Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register    
 
smk mk64 mksc mkdd mkds mkwii mk7 mk8
general   mafia   contest   |   smk   mk64   mksc   mkdd   mkds   mkw   mk7   mk8   |   problems   |   discord   irc
 
  Home Search Members Login Register
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvantage (Read 376 times)
David Wonn
Elite
***
Offline



6766 days karting
Ohio
Gender: male
Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvantage
08/18/08 at 21:41:21
 
During the recent Kart 64 / Goldeneye meet in Virginia, we came across something unexpected. Mark Jones was playing Toad's Turnpike shortcut on the Japanese version of MK64, trying over and over to execute the "warp" portion of the shortcut. This is the version of the shortcut where Lakitu automatically places you down to the second half of the track, and only works on laps 2 and 3. Mark probably had at least 10 attempts that should have worked, so this definitely got my attention. I had previously had access to a Japanese version of Kart 64 in the early days of kart (late 90s) and thought I had confirmed that every known shortcut (at the time) was reproducible on the Japanese version. Apparently, this one was missed. So here's what we did:

We had two TVs side by side, one running the U.S. version, the other running the Japanese version. We closely analyzed the two, looking for any potential differences. The only main difference between Mark's attempts and mine were that I have always played shortcuts in "view 3" mode, or the perimeter mode which shows your relative position on the track. I thought I had a successful execution on lap 2 since the kart was showing up on the second half of the track at the moment I had the kart stuck on the rail. Oddly enough, Lakitu placed the kart back down at the early part of the track and reverted the alleged progress that was made. I have never ever seen this behavior on the U.S. version in all the time I have known about the shortcut.

The strangest part about all of this is that the Japanese version came out before the U.S. version. It appears that some fix was done on Nintendo's part between the two versions, but this fix evidently had side effects, allowing for the warp to be possible on the U.S. version. In a nutshell, this version of the shortcut does not work on the Japanese version!

As a result of this, I propose that all NTSC shortcut times for Toad's Turnpike must be immediately separated, since our U.S. version has an unfair advantage over the Japanese version. I have long been an advocate of keeping records across each version separate, so this definitely confirms my reasons. I know it's not practical to separate everything now, but in the spirit of fair play, this must be done for Toad's Turnpike at the very least. I suspect that other shortcuts (both current and future) may be potentially impacted by this as well. Time will tell how far this goes.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile WWW David Wonn   IP Logged
Patricio
Titan
*****
Offline



6966 days karting

Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #1 - 08/18/08 at 22:00:20
 
Who cares. Robin has landed it (I think) and so has Shinji Masuda. Doesn't seem to be a problem.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
wheatrich
King
****
Offline



7569 days karting
Not Weatherton
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #2 - 08/18/08 at 22:17:06
 
I propose that all NTSC shortcut times for Toad's Turnpike must be immediately separated


Um, no.  It's way too far into the game to do this.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile WWW wheatrich   IP Logged
Etch
sage
*****
Offline

3.0+1.0=CUTE

6534 time runner-up

Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #3 - 08/18/08 at 22:43:19
 
I demand gab split charts as well!!! Grin
Back to top
 
 

Karters cannot create anything out of nothingness. Karters cannot accomplish anything without holding onto something. After all, karters pretend to be gods.
View Profile   IP Logged
KoopZ
Ninja
*****
Offline

i do what i can

7127 pics online
STL, MO
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #4 - 08/18/08 at 23:10:18
 
Etch wrote on 08/18/08 at 22:43:19:
I demand gab split charts as well!!! Grin


lmao, epic win
Back to top
 
 

the above has been certified by yours truly as a valid statement of fact.

Cooper Lovera, USA

a man among GODs

Honko wrote on 09/30/09 at 08:37:02:
Koopz ass pays for anything.

My Videos and some other randomness
View Profile WWW KoopZ thecoops702 thecoops702   IP Logged
Michael F
Titan
*****
Offline

wrvids.com

7449 movie reviews

Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #5 - 08/18/08 at 23:58:00
 
I just emulator-tested it.

The TT shortcut works exactly the same way in the USA version and the JP 1.1 version.  However, the shortcut does NOT work in the JP 1.0 version.  Other interesting points about the JP 1.0 version:

1. Not only does the shortcut not work, but also, when you get stuck at the beginning of lap 1, Lakitu places you down a little further back than he does in the JP 1.1 version.
2. I tested out both my FS SC 3lap TAS and my RRa SC flap TAS on the JP 1.0 version, and neither one desyncs (which means Lakitu behaves the same way in both versions in those tracks).
Back to top
 
 

See what movies I've watched recently on my iCheckMovies profile.
See what anime I've watched on my Anime-Planet profile.
My Youtube Channel: wrvids
View Profile WWW Michael F mjf345   IP Logged
Greg_I
King
****
Offline



