|
Mario Kart MB
https://www.mariokart64.com/cgi-bin/yabb2/YaBB.pl General >> Mafia >> Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] https://www.mariokart64.com/cgi-bin/yabb2/YaBB.pl?num=1233362112 Message started by Honko on 01/30/09 at 16:35:12 |
|
Title: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Honko on 01/30/09 at 16:35:12 PLAYER LIST 1. Clark - Modkilled Day 1 (Mii) 2. Ariath - Killed Night 5 (Wario) 3. Brutus - Lynched Day 4 (Mii) 4. dragondragon - Lynched Day 6 (Mii) 5. EnigmaticCam - Killed Night 1 (Mii) 6. Etch - Killed Night 3 (Luigi) 7. Extol - Lynched Day 3 (Mii) 8. Fababu - Killed Night 5 (Mii) 9. Goose - Lynched Day 2 (Koopa Troopa) 10. Howes - Killed Night 6 (Koopa Troopa) 11. In Hiding (Tom) 12. IsThatAGoodThing (Scott) 13. Ivootjes 14. Adam_L 15. K. McAteer 16. karterfreak (Matt) - Killed Night 4 (Peach) 17. Lenny - Killed Night 7 (Koopa Troopa) 18. nstinson 19. oneshotbilly - Killed Night 6 (Yoshi) 20. Sportsguy (Tyler) - Lynched Day 7 (Bowser) 21. SuperYoshi1 - Killed Night 2 (Mii) 22. syzygy (Tim) 23. TJazZ (Benoit) - Lynched Day 5 (Mii) What is this game? There are two teams, Town and Mafia. They are trying to kill each other. You know which team you are on by the Role PM I send you. Mafia members know who else is in the Mafia. Town members do not know which team anyone is on. There are two phases, Day and Night. This game will start in the Day. During each Day, people discuss in this topic and choose to vote for someone to lynch. Post your votes in bold like this Vote: Honko. If you want to change your vote, post Unvote first. At the end of the day, the person with the most votes is lynched, and his role is revealed. Then night begins. At night, the mafia discuss secretly who they want to kill. One of them sends me a PM, and the player they name will turn up dead in the morning. Some players on both sides also have special roles that allow them to do actions at night. Once everyone has sent me their actions for the night, morning comes, any new dead bodies are revealed, and the next day begins. The Town's best weapon is the Day lynch, so they will try to catch suspicious things the Mafia say and lynch them. Meanwhile, the Mafia try to misdirect the Town so they lynch someone innocent. The game ends either when all the Mafia are dead (Town wins) or there are at least as many Mafia as Town (Mafia wins). This is a team game - even if you died on the first day, you still win if your team wins. So don't be afraid to sacrifice your character's life if you think it will really help your team get the victory. ROLES There are 23 players in this game: 17 Town (7 with special abilities), and 6 Mafia (2 with special abilities). These are the specifics of all the roles in the game. You will get a PM saying one of these things. The roles were assigned to players completely randomly with a random number generator. Town Roles 1x - You are Mario, the Town Jack-of-all-Trades. You have four different abilities: scan, protect, roleblock, and kill. Each night you can PM me the name of a player and which action you want to do to them. You can only do one action per night. Once you have used one of your abilities, you cannot use that same ability again for the rest of the game. 1x - You are Luigi, the Town Cop. Each night you can PM me the name of a player to scan. You will find out whether that player is a member of the Town or the Mafia. 1x - You are Princess Peach, the Town Doctor. Each night you can PM me the name of a player to protect. If anyone tries to kill that player, they will fail. 1x - You are Yoshi, the Town Jailkeeper. Each night you can PM me the name of a player to swallow. Any night actions the player tries to do will fail, and any night actions by other players targeting the player you swallowed will also fail. 1x - You are Donkey Kong, the Town Vigilante. Each night you can PM me the name of a player to kill. You can only use this ability 2 times during the game. 1x - You are Toad, the Town Bodyguard. Each night you can PM me the name of a player to protect. If anyone tries to kill that player, you will die instead of the person you were protecting. What a noble sacrifice by Toad, the hero of the world! 1x - You are Baby Daisy, the Town "Dancer". Each night you can PM me the name of a player to roleblock. If that player tries to do any actions that night, they will fail, because they are too busy being doing dirty things with a baby. 10x - You are a Mii, a regular Town member. You have no night powers. Mafia Roles 1x - You are Bowser, the Mafia Godfather. You and your mafia buddies (PLAYER NAMES) can talk freely with each other. Each night, one of you can PM me the name of a player to kill. The player who sends the PM is the one considered to be performing the kill. As Godfather, you will appear as an innocent Town member in any scans done by Town Cops/etc. You are also so physically powerful that you cannot be killed by anyone at night. The only way you can die is to be lynched during the day. 1x - You are Wario, the Mafia Roleblocker. You and your mafia buddies (PLAYER NAMES) can talk freely with each other. Each night, one of you can PM me the name of a player to kill. The player who sends the PM is considered to be performing the kill. As Roleblocker, each night you can also PM me the name of a player to roleblock. If that player tries to do any actions that night, they will fail. 4x - You are a Koopa Troopa, a regular Mafia member. NOTE: None of these roles can target themselves. Peach cannot protect herself, etc. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Almost Started] Post by Honko on 01/30/09 at 16:38:03 RULES -Days will last 72 hours, or until a majority of votes are on 1 person. If no majority is reached before the deadline, then the person with the most votes will by lynched. If there is a tie, the one that was most recently ahead will be lynched. -Nights will last 24 hours, or until I have recieved all night action PMs. If you do not send your action before the deadline, then you won't perform any action for that day. If you don't want to do an action that night, please send me a PM saying that so I know we can move on to the next day. -No talking at Night (except for Mafia). This topic will be closed during the Night. -No communication about this game outside of this topic, except between Mafia members. If you have anything to say about the game, say it in here. Mafia can of course talk with other Mafia anytime and any way they want. -No talking once you are dead. I'll allow 1 post saying something like "good game" or "good luck" or "argh" or whatever, but don't post anything that could help anyone figure something out. -No editing posts. If you want to add 1 sentence to a post you just made, that's OK, but never remove content from your posts, and never change posts that are more than a few minutes old. -No deleting posts. Same idea as above. Basically, all players need to have equal access to all the information in this topic. If you take something out, that unbalances the game. If something needs to be modded, I will do it. -If you aren't in the game, please don't post. No matter how obvious it is to you who the mafia is, let the players figure it out themselves. -Don't post any kind of picture of your role PM as proof of who you are. You have to convince people with your words, not with your PrtScn button (or your photoshopping skills). -If you break these rules, you may be modkilled by me. A modkill counts as that day's lynch. STORY This is just for fun. None of the information in the story is important to the game. In 2020, Nintendo released yet another Mario Kart game, Mario Kart X, which featured some ridiculously stupid plot-device technology that let players actually transform into the character they were racing as! The Mario Kart community gathered from all around the world at a big kart meet to play this game. Everyone selected their character and had a great time racing. Night came and they decided to get some rest. The night was passing peacefully, until everyone was suddenly awakened by yells and fighting from one of the rooms. "FALCON KICK! FALCON PUNCH! FALCON--AUUGHGHGHGHGHGHGH!!!" By the time anyone got there, it was too late. Honko had been mortally wounded. With his last breath, he begged his friends: "Show me.........your........................moves...................." Honko has died. He was Captain Falcon, the Unimportant Secret Unlockable Guest Character. All the karters frantically searched for evidence of a killer, but it didn't look like anyone had broken in. This was an inside job! They began to accuse each other, and soon they decided to put it to a vote that day to try to decide who was the killer/killers. I'm gonna send out your Role PMs now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Almost Started] Post by Honko on 01/30/09 at 16:46:08 Before anyone else says it. Man, that story sucks! It looks like a 7th grade girl writing a bad fanfic! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Almost Started] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 16:59:57 If a town player scans someone and finds out they are mafia, can they post their find in the game topic? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Almost Started] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 17:07:24 K, I just scanned Scott and he's Bowser. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Almost Started] Post by Honko on 01/30/09 at 17:08:25 All Role PMs have been sent. Day 1 starts now! With 23 players, you need 12 votes to lynch someone. The deadline for the day is 5:00pm Pacific Time on Monday. If you have any questions about your role, PM me. Have fun! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 17:14:09 Odds are the first person we eliminate will be a townie, so might as well get rid of the most annoying person. Until something worthwhile happens. Vote: Nstinson |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 17:20:28 vote: isthatagoodthing The way I see it, we should get people to explain why we shouldn't vote for them. Voting for them is the best way to get people talking, so lets hear it scott, why shouldn't I vote for you? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 17:32:56 Vote: nstinson |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 17:36:13 You do have alot of knowledge on the people from this board scott, If you are townie, you could be pretty useful for later on in the game, however, don't think I'll play easy against you. Last time we played, I got duped for giving you benefit of the doubt in IRC mafia. unvote: isthatagoodthing vote:Brutus Why are you jumping on goose's bandwagon so quick? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 17:38:27 7A70636574634E776374707A110 wrote:
because I'm mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 17:40:04 there's probably a few people here that will do the exact same thing scott. It's best not to assume it though. For all you know, stinson could be a special townie role. Losing a special townie this early into the game could be bad for us. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/30/09 at 17:42:42 Lol, this is taking Mafia to a whole new level xD Well played Honko, have fun sifting through all the PMs you will get. Vote: SuperYoshi1 Reason: No reason :D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 17:43:42 That is rather suspiscious... Lets keep that in mind while we go over the rest of the players. unvote: Brutus vote: TJazZ Well, what's your story Benoit? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 17:45:27 Thanks for pointing that out Scott unvote: Brutus vote: TJazZ |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 17:48:52 Fact is, Nate Stinson is not that intelligent, he won't contribute much to the game, he doesn't have a lot of confidence to stand out and point out something he might feel is suspicious and he's probably spending all his team reading some faggy books about how to organize meetings. There's a 6/23 shot he's a mafia, just like there is with anyone else. I don't see him contributing to the game at all and he's an annoying guy to deal with. It's an excellent vote at this stage in the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 17:50:34 Unvote: Nstinson Vote: karterfreak |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:03:38 I think Matt is mafia because of his eagerness to act like a regular villager. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 18:05:58 Thats funny brutus, I'm actually trying to get information for all of the townies to use, which will be vital in this game. You on the other hand have only been throwing out votes for no reason. By all means, vote for me if you think I'm mafia, but if you've ever played this game before, you'd know how vital the information you get early in the game can be. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:07:39 Matt stop fucking with me I'm onto you. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by TJazZ on 01/30/09 at 18:08:19 676D7E78697E536A7E696D670C0 wrote:
Well, I don't really have a story. I agree that it was suspicious of me to randomly drop-by in the IRC tonight, out of all nights, so I won't take it personally that you voted for me. But you don't have to worry about me because from what I can see I'm on your side. BTW, your coming off a little strong. Don't pull a Honko on us. ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/30/09 at 18:08:21 It's day 1, chill out :S Throw some random votes around and see what happens. Unvote Vote: Karterfreak :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by SuperYoshi1 on 01/30/09 at 18:11:15 6A6063607E60190 wrote:
LMFAO, I knew you would vote for me even before the game has began ;D Same for me : Vote : Syzygy :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Lenny on 01/30/09 at 18:11:44 My recommendation: no lynch Why the hell do we need to lynch someone? The likeliness of taking a townie out are way too high, PLUS we have absolutely no information or leads. At least tomorrow when someone is dead AND we can get reports from people we'll have more to go by. :) Vote: No Lynch |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:11:48 Unvote: karterfreak Vote: Syzygy |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:12:35 Nevermind, Lenny that latest post was wayy too suspicious. Mafia for sure.. possibly in cohorts with Matt? Unvote: Syzygy Vote: Lenny |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/30/09 at 18:13:33 You're right, Lenny.....but it's going to be hard to stop 23 people from voting left and right for the next three days. I think it'd be best to use up the whole 72 hours with a plurality of NO LYNCH votes on the board, so as to maximize the time we get to see posts. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/30/09 at 18:14:09 When you unvote you don't have to put the name, just unvote. Mick, put your vote in bold for it to count. I changed mine anyway. x] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by TJazZ on 01/30/09 at 18:14:35 Anyone who disagrees with Lenny is Mafia. No exceptions. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 18:15:11 I'm all for throwing random votes, but I throw my votes for the purpose of getting information :) So, considering i've got two people voting me, I might as well throw out a bit of info myself. Being a casual mafia player, I could come in handy later in the game when looking over information to find the mafia is important. I also know alot of the people on these forums, so would be useful in seeing when someone is acting suspiscious compared to their normal posting habits. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/30/09 at 18:15:15 Why aren't we looking closely at people like Clark and Howes and Extol and others who haven't even talked yet. They are super suspicious. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:15:24 I think only mafia would suggest us be sitting ducks to them. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/30/09 at 18:17:32 Why did Jones not make the cut? He looked like he wanted to play in the other topic. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Lenny on 01/30/09 at 18:18:58 665651505157240 wrote:
In the mafia that I've played before (ww.epicmafia.com), on a setup like this, no lynch is standard play. Chances of taking out townies are too high, plus there's a chance that we could knock out a PR. Lynching on day 1 is fairly stupid. In any case, you seem to be pushing quite hard for a lynch. Mafia? I'm going to stick with my NO LYNCH vote no matter what for today, I don't see any sense in doing anything else. ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:21:20 Lenny and Benoit, you two are sure anxious to accuse someone of being mafia. I'm pretty sure I'm getting the bigger picture right now. I'm valuable to the good guy team. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by SuperYoshi1 on 01/30/09 at 18:22:17 Actually I forgot to put in bold my vote, anyway, was just kidding :P Vote : No-lynch It's really too early to give votes for now, honestly I would like to wait and let everyone post anything, then I'll see... [smiley=bath.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 18:23:04 TjazZ, as the odds stand right now, we have a 3/4 chance of taking out a townie, and a 1/4 chance of taking out a mafia. Voting no lynch gives the mafia a free kill, while at the same token, takes away all risk of killing a townie. No lynch could be a good option depending on the posts from people, but as of right now, it's best to get alot of information by using votes instead of saying no lynch. If the last couple of hours we have don't provide us with enough information/suspiscions, I vouch for no lynch as well, but until then, I say we try and find the most suspiscious player and vote them out. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Lenny on 01/30/09 at 18:25:30 ^Sounds like a plan, but it's most likely going to end in no lynch anyways. I'll unvote for now and wait to see if suspicions arise, and if not, in comes no lynch. :) Unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 18:26:12 unvote:TjazZ vote:Clark You played really quiet last game, care to give us some reasons why we should keep you in? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by EnigmaticCam on 01/30/09 at 18:27:11 wow, this topic is moving fast. I'm heading out for a bit, and I'll be back later tonight. I'll make my comments then. Don't lynch anyone while I'm gone >.> |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:27:21 I know for a fact that Clark isn't mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/30/09 at 18:29:17 You can't know that. Karterfreak: I was joking when I mentioned him earlier....he's probably asleep. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 18:30:26 Why should I trust you Brutus? You're already suspiscious in the fact that you've said you were mafia on the forums, while saying you're a townie on IRC. Doing something like that either sets you up in a bad position no matter how you look at it. I want to hear what Clark has to say for himself. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:31:45 Clark has nothing to say. He wants to speak to an attorney first. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/30/09 at 18:32:55 In this game of Mafia you do not have the right to an attorney. The only way to save your hide is to speak up for yourself. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:33:19 Clark pleads the fifth. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:34:01 Clark is being awfully suspicious. Unvote Vote: Clark |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 18:37:29 Brutus is stealing the way I play. I want to vote for Brutus, but he's obviously just a wannabe mafia townie trying to be as cool as I was in the first game. Mind you, Nate is a townie too, but fuck, I'm bothered by the fact he's even in this game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/30/09 at 18:38:20 If Goose wasn't in this game I'd vote for him automatically, but since he is I'll just wait for him to incriminate himself. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 18:38:25 *Sigh* Brutus is just being stupid now. Unvote I'll take a couple minutes to decide who I want information from now, considering Clark won't be around until early tomorrow. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:39:24 I don't know what to say to that, Goose. [smiley=smokin.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 18:42:11 Lole Karterfreak. Brutus is not being stupid right now. He is being unreadable. What did I say last game? I quote Lady fucking GaGa. Can't read my fucking pokerface. That's what Brutus is doing now. He's definitely a danger to us all but I'd rather get rid of all the boring people first :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/30/09 at 18:44:19 Already a 64 reply topic, only an hour and a half after roles were handed out. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 18:46:33 I take it you haven't seen me in action on GLB ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by K. McAteer on 01/30/09 at 18:47:44 Etch is mafia, I know it. [smiley=bath.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 18:49:22 Unvote Vote: Etch |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by AlexPenev on 01/30/09 at 19:14:49 00053A3B2637153D3D2137520 wrote:
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=glb ;D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by oneshotbillyII on 01/30/09 at 20:05:29 I'm gonna look at this differently Vote: Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 20:27:32 I feel threatened. Unvote Vote Oneshot I'm going to have to look at it this way. Why would you vote for someone as obviously innocent as me - unless you were mafia? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Ariath on 01/30/09 at 20:28:28 I didn't even know that the game had started yet xD I thought it was going to start tomorrow... Anyway though, I haven't seen enough yet, so I'm going to hold out on my vote until I see more posts. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 20:43:52 Vote: Brutus If he plans to play this way the entire game, there's no reason keeping him, even if he's a townie. He's not contributing anything, and isn't doing much other than causing confusion. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 21:04:26 That's a great vote Matt. But if I may quote you for a second 5B51424455426F564255515B300 wrote:
Now isn't that exactly what I'm doing? I guess your new vote must be frustration due to being outperformed. My condolences, but this game is for winners and not people who whine about how little is being contributed. Not to mention, since when is "causing confusion" a bad thing? I guess if you had asked nicely I could slow down so you could keep up but by acting on gut impulses I believe I'm helping MY team, the good guys. Not only is the confusion ineffectual but it affects both sides the same. I wonder why you haven't voted to lynch all of the people who haven't posted yet - their contribution pales in comparison to mine! I understand if you feel as if I am out-doing you at your own game. There is a method to my madness and although you would be inclined to think that I am playing this way "just because" I would have to assure you it is just the opposite. My playing is effectual and very valuable to the townie side. Might I add, this is much opposed to your playstyle... 5B51424455426F564255515B300 wrote:
What kind of a vote is this honestly. "Last game you were mafia so I suspect you". Don't bash my choices and then make equally frivolous and doubly stupid votes yourself. Unvote Vote karterfreak |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 21:27:38 774740414046350 wrote:
Read bolded section again, I've already said you're suspiscious considering what you posted in IRC compared to here, so you fit under that credential. Quote:
Causing confusion only causes confusion to the townies, it doesn't affect the mafia because they know who they are. Confusion in end makes it harder to lynch the mafia.[/quote] Quote:
Your playstyle, as I said above, confuses the townies and the townies alone, and impacts us negatively. My playstyle revolves around getting as much information I can and analyzing it, sharing the info with other townies. I'm pretty sure my playstyle is much more useful to the townies. Quote:
