Vote : Scott

Vote:  Scott

And yeah the mafia were terrible this game, including me.  And I really didn't know Clark was %Hat  

I think the town roles were overpowered though, it was way too easy for them, expecially having two virgins.

Fun game, some part of the stories were also pretty funny. I think town did a pretty good job, though we also were lucky several mafia simply did terrible most of the game. Besides that i think that mafia was at a disadvantage in this setting, it would have been more exciting in a closed game because mafia members could have claimed crazy roles and you also would have to question roleclaims more. I also dislike the "lets all roleclaim to get rid of the last 1/2 mafia members" as this has happened two games in a row. I don't say its wrong to do (it's possible in the rules, so do it for sure) but it does makes it shitty to be the last standing mafia member as you have 0% chance to win the game. The first 4 days were fun, but after that the game was played and basicly over. Those last 3 days were pretty boring. Conclusion: closed game ftw!

Some people in here shouldn't play btw, what's up with joining in if you're not going to say anything and do not try to help your team win? Oneshot was the worst, but there were some others who should seriously rethink before playing in one of these games. I guess some people just want to participate to just see themself in the list of players? Some other people just try to make their team lose. Like kevin booth faking he was silenced. That's just handicapping your team with no reason at all.   I dont get it.

Oh well, there were also people who were great, darius played pretty good for his first time, i think he was the most solid town player this game. Good stuff  

Do i need to host a new game, does someone else want to host a game? Or does someone wants to host a game with me? Like lenny/goose worked together this game.

btw: i really had to laugh when i noticed i was the transvestite, too bad i couldn't help you guys out anymore  from there on

I was onto a few mafia members before I was killed, but I never would have guessed that SuperYoshi was mafia. I remember looking at the votes and then Matt's votes and picking up on the fact that he probably knew more than the rest of the town...

It was a fun game, but I agree that the town was overpowered.  Two virgins and two alpha-males (although both of them being useless all game) sort of made the town invincible... Not to mention the moralist, who never could have died unless we lynched him...

I didn't like how long it took for the game to end, and I blame that on two things: too many players, and too many quiet players. Because lynches needed 13 people to be a majority, many posts were explanations as to why everyone should vote for someone, and most of the time the discussion was between 8 people. Needing to have another five votes at times was painful.

I say mafia games should max out at 19 players, and that the town should have less power roles.

Lol, reread my big post made earlier on day 4 karterfreak, if you read well you can see that i had fababu and syzygy clearly in sight already   Together with you as top suspects, but you had just played superpoorly until that point. Your defense was reasonable though, made me even more think that syzygy and fababu were mafia.

Only real surprise to me was superyoshi, didn't really expected him to be mafia.

LMAO.  Epic.

Classic.

it looks like a lot of the people I had pegged throughout the game actually turned out to be mafia.

Penev fooled me though

yep.  I thought he was mafia

Okay, modkill me

Scott died of AIDS?

There really is such a thing as a happy ending!

These teams were just hilarious.  I can't believe how many stupid things were done.

From my brief readings, it seemed like Kmacc really pegged a lot of people while other town players were too busy deducing shit from bullshit.  With so many players, you guys knew some people were not going to be active much.  That is not a sufficient reason to think one is mafia.  Not everyone sits on the fucking computer all day long with a raging hard on to see what the night actions were.  By post styles alone, it should not have taken long to see who the liars were.  There are 70 fucking pages to look at, no one can be that dense.  Despite the shitty town players, mafia was outclassed big time.  If you guys want to make this better next time, probably want to downsize it a little bit and just ban some people from playing since it fucks things up anyway.

Too many bad town and mafia players. xD

That's okay spazzup, not like I had a role and Kmacc pretty much played the way I would have.

You think after a few games people would get better, not worse at this. xP

Jack, don't use the word Vanilla like that.

Lenny has the night actions so you'll be waiting another couple of hours.