7388 days karting

Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #6 - 08/19/08 at 05:09:53
 
I propose that we seperate Brazilian and Dutch players from the rest of us as they obviously have some unfair advantage  Wink
Back to top
 
 

Non-Sc: #17 (GOD)
Shortcut: #4 (GOD)
England's.....number 1! England's, England's number 1!!
View Profile   IP Logged
shadow
Master Ninja
*****
Offline



7565 costumes worn

Gender: both
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #7 - 08/19/08 at 06:00:22
 
Greg_I wrote on 08/19/08 at 05:09:53:
I propose that we seperate Brazilian and Dutch players from the rest of us as they obviously have some unfair advantage  Wink


I agree with this.  Smiley
Back to top
 
 
View Profile mk64shadow   IP Logged
Honko
NinjaHonk
*****
Offline

Toad Runner 24: Honk
Another Day

7120 toadgasms
California
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #8 - 08/19/08 at 07:43:45
 
Patricio wrote on 08/18/08 at 22:00:20:
Who cares. Robin has landed it (I think) and so has Shinji Masuda. Doesn't seem to be a problem.

I never landed the lap 2 and 3 warp, just the shortcut at the beginning of lap 1 as best as I can recall.  Very strange that the glitch only works on later versions of the game.

I always knew I was playing at a disadvantage Wink
Back to top
 
 

<Roy> this theme plays while honko tells "more like" jokes
<Roy> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOIjzmMZi_s

VAJ wrote on 12/11/09 at 06:26:06:
Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Shocked
View Profile   IP Logged
David Wonn
Elite
***
Offline



6766 days karting
Ohio
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #9 - 08/19/08 at 08:44:34
 
Michael F wrote on 08/18/08 at 23:58:00:
I just emulator-tested it.

The TT shortcut works exactly the same way in the USA version and the JP 1.1 version.  However, the shortcut does NOT work in the JP 1.0 version.


Thank you for clarifying that there are indeed two Japanese versions. I was relatively certain that I had successfully done the warp on the Japanese version back around '98 or '99, so I must have been playing the 1.1 version at that time. Andrew's copy must be version 1.0. So is there any way of telling whether you are playing 1.0 or 1.1 other than by testing this particular shortcut?
Back to top
 
 
View Profile WWW David Wonn   IP Logged
VAJ
Ex Member




Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #10 - 08/19/08 at 08:57:04
 
Greg_I wrote on 08/19/08 at 05:09:53:
I propose that we seperate Brazilian and Dutch players from the rest of us as they obviously have some unfair advantage  Wink


wahhaha I guess you called it skilled advatages right... or does it has to do with GABSPLITIFITY,,,,,,,  Roll Eyes Smiley

VAJ
Back to top
 
 

Mk64 Video Proof Page! www.Kart64.eu Video Proof page.
  IP Logged
VAJ
Ex Member




Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #11 - 08/19/08 at 09:03:39
 
MORE INTRSETING 2 know is that the YV SC 3lap WR never can be tied by an PALIER....

nobody can.... except you would use my discovery.....

PRESS START IN A RACE IS A DISADVATAGE for about a couple houndreds 0'02 0'05 minus.

How I know...... well
start doing yv sc 3lap try to get these splits on the first lap on pal when you use the SC...

11'16 - 11'17 - 11'20 - 11'21  you'll never hit it onless you use start (pause) weird isn't it..
that means the timer loose some real time and slow down the flap... so another error in the game

TIEING MYLES is only possible when you break all laps and press start from time to time Tongue

VAJ
Back to top
 
 

Mk64 Video Proof Page! www.Kart64.eu Video Proof page.
  IP Logged
In Hiding
Ex Member




Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #12 - 08/19/08 at 09:28:03
 
VAJ wrote on 08/19/08 at 09:03:39:
MORE INTRSETING 2 know is that the YV SC 3lap WR never can be tied by an PALIER....

nobody can.... except you would use my discovery.....

PRESS START IN A RACE IS A DISADVATAGE for about a couple houndreds 0'02 0'05 minus.

How I know...... well
start doing yv sc 3lap try to get these splits on the first lap on pal when you use the SC...

11'16 - 11'17 - 11'20 - 11'21  you'll never hit it onless you use start (pause) weird isn't it..
that means the timer loose some real time and slow down the flap... so another error in the game

TIEING MYLES is only possible when you break all laps and press start from time to time Tongue

VAJ


err am I missing something here or would u want to break his wr not tie it?
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
VAJ
Ex Member




Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #13 - 08/19/08 at 09:33:57
 
The Gaff wrote on 08/19/08 at 09:28:03:
VAJ wrote on 08/19/08 at 09:03:39:
MORE INTRSETING 2 know is that the YV SC 3lap WR never can be tied by an PALIER....

nobody can.... except you would use my discovery.....

