Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register    
 
smk mk64 mksc mkdd mkds mkwii mk7 mk8
general   mafia   smk   mk64   mksc   mkdd   mkds   mkw   mk7   mk8   |   problems   |   discord   irc
 
  Home Search Members Login Register
 
Pages: 1 ... 72 73 74 
Send Topic Print
Update (Read 36563 times)
Zwiebel
Legend
*****
Offline

Kmaccy-Fan

6670 days karting
Stuttgart
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1825 - 11/12/11 at 04:39:42
 
@Flo case:

I wanna deal with it now, not whenever or if he wants to rejoin. Also, not only for MKSC, but also for other MKs, since Flo also plays other MK games. If he cheated here, it would also affect his credibility in other MK games. Why wait? The longer we wait, the more information will be lost. And I can bet that Flo KNOWS EXACTLY why there were 4 false times on the charts. I mean, come on, 4 typos? That's highly unlikely, when Flo was still playing he checked the site anyway, and afterwards sending in 4 typos? I can't believe it. He also got talked to ago about it, he didn't do anything. Now when he was under pressure he just deletes his account and everything just to "avoid problems" and to start over again. Every normal player would just have deleted the wrong times and apologized and said it was typos, if he was legit and if he thought it were typos(also, I think Pierre knows exactly which were the wrong times, so we could maybe have handled it). But he just removes his whole timesheet.

Sorry, but it is just about time that Flo has to stands up for what he did. Not only for MKSC, but also for the rest of the sites.
Back to top
 
 


TvK wrote on 05/27/14 at 03:07:54:
You should all listen to Timur. He's an onion.



View Profile Zwiebel willstdubestimmtnichtwissen 302561687   IP Logged
Alicia Kart
Legend
*****
Offline

Retired.

7972 days karting
Paris (France)
Gender: female
Re: Update
Reply #1826 - 11/12/11 at 05:12:51
 
Flo plays SC also, so 4 typos could be possible if his times aren't on his top 5 and if he didn't write his times immediately.

But for Sunset Wilds and Retro Bowser Castle 3 (2 of his 4 wrong times), they were ALSO on Cyberscore, where he's supposed to post his strongest times, so he doesn't have any excuse for them (if you go on Cyberscore, you'll see both times are now removed, as I put them under investigation a long time ago)... Cos of that, I'm more embarrassed...
Back to top
 
 

SMK's profile : former or current #1 on all 4 rankings (PAL NBT, NTSC NBT, PAL non-NBT and NTSC non-NBT), Player Of The Year 2003 & 2007, French Champion 2004, 2005 and 2006.

MKSC's profile : former #1 on "non-LB and non-SC" site, Player Of The Year 2006 & 2007.
View Profile WWW   IP Logged
Detective Spril
NinjaSpril
*****
Offline

Helping solve
conspiracies since
2006.

6793 days karting
Roanoke, VA
Gender: female
Re: Update
Reply #1827 - 11/13/11 at 16:24:35
 
Zwiebel wrote on 11/12/11 at 04:39:42:
@Flo case:

I wanna deal with it now, not whenever or if he wants to rejoin. Also, not only for MKSC, but also for other MKs, since Flo also plays other MK games. If he cheated here, it would also affect his credibility in other MK games. Why wait? The longer we wait, the more information will be lost. And I can bet that Flo KNOWS EXACTLY why there were 4 false times on the charts. I mean, come on, 4 typos? That's highly unlikely, when Flo was still playing he checked the site anyway, and afterwards sending in 4 typos? I can't believe it. He also got talked to ago about it, he didn't do anything. Now when he was under pressure he just deletes his account and everything just to "avoid problems" and to start over again. Every normal player would just have deleted the wrong times and apologized and said it was typos, if he was legit and if he thought it were typos(also, I think Pierre knows exactly which were the wrong times, so we could maybe have handled it). But he just removes his whole timesheet.

Sorry, but it is just about time that Flo has to stands up for what he did. Not only for MKSC, but also for the rest of the sites.


Question: is there any proof that Flo is possibly cheating on any of the other sites? Unless there is, there isn't a point in investigating someone that is no longer on the site. I don't know why 4 false times ended up on his profile (were they all submitted at the same time?), but his reason for wanting his times removed is his own, no one else's. I don't know what his reasoning was, but I imagine he probably felt like he was going to be accused of cheating (which I kind of feel like has been done) and people were going to bandwagon to have him removed because people on the MB pick on him.

