Then why is it that every vote made against me has no real reason, while i've justified my vote for you?

I have a feeling that I'm being teamed by mafia right now.

WAHAHHAHAHAHAH!!! I am the mofia... you are all going down!!

Ban Booth for the duration of this game if he's going to spam our topic.

Things I find suspicious:

Brutus's first post is a vote without explanation, followed by a claim to be mafia.

Karterfreak acknowledges the necessity of getting people to talk by votes, yet defends nstinson (who had 2 votes at the time) before nstinson has satisfied that by defending himself.

Goose puts out strong words against nstinson: is this a mafia being quick to vote someone out or is this a good townie making sure the voting arguments are strong?

Karterfreak and Brutus are at each other's throat from the get-go. Perhaps a mafia ploy to cause more confusion? I'm gonna have to watch them more closely.

Ariath trying to lay low by saying he's not gonna say much. Townies shouldn't be afraid to talk, they should be out there trying to get other people to talk.

These do not necessarily mean they're all mafia, just things I've noticed. We still got a lot of people left who haven't said anything. While I have my own suspicious, I think it's more important to get everyone to talk.

No Lynch on first day sounds like a good idea, but I'm not convinced yet. People gotta feel the heat of the votes to make them talk. If everyone talks and there's no clear indication of mafia, perhaps we can pick someone the most likely and have the cop analyze them overnight.

Vote: Clark

First one on the list who hasn't said anything yet, let's hear it.

Lol? I go to sleep seven hours ago and there are 4 pages of replies.
In my opinion, Mafia won't vote for lynch until there are several votes against one person. I haven't read all the replies, so I won't vote until I have read them.

Yeah! What's to stop all of the townies from blatantly admitting that they're all townies?

I am. Are you?

I'm with Tom on this one.  I trust him, so let's get this all out into the open.

vote
Jabes

Booth says he's mafia so if that's the case then

Unvote

Vote: Kevin Booth

x]

Alright, the way I see it right now, there are a couple of people here who seem really suspicious.

The first one is of course Brutus. Honestly, why would a 'townie' claim first that he is mafia and then later that he isn't? The mafia already know who's a townie and who isn't, so the only people he would be messing with are the townies. If he was actually one of us, the why would he pull a bunch of crap like that?

The next person I'm looking at is Tim. Tim blatantly stated "Throw some random votes around and see what happens." Odds are about three to one that a random vote would land on a townie. This should be obvious to anyone that thinks about it, which makes me wonder which side tim is actually on.

Last, I'm wondering if benoit and lenny are in league with eachother. After lenny voted 'no lynch', benoit stated that anyone who disagrees with lenny is definitely mafia. That seems like a very strong assumption to be making, which could mean that either one or both of them are mafia.

I'm still not sure if my presumptions are correct though, so I'm still going to hold out on my vote. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong about any of these.

Alright, I see what you're saying now. I still think that it's a danger to randomly vote though. If the person you vote for is away/asleep, other people could follow your random vote and vote the person off before they even get to say their alibi.

Vote Count

Brutus - 2 (karterfreak, oneshotbilly)
No Lynch - 2 (SuperYoshi1, Extol)
karterfreak - 1 (Adam L)
nstinson - 1 (Goose)
Clark - 1 (EnigmaticCam)
Jabes - 1 (Clark)
Lenny - 1 (K. McAteer)

With 23 players, 12 votes are needed to lynch.

Booth is not playing.  Votes on him don't count.