PRESS START IN A RACE IS A DISADVATAGE for about a couple houndreds 0'02 0'05 minus.

How I know...... well
start doing yv sc 3lap try to get these splits on the first lap on pal when you use the SC...

11'16 - 11'17 - 11'20 - 11'21  you'll never hit it onless you use start (pause) weird isn't it..
that means the timer loose some real time and slow down the flap... so another error in the game

TIEING MYLES is only possible when you break all laps and press start from time to time Tongue

VAJ


err am I missing something here or would u want to break his wr not tie it?


yep I wanne break it... tieing is impossible ask GREG himself it has sometin to do with the roundding error of the game I call it GABSPLITS Tongue  Cheesy
Back to top
 
 

Mk64 Video Proof Page! www.Kart64.eu Video Proof page.
  IP Logged
KGT87
King
****
Offline



7006 holabolas
Gramado, RS - Brasil
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #14 - 08/19/08 at 11:23:33
 
Greg_I wrote on 08/19/08 at 05:09:53:
I propose that we seperate Brazilian and Dutch players from the rest of us as they obviously have some unfair advantage  Wink



agreed!!!! no, wait, i am brazilian, uhmmm

i didnt get what vaj said. 1st i though he was saying that pressing start will make u loose time, and by the end of his post i think that he means that it saves times by pressing it... i dont get it

and... leave my TT sc WRs alone!!!! Tongue

Karlo Tomazelli
Back to top
 
 
View Profile KGT87 149807032 stafter000 stafter666   IP Logged
MJL
King
****
Offline

AKA xVx -J-,
Jxcxb_Sxnsxx,
Michael Jackson's
Legs

6546 days karting
Moore, Oklahoma
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #15 - 08/19/08 at 14:25:08
 
I remember not too long ago a much more controversial issue was brought to our attention and we decided it was better to just forget anyone brought it up...
Back to top
 
 

Spiral out ..

.. keep going
-
Notable Hold/Held WRs:
-
Mario Kart DS (Moo Moo farm flap)
Pokemon Red (SS Any% / SS Catch em' all)
Super Mario 64 (Princess Secret Slide)
Sonic Adventure 2 (Dry Lagoon Mission 3)
Resident Evil 4 (Pro, New Game, Segmented)
Pokemon Emerald (Various)
Metroid Prime (Frigate Escape)
Guitar Hero 3 (Various)
SSBM (Ice Climbers All-Star)
View Profile MJL   IP Logged
PYLemire
Legend
*****
Offline



helped 7569 people
Québec Canada
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #16 - 08/19/08 at 14:41:05
 
Yeah that was strange that the second version and the american version which came out after were allowing a bug that the first version wasn't Cheesy
Back to top
 
 

MK64 Non-SC: KingA SC: LegF
SMK Non-NBT: vet F

-Is the place really called Bumpass?
-Yes, the town has a dumb name. No it doesn't affect how awesome the meet is.
View Profile PYLemire   IP Logged
Etch
sage
*****
Offline

3.0+1.0=CUTE

6534 time runner-up

Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #17 - 08/19/08 at 15:45:47
 
I like how the later version of mk64 added the shortcut to the game, it's a good one.  Cool

About teh Gab splits or whatever we want to call them.

http://www.mariokart64.com/cgi-bin/yabb2/YaBB.pl?num=1141782138/0
Patricio wrote on 03/09/06 at 19:53:34:
I hope you guys know that a PAL player created the conversion rate. It is not like we are trying to cheat you because you guys created it.


All I can say is that it is a great and confusing read.  I bet if you TAS YV sc 3lap for PAL you could crush the WR.  It's just a matter of going faster, not hoping the conversion rips you off.  As for rivalries same applies, just beat the snot out of your opponent.  Apparently neither system has the advantage, pal has a extremely small chance of having an advantage over ntsc but it is so small it's not worth crying about.  Besides, Pobre proved the conversion rate is indeed 13200.  I think sully said in 5 sentences what vaj took 6 pages to explain!

My Gab splits will take me under 5 seconds on FS one day. Smiley
Back to top
 
 

Karters cannot create anything out of nothingness. Karters cannot accomplish anything without holding onto something. After all, karters pretend to be gods.
View Profile   IP Logged
David Wonn
Elite
***
Offline



hit 6766 moles
Ohio
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #18 - 08/19/08 at 16:11:44
 
MJL wrote on 08/19/08 at 14:25:08:
I remember not too long ago a much more controversial issue was brought to our attention and we decided it was better to just forget anyone brought it up...


