead.  I actually still don't know what healer does so I cant comment.  Hider was a slight blow but not too bad because it saved us a bit of trouble.  I had Extol pegged as mafia and was probably going to try and kill him off sooner or later.

The lynching of Tom was probably the biggest risk masons took all game and it blew up (literally) in our faces.  Luckily for us there was only one mafia left and we had a role blocker to save us.

This game also proved that there are a lot of players who act completely illogically and just blindly make decisions and actions.  I could name a bunch of guys who I don't think should even bother participating in future mafia games but I wont, and go on obliviously thinking that they will change their ways.

All I could do is stop 1 lynch.  Pretty pissed I didn't get to use that to pwn everyone had they ever lynched someone I didn't lead.

ah, thats why robin phrased it the way he did.  i overlooked that the poisoning takes two days to complete.  too bad i couldnt have protected myself (not that i'd have done it anyway, i was hoping to save other people)

Pobre ripped this game apart  
And Goose was just walking in his shadow... isn't that right Pobre?

Pobre wins at mafia.

Chained attack dogs would pull the walker, not the other way around

But for the most part we had a good alliance going.  It's just unfortunate I died and the three of us could never all talk together at once.