Nice job town! Many are saying to me that they suspected me because I was too quiet, but I don't come to the boards that often, so I only posted when I came on. I wouldn't be quiet just to stay low, because that would be stupid xD

Joe was annoying me which is why I went for him.  Lucky I was roleblocked.  I cracked it after the Ariath lynch, then it was obvious who was mafia.  The scan on Scott was just precautionary because he was annoying me    

You advanced the game how exactly?   Quitter.

I got more out of that day with just you two posting at eachother than I did from almost all of the other days. Purely because it was just you two and what you both said.

If people want to keep quiet then fine but thats sus in my mind. The time difference does play a part in some people not being able to post/talk as much as others.

Good game, good game.

I don't think we should introduce too many new roles, otherwise it will be confusing. It's probably better to keep most existing roles and introduce only a couple of new ones. I like the idea of Masons. Masons are townies who can talk to each other at night (like mafia) and they have the benefit of knowing that they're townies. They recruit others into becoming Masons as the game goes on. There are a few twists to apply to them. One is that if they accidentally recruit a mafia, then all Masons die. Another is that if they accidentally recruit a townie power role, that townie becomes a regular townie Mason and loses their power.


Quote:

Townie = Weedle
Mafia = Pidgey
Doctor = Chansey
Bodyguard = Machoke
Cop = Growlithe
Insane/Naive/Paranoid Cop = Psyduck
Tracker/Watcher = Gengar/Kecleon
Vigilante = Vigoroth
Town Drunk = Spinda
Miller = Voltorb
Bulletproof = Geodude
Bomb = Wobbuffet
Paranoid Gun Owner = Blastoise
Hunter = Haunter
Masons = Digletts
Jailer = Lickitung
Fool = Bidoof
Amnesiac = Slowpoke
Yakuza = Hariyama
Godfather = Slaking/Snorlax
Hooker = Smoochum
Most of the other roles won't work well for us.

I personally like to see a game with a closed set up, where the roles are only known to the mod.

stinson, btw, i knew you weren't mafia but it was a ploy to avoid being killed off for putting to much heat onto the real mafia. Had votes started going your way i'd have removed mine and defended you.

Undefeated in forum Mafia  

lol, even if I hadn't role blocked tim on night 4, joe still wouldn't have been killed xD

Quote:  oneshot (Yoshi) swallows Joe (Baby Daisy).

Joe was swallowed anyway, so he wouldn't have died :p

I thought town was going to lose at the rate it was going, good to see you guys pull off the win.

After all that bullshit, Benoit got lynched.

gg

I think Closed means you don't know the roles that are in the game.  It changes how you look at night actions (you don't know what kind of killing or blocking roles there are) and claims people make (mafia has to be more creative, and townies have to be convincing), and it allows some more interesting roles too.  If people know there's an insane cop in the game, they know to be careful trusting scans, and if they know there's a bomb they'll be scared to cast the final vote, so those roles don't work well in open games.

If the roles are secret, is it then better to play with roles that can reveal others' roles?
For insane, nobody except the Mod knows he's insane. It's his job to figure out he's getting dodgy scans.

Bomb does sound better as a secret role if it explodes during a lynch, but it could be useful for both mafia and town. I think mafia should get some extra roles next time because they only had a roleblock this game. What do you think of a mafia protector that can cast Mirror Coat?