I've got this suspicion that Kmacc's April play was a mafia tactic to get him as a virtually guaranteed townie for the rest of the game, which probably would have worked very well if Tim and Fababu didn't give themselves away so soon afterwards. I just saw Scott's post as I was about to post this and I have this even stronger compulsion to lynch him.

unvote
Vote: Kmacc

Scott, how can the mafia still win? We have too many guaranteed townies for that and as you roleblocked Sword, we're down to three suspects (Extol, Kmacc, Sully), one of whom hasn't even been online. If we're really worried we just have to get Drag to stop killing. If it's not Kmacc, it's Extol. If it's not Extol, it's Kmacc. Simple.

I'm a bored man, waiting for townies to say something so we can get this over with. Even if I go and vote Extol we still need 3 more votes.

Good enough for me. I looked back at how quickly Stinson got lynched and thought you might actually not have got to see it at all. Also, Extol has been online twice since this day started and not posted. If he's not the mafia he's still wasting our time.

unvote
Vote: Extol

I still can't work out why Drag killed Booth when Matt confirmed he was town. Drag?

Stinson here

I was gone from Friday to Sunday because of a family emergency, so I was not able to post or even be near a computer all weekend, that's why i was gone. I was just about ready to announce myself as alpha male also.

Anyways. It's obvious to be that Scott really needs to die. I don't think anymore needs to be said about the most annoying player in the game.

peace out

Sure thing Kmacc, I was just reading what had happened since I left.

Stinson not being mafia ... strange. But he explained his case, anyway.

And for the last time Darius, I am not Mafia, so that massive slap will have to wait

Scott roleblocked me just to be sure anyway x]

Vote :
Extol

Lets get this game over with already.

If DragonDragon isn't here, how about Extol votes for himself? The game is up anyway, you might as well turn yourself in

And to have the lynching vote on yourself would be cool imo

This game needs to end as soon as possible >_<

extol, just a random question: how did you guys not kill me night 3 after I pushed so hard for april's lynching? I thought for sure you guys would think I was cop...

Good Game Guys

Darius can get off my case now ^^

And yes, I'll have to shape up for next game.

Finally  

Great work, town, I think that's a very comfortable victory. Flo giving himself away so early was a real blow to mafia and the vig kill of Clark meant they were on the back foot straight away. I think Honko's reveal was actually key: if Tim and Fababu hadn't jumped on that bandwagon and Fababu hadn't subsequently tied himself in knots because of the whole vig scenario this probably would have dragged on even longer. As it was, once we got those two then Matt could reveal the scans he'd made and the game was over.

Extol: Tom was also convinced that Honko was mafia. You played the game pretty well compared to a lot of townies who were either far too quiet or absolutely terrible at putting together convincing, logical posts.

I think a lot of us got a bit frustrated at the end there; I know I did. We shouldn't have lynched Stinson so quickly. If we had waited even a few hours longer I think we might have got to the right conclusion; certainly Kmacc would have had the chance to post. An important lesson learnt for next time: quick days are generally bad for town.

Throwing something out there for next time (assuming people want to play again): we need to make sure that the people who are playing want to play and can be bothered to post more than one-liners with no analysis.

Great game, everyone!

Sportsguy001 wrote on 03/03/09 at 14:17:28:


I was 2/4 on my last predictions

Okay, day 8 starts.

vote: Scott

@sportsguy: I was gonna take my vote off you for day two cause I saw that you posted much more and I was going to vote for brutus. But I got on with about 3 minutes before the day ended, and tried to read like 10 pages as quickly as possible. I posted changing my vote to brutus but in that time, the topic got locked.

@sword: I don't think either side was necessarily overpowered role wise, but mafia didn't have any more experienced players which hurt them for sure.