My vote wasn't stupid in the least. If clark happens to be mafia again, he'll probably play similar to the last game and keep somewhat quiet. Voting for him gets him to talk. If he talks, he could slip up info that leads to him being mafia, or provide useful information if he's a townie. Your votes however haven't had any reason. My vote stands for now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Ivootjes on 01/30/09 at 21:37:26 We do have a lot of special roles this time :o I hope this will be enough to beat some of those mafiosi guys ^^ Anyway, how do you know that Clark isn't mafia this time Brutus? Do you know more beforehand or not? Vote Brutus Lol, so much replies. That's what you get for having 23 players :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 21:40:06 I dunno. I may know more than you suspect. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/30/09 at 22:09:56 Vote Count Brutus - 3 (Ivootjes, karterfreak, oneshotbilly) karterfreak - 2 (Brutus, Syzygy) No Lynch - 1 (SuperYoshi1) nstinson - 1 (Goose) With 23 players, 12 votes are needed to lynch. I talked to Jones and he said he wouldn't have time for board mafia. He's interested in the IRC one. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 22:13:11 is Jones still in this game as one of the 23 people? If this is the case, then that's really fucking gay. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/30/09 at 22:13:45 He's not in. I was replying to a post a couple pages ago asking why he didn't make it onto the list. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 22:30:06 Alright, sounds like it will do for now. I just like taking any possible chance I get to bash on oldfags, admins, past legends and the like. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/30/09 at 22:36:13 Too bad NGamer didn't sign up. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 22:38:51 Ngamer is okay, he just doesn't respond to IMs ever, to anyone. Comeasur is the one I really hate the most. Also, old guys like Derek Clark and marsh are severely overrated. Everyone sucks their dicks and they're not even part of the communities anymore. Like what the fuck. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Extol on 01/30/09 at 22:40:06 wow, i log in for the first time and get my role and already there are 4 pages of one-line posts... :P For now, vote: no lynch i want to keep reading and see if we can get any good leads as to who is mafia or not. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Adam L on 01/30/09 at 22:51:30 vote:karterfreak |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 23:04:31 What's your reason for voting me Adam? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 23:11:28 Apparently I'm not the only person who sees through your facade. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 23:15:10 Then why is it that every vote made against me has no real reason, while i've justified my vote for you? I have a feeling that I'm being teamed by mafia right now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 23:19:49 Only mafia would make that assertion... keep playing this way and you won't be sticking around for long. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Kevin Booth on 01/30/09 at 23:22:36 WAHAHHAHAHAHAH!!! I am the mofia... you are all going down!! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/30/09 at 23:26:14 If you say so brutus. ::) Either way, there's still a majority of people who haven't even responded to this topic yet. I want to see what they have to say about the current posts. also, LOL booth, you win the topic. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/30/09 at 23:32:56 Ban Booth for the duration of this game if he's going to spam our topic. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/30/09 at 23:36:31 Booth is clearly mafia. Although I still harbor a suspicion towards Matt, I have to go the way the clues lead me. unvote Vote Booth |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by EnigmaticCam on 01/30/09 at 23:48:27 Things I find suspicious: Brutus's first post is a vote without explanation, followed by a claim to be mafia. Karterfreak acknowledges the necessity of getting people to talk by votes, yet defends nstinson (who had 2 votes at the time) before nstinson has satisfied that by defending himself. Goose puts out strong words against nstinson: is this a mafia being quick to vote someone out or is this a good townie making sure the voting arguments are strong? Karterfreak and Brutus are at each other's throat from the get-go. Perhaps a mafia ploy to cause more confusion? I'm gonna have to watch them more closely. Ariath trying to lay low by saying he's not gonna say much. Townies shouldn't be afraid to talk, they should be out there trying to get other people to talk. These do not necessarily mean they're all mafia, just things I've noticed. We still got a lot of people left who haven't said anything. While I have my own suspicious, I think it's more important to get everyone to talk. No Lynch on first day sounds like a good idea, but I'm not convinced yet. People gotta feel the heat of the votes to make them talk. If everyone talks and there's no clear indication of mafia, perhaps we can pick someone the most likely and have the cop analyze them overnight. Vote: Clark First one on the list who hasn't said anything yet, let's hear it. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 00:00:39 7667524551525443745E45545B52370 wrote:
I'd like to defend myself here. Main reason I did what I did was because I didn't want people bandwagoning on stinson from the start. Espescially considering stinson hasn't had a chance to do just that, defend himself. What I did do can be taken the wrong way, but I hope it isn't. As for me going at Brutus, read the first two or three pages for an explanation of that. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Fababu on 01/31/09 at 01:05:48 Lol? I go to sleep seven hours ago and there are 4 pages of replies. In my opinion, Mafia won't vote for lynch until there are several votes against one person. I haven't read all the replies, so I won't vote until I have read them. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by In Hiding on 01/31/09 at 02:20:57 Christ, its only 10am on saturday and its already 4 pages of.. dare I say it waffle. lol I'm sorry but dont vote clark just for not saying anything yet, its the 1st day and he's probably not woken up. I dont understand why all the townies dont just admit we are? It'll at least form an aliance. I swear, on my families life that I am a townie. Who else can say that? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Jabes on 01/31/09 at 02:35:07 Yeah! What's to stop all of the townies from blatantly admitting that they're all townies? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by In Hiding on 01/31/09 at 02:49:34 are you a townie then? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Jabes on 01/31/09 at 02:51:54 I am. Are you? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by In Hiding on 01/31/09 at 02:56:54 yes, i swore on my families life. Ok, thats two of us. I believe you as you're not being anything other than simple. (not in a bad way). So i'll vote with you but we need to ask more people if they are townie or mafia and see what they say. If anyone wants to tell us you're a townie then do so. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Jabes on 01/31/09 at 02:59:35 I'm with Tom on this one. I trust him, so let's get this all out into the open. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Ivootjes on 01/31/09 at 05:02:18 Which family are you swearing your life on In Hiding? Your mafia family? ::) Anyway, i'm town but most people will say this i guess. I'm gonna unvote for now. I'll wait a little longer to see what other people have to say in here. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by %hat on 01/31/09 at 05:31:05 vote Jabes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by SuperYoshi1 on 01/31/09 at 07:07:06 Woah this thread is so quiet when America is at bed ;D I've read some interesting things and have some ideas, but I stick with my no lynch for now, I think some people still haven't talked yet... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/31/09 at 07:09:50 Booth says he's mafia so if that's the case then Unvote Vote: Kevin Booth x] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Sportsguy001 on 01/31/09 at 07:13:54 Is booth playing? It's probably best for a no lynch day one so i'll stick with no vote until someone looks more suspicious. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Ariath on 01/31/09 at 07:14:54 Alright, the way I see it right now, there are a couple of people here who seem really suspicious. The first one is of course Brutus. Honestly, why would a 'townie' claim first that he is mafia and then later that he isn't? The mafia already know who's a townie and who isn't, so the only people he would be messing with are the townies. If he was actually one of us, the why would he pull a bunch of crap like that? The next person I'm looking at is Tim. Tim blatantly stated "Throw some random votes around and see what happens." Odds are about three to one that a random vote would land on a townie. This should be obvious to anyone that thinks about it, which makes me wonder which side tim is actually on. Last, I'm wondering if benoit and lenny are in league with eachother. After lenny voted 'no lynch', benoit stated that anyone who disagrees with lenny is definitely mafia. That seems like a very strong assumption to be making, which could mean that either one or both of them are mafia. I'm still not sure if my presumptions are correct though, so I'm still going to hold out on my vote. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong about any of these. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/31/09 at 07:17:09 I'm said that based on what happened in the last game. If someone gets voted for chances are they will retaliate with a vote or comment. Now that may or may not help, but at least you can see how people react to things which lets you make better decisions. I don't see how that qualifies as "suspicious" behaviour. Remember, it takes 12 votes for a lynch. A few random votes won't hurt anyone. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Ariath on 01/31/09 at 08:23:12 Alright, I see what you're saying now. I still think that it's a danger to randomly vote though. If the person you vote for is away/asleep, other people could follow your random vote and vote the person off before they even get to say their alibi. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by K. McAteer on 01/31/09 at 11:05:38 Quiet so far today.. Lenny seems suspicious, trying to campaign hard for a no-lynch to possibly get the attention off of him, and make him look like he's looking out for the townies. vote: Lenny |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 11:11:54 Vote Count Brutus - 2 (karterfreak, oneshotbilly) No Lynch - 2 (SuperYoshi1, Extol) karterfreak - 1 (Adam L) nstinson - 1 (Goose) Clark - 1 (EnigmaticCam) Jabes - 1 (Clark) Lenny - 1 (K. McAteer) With 23 players, 12 votes are needed to lynch. Booth is not playing. Votes on him don't count. ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 11:15:09 oh unvote vote: booth |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Jabes on 01/31/09 at 11:39:36 I had a feeling Clark was going to vote for me whether or not he truly believed if I was mafia or not, seeing as though he's completely predictable like that. So far I'd vote No Lynch for the day because it's just too soon. The only people that seem suspicious are Brutus and now Clark to me, but that's only because he didn't have a reason for voting for me. vote: no lynch |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 12:37:40 LOL you guys are ridiculous. No lynch means MAFIA GETS FIRST KILL and then they essentially have the advantage since they started the game (like getting serve in tennis, an advantage set.) Might as well lynch someone accepting your not even horrible 6/23 chance of hitting a mafia because when the mafia kills the first person they are guaranteed to kill one of those 17 townies. fuck, l2play. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 12:45:09 I already went over the odds goose in a previous post, however, if we choose the wrong person, the mafia get an even bigger advantage, because they'll get two townies killed within a day and night, instead of only one kill at night. No lynch is the best option when there's nobody who's suspiscious, but right now, I still believe brutus is suspiscious. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 12:54:24 They won't get a bigger advantage if we kill a townie now. They will have less opportunities throughout the game to make a kill by 0.5. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 13:03:01 Matt keep making inflammatory comments like that and you're going to die in the night. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 13:06:29 Now why would I die in the night, unless you plan on killing me because you're mafia brutus. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/31/09 at 13:18:15 6A6F50514C5D7F57574B5D380 wrote:
For someone who comes across as so smart I can't believe you wrote less when it should be "fewer" :P Unvote Vote: Goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Kevin Booth on 01/31/09 at 13:20:29 636659584554765E5E4254310 wrote:
I thought it was funny. It's not like it was continuous and it was meant to be a lol moment. Two people actually voted for me?!?!?!?! seriously! I knew I should not have saved the goose. I say definitely vote for him, since I can't, but hey I can't be lynched either, so beat that! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 13:21:21 TAN HIS POKER |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Adam L on 01/31/09 at 13:25:37 unvote vote: Goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 13:27:10 Booth, please stop posting in this topic. :-* |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 13:29:40 BOOTH EDITED MY FUCKING POST. BAN HIM! BAN HIM! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 13:32:27 all your post said was "BAN THIS JOKER" anyways, but yeah, Booth, dont edit posts man [smiley=smokin.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 13:37:29 unvote Vote: Goose I am suiciding until Booth is banned. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 13:39:03 I already talked with booth, he doesn't plan on posting anymore in this thread anyways. So you suiciding is just being an idiot. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Lenny on 01/31/09 at 13:40:14 3D3B373535560 wrote:
In my defense, haven't I given full reasoning of why not to lynch? Day starts usually call for a no lynch because there is little to next to no information, although in forum mafia where everyone posts, I suppose you can pick up on things more. I would agree with throwing around random votes for now, but in the end, it's probably going to end up in no lynch. In any case, I wouldn't want the attention off me at all, even if I was mafia, because that'd make me an obvious target to get lynched. But still, in my opinion it's still too early to be throwing around accusations. Everyone can do what they want, but I still feel that it's in the town's best interest to no lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Etch on 01/31/09 at 13:48:35 All these people analyzing and shit are hiding something. You can't deduce who is and isn't mafia off the bat, unless you already know. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 14:24:40 You may not be able to deduce mafia off the bat, but you can find the people who are suspiscious. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 14:27:02 Unvote Vote: goose Since goose was mafia last game, it's very likely that he is mafia this game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 15:06:05 Vote Count Update Goose - 3 (Syzygy, Goose, Brutus) No Lynch - 3 (SuperYoshi1, Extol, Jabes) Brutus - 2 (karterfreak, oneshotbilly) Clark - 1 (EnigmaticCam) Jabes - 1 (Clark) Lenny - 1 (K. McAteer) Not voting - Ariath, dragondragon, Etch, Fababu, Howes, In Hiding, IsThatAGoodThing, Ivootjes, Lenny, nstinson, Sportsguy001, TJazZ With 23 players, 12 votes are needed to lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 15:09:17 I've noticed that syzygy, adam, and brutus have been voting for the same person over the last little while. Basically whoever brutus votes for, syzygy also votes for, adam seems to be doing it as well. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 15:12:02 Shit... he's on to us... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/31/09 at 15:14:16 In case you haven't realised Matt, this game has just started, and people have been voting for whoever talks really, not with any good reasoning. x] It was like this in the last game in that me + Lenny + Adam all posted within seconds of each other and therfore we were suspected yet only one of us was mafia (Adam). Unvote Vote: Karterfreak (for being too suspicious) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 15:18:03 I got Nathan Stinson to speak! NathanStinson (6:13:43 PM): only thing I'll say is, you'll be sorry if you get rid of me on mafia;-) NathanStinson (6:13:44 PM): but your loss:-P RyanWhiteGoose (6:14:09 PM): so you're Mario NathanStinson (6:14:14 PM): maybe maybe not! NathanStinson (6:14:19 PM): I can't reveal that for sure RyanWhiteGoose (6:14:21 PM): we can't talk about this in here NathanStinson (6:14:23 PM): but I'll be out tonight anyways:-P NathanStinson (6:14:51 PM): and I don't figure how you say I'm not intelligent, since I undoubtably have a higher GPA than you? RyanWhiteGoose (6:15:09 PM): that doens't mean anything RyanWhiteGoose (6:15:15 PM): it's a direct function of effort NathanStinson (6:15:18 PM): it does for me!:-P NathanStinson (6:15:25 PM): I don't put any effort into sounding smart online anyways RyanWhiteGoose (6:15:26 PM): which is a non relative factor to intelligence NathanStinson (6:15:31 PM): but, seriously, who do you think are the mafia? RyanWhiteGoose (6:15:32 PM): it's a game Nate RyanWhiteGoose (6:15:37 PM): I have no idea yet RyanWhiteGoose (6:15:38 PM): no one can know NathanStinson (6:15:39 PM): me neither NathanStinson (6:15:47 PM): no inkling of ideas?:-P RyanWhiteGoose (6:15:52 PM): anyways, I only called you unintelligent to get on you a bit RyanWhiteGoose (6:16:05 PM): well obviously I have ideas but come on, what are the odds of them being right NathanStinson (6:16:09 PM): I should say something about you being a virgin, and can't be trusted! NathanStinson (6:16:11 PM): oir something:-P NathanStinson (6:16:14 PM): heh RyanWhiteGoose (6:16:21 PM): only person I feel is mafia right now is Tom NathanStinson (6:16:26 PM): heh NathanStinson (6:16:32 PM): everyone always thinks Tom is NathanStinson (6:16:33 PM): don't they? NathanStinson (6:16:37 PM): he seems pretty suspicious RyanWhiteGoose (6:17:32 PM): Ok well I gotta post all this in the topic now |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by nstinson on 01/31/09 at 15:19:13 I only have one thing to say in my defense. I'm not the mafia. so there I'll consider my vote I'll throw my first vote onto Goose I guess. Probably will change it later |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Fababu on 01/31/09 at 15:19:58 IMO, non-lynch is the worst option that we the townies have. If we don't lynch, mafia will get an advantage of -1/0; but if we lynch we can kill one mafia before they kill some of us. The possibility of kill someone inocent also exist, but lynching can cause a mistake of some mafia; what could give us an advantage in next votes. BTW, I haven't decided who to give my vote, cause I find silly to vote without proofs. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 15:21:31 Don't be talking about the game outside this topic. Especially things like "who do you think is mafia?" Keep everything in this topic, where all the players can see it. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by nstinson on 01/31/09 at 15:25:11 well, dang, I guess that means no forming alliances, Survivor style We aren't even asking the most important question... WHO would want to kill captain falcon? Which people here have a grudge against him? Did any of us stand to gain anything by killing him? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/31/09 at 15:27:37 Unvote Vote: Honko>=D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 15:28:24 But I'm already dead! :( |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/31/09 at 15:29:01 Unvote >___> |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 15:30:10 lol it was just pointed out to me that Adam L is not actually in the game. I took his vote off the vote count now >_> :-[ |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 15:34:22 Wow, suprised i didnt notice that :-/ |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Ariath on 01/31/09 at 15:39:01 Ok, I'm pretty sure brutus is mafia now. There's no reason for him to act so weird if he's a townie sense the mafia already knows who's who. I also just remembered that Goose did the same tactic in the last game and turned out to be mafia. Vote: Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 15:47:52 smart vote bro ;)) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 16:05:49 ROFL this game is getting too ridiculous already. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 16:43:15 I'm a townie. I swear. [smiley=smokin.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 16:51:29 unvote Vote: syzygy I've just received undeniable evidence that Tim is in the mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 01/31/09 at 17:02:43 Unvote Vote: Brutus ...for double posting |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 17:04:47 You're so quick to defending yourself, it's undeniable. Just give it up already. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 19:37:54 Okay, finally caught up on 20 hours and a handful of pages worth of posts. By reading them all in one shot, I find it easier to tell how people have responded to things because I don't have to wait an hour for the conversation to continue. Right now Goose is on the top of my list, but I'll still support the no lynch. Goose and Fababu BOTH advised to NOT vote no lynch, and to me this makes no sense and even makes them suspicious. They know that we're very likely to lynch someone who's a townie, so the only reason they would support that is if they are mafia. If Ryan gets any more suspicious I may at least put a bolded vote on him for a bit to see what others think. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 19:39:12 Nathan Stinson: PLEASE read the rules. I don't care if you are smart, act smart, or are not smart at all, you should know that you've made two actions in violation of the rules already. Don't talk about the game outside of the topic, as the point is to talk ONLY in the topic. Also, when you vote you need to bold the vote or it won't count for anything. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 19:56:01 Ok, Scott, if it makes no sense I will try to explain. One of these happens Day 1 -nothing night 1 - mafia kills a townie Day 2 -maybe a lynch? night 2 - mafia kills a townie etc etc OR 17/23 chance of happening Day 1 -lynch a townie night 1 -mafia kills a townie The difference here is that the TOWNIES have control of who to lynch. They will get the 1st, 3rd, 5th, 7th, 9th, 11th kills. There are 23 kills in this game, so hypothetically (ignore people using special powers) they get 12 kills. In the first one, they only get 11 kills. This is STILL better than a no lynch because the townies overall will get 1 more kill in the game. 6/23 chance Day 1 -lynch a mafia great Seriously Scott, for someone who values intelligence and education so highly, you could really use some. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:00:49 Yeah but if they hit the 17/23 chance, already by day 2 the mafia has a larger % of the power than they would if only ONE townie had died. Doesn't matter how many kills the townies get, it's more important to make good kills. By not killing, that gives the townies another vote, and makes it harder for the mafia to swing their weight around in the day before we can tell who's clean and who's not. Last game we played everything VERY quickly, and it turned out terribly. Maybe we should slow it down this time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 20:03:59 Essentially, the point I'm trying to convey is that action is better than no action. By voting "No Lynch" you are essentially delaying the start of the game. It's as if the game didn't even start yet, and that mafia gets first kill (which will obviously be a townie.) The mafia is already in control as it is. Why give them more control? The ONLY reason to vote No Lynch would be in fear of killing Mario or DK, which is ridiculous because there are 2 of these people and 6 mafia members. The odds of killing one of these important townies is 1/3rd that of killing a mafia. That's horrible mathematically. Fuck man. Just FUCK. I need something to distract my mind from how retarded you are. http://guanabee.com/selena_gomez_10.2.08.jpg |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 20:05:26 My vote on myself still stands and if you guys are going to act like idiots all game trying to "detective" yourselves into figuring out who is mafia and who is not then please, kill me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:08:42 Doesn't matter if the "TOWNIES have control of who to lynch" when you have no real targets at all. No lynch will give the townies a guaranteed 6 mafia to 16 townies ratio after the first day, while lynching someone nearly at random will give the townies a 74% chance at being stuck with a 6 to 15 ratio and a 26% chance at getting a 5 to 16 ratio. If it was a 50/50 shot at having the 5:16 ratio, I'd say to go for it, but when we have hardly anything to go on because special roles, etc haven't acted yet, why in the world would we take a 25% shot at a small gain? By waiting until day two I think our chances at having a successful first lynch would go up dramatically, at least to 50/50. At that point we would be looking at a 50% chance at going to 5:15, and a 50% chance at going to 6:14......if we got the 75% bad chance, we'd be looking 50/50 at 5:14 or 6:13, BOTH of which are worse than we would be if we don't lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:10:07 6D6857564B5A7850504C5A3F0 wrote:
