Its the "no-reason" voting which frustrates me. Everyone should say why they are voting or it contributes nothing. You may as well state you are voting out of provocation if you are!

cheers

the  main point of no reason voting and changing is to gauge people's reactions IMO :-p

Extol, are you mafia?

Extol is mafia, fo fooking sho.

lol, i am not

are you, %hat?

Ok there is a Bodyguard in the game but there is only 1/2 chance that the protecting ends to be successful... this guy will have to be a bit lucky to block the mafia

AlexPenev wrote on 02/26/09 at 05:08:05:


Well I agree with this, but why am I in the list, I visit the board everyday for usually some hours
Btw I'm ready to really play the game this time (at least when I'll get a better connection tomorrow ) I don't won't to leave the game with only 3 posts like the previous game...

Tbh I don't really know who to lynch now (27 people is a lot, and half of them haven't even posted yet) anyway the first lynch will just be highly random

These first few days are going to be hard to figure out much of anything. The best way we can start to get ideas is to see who isn't being lynched during the night by mafia. Mafia is obviously going to target strong players who are very experienced. If those players stay alive after a few days then it's either very suspicious or a miracle.

There's really nothing we can see right off the bat right now, except that Tom once again claiming a power role is suspicious. Although he did this in the last game and was telling the truth and probably played the biggets role in getting the townie win, he could be using this strat again to try and look innocent and play a big help. Meanwhile, we could be trusting him due to his well played game last time around, and he could be mafia.

vote: In Hiding

Why should we trust you this time around for sure for the time being at least?

Well, this game is going to be much different from the previous game, considering that we don't have a sure-fire protection role (like yoshi in the last game). The only thing we have is the "Clingy Whipped Boy", and he has a 50% chance of dying if he protects someone.

The town special roles need to be much more careful this game to avoid being killed by the mafia at night. If they get killed, we would be leading into a serious disadvantage, espescially with three powerful roles on the mafia side (Silencer, Dominatrix, Lawyer... Overkill much on dangerous roles?).

Another thing we need to seriously avoid is having the Cockbite killed. If this happened, then the mafia could easily bandwagon votes without us knowing, and could lead to us being killed MUCH faster.

Finally, I think we should draw out today for as long as possible, questioning the people who don't talk, and gathering as much info as possible before making a vote. If we don't have enough information, I vouch for no lynch. We have a much bigger chance of killing a special townie role or townie if we lynch someone today compared to the next day when we have more information.

Vote: No Lynch

This is my vote for the next couple of hours until I get more information on who's talking or not.

Kmacc, read the bottom of my post, I haven't decided who I want to question yet.

Ah so the game has started.  I'd love to get Scott out early; last game he drove everyone insane but I don't think he'd be so passionate if he wasn't innocent.  Also, In Hiding was our best player in the last game so it would be good to keep him around for a while.  If he's mafia then we could be in trouble; he's one to watch.

Vote: Honko

He was mafia in the last game and he reeks like a CUNT.

It's not like I'm throwing a definite accusation on you, I just wanted a bit more information out of you. What else can we do right now besides get info out of people by throwing some votes around? At the moment, we have nothing else to evaluate, because no night actions have taken place yet..