Also, the information won't be lost. We can recover any information needed to evaluate this should he want to rejoin (this is the Internet -- we can find it). So unless there is concrete proof that he did cheat on any of the sites, let this go and leave him alone. He doesn't have to explain his logic to anyone.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
The Gaff
Ex Member




Re: Update
Reply #1828 - 11/14/11 at 02:33:37
 
having met flo, he doesn't strike me as the sort of person who would cheat or want to cheat.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Nicola
Titan
*****
Offline

MKDS will never die!

6910 holabolas
Italy
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1829 - 11/14/11 at 05:16:22
 
A person must prove himself with objective proof, not with other people's opinions that are based on impressions.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile WWW   IP Logged
Zwiebel
Legend
*****
Offline

Kmaccy-Fan

drank 6670 beers
Stuttgart
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1830 - 11/14/11 at 05:25:53
 
The Gaff wrote on 11/14/11 at 02:33:37:
having met flo, he doesn't strike me as the sort of person who would cheat or want to cheat.


This is your reasoning? You know it has been quiet a while ago since he submitted that times(probably) so it might have been that he changed in the meantime. But does this close our case? No. I'm not saying FLO IS A CHEATER I just think it is possible he was frustrated about some courses that he might have lied about some times...which would, in the end, be cheating, yes. But that doesn't mean you can look in his face and see he's cheated in the past.

Damn, I can't believe no one cares about this.We let Fenner back on the site, fine, but that doesn't mean we can stop looking to keep our charts clean. When has been the last stream of Fenner? Has he proven all of his times? I don't think ANYONE is looking for it anymore, even though fenner has submitted some times in the last weeks I think. Now everyone blatantly IGNORES the fact that Flo might have been cheating. What's happening here? "I don't care, he's not on the site anymore?" is no argument, since he himself mentioned he wants to rejoin some times, and I know that he will be active in MK7 so it does matter if he is reliable or not. Gaff, I have nothing against you, but this 1liner again makes me think you don't have the time to run this anymore. Do you even care what happens? Does anyone even reads my posts fully?

@April: what in the world are you talking about, it MATTERS if he cheated HERE, we don't know if he cheated in other MKs. But that's the sense of the investigation: find out if he's reliable.

LOOK; I'LL EXPLAIN IT ONE MORE TIME:

Flo had 4 WRONG times on the charts. Pierre knew about this for a long time, and also said something, but NOTHING happened. Why didn't Flo already then remove his times? HE KNEW they were on the chart, still he let them there for a long time(which is shit as fuck in any case). But no one pressured, so he just left them there. Now, when we ask him for a reason, he just removes his times without ANY explanation for how it could have happened(by it typo or something). THIS IS NOT ACCEPTABLE. I want a reason, I want an explanation, but I alone can't force him to that unless the Staff is on my site. He won't care what I say, because in the end, I won't decide if he can rejoin or not.

Seriously, what in the world could happen??? If he's legit, there should be no fucking problem for him to be investigated, since it would come out that he's legit. Why, why is everyone so stubborn on just leaving the case.

Sorry to say, but if this is just dropped, I will not help this site anymore. And I hope TvK thinks the same. I don't want to leave all the people and active players like that, but I'm not gonna help a site that looks 52394720472309 hours into fenner to make him legit, and 0 hours to prevent other shit. This is bullshit, and I think you know it. If you don't have the time to deal with it, fine, but then say it.
Back to top
 
 


TvK wrote on 05/27/14 at 03:07:54:
You should all listen to Timur. He's an onion.



View Profile Zwiebel willstdubestimmtnichtwissen 302561687   IP Logged
ALAKTORN
Myth
*****
Offline

Resident weeaboo

punched 6519 kiddies
Italy - Viserba
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1831 - 11/14/11 at 05:43:04
 
this site’s management is laughable Grin
Back to top
 
 

ALAKTORN wrote on 11/22/17 at 05:24:31:
OH YEAH WHY AM I NOT GLOATING MORE

I PINNED DOWN KF!TIMUR AFTER 10 FUCKING POSTS

LOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL GET FUCKED

My YouTube

MKDS: 31 GODs, 28 Myths, 5 Titans, Hold 9 NoPRB CRs, Hold 11 PRB CRs, Hold 2 NoMT WRs, Held 7 NoPRB WRs and 8 Beta WRs
MKW: Held 2 3lap WRs, many Flaps
MK7: Held a lot of WRs
MK8: Held some WRs
View Profile alaktorn91   IP Logged
Chris
Ninja
*****
Offline

wao

helped 5654 people
Germany, Pforzheim
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1832 - 11/14/11 at 05:43:51
 
Timur activated rage mode

I don't really know what to think about that, I just saw that now... have to read the messages Cheesy

EDIT: ok, I read some messages. I think Timurs right Smiley
Back to top
 
 

Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin Shocked
View Profile mkchraizy   IP Logged
Detective Spril
NinjaSpril
*****
Offline

Helping solve
conspiracies since
2006.

punched 6793 kiddies
Roanoke, VA
Gender: female
Re: Update
Reply #1833 - 11/14/11 at 06:22:00
 
Alright, just to humour you (because I have yet to see any concrete proof that Flo possibly cheated here): when was this brought up two years ago? Someone link me a post and I'll look into it.

