Honko wrote on 03/03/09 at 10:37:02:Hey Tom. I'm curious why you won't explain why I'm on your suspect list. It's impossible for people to defend themselves when you don't give reasons, and look how that turned out the last two games: lots of bad lynches. Until you start backing up your votes with more than just "I have a bad feeling," you're pretty much a joke and I'm going to ignore everything you say.
And to everyone who thinks you can figure people out 100% from your gut. You're stupid, really. If you're town, you will never be more than like 75% sure on anyone. There's always room for doubt. The only time you can be 100% sure about anything is when you're mafia. It's ridiculous how some of you are so cocky that you think after playing this game twice you are suddenly part-psychic and can figure out someone's alignment with zero doubt from skimming a couple posts. This arrogant bullshit makes me want to stop playing, since half of you seem to prefer random gut feelings over actually reading people's posts who try to give real analysis.
Sorry about page 28, I was ridiculously bored and decided to get the lamest 3000th post of all time. Won't happen again, unless this game gets so big that I have a chance to reach 4000 as well. I'm sure people will read into that somehow as I'm mafia. Sorry, but you're wrong.
Unvote
Nope, at least no in my opinion. I agree with you when you say that votes may be fundament in the posts that you read, but this game also has a important part of intuition cause if not the job of finding mafia could become impossible.
Your argument is valid for me, and after it I'm 75% (

) sure that you aren't mafia. The same happens with Darius and Scott. I don't know if Darius has played before, but his analysis about people make a lot of sense. Scott posted some messages where he was angry and he insulted some people, but It's because he's trying to find mafia really hard. BTW don't worry, this is just a fucking game; if we lost, bad luck, but we should try to be calmed during this.