Mario Kart MB - Print Page

Mario Kart MB
https://www.mariokart64.com/cgi-bin/yabb2/YaBB.pl
Mario Kart >> Mario Kart 7 >> Why it would be best to remove Erwan.s from the PP
https://www.mariokart64.com/cgi-bin/yabb2/YaBB.pl?num=1535303653

Message started by Frederiek on 08/26/18 at 09:14:13

Title: Why it would be best to remove Erwan.s from the PP
Post by Frederiek on 08/26/18 at 09:14:13

Erwan.s has a frozen status for a few weeks now.
In fact we should have asked Erwan to prove his times before accepting him. We knew he had a few times that were unproven. But there he suddenly was on the PP ranking 11th. And in the end he did make his timescroll and he was even so honest to confess that a couple of his NG times were never achieved.

Nevertheless I think it would be best if we remove him from the PP: He made up a lot of excuses so he shouldn’t make his timescroll and was sometimes completely ignoring me. He only made the timescroll because I forced him with a deadline. There were a lot of differences between his timescroll and his timesheet, sometimes big differences like on RIW. On top of that he says that some of his NG times were never achieved. We know for sure now that his MW NG and rBC1 NG are false and he deliberately gave those fake times to Aizen to submit them on the PP. Those times were also on the French mktrial site for years already. And his rBC1 NG time even was in the WW top 10. He confirmed back then that the time was real but it got removed there afterwards because he had no proof.

For several reasons I feel bad for Erwan because how things went, but he shouldn’t have lied in the first place. And yes, it were lies that he made years ago but he kept pretending they were real and all his attempts not to make his timescroll shows that he hasn’t changed that much since then in my opinion.

Full conversation with Erwan.s:
https://twitter.com/FreWarreyn/status/997340682116386816
and
https://twitter.com/aizen667mk/status/1016080168006406145

Timescroll from Erwan.s:
https://twitter.com/ErwansiS/status/1024231308380258304/video/1

Differences between the times he claimed and his time scroll video (the NG times are not included):
https://docs.google.com/document/d/18-gGSdF5yoGaQLJBXF5LU5WZ06iwRRC2TiiXhzu332Y/edit

Title: Re: Why it would be best to remove Erwan.s from th
Post by Nick Renzetti on 08/26/18 at 09:27:14

Could it be possible that he had some of his PRs on a different game cartridge? Not all of my current PRs are on my 2nd game cartridge so it would be the same with me if I were to do a timescroll

Title: Re: Why it would be best to remove Erwan.s from th
Post by Martijn Veldhuis on 08/26/18 at 09:35:53

5A7D777C7B78756746717A140 wrote:

Could it be possible that he had some of his PRs on a different game cartridge? Not all of my current PRs are on my 2nd game cartridge so it would be the same with me if I were to do a timescroll

I don't think so

Title: Re: Why it would be best to remove Erwan.s from th
Post by Frederiek on 08/26/18 at 23:23:00

No, he admits it.

Title: Re: Why it would be best to remove Erwan.s from th
Post by Nick Renzetti on 08/27/18 at 00:52:22

What if instead of banning people, you make people that have been proven cheating or lying to provide video proof for all their times?

Title: Re: Why it would be best to remove Erwan.s from th
Post by Martijn Veldhuis on 08/27/18 at 02:24:07

694E444F484B4654754249270 wrote:

What if instead of banning people, you make people that have been proven cheating or lying to provide video proof for all their times?

I understand your point. But lying to the updaters or cheating in the game deserves a punishment. It's important to have trust in people and if they lie or cheat. You'll lose a lot of trust in that player. So the best option is still removing if you ask me.

Title: Re: Why it would be best to remove Erwan.s from th
Post by Master Kek on 09/12/18 at 04:15:40

Funny how every time I visit this board, there's another cheater