I think I know what you are referring to. Without getting into specifics, in that particular case, it regarded something that was possible on all versions, but was detrimental to the competitive nature of the game. In such cases I would agree, and oftentimes certain "killer" glitches are never made public for this reason. Those are the kinds of glitches I regret finding when they do happen, and hope that nobody else encounters them.

However, this recent TT sc situation is different, and I wish I had run into it sooner. The strat is already well known, but people playing on certain versions (specifically Japanese 1.0) are at a distinct disadvantage in that they cannot execute this version of the shortcut. If we were to find that some Australian PAL versions could do certain shortcuts, but the US NTSC could not, would anyone really want those times integrated? How about if something could be done on the Japanese NTSC version but not on the European PAL version? Seriously, let's be fair and impartial about this instead of just "sweeping it under the rug."
Back to top
 
 
View Profile WWW David Wonn   IP Logged
Patricio
Titan
*****
Offline



6966 days karting

Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #19 - 08/19/08 at 17:07:08
 
I'm not trying to be mean or anything but there just aren't a lot of japanese mk64 players on the site and few if any are active.

If we create a seperate chart there will be like two players on the other list.

@Etch: Two year old quote FTW!  Grin
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
David Wonn
Elite
***
Offline



6766 days karting
Ohio
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #20 - 08/19/08 at 18:27:23
 
Patricio wrote on 08/19/08 at 17:07:08:
I'm not trying to be mean or anything but there just aren't a lot of japanese mk64 players on the site and few if any are active.

If we create a seperate chart there will be like two players on the other list.


True, however we do have separate listings for things like the zero second glitch on Royal Raceway. I think a short listing or a brief mention like that would be a good compromise. Just have the highest time for Japanese 1.0 on Turnpike sc listed with a note stating why.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile WWW David Wonn   IP Logged
KoopZ
Ninja
*****
Offline

i do what i can

7127 pics online
STL, MO
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #21 - 08/19/08 at 18:59:38
 
David Wonn wrote on 08/19/08 at 18:27:23:
Patricio wrote on 08/19/08 at 17:07:08:
I'm not trying to be mean or anything but there just aren't a lot of japanese mk64 players on the site and few if any are active.

If we create a seperate chart there will be like two players on the other list.


True, however we do have separate listings for things like the zero second glitch on Royal Raceway. I think a short listing or a brief mention like that would be a good compromise. Just have the highest time for Japanese 1.0 on Turnpike sc listed with a note stating why.


the zero glitch isnt really a fair comparison though, cuz we dont know if that will ever be recreated, nor do we know why it happened in the first place.  plus, its up on the page for the very special reason that its absolutely nothing, and it happened in a real race.
Back to top
 
 

the above has been certified by yours truly as a valid statement of fact.

Cooper Lovera, USA

a man among GODs

Honko wrote on 09/30/09 at 08:37:02:
Koopz ass pays for anything.

My Videos and some other randomness
View Profile WWW KoopZ thecoops702 thecoops702   IP Logged
Etch
sage
*****
Offline

3.0+1.0=CUTE

6534 time runner-up

Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #22 - 08/19/08 at 19:16:09
 
Shinji Masuda  1'33"90  - 29"83
Robin Usher  2'05"28 - 32"82

I don't know about japanese times elsewhere but those are the only good times set here.  Obviously Shinji's are done on 1.1 but maybe Robin used 1.0, otherwise he was a complete n00bert driving those times.  A chart for possibly one person is dumb, I rather see Robin's sexy mug on the WR tally for the time set on his version of mk64.

It might be the only WR Robin ever gets. Wink
Back to top
 
 

Karters cannot create anything out of nothingness. Karters cannot accomplish anything without holding onto something. After all, karters pretend to be gods.
View Profile   IP Logged
wheatrich
King
****
Offline



7569 holabolas
Not Weatherton
Gender: male
Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #23 - 08/19/08 at 23:06:52
 
the Japanese 1.0 people can go out and easily obtain 1.1 versions.

Problem solved.  (darn Wonn going way overboard on trying to be fair again...)
Back to top
 
 
View Profile WWW wheatrich   IP Logged
VAJ
Ex Member




Re: Important discovery! TT sc Japanese disadvanta
Reply #24 - 08/20/08 at 00:54:57
 
KGT87 wrote on 08/19/08 at 11:23:33:


agreed!!!! no, wait, i am brazilian, uhmmm

i didnt get what vaj said. 1st i though he was saying that pressing start will make u loose time, and by the end of his post i think that he means that it saves times by pressing it... i dont get it

and... leave my TT sc WRs alone!!!! Tongue

Karlo Tomazelli


What I meaned was you loose time by pressing start.... it doesn't save your ass at all... Cool
Back to top
 
 

Mk64 Video Proof Page! www.Kart64.eu Video Proof page.
  IP Logged
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print