Edit: Still haven't found a post where the times were claimed as wrong (or even which 4 times it was). I'm still digging. I'm also compiling a list of every time he submitted in 2009 and his most recent timesheet (since that was the one timesheet I did not keep a screenshot of).

Also, for what it's worth, Timur: you claim you haven't accused him of cheating. What is this then? Tongue

Zwiebel wrote on 07/19/11 at 03:11:13:
Flo isn't only not funny he's also a cheater.


Maybe this is just me, but as staff, I expect everyone to be fair and unbiased and to bring up allegations if and only if there is concrete proof. Someone else's opinion isn't concrete proof, and the 4 false times in and of themselves are not either, since we don't know when they were submitted (chances are if they were not submitted at the same time, they are probably typos). If this means that Gaff and I are the only staff left and we go back to the news once a month/times once a week system that was in place before everyone else was brought in, such is life. But getting pissy because "no one's listening to you" (when in fact the time I'm taking to "investigate" someone no longer on this site could be spent doing other things, such as making sure Fenner's proof is up to date, since you brought that up) because you are accusing him of cheating with no other "proof" than 4 false times from two years ago (when we had one, maybe two updaters on staff, depending on when this happened, and a several-month backlog of news and times updates -- check earlier pages of this thread for details).

Also, since we are now investigating all the wrong times on the site, anyone who wants to bring them up, start sending me PMs of players with wrong times and I'll look into each and every one. If anyone has more concrete proof of Flo, bring it up.

Anyway, since you want an investigation, I'll give you one.
Back to top
 
« Last Edit: 11/14/11 at 06:54:45 by Detective Spril »  
View Profile   IP Logged
Zwiebel
Legend
*****
Offline

Kmaccy-Fan

6670 days karting
Stuttgart
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1834 - 11/14/11 at 06:48:08
 
Alicia Kart wrote on 07/18/11 at 05:55:00:
I ask a little parenthesis about Flo (Fantomas) : he has (at least) 4 false times on the site since a long time. Tom and Termo already know that, and when I told Flo about it last year (or maybe even in 2009), he refused to cooperate.

He's not the only one, but he's still active here, and is the highest ranked with this problem, so I'd like to see this issue solved.

For the other players, it depends what you think. I know that even at SMK, some very old members, former high ranked, have wrong times but are still on the site, even if it was admitted the wrong times were estimations !


I can't really tell you the posts back then, but I can show you this one. I believe Pierre, and it seems even Tom knew about it. Why did he refuse to cooperate back then? And now, when we finally step up, he immediately removes his times.

Can it be more obvious?
Back to top
 
 


TvK wrote on 05/27/14 at 03:07:54:
You should all listen to Timur. He's an onion.



View Profile Zwiebel willstdubestimmtnichtwissen 302561687   IP Logged
Zwiebel
Legend
*****
Offline

Kmaccy-Fan

6670 holabolas
Stuttgart
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1835 - 11/14/11 at 07:15:48
 
Just to say, the "Flo isn't only not funny but also a cheater" was merely to get Flo to talk. Tbh, at first I didn't really think he really was cheating, I thought he would have an explanation for it. I'm trolling him all day long because he really acts dumb sometimes, but really, I didn't think he was a cheater, I thought there would be some logical reason. So that post was just a troll, with maybe a little provocation in it to make him justify himself.

But as things went on, it's undeniable there's something totally going wrong. Just because we have not investigated it the last 2 years, does that mean we shouldn't now too? That's no good reasoning. He's not cooperating, he's not willing to even think about how those times got onto the site. Again, he did not even say that it might be typos. and he knew it for more than 1 year (like Pierre said) and didn't ask the times to be removed. How do you want me to act now?

I'll also send a PM to Pierre and ask him if he still has a copy of the PM he sent to Flo and if he got an answer.
Back to top
 
 


TvK wrote on 05/27/14 at 03:07:54:
You should all listen to Timur. He's an onion.



View Profile Zwiebel willstdubestimmtnichtwissen 302561687   IP Logged
Iceman
Elite
***
Offline

Strongest MC in my
'hood

missed 5300 mts
Lodi, IT
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1836 - 11/14/11 at 08:27:10
 
Zwiebel wrote on 11/14/11 at 07:15:48:
But as things went on, it's undeniable there's something totally going wrong. Just because we have not investigated it the last 2 years, does that mean we shouldn't now too? That's no good reasoning. He's not cooperating, he's not willing to even think about how those times got onto the site. Again, he did not even say that it might be typos. and he knew it for more than 1 year (like Pierre said) and didn't ask the times to be removed. How do you want me to act now?


Timur is right now. He may have been a little "hard" while explaining, but he is right. There may be another explanation, which we all hope, because is never funny to see someone accused of cheating, but an investigation is required. There is no counterpoint with that.
But, if i understood well, we have a problem: Flo hasn't anymore his MKSC. Don't want to accuse him, but this a clichè Roll Eyes

EDIT: This is the update topic, so a proper topic is required. Mods?

EDIT 2: @ Timur: News? Update? The world needs an update about our fight Wink

EDIT 3: i'm becoming an Alaktorn Shocked
Back to top
 
 


6th Italian Karter

SMK: War C, Italy #5
MK64: Elite B, Italy #5
MKSC: Exp A, Italy #2, 16 CRs
MKDS: Exp E, Italy #12
MKW: Int A, Italy #11
MK7: -, Italy #14

Activity: MKDS
Goals: Top 200, Expert D or better

Planning for: MKSC
View Profile the.doc   IP Logged
Detective Spril
NinjaSpril
*****
Offline

Helping solve
conspiracies since
2006.

ate 6793 donuts
Roanoke, VA
Gender: female
Re: Update
Reply #1837 - 11/14/11 at 12:13:03
 
Zwiebel wrote on 11/14/11 at 07:15:48:
Just to say, the "Flo isn't only not funny but also a cheater" was merely to get Flo to talk. Tbh, at first I didn't really think he really was cheating, I thought he would have an explanation for it. I'm trolling him all day long because he really acts dumb sometimes, but really, I didn't think he was a cheater, I thought there would be some logical reason. So that post was just a troll, with maybe a little provocation in it to make him justify himself.

But as things went on, it's undeniable there's something totally going wrong. Just because we have not investigated it the last 2 years, does that mean we shouldn't now too? That's no good reasoning. He's not cooperating, he's not willing to even think about how those times got onto the site. Again, he did not even say that it might be typos. and he knew it for more than 1 year (like Pierre said) and didn't ask the times to be removed. How do you want me to act now?

I'll also send a PM to Pierre and ask him if he still has a copy of the PM he sent to Flo and if he got an answer.


Here's the thing (and I hinted on this in a previous post): two years ago, aside from Gaff, there were really only two active news/times updaters: karterfreak (he stepped down in summer sometime) and myself (I started in June). If Gaff knew about the improper times, then okay, but I knew nothing of this until July of this year. No investigation was done because the two people who essentially did all day-to-day operation at the time knew nothing about this (or at least I didn't, and karterfreak never brought it up with me), and we were so behind in generally keeping the site up that if it had been brought up, it would likely have been overlooked at the time. This is why I keep saying over and over again: if there's an issue like this, then I need to know about it. If I don't know anything about it, I can't do anything about it. Flo didn't "cooperate" because there was no investigation to "cooperate" with. Pierre (to my knowledge) has never been a staff member of this site. Anyone is more than welcome to communicate with anyone else regarding times and such, but if the site staff doesn't know, there is no official investigation. (As I said, I'm not speaking for Gaff here as I don't speak with him that much myself, but I knew nothing about this until a few months ago.)

As for how I want you to act, I expect you to be respectful. You are more than welcome to disagree with me or Gaff or anyone else, but you need to be respectful of not only Gaff and I, but to others in this community. As staff, quite frankly, you shouldn't be trolling people, no matter what you might think of them. You should be setting an example, and any concerns you have should be addressed with Gaff or myself rather than "investigated" on your own, as you do not have decision-making authority on this site. If that isn't acceptable for you, you do have the option of stepping down. I'd rather have staff that works with Gaff and I, not against us. Trying to bandwagon TvK into stepping down isn't going to make me do whatever you want. As a matter of fact, what do you want? So far, I've seen nothing that suggests he did cheat, and he's not on the site anymore, so there is no question of removing times.

I have PMed Flo, and I'll PM Pierre, because all of the investigation info needs to go to me, as I am the one now investigating this. You still have not brought me any valid reason why this needs to be investigated, and no, his sudden desire to remove his times isn't enough, because he doesn't have to explain himself, to you or anyone else, but since this is what you want, your wish is my command.

Edit: FYI, I'm making a topic to discuss all improper/wrong/inaccurate times and this situation. I would appreciate this being reverted back to news updates discussion.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
TvK
NinjaTvK
*****
Offline



ate 5510 donuts
Belgium
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1838 - 11/14/11 at 12:35:37
 
I can totally follow Timur's logic. This totally deserves an investigation, but actually that investigation should have taken place two years ago, when Pierre told about the Flo's times the first time. I can also follow April's point a bit here. Back then people were lucky if their times were updated once a month, and if there was a news update twice a year, but the site was pretty much dead back then. So when Flo's false times were put on the site, I can understand that it just happened (I wouldn't be able to spot false times either when doing a times update). But when Pierre told both Gaff and Termo about false times being on the site, that's where I can't really understand why no further actions were taken. Apparently April wasn't aware of this, so I will fully support her if she wants to start an investigation to all the false times on the site.

Timur may sound a bit harsh (OK, pretty harsh) in this discussion and people who don't know may think that he's just trying to storm over Flo with a string of accusations, because he doesn't like him, but I can assure you that that isn't true. Like he said, he was joking in the beginning. He started this argument normally, but that's the thing with this section of the site. This sections tends to let problems die (I'm not making statements, this is what it looks like to me), maybe this is because the staff doesn't have enough time to deal with them, but the thing is that if nobody overreacts, than nothing happens.

I honestly hope that April's investigation will come out positive, because I have the feeling that somehow the staff is losing grip here. I'm not saying that you're not trying your best to do the best for the site, but (again this is just a thought) I kind of feel like you both don't have the necessary time anymore to fully run this section (April please prove me wrong with yoour investigation). I hereby also want to offer all of my power to help you with the investigation or to run the site.

Timur, I can understand how you feel, but will certainly wait for the outcome of this discussion before I make a decision if I keep doing updates for the site or not. But in any case I don't want the players who have nothing to do with this discussion to be the victims of some wrong decisions. I fully support your opinion on this matter, but I won't use the resignation from being an updater as a threat.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Zwiebel
Legend
*****
Offline

Kmaccy-Fan

6670 days karting
Stuttgart
Gender: male
Re: Update
Reply #1839 - 11/14/11 at 12:57:27
 
I said I'd stop updating if the issue was just layed down. As long as the investigation is in process and everyone tries their best to find the truth, I will not stop updating. I didn't want to threat like that, but the way April and Tom spoke made me scared it could be forgotten again so I just did. Maybe it was a bit harsh formulated, if I was too harsh I apologize, but my points still stand and I stand for my opinion.

//I guess we can finish the discussion here now anyway, if there's anything else we can use the new topic.
Back to top
 
 


TvK wrote on 05/27/14 at 03:07:54:
You should all listen to Timur. He's an onion.



View Profile Zwiebel willstdubestimmtnichtwissen 302561687   IP Logged
Detective Spril
NinjaSpril
*****
Offline

Helping solve
conspiracies since
2006.

6793 days karting
Roanoke, VA
Gender: female
Re: Update
Reply #1840 - 11/14/11 at 17:31:44
 
^Also, I came up with an idea that should hopefully reduce/eliminate issues like we currently have, but I want to clear it with Gaff first before bringing it up.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
The Gaff
Ex Member




Re: Update
Reply #1841 - 11/14/11 at 23:56:18
 
it wasn't dealt with because those players were inactive at the time and it wasn't a considerable amount of times which would impact the rankings. I assumed at the time they were typos. I wasn't aware that those times were on cyberscore.


This isn't a big issue, April has a plan and i'm with her on that. (pms not working).

I'm not saying having met flo he can't be a cheater, i'm saying having met flo it doesn't strike me that he's at all malicious or would try to cheat.

When flo and i met i asked him to play knowing that Pierre had raised some questions. The thing was he was long inactive so his level was lower.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Etch
sage
*****
Offline

3.0+1.0=CUTE

6964 time runner-up

Re: Update
Reply #1842 - 11/15/11 at 16:30:43
 
What is this I don't even...

Back to top
 
 

Karters cannot create anything out of nothingness. Karters cannot accomplish anything without holding onto something. After all, karters pretend to be gods.
View Profile   IP Logged
Pages: 1 ... 72 73 74 
Send Topic Print