We're not giving them more control, we're trying to find out more information. The townies with special roles will be making their moves in the night, and we'll start day 2 one member down, which is better than being two members down with the same amount of information. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:10:49 It's not "delaying the start of the game," it's just being careful before getting the town into a lot of trouble. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 20:15:09 unvote Vote: Nathan Stinson Just fucking do it. This shit head IMs me over and over about the fucking game. He claims he is intelligent because he has a "good GPA" but all he is good at is organizing wankfests of nerdy virgins. Fuck, he needs to be fucking modkilled for his bullshit. I'm sick of people like this. At the very BEST he is pretending he doesn't know how to play the game (like I did last time) because he is mafia or some shit. Killing him either gets rid of a maf or gets rid of annoying cranial hemorrhaging. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Howes on 01/31/09 at 20:16:07 Finally read everything. Brutus' actions this game remind me of Goose's actions at the end of last game. Goose was mafia last game. Brutus is probably mafia this game. That, or he's screwing with us. Vote: Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:17:46 Rundown of what would be the situation at start of day 3, following those general numbers I put forth in above post: Using no lynch first day and lynch at 50/50 shot 2nd day: 50% chance of 6 mafia, 14 townies 50% chance of 5 mafia, 15 townies Using lynch first day at the random 74/26 odds we have now, and lynch at 50/50 shot 2nd day: 37% chance of 6 mafia, 13 townies 13% chance of 4 mafia, 15 townies 50% chance of 5 mafia, 14 townies As you can see, our odds are definitely worse if we lynch someone with nothing to go on. The 50% chance of 5 mafia 15 townies is a better result than the 50% chance of 5 mafia 14 townies, since we have more townies alive. On the other hand, the 50% chance of 6 mafia 14 townies is a better result than the 37% chance of 6 mafia 13 townies, while the 13% chance is the best situation but the least likely. Overall, both situations in no lynch are better than anything that can happen with a lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 20:19:15 you're never going to figure out who the mafia are just by waiting, hoping that clues will catch your eye and you'll suddenly be able to deduce the culprits. this isn't fuckin csi. howes you are a dumb fuck |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 20:21:14 Vote Count Update cuz I have nothing better to do :-/ Brutus - 5 (karterfreak, oneshotbilly, Ariath, Syzygy, Howes) No Lynch - 3 (SuperYoshi1, Extol, Jabes) Clark - 1 (EnigmaticCam) Jabes - 1 (Clark) Lenny - 1 (K. McAteer) Syzygy - 1 (Brutus) nstinson - 1 (Goose) Not voting - dragondragon, Etch, Fababu, In Hiding, IsThatAGoodThing, Ivootjes, Lenny, nstinson, Sportsguy001, TJazZ With 23 players, 12 votes are needed to lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:23:20 Well after a full week (end of day 2) we should be able to tell what's up. It will be clear which players are either avoiding posting at all (by mafia design or by lack of interest), and which players are posting a ton. After only 2 days it's much harder to tell this. At that point we could lynch a non-playing person who isn't helping even if he is a townie, instead of just lynching someone that's active, who would've actually helped. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by nstinson on 01/31/09 at 20:24:46 00053A3B2637153D3D2137520 wrote:
lol vote: Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:25:46 Nathan: read my post addressed to you, and what was this supposed to mean: Quote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 20:25:48 isthatagoodt (11:24:08 PM): BINGO NathanStinson (11:24:20 PM): lol your an idiot, scott SEE, he's doing it again. If you need a screencap I'll take one. I've had it with this fucking bullshit. AND WHAT THE FUCK NO BOLDED VOTE AGAIN FUCK MY FUCKING LIFE THERES NO POINT LIVING. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 20:27:16 *starts modkill chant* MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL MODKILL |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:27:28 Stop editing your post, Goose. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:28:25 Goose why in the world would you be advocating to modkill Stinson if you are not a MAFIA. You better get your act together quick, because you're now for sure my prime suspect. Don't think you're invincible just because we didn't vote you out last game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 20:30:53 I want to repeat this so it's absolutely clear, because some people don't seem to understand. Unless you are a mafia member talking to your fellow mafia, do not talk about the game outside this topic. Not in IRC, not on AIM, not by PM, not by telephone, not at all. If you have questions about the rules or your role or how the game works, PM me. Otherwise there's no reason to be talking about the game anywhere but in this topic. The point of the game is to make your conclusions from the information in here. Talking about the game outside the topic excludes other people from seeing that information and is cheating. I don't care if you joke about the game, "OMG IM MAFIA OLOLOLO" or say something like "wow thats a lot of posts." But any new analysis, or new information, needs to be posted here. Obviously I can't always catch people when they do this. But you signed up for this game, and these are the rules. Play it the way it's meant to be played. Keep everything here, where everyone can see it. If you don't feel like following this simple rule, I'll just modkill you and everyone else can continue playing fairly. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:32:55 I haven't done anything in violation of the rules, Robin. I was just making it clear to Nathan that he shouldn't be talking like that. He's often ignorant of simple things like this, so maybe he's not trying to violate rules. I'd also like to bring up the fact that jfk has been talking about this in IRC more than I'm comfortable with: Quote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 20:38:30 Scott, now you have touched my deepest, most sensitive, loving nerve in my body. Do you want to know why I want to get rid of Nate? Well I will explain to you. Take a seat and listen. I have made my living on the internet for the past 42 months or so. I am a very popular, well loved, respected person online. People look up to me for a laugh, a spirit boost, confidence in themselves among many other things. Mind you, I also screw around like all young men do, confiding in my peers to enjoy ourselves by having a good time with loving insults, funny images or topics and other trolling or attention whoring activities. Nathan Stinson is essentially the anti-thesis of what I am. Not everyone enjoys what I do, but almost everyone either loves it or hates it. While those who hate me are not always pleasurable to run into, I respect their decision because they make one. I run into issues with those who are too dumb, too careless or too simple minded to even notice that I am here. Nathan Stinson is one of these people. All the attention that I need to survive in this hostile climate comes from loving or susceptible people. This is all good and great, because in life, deep down in our instincts men are not hunters, but scavengers. I can find what I need to survive here by looking around hard enough and using my brain to work situations in my favor. The problem with Nathan Stinson is that he has nothing that I need. Nothing that keeps me alive ever comes out of him. He is not resourceful, yet he uses resources. There is an economic crisis in the states because an unresourceful population has used too many resources, and this is the very definition of Nathan Stinson. I help people out, make them laugh, teach them to have a good time, and in return I ask for attention, love and care. Nathan does not give me anything and he doesn't appreciate what I give. Not only this, but he does not even make it known who he is. After years of dealing with this man, I have only learned that he is what I am not. We belong in exclusive universes with no possibility of interaction. What occurs when our destinies do cross paths is not good. This is why I want to eliminate Nathan Stinson. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 20:38:48 I wasn't talking to anyone in particular. Maybe. There are a few people who have been bending the rules, and that post was intended as a final warning. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 20:39:42 Scott you are gayer than I am comfortable with. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:42:31 Ryan you have to set your personal opinions on people aside for a game like this. If you're a townie and he's a townie you'll just have to get along. If you're a mafia, then it's obvious you're just pushing to get rid of the person you think is worst. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 20:52:39 This is not personal Scott. This goes beyond personal. This is a far greater cause than an individual could ever be. Nate's existence and lifestyle dares to ask not only what it means to be alive. Not only what it means to live. But also what it means to progress. We are stronger together, and when we do things for each other, it is better. Have you ever noticed that when you are happy with a few friends, you are happier than if you are happy alone? The entire goal of life itself is to be together, give, love and enjoy life. Nathan Stinson represents everything it is to die, take and hate. A vote for Nathan Stinson is a vote supporting that we should all LOVE each other, let each other LIVE and PROSPER as a whole rather than hate each other and die as individuals. If we do not get rid of Nate we are supporting things like war, famine, rape, global warming, and socialism... and personally I cannot support such things which are the bane of evil. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 20:54:27 Would be really awesome if Goose and Stinson are both mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Etch on 01/31/09 at 21:04:55 I say we just lynch the people who talk too much. Mafia or Town, I don't give a fuck. Watch you guys lynch Brutus and it turns out he isn't mafia. It's just because he gives you shit but hey, some bridges need to be burnt. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Lenny on 01/31/09 at 21:13:16 It seems that a decision is going to be really difficult to reach... :-/ |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by MVT on 01/31/09 at 21:24:14 Goose is becoming a big poster all the sudden. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Jabes on 01/31/09 at 22:04:51 unvote vote: goose I don't care if he's mafia or townie, I can't stand seeing his posts anymore. Also, why would anyone talk so much if they are a townie? Why is he purposely trying to goad us into voting him? Either way, any way he's out of the game is much better for this thread... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 22:13:09 I agree with Jabes in the fact that goose is getting annoying. You cant possibly be that annoyed at stinson being alive goose, and if you are, I feel sorry for you.\ My vote however, stands. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 22:22:51 unvote vote: goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Etch on 01/31/09 at 22:27:18 Okay Joe, basically what I want to see done. Someone needs to die first, Matt you just don't like Brutus. ::) Vote: Goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 22:27:41 Matt the fact that your vote stands (which you have been eager to let everyone know) is a standing example of your idiocy. I'm obviously a townie, and for someone who seems to take this game so seriously your vote is illogical and mega-retarded. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 22:34:10 I've explained my reasons, you haven't even tried defending yourself for what you said on IRC (See: Page 1) compared to what you said here. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 22:35:19 I don't need to defend myself. No reasonable person could believe that I am actually mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 01/31/09 at 22:41:34 Do we really want to vote Goose out now? So far he's the most suspicious, but it may be just him being an ass. He's probably a + role and just wants us to laugh when we kill off our helper. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 22:41:45 Please explain to me how I'm getting to be annoying? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 22:42:31 I'm voting Goose so that I don't die. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 22:47:30 Well, if you won't defend yourself, there's not much I can say. It'd probably be in your best interest TO defend yourself if you're a townie though. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 22:50:05 You're not really making yourself look any better by posting this way Matt. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 22:50:41 At least I explain myself, unlike you. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 01/31/09 at 22:55:23 what the fuck are you talking about I mean honestly |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Goose on 01/31/09 at 23:06:57 7C766563726548716572767C170 wrote:
No, it's just that wherever I go, I start off well in the community. People like me for a good while, I'm a cool member and then for whatever reason it all goes to Hell. This has nothing to do with the mafia game, but if people think I am annoying, then it's just my entire life story all over again. The internet is really all I have these days, and as pathetic as that sounds, I feel like I belong when I am here. You guys are cool and accepted me in with open arms, and now I'm screwing it all up. This just happens to me all the damn time and I don't know why :( I think I'm a pretty cool, likeable guy, yet after a few months of being around people, half the population ends up hating me. Right now on the elite I have a 20 post/day cap on the boards because the admin hate me so much, and over at GLB any topic I make gets labelled as trolling, attention whoring or general failure :( It's getting to the point where I just expect it will happen and well, on the surface it doesn't bother me much since I am so used to it, but deep down inside, the lack of "belonging" really kills me. I'm failing university and I attribute that to not feeling like I "belong" there (it's so big and I have no friends there.) Belonging is only on the 2nd level of Maslow's Hierarchy of Human Needs... I do get sleep, food and shelter so without it there's not much more advancing I can possibly do with my life. I just feel like such a FUCKING FAILURE OF A PERSON whenever this fucking shit happens. Anyways, I know that by posting this you will probably only hate me more and think even more lowly of me... and that really kills me on the inside. I'm just asking you guys, please give me a chance. Kill me all you want in this game, I don't care, but just for real outside of this game, give me a chance :( |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by karterfreak on 01/31/09 at 23:11:46 Goose, at least you're making an honest attempt at defending yourself. My post was aimed at brutus, but you posting does good too :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 01/31/09 at 23:36:49 Vote Count Update - once more for the night Brutus - 5 (karterfreak, oneshotbilly, Ariath, Syzygy, Howes) Goose - 3 (Jabes, Brutus, Etch) No Lynch - 2 (SuperYoshi1, Extol) Clark - 1 (EnigmaticCam) Jabes - 1 (Clark) Lenny - 1 (K. McAteer) nstinson - 1 (Goose) Not voting - dragondragon, Fababu, In Hiding, IsThatAGoodThing, Ivootjes, Lenny, nstinson, Sportsguy001, TJazZ With 23 players, 12 votes are needed to lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Kevin Booth on 02/01/09 at 00:07:02 OK I said I wasn't gonna post again, but well, I guess it calls for it. Note: I AM NOT IN THE GAME, BUT I SHOULD POST, so I'll make it quick. Ryan White, the reason you get into trouble is you don't get over yourself. You have this sense of pride that gets in the way, and you present a "i'm holyer than you" image. You have like no tolerance of others, and yet you expect others to tolerate you. Really if you would just get over yourself and let me people like Stinson have their fun, within reason, you wouldn't be seen like this. Show some humility and I know people would come around. Hell I think some people still think you are alright. I'm not honestly one of them, but hey, does it really matter in the end what Booth thinks? As far as Stinson goes, yes he has behaviors that can get on ones nerves, but he has a good heart, and means well, and I have met the guy a few times, so I guess that's why Ryan when you say you know the guy, I take offense to that cause I am pretty sure I know him better than you. Ok, I'm going to try to resist posting anymore. Maybe I should ban myself from the topic so Im not tempted lol. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by aidan foyel on 02/01/09 at 00:33:20 ok well im not in the game but i was reading this and im going 2 say something about wat has happened! plz dont criticize me if u dont agree with me! ok goose ive actually never met stinson at all and he probably doesnt know me but he seems like a nice person and if u dont like him then so be it but there is no need 2 over exaggerate it. I mean there r worse things that happen here then really hateing a particular person! Speaking of goose i have nothing against u! U seem like a nice person and i know how u feel by the way u r being treated! I mean it happens 2 me as well except i feel left out sometimes cause i only have 1 close friend and a couple of gd ones. So thats all im gonna say! ;D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Fababu on 02/01/09 at 03:46:01 417B5C60697C494F67676C5C6061666F080 wrote:
I'll try to defend myself. IMO, the only way that the town have to win is having the iniciative. If the town remains quiet, mafia will keep quiet too, what help them. But if we take attention to the posts, the pattern of votes of the people, the behaviour... mafia will become nervous and they will probably make a mistake. I'm not saying that we have to vote someone by the force, I say that if we find something that seems very suspicious, it will be good to vote for him, at least for see how he react. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by In Hiding on 02/01/09 at 05:08:54 vote goose if for no other reason than i can't work him out - he's simply to different to me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by TJazZ on 02/01/09 at 05:27:01 With all that being said, the "obvious" question is now: which bandwagon are people going follow? Goose or Brutus? Right? Well, you know what I say, WRONG! THAT'S WHAT THE MAFIA WANT YOU TO DO! Here's my theory so far: It's no secret that Goose and Brutus have been stirring up some commotion in here and for that reason, they both have the highest number of votes so far. They both make it pretty difficult to be read. So, let's think. What if at least one of them is Town? Well, in this case the mafia would jump all over that shit and make it seem as though the votes are piling up naturally for one of them and next thing you know there's one Townie down the drain, JUST LIKE THE MAFIA WANT. What if they are both Mafia? I feel the odds for this are very unlikely but nevertheless, I think they would change their posting habits because it's clear, at this rate, that one of the two are going to be lynched. The question now is : who REALLY started to get the ball rolling towards Goose after the initial handful of votes? In my mind, THOSE people are the most suspicious. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by EnigmaticCam on 02/01/09 at 07:54:20 This thread is moving too fast, and today is superbowl sunday. I'm not gonna get much of a chance to reread and analyze. Can we possibly extend the deadline till end of day tomorrow? Unvote Vote: No Lynch Just in case it ends before I get a chance to come back |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by nstinson on 02/01/09 at 08:05:26 wow, Booth defending me? :-* I honestly don't have a problem with Goose either. I think he'd be a cool guy in person, and is just different online, because I know I am the same way. Oh well:) I just messaged him originally because he said I was stupid, and I let it get to me. my vote still stands as of now unless Brutus can get give a good reason why he's not a mafia! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 02/01/09 at 08:18:17 That's stupid asking for a "good" reason. Anyone could say anything and noone may have a clue whether the truth is being told or not... Unvote Vote: NStinson |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Fababu on 02/01/09 at 08:45:36 303137382F5C0 wrote:
53694E727B6E5B5D75757E4E7273747D1A0 wrote:
6E4942434558736E4359485E494D592C0 wrote:
Those 3 seems important for me, specially TJazz one. Lenny's idea is good: no vote until we are sure of who are we voting. Scott reply doesn't seem suspicious for me. But TJazz is weird, might he be a mafia who follows the idea of Lenny trying to eliminate townies who are voting for lynch? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 02/01/09 at 09:55:54 507F6A767F704D6A77706D71701E0 wrote:
I'm not mafia because I got a PM from robin which told me that I am a mii. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/01/09 at 10:00:38 73544440544759350 wrote:
I'll try to defend myself. IMO, the only way that the town have to win is having the iniciative. If the town remains quiet, mafia will keep quiet too, what help them. [/quote] I didn't say we should remain quiet. It's fine to put pressure on people etc, but I think the best result at this point would be to play it safe, because we don't want to kill off townies prematurely. Ben: Kind of see what you're saying. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 02/01/09 at 10:06:08 It's the exact same thing as the description of the Mii character in the first post. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/01/09 at 10:09:37 Brutus that's not a very strong reason. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/01/09 at 10:11:18 Damnit, more people chatting about the game outside of the topic. Robin maybe you need to take a stand against this. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/01/09 at 10:12:13 Just now: [12:10:18] -->| snakeplissken (~clarkthes@ppp-0-82.edin-b-1.access.uk.tiscali.com) has joined #mariokart [12:10:22] <jfk> hey clark [12:10:23] <jfk> i think ur mafia [12:10:24] <IsThatAGoodThing> Hi snakeplissken [12:10:25] <snakeplissken> hey yunus [12:10:28] <snakeplissken> i aint mafia [12:10:31] <Fababu> hi [12:10:32] <snakeplissken> i was last game [12:10:32] <jfk> says the mafia [12:10:37] <jfk> I think you're mafia along with karterfreak [12:10:49] <snakeplissken> i wouldbt get given mafia 2 games in a row [12:10:58] <jfk> why not [12:10:59] <snakeplissken> hi scott [12:11:02] <snakeplissken> he wankabu [12:11:10] <snakeplissken> not fair on the others [12:11:16] <Fababu> you have the same possibility tahn everyone [12:11:40] <snakeplissken> robin told me thier is more of a chance of new players getting the bigger roles [12:11:49] <jfk> b/c thee's more new players [12:12:00] <jfk> the roles were given randomly [12:12:04] <snakeplissken> yeah, and also people who have had power roles wouldnt get them |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/01/09 at 10:13:36 [12:13:01] <snakeplissken> i just aint gonna post much in there and slip under the radar [12:13:05] <snakeplissken> so i dont get killed THIS is what he did last time, and he was mafia. I won't stand for such. Clark is suddenly a big target, IMO. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/01/09 at 10:14:23 Jesus will they ever stop: [12:13:17] <Fababu> bah, that's boring [12:13:28] <jfk> well the same fucktards that are advocating lynching me will go after me [12:13:32] <jfk> because they have no brain [12:13:33] <snakeplissken> goose more than makes up for my lack of posting [12:13:47] <snakeplissken> joe is mafia btw [12:13:51] <snakeplissken> i know this 100% [12:13:55] <jfk> Scott you are such a narc [12:14:12] <Fababu> vote for him so |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 02/01/09 at 10:14:33 Well it won't be considered posting outside of the topic as long as you copypaste everything we say from the chat to the thread. Thanks scott! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/01/09 at 10:15:27 No way for you to get in trouble unless I do post it here. I'm not going to stand for outright abuse of the rules like this. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/01/09 at 10:16:30 Clark the only way you could know if Joe is mafia is if you talked to him outside of this topic, which would get you BOTH in trouble. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 02/01/09 at 10:18:23 Robin said himself that you can't talk about who you think is who but you can joke about it and stuff. All me and clark did were joke at first and then discuss the distribution of power roles, not make any interpretations of who we thought was who. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by %hat on 02/01/09 at 10:18:38 Im making no secret of that fact Scott. As can be seen from your earlier posts. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/01/09 at 10:29:23 That wasn't joking, Brutus. The situation made both Fababu and I uncomfortable. He even left because you two were chatting too much. [12:19:14] <Fababu> i think i will go out a bit, i prefer to look for my own guesses about the game |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Brutus on 02/01/09 at 10:31:45 [12:10:18] -->| snakeplissken (~clarkthes@ppp-0-82.edin-b-1.access.uk.tiscali.com) has joined #mariokart [12:10:22] <jfk> hey clark [12:10:23] <jfk> i think ur mafia seems serious to me |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by nstinson on 02/01/09 at 10:50:21 unvote vote: Scott |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by %hat on 02/01/09 at 10:51:02 Stinson just mugged off Scott infront of his pals. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Syzygy on 02/01/09 at 11:03:00 Stop posting so much Scott and Brutus :S |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Etch on 02/01/09 at 11:58:09 Yea srsly, fuck off with this irc nonsense. I like Benoit's theory but like anything so far, the reverse can also be true. These guys are too stupid to trust! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by nstinson on 02/01/09 at 12:04:36 27252A2A2B2A272825362F440 wrote:
my specialty |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Honko on 02/01/09 at 12:37:19 Dammit. You'd think people who come to a forum for Mario Kart competition would understand something as simple as rules. If you play MK on an emulator, you're off the site. It's a simple rule, people follow it. This game has a simple rule too. If you share information or try to influence people's play outside this topic, you're out of the game. I explain this rule clearly, I warn people multiple times in person, but for some reason not everyone is capable of following it. If I personally ask you to follow the rules, and you say "fuck the rules," then I say fuck you, you're out of the game. Clark has been modkilled. He was a Mii. This counts as today's lynch. The Day is over, and it's now Night. Send in your actions for Night 1 via PM to me before tomorrow at 12 Noon Pacific time. There's no talking during night (except for Mafia to Mafia). |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 1] Post by Honko on 02/02/09 at 11:21:24 After an unsuccessful day of accusations, the players went to sleep again. This time they were awakened, not by the sound of fighting, but of complaining. "You've got to be kidding! Why do I always get killed on the first night?" said EnigmaticCam. EnigmaticCam has been killed. He was a Mii. As they realized that they had lost another of their own, the players' tempers once again rose. They started throwing accusations again as the 2nd day began. It is now Day 2. The deadline for a lynch is Noon Pacific time on Thursday. With 21 players alive, 11 votes are needed for a majority. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by Fababu on 02/02/09 at 11:36:33 6C7D485F4B484E596E445F4E41482D0 wrote:
Just a few posts of EnigmaticCam on the game, but I find this pretty interesting. I want to hear your opinions about that guys, maybe some of them get nervous when they had read his post and mafia decided to kill him? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by SuperYoshi1 on 02/02/09 at 12:20:41 Haha finally reopened ! I was writing a post about how ridiculous this game has turned out with people breaking the rules several times, or, talking about things which have nothing to do with the game, when Honko modkilled Clark and closed the thread >___< Well at least I was for the modkill... too bad it's was a townie (at least a simple mii, like Cam :() I think I'll need to reread most of the posts (I don't have enough time now...) , in the future those ones would probably be interesting clues tu find out the mafia guys [smiley=evil.gif] IMO Goose and Brutus are getting too much the attention by their acts and posts, indeed I don't know if they're trying to help us or to confuse us :-/ and anyway it's bad for both, don't matter if they are townies or mafia. I think mafia could get a benefit if they turned out to be townies, since they could easily avoid the attention. Maybe we have to be careful about the people who barely post here ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Ariath on 02/02/09 at 12:21:59 Well, looking at his post, there are obviously 4 people on there that are still alive. One of them being myself, I can promise you that I am a townie. He is referring to a post I made on page 3 in which I had said that I wanted to wait for more discussion to vote, simply because I didn't want to vote off a townie the first day. He obviously interpreted this the wrong way though. That being said, there is still the matter of goose, karterfreak, and Brutus. Obviously, I still find Brutus the most suspicious as I did before, for the same reasons. Moving on though, karterfreak may be annoying, but he shows no signs of being mafia. Goose stills puzzles me though. On one hand, it is unlikely that he's mafia two games in a row, but on the other, he's still acting very weird for being a townie. Putting aside that last paragraph, I don't think that it's likely that any of the people on that list are mafia. I don't believe that the mafia would kill cam if they were on that list, for fear of creating suspicion. This is just my two cents. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 1] Post by EnigmaticCam on 02/02/09 at 12:23:43 1B30372B36590 wrote:
lol pretty much. Ah well, have fun guys :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by karterfreak on 02/02/09 at 12:31:52 @ Fababu: Considering I'm up in the post by EnigmaticCam, I feel I should say that if anyone wants to question me, please go right ahead. As guilty as it may make me sound due to me being in EnigmaticCam's post, I'd like to point out that in previous mafia games I've played, that a common mafia strategy is to kill people who have suspiscions against a majority of people to have others turn on the people who were mentioned by the person killed. The mafia could be employing this strategy, which would mean Brutus, Stinson, Goose and I are all innocents. I think we should get the people who haven't said anything yet to talk. The fact that they've said nothing so far leaves me wondering what they're hiding. The topic has been around more than long enough for everyone to have posted at least once. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Brutus on 02/02/09 at 12:53:20 that's precisely what I was going to say before I saw your post |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Fababu on 02/02/09 at 13:06:45 ^Really? What a coincidence. Bah, don't worry, I'm just joking. I think that townies victory will be hard if we don't start to speak more, because if not it will be hard to get some conclusions. Howes, I think that you made a good game in last mafia, so I want to listen your opinion: apart from Brutus (who seems like the most suspicious for some people), who do you think that could be mafia? BTW, we have a lot of townies with special roles, I wanna listen some deductions about people who are able to scan; maybe it will open definitely our eyes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/02/09 at 13:39:41 Ahh, finally back open. Anyone think what Clark was going on about Joe being 100% mafia has any value? He was probably just jacking around the whole time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/02/09 at 13:42:00 Jacking around? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Howes on 02/02/09 at 13:50:44 This game is more confusing than the last game... :( Brutus still seems suspicious, but he is probably just messing with our heads for his own enjoyment. A fair amount of people still haven't posted yet, or have posted very little. Could they be hiding something? Some of these people: Extol, dragondragon, and K. McAteer. These people need to speak up or else they look suspicious. So far, there isn't enough evidence to lynch anyone. A large portion of the replies so far have been complaining about IRC, or people complaining about each other. It's probably still a bad idea to lynch anyone. If we wait now, voting patterns will start to emerge. Vote: No Lynch If people were wondering why I have been quiet for most of the game, I was out of town from after school Friday to late Saturday night. Yesterday, I had an excess of homework, and I just got home from school today (plus the topic was locked). |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Jabes on 02/02/09 at 14:19:21 Scott, Clark sent me a message on MSN saying the following (prior to his killing): 1/31/2009 1:28:04 PM %hat Joe TELL ME IF YOU'RE MAFIA OR NOT 1/31/2009 1:28:06 PM %hat Joe OR IL NEVER SPEAK TO YOU AGAIN 1/31/2009 1:28:11 PM %hat Joe AND DELETE YOU OFF MY MSN 1/31/2009 1:28:28 PM %hat Joe TELL ME NOW 1/31/2009 1:28:33 PM %hat Joe OR DELETION 1/31/2009 1:28:34 PM %hat Joe AND 1/31/2009 1:28:36 PM %hat Joe BLOCKAGE 1/31/2009 1:28:52 PM %hat Joe YOU HAVE 5 MINUTES FROM NOW 1/31/2009 1:28:57 PM %hat Joe ITS 19.28 HERE 1/31/2009 1:29:01 PM %hat Joe SO UNTIL 19.33 1/31/2009 1:31:10 PM %hat Joe 2 minutes 1/31/2009 1:32:09 PM %hat Joe 1 MINUTE 1/31/2009 1:33:12 PM %hat Joe TIMES UP FUCKBAG 1/31/2009 1:33:15 PM %hat Joe DELETED 1/31/2009 1:33:16 PM %hat Joe AND 1/31/2009 1:33:17 PM %hat Joe BLOCKED The rules of Mafia are: 1. You don't talk about mafia. 2. YOU DON'T TALK ABOUT MAFIA! He thought I was 100% mafia because I was following the rules (and also because I happened to be asleep at 1:30 :D). |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Ariath on 02/02/09 at 14:28:24 Howes, no offense, but I think that's a terrible idea :S I could understand voting no lynch on the first day because not enough information is given yet, but voting no lynch on the second day is just stupid... If we don't vote every day because we 'don't have enough information', then we'll lose for sure. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Howes on 02/02/09 at 14:43:56 Whatever, I don't suspect anyone in particular at the moment. People need to talk more. This is only my second game of mafia, so I'm not completely sure on what to do. unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Extol on 02/02/09 at 15:04:58 I was scared last night, I wasnt sure if i would see the light of day again... :P Well, there still hasn't been that much in terms of clues or leads as to whos mafia or whos just trying to make themselves look like mafia to steer us in the wrong direction. i think its easy to fake either situation, a townie looking suspicious or a mafia looking like a townie. But we have to vote for someone nonetheless, and i kind of agree with the people saying the ones who have not said much look the most suspicious. I know i am in this group, but i never post much on the board period, im the kind of person who sits back and reads all the posts and tries to deduce something from them. What i see right now is that brutus looks the most suspicious, but we dont know if he is just being stupid and making himself look that way, which is probably the case. he could be a townie with one of the important roles, but so could everyone else, so its going to be risky to vote anyone unless theres something that says were sure theyre mafia. The people who have not said much (inclusing myself) need to join in the discussion :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by karterfreak on 02/02/09 at 15:42:21 Off the main list, some people who have not contributed/barely contributed to the game. 4. dragondragon (Eric) 11. In Hiding (Tom) 13. Ivootjes (Ivo) 14. Jabes (Joe) 15. K. McAteer (Kevin) 17. Lenny 19. oneshotbilly 20. Sportsguy001 (Tyler) 23. TJazZ (Benoit) All 8 of you need to contribute more to the topic. Vote: dragondragon What's your reason for the absense of posts? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/02/09 at 15:55:09 Drag is just like Nate, but cooler and smarter. They're both pretty oblivious when it comes to almost everything :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Brutus on 02/02/09 at 16:10:40 matt i'm pretty certain that you're a mii now vote: ariath Ariath sees me as a threat because I'm too clever for a regular mii. he knows his mafia empire is going to crumble. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/02/09 at 17:17:38 Vote dragondragon He seems he is trying to stay under the radar like many other players including myself. I'm a little worried that he could be a power role, but he might also be mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Ivootjes on 02/02/09 at 17:18:48 Oh well, seems like we didn't lose one of our power roles, it could have been worse. What Clark did was just dumb, he knew the rules and decided to not follow them decreasing towns chances :( Not only by losing a townie, but also by losing the ability to see who actually voted out a townie. That's also a mistake that was made last game, that nobody analyzed any voting paterns etc. Anyway, i'll cast my vote for Oneshotbilly. He seemed kinda useless last game and this game and could very well be a mafia guy. Even when he isn't he's kinda useless to us as he seems to be someone who doesn't like posting serious at all, creating more confussion then neccesary. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Ivootjes on 02/02/09 at 17:20:08 Lol at using "kinda useless" two times in a row but i can't edit it out xD |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Honko on 02/02/09 at 17:23:39 Important rule1: Ivootjes must use "kinda useless" 2 times per post, and can never edit it out. Important rule2: karterfreak must always make lists of people in his posts, and then miscount how many there are, and can never edit to fix his mistake. :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by karterfreak on 02/02/09 at 18:15:39 At least I ahve an excuse, I've been awak for 35 hours and counting ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by karterfreak on 02/02/09 at 18:16:42 have* awake** |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/02/09 at 18:40:32 Ur mom is kinda useless kinda useless. Also note that Honko is Bowser. vote Honko |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by nstinson on 02/02/09 at 18:50:12 vote: Goose so I won't have to look at that banner every time I view the topic |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/02/09 at 19:08:04 Can't believe how oblivious you are. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Adam L on 02/02/09 at 20:44:14 vote: Adam_L He hasn't been saying much all game and I think he's trying to hide from us. We should lynch him. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/02/09 at 20:47:52 That doesn't make any sense at all, Adam.....and you shouldn't be posting here! :) However, I'm a bit put off by the total lack of town chat today, how will we possibly find the culprit if we don't talk! YOU PEOPLE THAT HAVE BEEN NAMED: SPEAK UP OR DIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Extol on 02/02/09 at 20:50:35 i agree with scott, there wasnt enough chatter today, we need to communicate! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/02/09 at 20:54:11 I scanned In Hiding last night and he came up as Mafia. Just letting everyone know. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Etch on 02/02/09 at 21:00:37 Power reversal. Watch my mkds cronies be mafia, they been too quiet. [smiley=ninja.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/02/09 at 21:12:58 Quote:
And what do you suggest we do about that? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/02/09 at 21:17:51 I suggest we all get drunk and bang hookers, that's what. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by nstinson on 02/02/09 at 21:27:26 on second thought, Goose convinces me for now unvote vote Tom |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Honko on 02/02/09 at 21:50:40 Vote Count Update - it's what I do dragondragon - 2 (karterfreak, Sportsguy001) Ariath - 1 (Brutus) oneshotbilly - 1 (Ivootjes) In Hiding - 1 (nstinson) Not voting - Howes, Goose, K. McAteer, SuperYoshi1, Extol, Jabes, Etch, oneshotbilly, Ariath, Syzygy, dragondragon, Fababu, In Hiding, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny, TJazZ With 21 players, 11 votes are needed to lynch. Important rule3: Honko must have important rules in every post. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Jabes on 02/02/09 at 22:29:14 It seems pretty clear to me that Karterfreak is mafia. He's consistently trying to pin everyone else down as mafia, and makes a pretty definite list of the people he suspects. I suspect Matt and Goose as being mafia based purely on this page of the thread alone. vote: Karterfreak |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Lenny on 02/02/09 at 22:31:39 346E35373D353F6B6B5E0 wrote:
Are you suggesting something? :'( Well, here's my view on things: why hasn't the cop claimed yet? We have TWO doctors, so that's at least two more nights that they stay alive, and that's if the mafia are REALLLLLY lucky. They have to have at least someone clear, or a mafia member, plus they'll clear themselves. We even have a bodyguard for protection. I'm going to wait for the cop to claim, that was the whole point of waiting to day 2 >_> |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Jabes on 02/02/09 at 22:34:44 I meant to say Matt and Brutus because they're both so quick to rely on one another. All Matt has done in this thread is try to blame everyone else for not posting/contributing, and this leads me to believe that he's trying to pin the Mafia word on everyone else but him. Brutus is probably Mafia with him since he has been agreeing with him for the past couple of threads. I stand by my vote to lynch Matt (karterfreak). |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/02/09 at 22:36:56 I am the cop. And Toad. And even King Boo. And the Goomba. And Wall-E and my girlfriend is EVE [ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829][ch9829] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Honko on 02/02/09 at 22:41:02 lol King Boo. Goose must be psychic! I almost put King Boo in the game but decided at the last minute that there were enough roles. Baby Luigi also barely missed the cut. :'( Important rule4: Goose is not allowed to use his mind reading abilities against me to get an advantage in the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/02/09 at 22:51:28 Can we re-enact this scene from Wall-E? http://ca.youtube.com/watch?v=2lkffSsImXc I'll be Wall-E and you can be EVE [ch9829] (next mafia game should be Pixar themed :)) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by In Hiding on 02/03/09 at 02:00:17 Stinson, did you miss my post where I swore on my families life that I was a townie? Does anyone else want to admit they are? I'm seriously struggling to work out who is mafia in this one, maybe cause there are more players or less people saying stuff. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 1] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 07:36:40 577C7B677A150 wrote:
So far to me, it appears that the most people suspicous are players voting No Lynch (SuperYoshi1, Extol) or players that are campaigning for No Lynch. No Lynch, like people have already alluded to, will just give the mafia a free kill with NO shot at killing 1 of the mafia. Even though it would be better to make a logical kill, any kill by the group is better than none at all. Personally I think campaigning for No Lynch is the most suspicous early in the game, so make vote is: Vote: IsThatAGoodThing P.S. Anyone that ends up voting me to the gallows after this is Mafia, so they should be taken out next if you guys want to win :). |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 07:42:13 One more thing to add, all votes must have purpose for the townies, so vote retaliation may help the individual, but as a town it will hurt them, because you're no longer trying to eliminate the most suspicious, but being selfish to save yourself. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by nstinson on 02/03/09 at 07:58:36 Tom has reswayed me unvote Vote: IsThatAGoodThing |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Fababu on 02/03/09 at 08:23:47 6F6A555449587A52524E583D0 wrote:
I don't know what to think after seeing that, you "have" scanned In Hiding last night and you know he is mafia, but you don't vote him? What kind of townie are you? Or are you mafia? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by In Hiding on 02/03/09 at 08:29:29 lol, yeah thats pretty stupid. I've said it once, i'll say it again, i'm a townie. by the way, someone roleblocked goose. Goose is mafia. Vote goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 08:57:07 At least if we kill Tom, and he turns out to be Mafia, we'll know to listen to Goose. However if we kill Tom and he's not Mafia, we can kill Goose next. Kill: Tom Goose, if he's not Mafia, I'm voting to lynching you next. So let us know before voting ends. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 08:58:07 Sorry, wrong word. Unvote Vote: Tom |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 08:59:34 I hate not being able to edit. I meant to say, Goose, let us know if you're lying about scanning him, so I can retract my vote. Because now you have something at stake if you're lying. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 09:13:52 3 possibilities for Goose, assuming we lynch Tom first, and if goose is lying, lynch Goose next. 1) He's Mario. We lynch Tom, and we find out he's Mafia. Finding out who Mario is huge in this game, and basically our goal from then on would be to keep Goose alive and he finds who the Mafia and who isn't. Great info for us. 2) He's Mafia. We lynch Tom, and he's not Mafia. We then lynch Goose, and he is Mafia. We now made a 1 for 1 trade and significantly improved our position as the town. We'll make that trade all game long as long as we outnumber the Mafia. 3) He's neither. He just wanted to screw with us. Now both Tom and Goose are gone, and we lose 2 townies. Personally I think it's a risk that's worth taking. I think 1 and 2 are the most likely, and they both significantly improve our position in this game as the town. Worst case 3 won't kill us either, if that ends up being the case, because we'd most likely do that anyway accidently killing the wrong people off. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Fababu on 02/03/09 at 09:21:40 4) He is Mafia. We kill Tom and he is Mafia. Then they lost one of them, but they're sure that we won't doubt of Goose. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 09:24:22 But that's why we still keep a watchful eye on Goose and once he's lying about a scan, we kill him. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 09:25:52 Innocent until proven guilty I say. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Fababu on 02/03/09 at 09:27:57 7A6661636F7D69763F0E0 wrote:
That will only means that or you're lying or you're Mario/Wario. I won't vote at the moment, I wanna listen some people who haven't speak in Day 2. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by In Hiding on 02/03/09 at 10:01:06 i'm donkey kong you mugs. If you dont vote goose then you're stupid. I've sworn "on my familes life" that I am a townie. Anyone who votes for me now is either mafia or just a mug. I tried to vote goose last night but was blocked. I'm now going to get killed by the mafia cause i've owned up, but you at least can go 1 for 1 now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/03/09 at 10:42:31 Holy fuck guys, L2play mafia. If I really scanned Tom why would I post about it? He dies, and the mafia knows I have scanning powers, so they kill me that night. Fuck guys, FUCK. FUCKADEE FUCK FUCK FUCKAROO. vote: dragondragon for not knowing how to play mafia :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Fababu on 02/03/09 at 10:52:37 ^What happens Goose? Are you trying to eliminate one of the few persons active? I've read almost every post of game, and your behaviour keeps seeming me extremely suspicious; your posts don't make sense to me, and if someone attacks you, you try to dodge it accusing a third person. Vote: Goose. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 10:58:13 Alright, Tom. You're off the hook for now. Unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Honko on 02/03/09 at 11:01:26 Vote Count Update dragondragon - 3 (karterfreak, Sportsguy001, Goose) Goose - 2 (In Hiding, Fababu) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (nstinson) Ariath - 1 (Brutus) oneshotbilly - 1 (Ivootjes) karterfreak - 1 (Jabes) Not voting - dragondragon, Howes, K. McAteer, SuperYoshi1, Extol, Etch, oneshotbilly, Ariath, Syzygy, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny, TJazZ With 21 players, 11 votes are needed to lynch. Important rule5: important rules are no longer necessary. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 11:03:25 Also, Goose, I see no other benefit to claiming you can scan. The Mafia will probably kill you tonight just to be safe, unless you're one of them. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/03/09 at 11:30:33 Screwing around in the mafia game has about as much benefit as "screwing around" in real life by fucking random girls/guys, yet people do it all the fucking time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/03/09 at 11:52:27 This game is more serious than real life, so we need people that give us clear tells. Vote: Goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Jabes on 02/03/09 at 12:42:18 unvote vote: goose Goose has been talking an awful lot the last couple of pages, and he's not convincing me that he's a townie. Especially when he pretended to be Mario, Wario, and everyone with a power. Ergo, I vote goose... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/03/09 at 12:45:59 the most obvious things don't need convincing. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by TJazZ on 02/03/09 at 12:59:07 I'm sticking with my initial theory (http://www.mariokart64.com/cgi-bin/yabb2/YaBB.pl?num=1233362112/200#205)! Nobody shot it down so I assume it's still valid. If you are a goddamn townie, you better wake the fuck up. If this goes on, we are going to be slaughtered. Vote: Jabes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Extol on 02/03/09 at 13:11:26 vote: oneshotbilly havent seen him say anything, so...convince me im wrong :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Brutus on 02/03/09 at 13:14:57 unvote Vote Extol |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Syzygy on 02/03/09 at 13:27:46 Lol, some people are being too quiet. In the last game we voted oneshotbilly out straight away without him even saying anything and he wasn't mafia, so I'll give him the benifit of the doubt this time. Vote: Extol Haven't really seen him so far but haven't been paying much attention. YEAH ME AND BRUTUS ARE IN LEAGUE AND WHAT? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Fababu on 02/03/09 at 13:32:38 0A0F30312C3D1F37372B3D580 wrote:
Goose, I won't linch an innocent, but your acts make me think that you're mafia. If you have something that deserve to be hear, say it. @TJazz: Your theory isn't bad, but why if you at the beggining of the post you mention Goose and Brutus but at the end you just speak about Goose? Quote:
And respect of Quote:
@Extol: Not bad idea, it will be nice to hear what oneshot have to say. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Syzygy on 02/03/09 at 13:34:16 It's stupid voting out someone who hasn't said anything. Oneshot said nothing in the last game, got killed and that was that. He probably doesn't give a crap about the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by karterfreak on 02/03/09 at 13:40:40 74714E4F52436149495543260 wrote:
Goose, that's the stupidest thing you've said all game. If you say you've scanned Tom, and he turns out to be mafia, then one of the people who have the power to protect you at night would do just that, protect you. Retracting your statement in this post and saying you wouldn't have posted about it if you were a cop is either just not knowing how to play the cop role, or not being the cop and wanting Tom dead for other reasons, aka, being mafia and setting up a townie. I'm guessing the second statement above is true, and you noticed the mistake you made, and tried to fix it. Vote: Goose Now would be a good time to do some explaining. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by karterfreak on 02/03/09 at 13:41:40 fix to my above post, as i forgot to unvote first unvote vote: Goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Honko on 02/03/09 at 14:03:16 Vote Count Update - doo doo doo Goose - 5 (In Hiding, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, karterfreak) dragondragon - 2 (Sportsguy001, Goose) oneshotbilly - 2 (Ivootjes, Extol) Extol - 2 (Brutus, Syzygy) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (nstinson) Jabes - 1 (TJazZ) Not voting - Howes, K. McAteer, SuperYoshi1, Etch, oneshotbilly, Ariath, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny With 21 players, 11 votes are needed to lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Honko on 02/03/09 at 14:17:47 A little less than 48 hours left in Day 2, btw. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by nstinson on 02/03/09 at 15:21:31 unvote vote goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Extol on 02/03/09 at 16:04:37 unvote vote: goose some good points have been presented in the argument against goose. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Ivootjes on 02/03/09 at 16:06:52 Well, as goose doesn't seem to take this game serious, plus he could very well be mafia Unvote Vote goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Brutus on 02/03/09 at 16:10:27 unvote vote: goose He isnt mafia though |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Honko on 02/03/09 at 16:11:56 Vote Count Update Goose - 9 (In Hiding, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, karterfreak, nstinson, Extol, Ivootjes, Brutus) dragondragon - 2 (Sportsguy001, Goose) Extol - 1 (Syzygy) Jabes - 1 (TJazZ) Not voting - Howes, K. McAteer, SuperYoshi1, Etch, oneshotbilly, Ariath, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny With 21 players, 11 votes are needed to lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Brutus on 02/03/09 at 16:12:44 unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/03/09 at 16:17:31 What is your reason for unvoting Brutus? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/03/09 at 16:19:29 unvote Vote Goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Brutus on 02/03/09 at 16:19:42 i'm mafia |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/03/09 at 16:20:56 Alright guys, it looks like I'm about to get lynched, so I have one last thing to say. I am mafia. I am going to die tonight, and you will find out that I was mafia, a Koopa Troopa. I've never lied once playing this game (I admitted to joking about being the cop, last game I told everyone I was mafia) and I never intend to lie, since being honest is the way to win anything in life, even a simple game of deception like this. With that in mind, I want to play a game. I am going to list 11 karters. 5 of whom are the rest of the mafia. Right now, there are 20 players left, 5 mafia and 15 townies. If you kill these 11, you are ensured victory. It's that simple. Extol Fababu Howes In Hiding Isthatagoodthing Jabes K. Alteer oneshotbilly Sportsguy001 SuperYoshi1 TJaZZ The choice is yours. Just know that what I am telling you is true and then make your decision. Are you going to pick off these men one by one, or are you going to try to get smart and vote for the other 9? The five mafia members are in that list, I assure you. Why am I doing this? Perhaps I think everyone can benefit from a little honesty and trust. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Brutus on 02/03/09 at 16:29:24 why im not there |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Ariath on 02/03/09 at 16:31:01 Eh, that's enough proof for me xD Vote: Goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/03/09 at 16:31:05 Don't worry Brutus. If the mafia there doesn't kill you during the night to avoid killing off people from that list and narrowing down alternatives, the townies on that list will kill you from fear of getting lynched themselves. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Ariath on 02/03/09 at 16:37:20 Ugh, I can't edit my last post, so I'll make a new one. I didn't vote before this because I never really suspected Goose before. I'm still not even sure if he's telling the truth about being mafia, but I'm certainly hoping he is, so I'll put my vote in for him now. (in my last post) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Goose on 02/03/09 at 17:04:29 [media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V3KN_bLjzpM[/media] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Howes on 02/03/09 at 17:07:51 Sorry about this Goose, I have nothing against you as a person. But what is that about saying that I'm mafia? Vote: Goose |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by Honko on 02/03/09 at 17:28:10 After hearing Goose's shocking confession, the other karters quickly gathered around and beat the shit out of him with their handy lynch baseball bats. Goose has been lynched. He was a Koopa Troopa, one of the Mafia. Final Day 2 Vote Tally. Goose - 11 (In Hiding, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, karterfreak, nstinson, Extol, Ivootjes, Sportsguy001, Ariath, Howes) dragondragon - 1 (Goose) Extol - 1 (Syzygy) Jabes - 1 (TJazZ) Not voting - Brutus, K. McAteer, SuperYoshi1, Etch, oneshotbilly, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny It is now Night 2. No more talking. Send me your night actions via PM by 5:00pm Pacific time tomorrow. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 2] Post by Honko on 02/04/09 at 15:46:19 Uhhhhh during the night some bad stuff happened and in the morning someone was dead. SuperYoshi has been killed. He was a Mii. Day 3 begins now. With 19 players alive, 10 votes are needed to lynch. The deadline for the day is Saturday at 4pm Pacific. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Brutus on 02/04/09 at 15:50:01 Vote Extol |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/04/09 at 15:51:46 That's what he gets for not lynching I guess. RIP n00b [smiley=lolk.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/04/09 at 16:00:25 whew, i wasnt sure i would make it out alive... vote: Jabes somethin tells me hes in league with the bad guys... im probably wrong though, and will probably retract my vote later :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Ariath on 02/04/09 at 16:10:51 Nice, the thread's finally back open :] It's actually starting to look good for the townies now too. Not only did we already get rid of one of the mafia, but we didn't lose a power role last night either. Now the question is though, was that list goose gave actually real? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/04/09 at 16:21:42 Some posts just got deleted by someone. Whoever did that, don't do it again. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Brutus on 02/04/09 at 16:22:57 MY BAD |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Ariath on 02/04/09 at 16:28:46 It was either Goose or a mod. Nothing important was lost at least though. They were only Goose's spam lyrics and songs that he posted after he was voted off. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by karterfreak on 02/04/09 at 16:33:34 So, the question now is whether or not we believe goose's list. What does everyone else think we should do? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/04/09 at 16:40:29 I'm not sure. I think we should ignore it completely, but maybe he's telling the truth. If someone on that list gets hit up as mafia, then we can go back to it maybe. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/04/09 at 16:42:33 i think i agree with scott, dont bother with the list now, but if we find out someone goose named actually is mafia then itll be worth taking another look at |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/04/09 at 17:09:13 hmmmm... i'm a bit stumped. I'll go for Vote: Karter Freak |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/04/09 at 17:11:21 I think oneshot is a mafia. He wouldn't post so simply unless it's a ploy. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/04/09 at 17:13:12 People who want to ignore the list and are on it don't seem so innocent. ::) Sure, a few people on there are town but what do we have to lose picking off some maybe mafia? Goose might be doing what is best for the gander. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/04/09 at 17:15:57 looks like scott and i are in the same boat, huh etch? [smiley=ninja.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/04/09 at 17:18:55 48725569607540466E6E655569686F66010 wrote:
your a fucking idiot |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Ariath on 02/04/09 at 17:19:26 I didn't even notice that Etch. Both people who said not to use the list are on it. I'm going to keep that in mind. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/04/09 at 17:23:41 thats probably because we dont want to get falsely lynched ::) but lets hear from people not on the list, what do you guys think about using it? edit: 100th post lol |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by karterfreak on 02/04/09 at 17:29:39 Right now, I say we pick off the most suspiscious person from the list, and lynch him. If we get a mafia, he might have been telling the truth in his post. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/04/09 at 17:32:10 I'm worried about the people not posting. Maybe they will show up when it's time to start covering their ass. From the mafia's point of view, town players with powers might want to keep quiet because they do not want to lose their advantage. Get them off now before they have a chance to exercise it or learn something through guessing. As a town player, you shouldn't just fucking sit in the shadows. It's imperative to discuss and notice discrepancies when shit comes forward and already this far in some people remain silent. If town wants to win, it doesn't help if you just spout bullshit. The object is winning and it doesn't sound like some people want to because they aren't who they say they are. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/04/09 at 18:05:54 To be honest i've been given a few clues, but beacuse its such a large game there not helping much. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by nstinson on 02/04/09 at 20:14:28 Why would the mafia want to take out Superyoshi? Wasn't he advocating no lynching, which would help them out? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by K. McAteer on 02/04/09 at 20:36:16 According to the MKDS news, etch is mafia. It seems trustworthy! vote: Etch |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/04/09 at 20:40:03 They must have thought he had some town power Stinson, wanting to seem weak yet hiding some ability. Okay, time for my first spite vote. This is one guy I expect to be mafia. If not, he isn't helping the town out very much. Vote: Kmacc :-* |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by K. McAteer on 02/04/09 at 20:43:59 I couldn't help the town out yesterday because I had school for 11 hours :P I would have voted Goose but I got home just as Night started. Waiting to see what else happens now for a bit. But I won't be home tomorrow basically either so I'll miss a lot of what happens tomorrow too.. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/04/09 at 20:48:24 I was in the same boat on Goose's day of death. I finally saw what had happened after night had already fallen :( |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by In Hiding on 02/05/09 at 02:29:18 Can I just point out that I was right about Goose. After trying to expel him with my super power he was role blocked by someone. I said all this.. and low and behold I was right. I'm a bit unsure about what goose was saying in his list. I think he was being honest as in his second paragraphy he says that the mafia are in that list - but the list is longer than the remaining amount of mafia. Take me out of the list 100% and the odds are smaller. I will be voting for someone in that list and I will be using one of my power votes too. If you're on that list, you want to be telling me now why I shouldn't vote for you. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Syzygy on 02/05/09 at 03:17:13 I agree with Tom, I believe Goose's list and it had some names on who I thought were suspicious. I think Goose just sensed his end and wanted to mess with us [smiley=lolk.gif] For now, I will vote Extol, who I voted for yesterday, just for the fact that he seemed quick to want to get rid of those who weren't really talking, a strat which I don't buy. Vote: Extol |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by In Hiding on 02/05/09 at 03:49:23 vote extol i was sus of him before, my opinion can be changed but for now i'm going with Tim. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/05/09 at 05:32:32 Sounds like a plan. He'll defend himself if he's really innocent, and I doubt that defense will be sufficient. vote: EXTOL |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by nstinson on 02/05/09 at 07:46:09 Another question... who would try to roleblock and save Goose? vote: Extol |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Ivootjes on 02/05/09 at 07:49:44 Why exactly do people find Extol suspicious? He hasn't said too much yet and he was part of the people who lynched Goose. ::) Which was pretty good. Oh, and i just noticed that this actually was your FIRST vote scott, in the entire game. Are you actually trying to find mafia or just hop onto the bandwagon to quicklynch. This looks like mafia behaviour to me. Vote Isthatagoodthing |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by TJazZ on 02/05/09 at 08:08:45 Oh my God my mind totally blown! I was thinking that surely Goose wouldn’t act the same he did last game if he was the same role... but he did and he was. It seems that paranoia made me over-analyzed a lot of people in this game. I owe an apology to Jabes for voting for him I wasn’t sure if you were 100% truthful this whole time or that you were joking around this whole time. The fact that Goose was mafia changes pretty much everything to me. I read this whole topic again and I can now say that I trust: In Hiding, Etch, Fababu, Jabes, howes and karterfreak. Unfortunately, according my own reasoning for trusting you guys, I shouldn’t trust myself at this point. Alas, I hope you will forgive me. I swear that I am a Mii and I’ll prove this to you by going along with you guys from now on. If you guys go with Extol, I'll follow but for some reason I kinda had pinned in as a townie. I'll re-read the whole topic again to see if I can figure something out. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Fababu on 02/05/09 at 08:29:40 I have to admitted that Extol was one of the persons that I thought since the beggining of the game. His posts aren't helpful to find mafia guys, and some of them seem empty to me. So, Vote: Extol But everyway, I will like to listen his deffense, if he has one. In other terms, I don't know what to think about Goose list. If what he said is true, now they will remains 5 and 5. Attending to my guesses, I'm almost sure that there are at least 3 mafias on the list; but who knows if there are the 5 of them. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/05/09 at 08:30:09 Crap, i would prove that i'm a townie by doing what Benoit said hes gonna do and vote with everyone else, but how can i do that if everyone is voting for me? I am a townie, by the way, and i dont remember doing anything suspicious to make you guys think im mafia. Goose's list probably did list the mafia, but it also listed some townies, one of which was me. Im not sure why i was on that list, maybe because im one of the ones who is actually talking? Anyway, if you lynch me youll have lost a fellow townie that is actually participating semi-regularly in the game, even though i may not be the best at figuring out who the mafia is, and i will say i told you so. Thats my defense :) Now, back to the game... I like Ivo's point about Scott. He made one vote so far, and thats when he saw that everyone else was voting for the same person. It looks kinda suspicious to me, so unvote vote: IsThatAGoodThing |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Fababu on 02/05/09 at 08:35:47 Quote:
That's the problem in my opinion. In your 1st post you just vote for no-lynch, and in a couple of the other one you just say "Yeah, I'm agree with Scott". If you were a townie, you shouldn't have fear to say anything about who do you think that could be a mafia or a townie; trying to help the other one of us to find the mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/05/09 at 08:42:12 I guess youre right Fababu.. In my defense of the no lynch vote at the beginning, this is my first game of mafia and then i was just learning the game, so i guess since i didnt suspect anyone of being mafia yet, i thought a no lynch was logical just cause i didnt want to vote for someone who ended up to be a townie. But ive learned more about the game now, so im trying to fulfill me townie roles and vote for who i think is mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Flo1 on 02/05/09 at 08:47:36 I think this game is like a french game called Le Loup Garou. That sounds fun. Are there any special characters like a viewer or someone else? I may play this game too :D (Of course if you accept to play a second time...) ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by In Hiding on 02/05/09 at 08:49:35 I'm going to re-read the topic later tonight or tomorrow. My first pm was to power role out Extol but i switched it to goose after reading one of his posts. I do suspect extol but i want to be sure. His defense was good but not quite convincing enough. I think i've been watching too much Columbo :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/05/09 at 09:40:07 Vote count update - the return Extol - 6 (Brutus, Syzygy, In Hiding, IsThatAGoodThing, nstinson, Fababu) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (Ivootjes, Extol) karterfreak - 1 (oneshot) Etch - 1 (K.McAteer) K.McAteer - 1 (Etch) Not voting: Ariath, dragondragon, Howes, Jabes, karterfreak, Lenny, Sportsguy, TJazZ With 19 players alive, it takes 10 votes to lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Ariath on 02/05/09 at 12:24:13 Well, maybe this is just my opinion, but I really don't find Extol to be that suspicious :S Though I would like to note the point that Ivo brought up about scott. I didn't even notice the fact that this is his first time voting the entire game. Whether it is an attempt to stay low to avoid suspicion or not, I'm not sure, so for now, until I see further posts that prove me right/wrong, I'm going to vote for scott. Vote: Isthatagoodthing |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/05/09 at 13:00:40 I think the people we should suspect the most should be the people who knew Goose was mafia before he was lynched, which I believe to be the people who voted against lynching him. Try to keep in mind that the mafia all know each other and probably wouldn't vote for one of their own to be lynched. I don't remember off the top of my head who was quick to vote against lynching Goose, but I'll reread the first couple of pages and vote for that guy... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Brutus on 02/05/09 at 13:10:17 Scott is mafia, but we should kill Extol first. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/05/09 at 13:38:05 Ivo it was my first vote for reasons I have already explained. The whole day when everyone piled votes on Goose I was GONE, as you will see in my previous postings. Before that I was waiting out the three days of Day 1 to get more information before casting a vote. The vote on Extol wasn't so much to vote him out as to hear what he has to say, which still hasn't had much content but his excuse of being a first timer seems totally legit. I think I'll withdraw my vote on Extol and change it to someone else who hasn't said much at all yet, like KMACC!!! unvote vote kmacc |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/05/09 at 13:41:20 Brutus: WTF man, why are you attacking me like this. There's no reason to just flat out call me mafia. You are either very mean and just want me to lose because you think it would be funny, OR you are a mafia and your silly attitude is just continuing to grow. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Fababu on 02/05/09 at 13:57:40 It's hard to deduce something after that posts, so I will wait until tomorrow. I will keep my vote in Extol until tomorrow morning, when I read the posts that you write during the night. Tomorrow I will be out almost all the day, but I hope I can connect during the evening a bit. The same happens the Saturday, I will be in a tourney almost all the day and in a concert at night; but I will try to find some free time to read posts and post too. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/05/09 at 13:58:24 As it stands right now, the people that I trust are Scott, Tom, and Matt. TjaZZ voted for me right before Goose was lynched, so he seems pretty suspicious to me, but that's probably just me. I re-read the entire thread, and that's the conclusion I've come up with... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Syzygy on 02/05/09 at 14:02:29 You mean you trust the ones who try to swamp us with loads of posts trying to defend their corner? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/05/09 at 14:05:12 They have legit reasons to their actions, unlike some people around here. They talk a lot, yes, but they're trustworthy posts. What problems do you find in them? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Syzygy on 02/05/09 at 14:09:47 I don't have a problem, I was just wondering what your reasoning was for finding them the most trustworthy. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by dragondragon on 02/05/09 at 14:45:26 I also find Extol suspicious, but Ivo seems right up there with him. They always vote for the same person for one. They did both vote for Goose yesterday, but they were ones of the last ones to vote for him in back to back posts. One final person that seems suspicious to me is Lenny. He is the only person to have not voted yet. My opinions could always change, but for now that is where they stand. Vote: Extol |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/05/09 at 14:45:50 I bet many don't even know who Extol is so the who's this n00b gtfo mentality sets in. If he's mafia, then he is lying through his fucking teeth right now. Why are so many eager to get rid of him? Perhaps the mafia want us to vote off one of our own. ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by dragondragon on 02/05/09 at 14:48:07 Etch, making a comment like that could be very costly if he indeed is mafia ::). You'd jump right up on the list for defending him. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/05/09 at 14:54:43 If he is mafia I would know it. :P Just speculating but he doesn't seem to be the pathological liar type, idk. The mafia knows I am town, I got nothing to hide. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Brutus on 02/05/09 at 15:05:42 5E64437F76635650787873437F7E7970170 wrote:
this attitude is unbecoming of you, mafia |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/05/09 at 15:15:40 Vote count update Extol - 6 (Brutus, Syzygy, In Hiding, nstinson, Fababu, dragondragon) IsThatAGoodThing - 3 (Ivootjes, Extol, Ariath) K.McAteer - 2 (Etch, IsThatAGoodThing) karterfreak - 1 (oneshot) Etch - 1 (K.McAteer) Not voting: Howes, Jabes, karterfreak, Lenny, Sportsguy, TJazZ With 19 players alive, it takes 10 votes to lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by nstinson on 02/05/09 at 15:45:24 Quote:
Not me? :( |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/05/09 at 16:08:25 What's everyone's reasons for voting Extol? because he is first on Goose's list? Vote K. McAteer |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by In Hiding on 02/05/09 at 16:20:32 i was the 1st to try to lynch goose as i was doing that as a power play. so that philosophy is completely wrong as i'm a townie. you look as sus as extol now. been drinking but will have to re-read everything in the morning. extol is still being voted for. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/05/09 at 16:50:11 I can assure everyone that I am a townie, i want to live to see another day! :P I think perhaps the people that we should look into might be the people that didnt vote for goose. since he was mafia, the other mafia knew that he was, so they probably wouldnt vote for him cause they didnt want to vote for one of their own. Unless they really didnt care to lose a fellow mafia member, but i wouldnt think they would want to do that...ill make a list of my own: Brutus, Kmacc, tjazz, syzygy, etch, oneshot, isthatagoodthing, and lenny are the ones that didnt vote for goose. Is this theory legit, or am i completely naive here? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Brutus on 02/05/09 at 16:52:37 Extol I told you not to fuck with me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/05/09 at 16:53:33 lol, i dont remember that... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/05/09 at 16:55:49 071A160D0E555A55620 wrote:
Dude I pretty clearly explained already why I didn't vote for Goose. The topic was still LOCKED before, and by the time I came back Goose was already killed and it was locked again. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Brutus on 02/05/09 at 16:56:51 or maybe you're just mafia [smiley=lurk.gif] [smiley=ninja.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/05/09 at 17:00:48 ok my bad, i forgot your explanation scott, youre off the hook. but as for the others... :-? unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by TJazZ on 02/05/09 at 17:07:46 5671766C7D76727748776F7D6A180 wrote:
Like I said, I'm feel really bad about that. I was caught over-analyzing this whole thing and I was sure that you and Tom were putting on a show from beginning but since you guys initiated the voting against Goose and he was mafia, speaks volumes in my mind. That's why I said, I now trust you, Tom, Matt and Fababu. I'm voting with you guys now. ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/05/09 at 18:19:07 Don't mean to sound like I'm jumping on Ben's wagon here, but I agree with his analysis. Tom and Matt seem clean to me, although I don't know what to think of Fababu at the moment. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by TJazZ on 02/05/09 at 18:20:03 What's wrong with Fababu? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/05/09 at 18:20:26 Well I read a little more into Fababu's posts, and he seems to be pretty solid as a townie. If he was mafia he'd have to be playing a really strong fake-out to post like that. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/05/09 at 18:26:12 I'm always afraid to post my opinions now in the topic because I feel if I say something I mean, everyone gets all on my case and I can't defend myself. This is what happened in the last game, and I was mad. First in this game I wanted to sit back a bit and vote at the end of Day 1 so I could have a better shot of seeing who was being criminal-ish, but that backfired when the modkill of Clark happened. Now I'm getting my own opinions of the game but I'm afraid to share them because people always try to peg me as suspicious as soon as I do. Regardless, here goes..... I am a bit mystified by these people making lists of "I trust these 4 guys" like Benoit and Joe both have. Yeah, they've probably got great reason to post those lists, and they're probably 100% right, but what if just ONE of those people in that list was a mafia, it would let everyone kill us. Maybe those guys are posting those lists but not really meaning it? I want to team up with some others who are for sure townies, but how do we make sure you're not a mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/05/09 at 18:29:05 I think something important to pay attention to is the previous experience with the game mafia of the players involved. I think there is a bit of a mismatch going on, since a handful of the 20 players or so left have played mafia more than just a little, and the rest are pure beginners. If two or three of the experienced ones were in the mafia, they'd be able to own us like no other. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by TJazZ on 02/05/09 at 18:42:03 Well, the difference between this game and last game is that the town actually caught a mafia. We caught him early too! There's LOADS of informations out there now and not just a whole bunch of confusion stacked on top of bullshit. In my mind, no mafia would jump (early) on a bandwagon for voting against another mafia. It would be possible that mafia would jump on it relatively late in an attempt to hide their identity. So there you have my reasons for making a list. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by karterfreak on 02/05/09 at 18:43:07 Even beginner mafia players can catch experienced mafia players when they're on the mafia side. Right now, i'm undecided on who i'm going to vote for. At the same time, I'm worried that people are making the lists above about trusting certain people, ESPESCIALLY considering i'm on alot of those lists. If the mafia knows that these people are trusted, they also know they're least likely to get lynched, so they'll aim to kill off the people who are trusted to make it harder for the townies to decide who the mafia are. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by TJazZ on 02/05/09 at 19:03:53 Interesting, karterfreak! Assuming you are town, wouldn't getting lynched solidify even more the remaining town alliance? Like it or not, if you're town you are not 100% certain of what you are doing. Pretty much everything that went on since the lynching in Day 2 is nothing more is rhetoric (which the mafia would obviously try to steer in a favourable direction for them). I'm saying that there's real, honest, logical information before that. So now that there's real non-BS information out there we can unite and narrow the odds of lynching a fellow townie to close to 50-50 or even tilt it in out favour. Like I said, when I read back this topic, sadly, even I feel like I'm not exactly the least suspicious around but I'm trying to put things to the town's advantage by siding with the people who were honest this whole time. That's why for this round, I rather follow than lead. It's a show of good faith! Mafia aren't that smart. ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by karterfreak on 02/05/09 at 19:21:17 5E7972737568435E7369786E797D691C0 wrote:
If one of the experienced mafia players is on the mafia team, I can almost guarantee they are that smart. Logically, mafia are going to avoid lynching people on gooses list (espescially if its true), for the sole reason that it narrows it down. Mafia will also try and get rid of the most experienced/trusted people on the townie side who is NOT in goose's list to make it harder for the people on the list to decide who is who (the more people on that list goose posted, the better for the mafia obviously). In the same token, the people forming the lists could easily be mafia, and listing people who they SAY they trust, so when they get lynched, they will look more innocent. All I'm going to add to this, is it's perfectly fine to keep these "trust" lists in your mind, but saying them here puts a target on the head of those people, espescially if they aren't on goose's list. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/05/09 at 19:23:10 This game is so much more fun being mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/05/09 at 19:27:30 Vote count update Extol - 6 (Brutus, Syzygy, In Hiding, nstinson, Fababu, dragondragon) K.McAteer - 3 (Etch, IsThatAGoodThing, Sportsguy) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (Ivootjes, Ariath) karterfreak - 1 (oneshot) Etch - 1 (K.McAteer) Not voting: Extol, Howes, Jabes, karterfreak, Lenny, TJazZ With 19 players alive, it takes 10 votes to lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/05/09 at 21:32:40 (I'm posting from my iPod touch, so I apologize for any spelling errors or mis used words because of auto correct from this device...) I guess I never really considered the ramifications of listing the people I trust, but I do believe that posting what you're thinking is a major part of the game. How else will people start to decipher anything if I keep quiet about who I think is on the ball or who I think appears to be suspicious. I also believe that in my posting about all this that I can also be trusted by all of the town. But I guess I never realized that the mafia could easily pick off the people that I listed as trustworthy. So I apologize for that... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/05/09 at 21:44:06 Extol didn't really say anything useful to clear his name, and quickly after that Tyler shot in a vote to lynch someone else. If he's a townie it's an awfully ballsy thing to do when everyone is swaying a certain way. I agree with Benoit about his rhetoric theory, and because it's a sound theory, Tyler and Extol seem the most suspicious. Vote: Extol If he turns out to be mafia, then we have a good idea who to lynch next. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by K. McAteer on 02/05/09 at 21:44:08 Just quickly read through the last couple of pages, saw I got a few votes. I know I haven't been able to contribute much, I've been rather busy lately though. Like today I left my house at 9 AM, and just got home not too long ago (12:15 AM or so). So I haven't had the time to sit around here and read everything all the way through. When I get home from classes tomorrow I'll read through some stuff again and give my opinions, ideas, etc. I am a townie though. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Lenny on 02/05/09 at 21:46:09 Holy shit, I get an opportunity for the first time in like more than a day to look and there are always hordes of votes. o.o I'm going to go back a little and read through what's been going on and then see. :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by K. McAteer on 02/05/09 at 21:51:40 I just read more of it, and saw Sportsguy jumped on the bandwagon to vote me out without explaining his motives. Is it because I don't talk enough, or do you have any other reasons? To me it seems suspicious that you vote for me so suddenly and give no reason why.. unvote vote: Sportsguy |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Lenny on 02/05/09 at 22:06:40 OK, read through and such. As far as I can see, all that's going on is people are chucking votes all over the freaking place. Also, NO-ONE can be trusted in this game, those people who made lists. In forum mafia it's like 50 billion times easier to pretend you're a townie if you're mafia than in instant mafia. I feel slightly suspicious of these people, because for all I know, they could be just mafia in league with each other trying to look like they're all innocent. An effective strategy indeed. Also, there are people who are analysing things thoroughly, namely Matt, but there are others. In the first game when there was someone like this it was fos on them straight away, but we've become more wary and we're not lynching them just because of this, as was the case with Robin. I think the mafia may be employing a number of strategies to make them all look innocent, but I'm not buying it. As far as I'm concerned, you aren't innocent unless you claim, OR if you're cleared by the cop(s). As such, I think Luigi should step forward tomorrow IF Peach is still alive, so that we can either get some guilties or innocents. I can see the mafia counter-claiming this, but if they do, it's as simple as lynching to find out who is telling the truth. For now, I'm not voting, there is still no incentive (for those people who think that no-lynching is mafia behaviour, stop being noobs and learn to play. No-lynch does not help the mafia, in any case it makes it harder for them. Look what happened last game xD It's even more likely to knock out a townie in this game than in the last, lynching is not good unless we've lost at least one power role) I stand my ground, I am not going to vote right now. ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Fababu on 02/05/09 at 22:56:49 6933686A6068623636030 wrote:
Your first affirmation could be understand in two ways: 1) You're mafia or 2) You're a scaner. I have to go to school in a few minutes, so I haven't got enoguh time to read all post; but don't woryy, when I will have returned to my house I will read intensily and I will show my point of view about them. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by karterfreak on 02/06/09 at 04:18:39 Well, one thing I'd like to point out. Town still has all of their power roles, as does mafia. That means townies still have Peach, Yoshi, Toad and Mario, all of whom have a protective ability. That would mean that if we DID go through goose's list, we could have the cop own up to who he is (hopefully the legit cop, but we can lynch him during the day if he posts someones a mafia and they're really a townie) and we could effectively cover the list two times as fast by doing a day lynch of one person, and a scan of another person (with the protectors obviously protecting the cop). The only problem with the above strategy is Bowser, but thats only 1 mafia. With the amount of players left, there should be no problem finding the Bowser before the townie total is equal to the mafia total. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/06/09 at 04:29:16 Is it too dangerous for us to admit our townie roles? I asked Robin this very question in a PM and he told me that "you can say anything you want, it's just up to everyone else to believe you." I had an idea of linking people whom we suspected to be mafia and lynching the first one to see if we were right, and I believe that lynching Goose was a major step in the right direction (only because he turned out to be a mafia member, and we didn't off 4 or 5 of our own without a single mafia member lost). It's been harder to try to weed out the other mafia members because lynching Goose was so quick and efficient, there really wasn't any time for any other mafia members to go "HEY! NO! LYNCH SOMEONE ELSE!!" Tyler has been fishy as of late, so I still suspect him... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by karterfreak on 02/06/09 at 05:02:43 The only person who would need to tell their role is the cop for the above strategy to work. However, the cop needs to trust players who have the ability to protect him TO protect him. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/06/09 at 05:07:03 6933686A6068623636030 wrote:
1) If you are mafia then you know everyone else who is, there be no doubt in your mind. 2) You don't have to scan someone to be suspicious of them. 3) I am town, mafia can't refute the truth or they might reveal themselves by acting stupid. We wouldn't be having this conversation if we were both mafia. Other case is you are mafia or we are both town which is most likely case. It's a risk to lynch people off of plain guess work. We do this wrong another town guy is going home. If you think I am mafia be prepared for Robin to post another town died when I get lynched or killed, lol. People I think are mafia jumped on the Extol kill train quickly, if he's town it will look bad. :-X |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/06/09 at 05:07:16 Alright, well, let's think about this. I am not the cop, but I also don't want to give away what, if anything, that I can or can't do, because if the mafia learns too much about what each person can do, they're going to pick off the important town members each night, one by one. But let it be known that I am not the cop. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by TJazZ on 02/06/09 at 05:36:00 I said it before, I AM A Mii! I wish i could help out more. :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by dragondragon on 02/06/09 at 07:11:54 Hey Robin, when you give us the vote updates, could you tell us how much longer we have to vote? I missed out on day 1, because I thought we had more time than we did. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/06/09 at 07:21:51 This is my suspicion, and i dont know if i should mention this for fear of losing a valuable townie, but I think Etch might be mario or luigi, because he seems to be pretty set on me not being mafia and hes defending me, which is the right thing to do because im not, i repeat, not, mafia :). He may have scanned me before or something and seen that i was not mafia, which leads me to believe that we should keep him around... i may be wrong though. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by In Hiding on 02/06/09 at 07:35:30 who ever is "scanning" please tell us who is innocent! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Fababu on 02/06/09 at 08:43:54 @Extol: If Etch has scanned you and you appear like townie doesn't mean that you are a townie. You could also be Bowser. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/06/09 at 09:02:46 Oh, looking at what bowser does i guess youre right. I didnt know bowser could do that. Im not bowser, but i guess as a warning to whoever is dong the scanning, watch out for that... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/06/09 at 10:20:39 726477717978726477717978160 wrote:
Sure, I'll include the amount of time left in the day, but the day also ends instantly if someone reaches the number of votes needed to lynch, so don't rely on the day lasting its full length. Vote count update Extol - 7 (Brutus, Syzygy, In Hiding, nstinson, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes) K.McAteer - 3 (Etch, IsThatAGoodThing, Sportsguy) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (Ivootjes, Ariath) karterfreak - 1 (oneshot) Sportsguy - 1 (K.McAteer) Not voting: Extol, Howes, karterfreak, Lenny, TJazZ With 19 players alive, it takes 10 votes to lynch. The day will end in 30 hours, or when someone reaches 10 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/06/09 at 10:23:17 Robin- I don't know if you noticed, but Clark posted recently, and I don't want to break the rules and delete his post. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/06/09 at 10:27:39 Thanks for pointing that out. It's gone now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Fababu on 02/06/09 at 11:09:19 So it seems that the controversy is caused by Goose's list. In my case I think I won't follow it. It's true that some of the people who appear on it could seem suspicious, but at least I can't be sure of the veracity; so I will keep following my intuition. Respect telling what roles we have, it won't be a good option in my opinion. People can't be sure of the veracity of the role, but mafia could know who have the important roles and go for them. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by K. McAteer on 02/06/09 at 11:24:11 I saw Goose's list, not sure if it should be taken seriously or not. Like people said though, if someone gets lynched from that list and is mafia, then we can always refer back to it. I'm saying that even though I'm on the list as well. If the list is true then we would have to follow it somewhat I guess, even if it sacraficed townies such as myself. The mafia must be brought down! Saying that, I don't believe Extol (who is on that list) is mafia. He seems to have put up a good defense for himself. I know this may make me the next target being that I have the next most amount of votes, but of the three votes, only one gave a reason, which was that I didn't post enough. Etch only voted for me because I jokingly voted for him. Tyler voted me as well, without a reason. That's just why he seems suspicious to me, trying to jump on the bandwagon without saying a reason for it. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Ivootjes on 02/06/09 at 11:46:20 At the moment there are more dangerous bandwagons going on, which he could have jumped on instead. But still, not giving a reason why you vote for someone could be scummy instead. I still find the band wagon on extol a little bit strange, as none of these guys actually gave a good reason what they found suspicious, I bet there are some mafiosi's on this list, except if extol is mafia himself ;D than it would be correct, hopefully it is. I'll keep my vote on scott for now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by TJazZ on 02/06/09 at 12:38:54 Well, Extol put up a good defense in my opinion but can we trust his word? Surely Mafia would say/do anything to escape a good old-fashioned lynching. It surprises me that some people are so rock-solid towards Extol's guilty-ness, TBH. He was very convincing so if we lynch him and he ends up being Town, I'm going to be very suspicious of the people who simply voted for him and left this topic avoiding discussion. It's obvious who they are so I don't have to name them. On the flip side, maybe those people know something above my pay grade (cuz I'm a Mii like I already said a bunch of times) and he actually IS, in fact, Mafia. So... who to trust? What an excruciating dilemma. :-/ That being said, there's only one way to find out. Vote: Extol I don't expect things to change drastically within the next 24 hours unless someone comes up with the ultimate mobilization theory against someone else (unlikely). At this pace it was probably going to be you regardless... so I kinda see the act of lynching you as either a) getting some information on the people who started the bangwagon against you OR b) getting some information on the people who tried to defend you. a) being if you're a townie b) being if you're mafia I said I'd keep my vote with the people who acted as townies logically would in Day 2 so the only way I'm changing my vote is if they do too. Extol, if you're a Townie, I'm very sorry and I hope you understand my reasoning. If you are Mafia, you can burn in hell sucka! [smiley=uzi.gif] [smiley=dead.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by K. McAteer on 02/06/09 at 12:58:16 Well it's not like we can say Extol is 100% townie. Anyone could be mafia. It just seems to me like he isn't the best choice to lynch, but that's my opinion. I'm not trying to defend him, that's just what I think. It seems nearly certain though that he is going to be the one lynched. Hopefully he is mafia then. If not, then that'll suck. [smiley=dead.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/06/09 at 13:21:36 lol @ tzazz, i wont be burning in hell, but i do understand your reasoning, cause, lets face it, youre the man [smiley=thumbsup.gif] well, i have 8 votes now, so i guess it seems sensible just to get the other two votes, so when i'm lynched and you all find out that i am a townie, you can, like benoit said, get some information on the people who started the bandwagon and the ones who votes to lynch me with no reasoning. they will probably most likely be the mafia. honestly that seems like the best solution, cause as it is, the games going nowhere, so me getting lynched might shed some light and clues for the next day or whatever... that being said, i really dont want to be lynched, i like putting in my two cents here and there, but i guess if everyone is against me, ive tried to defend myself a good bit already, so theres not really much else i can do. I'll say this though, im only a regular Mii, i dont have any power roles or anything, so you fellow townies wont have lost anyone that important if i end up getting lynched, some of you will just have the guilt of voting for me on your conscious :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 13:44:47 I think Ben may have started to go too far. I now think he might be a mafia. In EVERY one of his posts he's getting all smartypants on us, even more so than he normally is on the forum (which is quite a bit), so maybe we need to start looking at BENOIT.....just a thought..... I'm afraid if I switch my vote to Extol now that people will accuse me of "being mafia and jumping on the bandwagon late to not look suspicious" because that's already been mentioned in this topic. For now I'll leave my vote how it stands, even though KMACC has done some good explaining. I'm up in the air over Extol, and his last post seems like it could be a last-ditch effort to overturn our votes by drawing our emotions :-/ |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Howes on 02/06/09 at 13:54:38 I'm pretty sure that Extol is not the mafia. Any number of people could still be mafia, but I'm not confident in any of my thoughts to vote for them. Also, Extol, if you have any thoughts on who is in the mafia, now would be the best time to get them out, before you are killed. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Brutus on 02/06/09 at 14:00:03 If extol isn't mafia, I'm mafia |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/06/09 at 14:04:39 Before i get lynched, which i probably will, ill let people know where my suspicions lie. As far as whos mafia, theres no one that im absolutely positive is mafia, but a few people im up in the air about. Jabes, stinson, lenny, and syzygy would be my guesses. I havent really seen them try to contribute to finding out whos mafia, they usually just go for the throat and vote for someone or dont vote at all, and they havent said much of anything else either. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/06/09 at 14:21:54 How have I not tried to find out who's mafia and who's not? I've been with Tom and Matt trying to get to the bottom of it since page 2 or 3, so I don't see why you'd say something like that. I have been posting a lot lately, yes, but that shouldn't be a reason for you suspecting me to be mafia. I do agree that Lenny and Szyzyzyyzgy appear to be pretty suspicious to me, but Stinson has said little to nothing in this game, so I don't even know why he's playing... Speak up people. If I get incriminated because I'm trying to accomplish something in this game by saying what's on my mind, I'm going to lose it. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Syzygy on 02/06/09 at 14:30:34 I'm not mafia. If I get killed by the mafia then fair enough, if I get lynched by the townies then I hope the mafia cut off your balls and feed them to the lions. Anyway Extol, it's not a personal thing, it's just I thought you were suspicious and then when you appeared in Goose's list then I had better reasoning for thinking you were mafia. If that list is correct and you get lynched, then because superyoshi was killed last night that list would be down to seven. Now I'm a bit stumped though because while I thought Goose's list was legit at first, I don't understand why the mafia would then lynch Superyoshi if the list is in fact correct as that would bring us closer to finding out who is who. Anyhow, K.Macc seems quite suspicious to me ::) About my role, I am not a mii and I am not mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/06/09 at 14:30:48 54525E5C5C3F0 wrote:
I wouldn't say i jumped on the bandwagon to vote for you. It was more of i didn't think Extol was mafia and you hadn't said as much as others. I could have voted for someone that had said less than you, but i decided to vote for someone who already had votes to see if anyone followed me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/06/09 at 15:02:37 Unless all you guys decide to vote for someone else, it looks like Extol will be lynched. If I could scan and knew Extol was mafia I sure as hell would sacrifice myself to at least take one guy out. If he's town, well that's your guys faults because I have no idea. Just a hunch that maybe he isn't. There are plenty of town people so if he gets killed it isn't a huge loss. He's starting to get drawn out in his argument so maybe he really is mafia. I just don't want to be in the group of people that readily lynched a town guy out because I am not certain of it. Benoit is mafia? I am nearly sure he is town based on his posts, people wanting to lynch a town member go up on my suspicious list. Why would you admit you have a power town role Tim, how is that helping? [smiley=lolk.gif] I feel like there is some serious bullshit going on somewhere. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Syzygy on 02/06/09 at 15:04:43 Well Tom did as well and then it's up to whoever to believe me or not. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by K. McAteer on 02/06/09 at 15:09:40 Tim, is there any specific reason that you feel I'm suspicious? And Tyler, I see what you mean I think. I guess it was like a senseless sort of vote? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Lenny on 02/06/09 at 15:46:28 Why are people suspicious of me? I post when I can, it's called school + different time zones + 1.5 hours to get home = not much posting when others do. I'm on the comp for around 5 hours a day or so, at max, don't kill me for it :( Also, I suggested that the cop should have claimed aaaggees ago. Why did no-one listen? >_> The people who outed themselves as power roles are stupid, there aren't that many doctors. We're going to lose too many power roles because of that. One thing to remember in this game is that things aren't always what they seem, ANYONE could be mafia as it's so easy to pretend to be town, so trusting other people is pretty much going to make us lose. Regarding Extol, I'm still a little lost as to why people think he's mafia, there are reasons all over the place and people are jumping on the bandwagon for different reasons. If the mafia is trying to confuse people witht his, they got me. :( Etch is right, Extol is pretty much dead and there's nothing we can do to change it now. I think that if I vote for him now, people are just gonna jump on me saying OMNGSOIGFIOSGJLKSHS YOU JUMPED ON THE BANDWAGON DIEZORZ!?!?! or some shit like that. As stated, Extol isn't going to survive today when you look at it realistically, so I'm gonna go back and read some more to see if there is good reason for people thinking that he's mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Extol on 02/06/09 at 15:53:47 There isnt much i can do now, it looks inevitable that ill be lynched. Im not going to try to convince anyone else, i think my defense is pretty good, so i'm just going to look at what everyone says until the day is over and try to help figure out who is mafia. Im honestly pretty lost. If anyones giving subtle hints at being mafia im not picking them up, because it seems to me that the mafia are putting on really good disguises. Its been a good first game for me, its fun, and im sorry that i havent been able to really help out the other townies too much :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Lenny on 02/06/09 at 16:02:08 OK I just looked through, and strangely enough, there is a point where four people in a row vote for extol in four different posts. That alone looks very suspiscious to me. Tim voted, then Tom came on, as did Scott and Nate. I'm still not sure about Tom, admitting to be a power role doesn't necessarily mean he's not mafia. Scott and tim are pretty mysterious though, they both could be anything. These people people are going to be really suspicious for me if Extol turns out to be a townie, so I'll probably have to have to vote for him in that regard. Vote: Extol |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/06/09 at 16:03:44 Vote count update Extol - 9 (Brutus, Syzygy, In Hiding, nstinson, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, TJazZ, Lenny) K.McAteer - 3 (Etch, IsThatAGoodThing, Sportsguy) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (Ivootjes, Ariath) karterfreak - 1 (oneshot) Sportsguy - 1 (K.McAteer) Not voting: Extol, Howes, karterfreak With 19 players alive, it takes 10 votes to lynch. The day will end in 24 hours, or when someone reaches 10 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Syzygy on 02/06/09 at 16:17:45 Well I'm gonna leave it up to others to decide Extol's fate. Personally I'm completely unsure now as to whatever he is. Unvote Vote: KMacc Reason: Because he is mafia, why else? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/06/09 at 16:18:33 A lot can change in the course of 24 hours, so your admitting defeat shows to me that you are a mafia member and we played our cards right. If my town tries to lynch me I can guarantee you that I'd fight it tooth and nail. I just hope to god that we're right in lynching you, otherwise the game turns upside down for me and my suspicions as to the rest of the mafia is... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 16:27:17 Tim, Joe, Matt, and Ben are all mafia. It is as plain as day. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Syzygy on 02/06/09 at 16:28:44 Lynch me to regret it then idiot. If it's as plain as day then you are as thick as shit. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 16:47:35 EDIT: Tyler, Joe, Matt, and Ben are all mafia. I meant to say Tyler on the last one. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 16:50:01 Screw it, all I really think is JOE AND MATT FFS YOU TWO INTERLOCK SO GOD DAMN MANY POSTS YOU ARE FUCKING MAFIA GTFO AND DIE unvote VOTE MATT |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/06/09 at 16:58:59 I want Kmacc to be mafia too Tim, lol. Scott keeps trying to lynch most likely town players. Not very helpful. ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 17:04:53 Hmm, also BRUTUS is a fucking mafia, look how he conspires with Goose so elegantly in the early pages of the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 17:06:32 For some reason the mafia has been working on Extol for a long time. Brutus voted Extol for no apparent reason at the start of Day 3, then everyone has just rolled with it. Perfect way for the mafia to play, using the regular posting habits of the people they've got. They probably let Goose die because it wasn't going to hurt them anyway, and gave them all a great alibi. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 17:10:17 Also, most people who have tried to peg brutus for anything have been killed or hit hard. He's got to be a mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 17:13:13 Honko how many mafias are left? I want to say: Goose, Matt, Ben, Brutus, Tyler, and Joe are the mafia....but how many did we start with and how many are left |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Etch on 02/06/09 at 17:15:59 Playing dumb eh? I will just go with my fellow town members so you can shut up. unvote vote Extol |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/06/09 at 17:17:11 At the start of the game it was 1 Bowser 1 Wario 4 Koopa Troopas So with Goose dead there are 5 mafia remaining. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/06/09 at 17:19:19 Vote count update Extol - 9 (Brutus, In Hiding, nstinson, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, TJazZ, Lenny, Etch) K.McAteer - 2 (Sportsguy, Syzygy) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (Ivootjes, Ariath) karterfreak - 2 (oneshot, IsThatAGoodThing) Sportsguy - 1 (K.McAteer) Not voting: Extol, Howes, karterfreak With 19 players alive, it takes 10 votes to lynch. The day will end in 24 hours, or when someone reaches 10 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Jabes on 02/06/09 at 17:28:21 Scott, if anyone should be criticized for interlocking posts, shouldn't it be you? Every time you post you post three separate times... And you thinking i'm mafia is pretty stunning because i've pretty much agreed with you throughout this whole game. I don't know the best way to convince you that i'm not in the mafia, except to state very blatantly what my townie role is, but i don't want to give the mafia any information. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 17:32:45 Obv bowser, says it under your avatar. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 17:35:29 Haha I find it funny how no one wants to be the final killing vote on Extol...probably because we all realize or think he's town and don't want to kill him, and because whoever kills him last will be called mafia.....I don't care! But this is just so you can all see what I'm saying is right! So i will kill him haha. it's inevitable anyway, with such a strong lead in votes. unvote Vote Extol |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 17:36:15 Joe the reason I post a lot is because you're not supposed to edit stuff in here.....noramlly I edit posts a TON everyehwere else on the forum, but here I'm not supposed to do it so I dont! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/06/09 at 17:37:10 Now we can move on.....watch who the first people attacked by my suspects are! Especially brutus who sseeeeeems to have a ton of power....these are the mafia and they will hunt us down! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 3] Post by Honko on 02/06/09 at 17:48:40 Although they had lynched the evil Goose the day before, the players knew there must be another killer. They quickly ganged up on Extol. "Your name has an X in it, and the title says Mario Kart X Mafia, so you must be mafia!" "No, please wait, I can explain everything," shouted Extol, but it was too late. The other karters grabbed their handy lynch machine guns and shot him down. Extol has been lynched. He was a Mii. "Oops." Final Day 3 Vote Tally Extol - 10 (Brutus, In Hiding, nstinson, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, TJazZ, Lenny, Etch, IsThatAGoodThing) K.McAteer - 2 (Sportsguy, Syzygy) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (Ivootjes, Ariath) karterfreak - 1 (oneshot) Sportsguy - 1 (K.McAteer) Not voting - Extol, Howes, karterfreak It is now Night 3. No more talking. Send me your night actions via PM by 5:00pm Pacific time tomorrow. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 3] Post by Honko on 02/07/09 at 17:15:06 Morning came, and everyone felt better after a good night's sleep. Sure, they may have killed another one of their own yesterday, but it's a new day today! Anything can happen! As they were enjoying some bacon and eggs for breakfast, they suddenly realized something was wrong. Someone was missing. Another murder! Oh no! Etch has been killed. He was Luigi, Town Cop. Day 4 begins now. With 17 players alive, 9 votes are needed to lynch. The deadline for the day is Tuesday at 5pm Pacific time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Syzygy on 02/07/09 at 17:20:49 Vote: Kmacc because he's mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by K. McAteer on 02/07/09 at 17:24:20 I'm not mafia.. I think I explained myself pretty well. Also if I was mafia I would have been one of the people lynching Extol, but I didn't because I didn't think he'd be mafia. I don't know what else you think I've done that you think looks "suspicious". |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 17:28:21 I read every page of this entire thread yesterday and today, and i've made a list of all the people i suspect to be mafia. I will not mention any of the players names, but since we've lost our cop, all i will say id that no one on goose's list appears on mine. Vote Brutus It's now or never. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 17:43:11 Vote kmacc Kmaccs actions have been largely unhelpful thus far and that leads me to believe that he is mafia. I was certain Extol was mafia. I guess not. Kmacc is the way to go. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 17:43:59 Any good guy who votes for me is an idiot |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by karterfreak on 02/07/09 at 17:48:33 Quote:
My theory was right that the mafia would vote someone off who WASN'T on this list. Problem is, now we cant do the strategy i brought up because our cop is dead. What does everyone think we should do? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by K. McAteer on 02/07/09 at 17:56:10 How have I done nothing helpful? I tried to say that it was stupid voting for Extol, cause I didn't believe he was mafia. He still got lynched and look he was a townie. How was I not helping out? At least I was trying to save someone who turned out to be a townie.. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 18:01:28 We should kill everyone on that list |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by In Hiding on 02/07/09 at 18:03:10 i'm sorry for voting for him but he was sus. Anyone got any ideas? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 18:04:46 Awfully suspicious that Syzygy shot in a vote as soon as the thread opened without even responding to the nights action in the least. He and brutus seem very mafia, and if they aren't then they haven't helped the town at all for the whole game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by K. McAteer on 02/07/09 at 18:08:54 Yeah, between day 3 and now, Tim has been just voting for me just because it seems, not really caring how I justify myself. It is suspicious but it's too early to vote today. I'm gonna read back some more on some of the day three actions. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by TJazZ on 02/07/09 at 18:15:22 Vote: Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 18:18:21 you sure you wanna kill a townie benoit |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by TJazZ on 02/07/09 at 18:22:43 49797E7F7E780B0 wrote:
6E5E5958595F2C0 wrote:
231314151412610 wrote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 18:27:17 Brutus has been vague all came, and I've got little doubt in my mind that he's mafia. Matt was right, but extol was a good stepping stone to see if we could trust his list. I want to say that nearly all of the list appears to be town to me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 18:29:23 *vague all game, and trust goose's list. Typing on an ipod touch is tough.. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 18:30:21 you're all bein misled by the mafia |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Ariath on 02/07/09 at 18:30:52 Ugh, we lost our first power role :S Anyway though, I haven’t suspected anything of Brutus since the beginning of the game, but I’m now starting to change my mind. I just realized that ever since Goose was lynched, Brutus has been relatively quiet. I find it funny that he acted the exact same way as Goose up until Goose was lynched. Now he’s mysteriously quiet though. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by TJazZ on 02/07/09 at 18:36:07 Brutus, for the record, you were so sure of yourself that I gave you the benefit of the doubt that you and Syzygy knew what the hell was going on because of your power-roles. I was hoping you were on my side but that was obviously not the case because of Extol. You're the Wario and Syzygy is Bowser. One of you can go get lynched now. [smiley=uzi.gif] [smiley=dead.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 18:36:28 Brutus I don't know what to think of you. Joe's a pretty smart poster though. I agree with him that upon rereading the entire topic you seem suspicious. I'm afraid, however, that the people talking about rereading are all mafia :-/ .... I cannot think of anything else to do but vote for Yunus. If he (or anyone else) can convince me that someone else is a more dangerous suspect, I'll be fine to change my vote. Also, I have something I got by IM last night, I'll let you guys see it and just see what you think it all means and stuff. Quote:
Could be a mafia ploy because I mentioned him in a post and he wanted to clear his name, but I think he's probably telling the truth but I don't really know what to think. I don't even know if this is really syzygy....I have over 200 contacts from here but not him, even though we were in IRC together for quite some time. Maybe someone can confirm this is Tim? vote: Brutus Also does everyone have to re-vote after the lynch has happened? Like if someone had a vote on Matt but then the lynch happened, do they have to re-vote or does that vote still stand? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 18:37:38 Ariath, do you feel confidentin your suspicion enough to vote Brutus as well? The more support we have against him can go a long way. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 18:38:10 I see Ben's last post now, after making mine...I agree with him that Brutus has seemingly had a ton of power but I JUST thought of something.... BEN AND JOE HAVE BEEN MAKING IT LOOK LIKE BRUTUS IS IN POWER THE WHOLE TIME IT IS A GREAT PLAN MAKES THEM LAST A LONG TIME, BECAUSE BRUTUS IS GOING TO GET LYNCHED HERE THEY HOPE Each time brutus cast a vote they made sure that person would get lynched. What do you guys think? unvote Vote Ben |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 18:38:58 BEN AND JOE ARE SUCH A TAG TEAM THEY BOTH MADE THE "LISTS" THEY ARE FUCKING WITH US SO BAD THEY JUST HAPPEN TO BE THE TWO MAFIA WHO CAN BLOW OUR MINDS SO EASILY |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Honko on 02/07/09 at 18:40:15 Votes always reset after a lynch. Vote count update Brutus - 2 (Jabes, TJazZ) K.McAteer - 2 (Syzygy, Brutus) TJazZ - 1 (IsThatAGoodThing) Not voting: In Hiding, nstinson, Fababu, dragondragon, Lenny, Sportsguy, Ivootjes, Ariath, oneshot, K.McAteer, Howes, karterfreak With 17 players alive, it takes 9 votes to lynch. The day will end in 70 hours, or when someone reaches 9 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by TJazZ on 02/07/09 at 18:42:53 I think you are mafia with Syzygy and Brutus, Scott. I've pinned you as mafia since day 2. ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 18:48:06 Scott, you keep flip flopping sides that its tough to read if youre mafia or not. How's this, if you support me for lynching Brutus today and im wrong and he ends up being a townie, then lynch me the very next day if you think i'm mafia. Extol was already sacrificed to get the information i wanted from brutus and syzygy. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 18:50:11 You guys are so totally mafia, if not then Brutus is....because I don't know what to think, I will attack the tag team because you two seem so much more powerful! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 18:51:00 Also stop calling me mafia. If I was mafia I wouldn't be playing like a dumbass that didn't know what the hell was going on all the time. I could own you losers if I was mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 18:56:04 I'm getting really offensive lately in here....probably because you guys are shit at this game and our good guy Etch got killed. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 18:56:29 Right now the town has an advantage, and im doing everything in my power to maintain our power. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 18:57:13 Yeah, more like kill all the other townies. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 18:58:08 If you and Ben aren't mafia, then who is, Joe????? Maybe brutus is...but that's only ONE, there are FIVE MORE.....Maybe some of them have been quiet but I'm betting that at least a couple of them have been VERY ACTIVE and are swinging our feelings with EVERY FUCKING POST, and the most people that have been doing that are YOU AND BEN. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 18:58:36 *maintain our towns power. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 19:03:11 Its not my fault that im participating in the game and stinson and syzygy wont ever reply. It seems that brutus, stinson, and syzygy are suspects. I still stand by my vote to vote for brutus. Also, the vote to lynch him was getting respect before scott shot in to lynch me and ben because of a supposed tag team. Scott also appears to be mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 19:03:56 Yeh you better cover up for yourself, mafia scum. You still haven't shown me why you're not mafia. You're afraid to let BEN back you up because you'd be FUCKED then as it would prove my POINT. GTFO! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 19:04:49 Dude I thought brutus was mafia until I realized he cant have THAT much power. everything hes said was right, you guys have been EMPOWERING HIS VOTE. he's too retarded to be mafia and not blow it, anyway. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 19:10:42 Scott is doing a good job at covering for brutus. I really need the towns support to lynch brutus, because the more scott posts, the more im sure im right. And remember, if brutus isnt mafia, lynch me the very next day. I promise you that. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:11:00 fuck you scott I am mafia ok. i sure fooled you. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 19:11:55 FUCK you then, Joe....I will vote for brutus, fine. I guess I was wrong about you two fuckers but if you are turning the tables on me with this shit I give the fuck up. unvote Vote brutus I also note that Ben still isn't posting in your normal tag team fashion. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:12:44 asshole |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:13:29 scott stop swearing, you just sound like a retard |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Lenny on 02/07/09 at 19:14:29 Clearly, Scott, Brutus, Joe, Ben and Tim are all in league with each other [smiley=lolk.gif] Brutus is now being REALLY suspicious. His general posting manner actually seems like it could be an awesome cover for mafia. I'm sticking with him until he provides solid evidence that he's not mafia, which is pretty impossible imo. Vote: Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 19:14:41 WTF am I suppsoed to do. Joe and Ben are tag teaming the shit out of everyone, IMO....but whatever It seems I must vote for brutus who is probably also mafia. If the mafia was brutus goose joe ben and matt you guys have such aperfect setup by making them vote off two of their own then they totally own the shit out of us the rest of the game but thats probably not happening so WHO TEH FUCK IS MAFIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BRUTUS YOU BETTER FUCKING BE ONE BUT IF YOU ARE IM STILL VOTING FOR JOE OR BEN UNLESS THEY PROVE TO ME WHY THIS TAG TEAM BULLSHIT ISNT SOME SCAM |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:14:57 all three of you are mafia |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:15:39 (scott, joe, ben) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Honko on 02/07/09 at 19:16:25 Clam down people, no need for swearing, it's just a game, etc etc. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:16:39 i'm sure the power role could tell you guys i'm not mafia |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 19:17:16 Yeah fucking right. Ben has just enough personal contact with everyone that he can be the evilest SOB ever, him and Joe too...they also both have yellow names which makes us more comfortable around them. You guys are a bunch of shit but joe seems to be pleading well and that must be the plan to vote of brutus but hes freaking out hardcore shit over just ME voting for him. usually when just one person has a vote on someone you dont get like 8 response posts freaking out about it, I bet I hit a nerve. We will attack joe soon! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by K. McAteer on 02/07/09 at 19:17:34 I think I may have to agree with Joe and Benoit to an extent, that both Brutus and Tim seem very suspicious. I looked at the day two voting, and both neither of them voted towards Goose. Brutus did briefly but then took that vote right back off. Neither contributed to that lynching. Then Goose said this: 77724D4C5140624A4A5640250 wrote:
In my opinion, it seems to me that Goose is trying to throw us off here. Making it seem like Brutus is a townie. On day three, Brutus was the one who started the bandwagon to take off Extol, and Tim was the first to follow it. They also both voted to lynch Extol on day two at some point. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:17:41 actually I don't know what he'd say. [smiley=roll.gif] unvote vote: joe bernier |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 19:18:32 Robin I can say what I want, I want to get my point across that I'm not pleased and this game seems to be going very slow. no one is helping much, we will be mowed down two by two, one in day one in night. now that our super role etch is out of the running, we are seriously in trouble, so what should we do now other than KILL THESE FUCKERS WHOARE FCUKIGN WTIH US BECAUSE THEY WANT TO WIN AND ARE OWNING THE SHIT OUT OF Us!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 19:20:01 brutus tim and who else, kmacc.....we need to have a good set of names at this point, not just one or two.... THERE ARE FIVE MAFIA LEFT THAT IS A HUGE NUMBER AND YOU HAVE TO REALIZE TONS OF POSTS ARE PROBABLY BY THEM UNLESS THEYRE ALL BEING REALLY QUIET. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:20:57 Me, Ariath, Syzygy Benoit and Adam L are mafia |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 19:21:24 Vote brutus and find out he's mafia. If he's not, then it puts a majof hole in my logic, and that doesnt happen very often. I will sacrifice myself for a town victory. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:22:14 youre stupid |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 19:23:45 Adam L isnt even in the game idiot brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:23:57 unvote Vote: IsThatAGoodThing |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:25:53 unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 19:25:59 vote me off and you lose someone whos actually posting and saying everything he thinks as soon as he thinks it, intot he topic....I read everything in here and I want to know what to htink but I just dont. I'm not going to go on for 5 pages of excuses like Joe did when i voted for ben and called him out by name. just so you know i think ben is still mafia but joe has done a good job here of sounding totally pissed off. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:26:38 vote: IsThatAGoodThing |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Adam L on 02/07/09 at 19:28:09 Scott, I am in this game, I'm just not on the list. Me and Honko talked it over and he agreed it would be a fun twist on the game. I'm a hidden mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:29:18 Don't blow your cover! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by K. McAteer on 02/07/09 at 19:30:26 Scott: It may be only a set of two names right now, but you gotta remember it's hard to analyze everything and always catch onto things. We won't be able to get a solid list of five people right now, and I'd say having any people who we feel strongly towards being mafia is a great start. Like I said, as of right now, Brutus and Tim seem the most suspicious to me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 19:31:59 Ive made no excuses, ive only stated my opinion. Can we get a vote count? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Honko on 02/07/09 at 19:35:12 Vote count update Brutus - 4 (Jabes, TJazZ, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny) K.McAteer - 1 (Syzygy) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (Brutus) Not voting: In Hiding, nstinson, Fababu, dragondragon, Sportsguy, Ivootjes, Ariath, oneshot, K.McAteer, Howes, karterfreak With 17 players alive, it takes 9 votes to lynch. The day will end in 69 hours, or when someone reaches 9 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Howes on 02/07/09 at 19:38:24 First of all, Scott, most of the posts that you have been making for the last page could also describe your posting habits. You say that the mafia could have some people posting a little while others post a lot, and lately, you fall into the second category. However, that has been your posting style for the last few games, so at least you are consistent. You probably need to calm down, and maybe change your posting style a bit to give others a chance to speak. Secondly, and more importantly, Brutus. You haven't given us much analysis all game, and have voted by just giving simple reasons for your choice. You have proven to be more suspicious than Scott, and aren't helping anyone but yourself. We would probably be better off if you were gone, as you seem guilty, and at the very least, the input that we get will be backed up with better reasoning behind it. Vote: Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 19:46:38 idiot |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Ariath on 02/07/09 at 19:51:10 Sorry for not replying to you on page 20 Joe. I actually meant to vote for Brutus in that post, but I actually forgot. I'm going to hold off right now though, because now I'm actually not totally sure that Brutus is mafia. Yes, he's acting weird, but perhaps he just thinks it's fun screwing with us? I'll vote after seeing a couple more posts. Also, on another note, I just realized that nobody (at least I think nobody) has gone back and checked Etch's posts. If he was a scanner, then surely he must have been hinting at who was and wasn't mafia. So I'm going to look back at Etch's posts right now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 20:00:39 Brutus isnt trying to help the town and now weve got him on the ropes. And remember, if brutus was scanned and he is bowser, etch would have been told he was a normal townie. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Ariath on 02/07/09 at 20:04:35 Quote:
Quote:
Just a thought, but perhaps these two quotes from etch are actually both correct? In the first, he seemed pretty sure that Benoit was a townie, so I'll continue to trust him. In the second post though, he stated that his vote for Kmacc was a 'spite' vote. Maybe he scanned kmacc and he actually is mafia; Etch could have been giving subtle hints as to who's who. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by K. McAteer on 02/07/09 at 20:08:51 Well that is because I voted for Etch jokingly. As you can see in the MKDS news title, I even jokingly said Etch is mafia. Nothing more than a joke. That is why Etch said it was a spite vote. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Ariath on 02/07/09 at 20:08:56 Eh, I'm still going to hold back on my vote Joe. I see your reasoning and I would agree with you if this were any other person we were talking about, but it's Brutus, so I can't say that I would be surprised if Brutus just didn't care, and that people saw Brutus' screwing around as 'mafia' behavior. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Ariath on 02/07/09 at 20:10:30 Yeah, that's probably the case Kevin, but I'm just throwing out ideas right now, because I'm honestly clueless as to who's mafia at the moment. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 20:19:27 I'll give you a hint: |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 20:59:00 Ok here it is Anyone who votes to lynch me is mafia - so far at least, unless they have doubts that I am on the team against them. Anyone who votes for me and is on the good team should feel bad that they are so stupid. Sayin that you gonna vote for me, and don't care if I am a townie because I am "not adding anything to the game" is stupid as fuck and you deserve to lose the game. The most logical move by the mafia would be to vote to lynch me right now. I'm the perfect target. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 21:07:01 How are you the perfect target? You've been dishonest the entire game, and now you're saying that anyone who votes for you is mafia. You need to get out of the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by nstinson on 02/07/09 at 21:16:44 I really wanted to vote syz, since he jumped on Brutus so soon after the night events without saying anything about what happened (us losing a power guy).... but, then I want to vote for Scott, Joe, and Brutus, because of the whole mess with them... So, for now, vote Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:17:17 Probably because you guys are mafia and are setting us up by helping to vote out both Goose and Brutus....I expect that one or two of hte mafia are rather experienced and intelligent players in this round, and they're orchestrating an entire collapse of shit around the town once they realize waht has just happened. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:18:12 Stinson just because we have a mess doesn't mean were a target. I've been just trying to work my thoughts out in here and you know everything I say gets more info out of people. Now we have about 15 more posts for free just from me going on a total craze there for a bit. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:20:59 Ariath why arent you voting for brutus. Better not be because the mafia are a bunch of idiots that ARENT trying to totally fuck this shit up like crazy, if thats the case then you are mafia, kmacc is mafia, and stinson is mafia. Except tehse are people i didnt even talk about before! But I bet we will know more if we kill brutus. but he seems to want to live he is doing a great job defending himself. he wants us all to be confused as shit. the reason people want to vote out brutus is because we feel hes dangerous but wtf man lets do it anyway? i dunno, but he is a maniac sometimes so we have to see about this. he will probably be either mafia or town or have a sepcial role, i think, because he is a smart player. i bet he has a big plan with the mafia to be a total lunatic, now in the next 2 days, joe and ben will choose a different target, after going SO strong on brutus for this short time. then they will lynch out osmeone else, brutus joe and ben will be free sailing because they put such hard pressure on each other. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:22:00 why does everyone seem to think tim's so strong? imo hes just retarded noobness and doesn't really know what hes doing, like me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 21:24:12 I dont mind you posting your thoughts and trying to get information from people, because thats the entire point to the game. Imagine how much more fun it would be to still be in day one with no one talking. The only problem i have with you scott is that you flip your thoughts around and its hard to read. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:24:20 but the good thing is we finally ahve some input from people outside the whole big thing there earlier. kmacc seems to have a level head in his stuff here. ariath I am not so sure about I think it is very suspicious that sinson pops in like this, IMO if he wasn't a special roll of some sort he wouldn't even LOAD this shit up because like he was playing some shit off with goose which was quite epic, maybe they were in league or something. stinson just starts jumping on this brutus stuff i bet he hasnte ven been reading, why does he suddenly change modes so fast? he was acting absolutley clueless earlier and going back and forth with goose so strong, maybe it was all part of their plan so maybe i was super wrong int he last couple pages nad stinson is the fucking mafia which would be so funny but seriously think abou tit THINK ABOUT IT stinson would not be posting if he was just a MII, anyone agree? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 21:25:27 I'm pretty sure that me, scott and tim are all good guys. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:26:48 joe im just saying man I type everything I think of, it has to help because we will be able to pick up on something eventually. I think by saying every single idea I get we are going to fucking win this thing!!! but i haven't reread this shit in the last about day or so so maybe in a bit here i'll just start from the top again and see what I get. good thing there is still a lot of town left, so after whoever dies here, we will be able to still have some power. just need to get those certain people checking in on the game WHERE IN THE HELL IS SPORTSGUY ??????????? Staying out of sight, perhaps? I doubt it....I'm thinking he's one of those town people who can do a special move! So this is why he is being quiet! Hopefully ! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 21:28:01 4B6C6B71606B6F6A556A726077050 wrote:
because I set myself up by saying "if extol isn't mafia, I'm mafia", i have been very ubiquitous and incognito the entire time and been confusing stupid people. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:28:52 Brutus is afaggot probably mafia, he is saying me and tim in his posts to try to get some sort of association between us there is nor eason for him to say that, but maybe he is a town if he is town then these people attacking brutus so hard need to be OWNED, btw. But it is a long time until brutus can be voted off because he is needing a handful more votes. I bet something will try to change the tide of the game here in coming time and it will tell a lot! But maybe it would be a good idea to ask ariath more. is he just a tard or is he got some serious reason why he think brutus is clean? But remember this BRUTUS is able to seemingly get whoever he wants voted off in the earlier days! like he just randomly voted at the start of day 2 and look what happened! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/07/09 at 21:28:59 477770717076050 wrote:
Vote: Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 21:30:54 unvote vote: dragondragon |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:30:56 so at this point ive pretty much brought up everyone I think in all my raving and pointless shit, but i realize dragondragon hasnt been brought up!!!!!!!!! he seems to be taking this very seriously his posts were well thguoht through and stuff. maybe he is taking it seriously! I bet he is a good player and probably town but maybe he's fucking with us I should go read everything he said again great time to pop in eric, now yuo're under my magnifying glass! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 21:31:43 Scott at this point you're fucking with yourself |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 21:34:43 Vote count? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:36:44 Okay huge problem: IVO IVO you have not been in IRC like you were all the time in the first mafia game you also have not been posting here as often this is a dramatic change in your behavior, almost as if I dont remember you're there. I actually didnt even think of you until this moment. How did I think of you now? Because I was reading some stuff in/around dragondragon's posts. Now I realize one way this huge shift might happen is because you are now MAFIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! But it just might be that you aren't the host anymore :( |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by dragondragon on 02/07/09 at 21:37:42 7 for Brutus I believe. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:37:56 But you see what I am saying? Ivo was so totally into the game but now he isn't posting as much and his posts don't have very much content! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by dragondragon on 02/07/09 at 21:42:58 I think Ivo is fine, since he was siding with Extol before. Of course nothing is 100% in this game, so everything should be examined many times. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by K. McAteer on 02/07/09 at 21:44:30 The only problem with the quiet people is they could also be a power role. Like mafia tries to hide under the radar sometimes from being lynched so they don't talk much. Power roles could be doing the same, so they can being slowly getting some information without being noticed, so they have a better chance at staying in the game. But at the same time that'd be a stupid strategy because you wouldn't be letting any of your discoveries known (assuming they're a scanner). I guess the above behavior would be understandable for a role-blocker though. Anyway, since we shouldn't really risk lynching people who have been quiet this early, we really need to focus on who is more active and giving us stuff to work with. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Honko on 02/07/09 at 21:47:34 Vote count update Brutus - 7 (Jabes, TJazZ, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny, Howes, nstinson, dragondragon) K.McAteer - 1 (Syzygy) dragondragon - 1 (Brutus) Not voting: In Hiding, Fababu, Sportsguy, Ivootjes, Ariath, oneshot, K.McAteer, karterfreak With 17 players alive, it takes 9 votes to lynch. The day will end in 67 hours, or when someone reaches 9 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Jabes on 02/07/09 at 21:49:46 Kmacc, are you voting brutus as well? After you we would only need one more... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 21:51:48 joe, benoit, lenny, stinson, dragon dragon ^ mafia i think howes is just stupid |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by K. McAteer on 02/07/09 at 21:51:53 With the way Brutus has been acting, it seems voting for him is inevitable. Even if he is a townie, we can't even blame ourselves for voting for him because he is acting in such a confusing manner. He is actually making it worse for us townies to try and figure things out, by constantly saying he's town, mafia, etc. At this point it seems like there's no other choice really. I feel he's suspicious anyway, so I guess soon, we may find out. vote: Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:53:45 Clark 3 Adam L 4 Aidan foyel 1 alexpenev 1 Ariath 17 Brutus 81 Drag 16 Cam 4 etch 15 extol 19 fababu 17 flo 1 Goose 42 honko 42 howes 6 tom 13 isthatagoodthing 95 ivo 7 joe 36 kmacc 15 karterfreak 42 booth 3 lenny 11 mvt 1 stinson 14 oneshot 5 tyler 6 superyoshi 4 syzygy 22 benoit 15 |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by K. McAteer on 02/07/09 at 21:53:59 Posted that without seeing your post Joe, but yeah voted for him in my previous post, seems like there's no other choice. He only seems to be making things worse and more confusing to us. If he is townie, then he's doing a terrible job of helping us find the mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Brutus on 02/07/09 at 21:55:08 hm well going by gooses list seems like joe and benoit are both mafia. howes could possibly be as well. I'd put kmacc on that list as well. this is my definitive list. unvote vote Brutus |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/07/09 at 21:55:25 Above is the total posts through the first 558 posts in the topic, i didnt add in the new ones that happened since i copied downthe infos. look you can see who is being VERY quiet and stuff like that in my opinon: oneshot is super quiet because he dont give a shit hoews is really quiet because he has a role of some sort there are a load of people between 10 and 20 posts, in that range.....even between 15 and 20, it's almost shocking. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 4] Post by Honko on 02/07/09 at 22:05:29 Desperate to find Luigi's killer, the group became angrier than ever. "Hey, that guy has a funny hat! Die, mafia scum!!" "Yeah, I'm mafia! Come get me! Just kidding, I'm town! No really, I'm bad. But not that bad. OLOLOLO" taunted Brutus as the group chased him around. They grabbed their handy lynch beam katanas and struck him down. "Long live the south!" cried Brutus, as he put himself out of his misery. Brutus has been lynched. He was a Mii. "Oops again." Final Day 4 Vote Tally Brutus - 9 (Jabes, TJazZ, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny, Howes, nstinson, dragondragon, K.McAteer, Brutus) K.McAteer - 1 (Syzygy) Not voting - In Hiding, Fababu, Sportsguy, Ivootjes, Ariath, oneshot, karterfreak It is now Night 4. No more talking. Send me your night actions via PM by 10:00pm Pacific time tomorrow. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 4] Post by Honko on 02/08/09 at 22:09:56 The karters woke up on Day 5 nervous but ready. After all, the worst had already passed, right? Sure, someone had probably died, but who could die that was more precious than Luigi? Oh, wait. karterfreak has been killed. He was Princess Peach, Town Doctor. Day 5 begins now. With 15 players alive, 8 votes are needed to lynch. The deadline for the day is Wednesday at 10pm Pacific time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 4] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/08/09 at 22:12:47 Dangit guys! We lost another power role. Those scanners are really getting the job done well. Shame to see Karterfreak go. For now I want to refer to a few things from before the lynching of brutus that seem to have great value now. 5B61467A736653557D7D76467A7B7C75120 wrote:
vote: BENOIT I think this is pretty clear, at least in my mind. I Love how ben stopped posting with that tagteam they had going, as soon as I accused of it. Let's vote out ben unless he shows a screenshot of his Mii PM ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/08/09 at 22:14:52 Well that blows... I can't even think of who may be mafia right now. My only other suspicious person was Tim, but that had direct correlation with Brutus. So since Brutus was a townie, it throws off my reasons for thinking Tim is mafia. Well, back to the drawing board. [smiley=thumbdown.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/08/09 at 22:17:59 I drew a pretty large board as to why Ben and Joe are killing us, let's try to kill Ben. If he's not mafia then we need to start looking at all the quiet people, as indicated by my small stats on posting. For example oneshot, howes, ivo, sportsguy. But first I think we need to kill Ben. It MUST happen! I see you were waiting for the topic to open again too, KMACC, do you have a mafia connection? (I hope not) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/08/09 at 22:18:17 Quote:
Posting a screenshot of a PM from me will get you modkilled. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/08/09 at 22:24:29 Let's at least give some time for others to say something first before we make any votes.. I'm probably going to have to go back and re-read yet again, but that's not happening tonight. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/08/09 at 23:41:13 Alright, Scott has seemed very suspicious, IMO... So, I am going to follow his vote one last time. If We get Ben, and he ended up being mafia, then Scott is the man. If not, then we'll know for sure Scott's a mafia (he wouldn't be so adamant about Joe and Ben) vote Benoit |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/09/09 at 00:18:57 I am totally shocked. I really couldnt believe that brutus wasnt mafia, and now this throws off the entire game and what i think to be right. This makes me look really really guilty, and im not sure if i can convince you that im not mafia. I told you to vote brutus and if he wasnt mafia then lynch me, and now im really regretting it. The way brutus played all game had me convinced that he was mafia. I do find this to be strange however: where has tom been? I know its going to seem that im just trying to get you to think about someone other than me, butif hes really a townie then we could really use him right now. Truth be told i almost quit the game last night when i read that brutus was a mii. I got so angry that i u locked the topic and wrote a whole paragraph about how i hate the fact that six people are playing the game while twelve people refuse to post and offer any insight. I dont think its fair and i really dont care to play anymore if it continues like this. Lynch me and find out that i havent been lying about absolutely anything in this game. I promise to mh entire town that ive only tried to help... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Lenny on 02/09/09 at 00:52:58 Whoa... I was really suspicious of Matt the way he was going spastic about everyone... Mafia are playing really well this game, they know what they're doing. :-X Anyway, who can we look at now? There are a number of suspicious characters, namely scott, joe and ben, as mentioned before. Although, the one I'm most suspicious of is... KMACC! His posting manner is pretty scummy, and he still remains suspicious. I'm not going to vote for anyone just yet though... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by karterfreak on 02/09/09 at 02:08:35 GG guys, knew my death was coming over the last 3 nights. I'm not gonna say anything cept I think you're all silly for voting both extol and brutus (well, voting for extol, even bothering to read brutus' posts after day 2), and that you should probably all reread the topic now ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by In Hiding on 02/09/09 at 02:19:46 Guys, Im here, i'm just wondering who the fuck to vote for. Lenny, are you mafia? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Lenny on 02/09/09 at 02:37:28 ^wtf, what kind of question is that? It defies the purpose of the game, you can't just ask someone if they're mafia lol. Too many people are asking that. xD In answer to your question, I am a mysterious role that does mysterious things at night ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/09/09 at 03:28:26 Fuck this game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/09/09 at 03:34:24 First of all i want to apoligize for not posting at all yesterday. The topic was closed, i was busy for about a day and when i came back to check again brutus was lynched and the topic was closed again:( Lenny, that could be either good or bad for us if it's good ----> basicly you've given away that you're a special role and are a target for the mafia now. With our doctor died this is basicly asking to get killed. if it's bad ---> you're mafia? I don't know why you would admit to this though. if you're lying ----> townies shouldn't lie. In summary: dumb suspicious post I'm going to do a reread of the topic now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ariath on 02/09/09 at 03:51:34 Wtf at Lenny's post. I'm not sure whether you're a power role or mafia, but that was a VERY suspicious post. Vote: Lenny |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/09/09 at 03:53:00 Can we possibly have the game go any slower? Because right now I'm seriously considering getting modkilled... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/09/09 at 03:53:38 Okay, I'm starting to see a trend forming here. A townie gets lynched People who started the lynching are now suspicious the next day those people get lynched... guess what they were townies too. I'm starting to think that the Mafia are pretty much letting ourselves self-destruct by kinda staying in the shadows and just popping up with a 1 post vote with limited explanation. For example, Nstinson. He just pops in, votes and leaves until somebody gets lynched. I'm not voting for him yet but I'm just sayin'. Unfortunately, I don't have more time to post all my thoughts because because I'm leaving for work in a couple of minutes. Hopefully when I get back, it's not night 5 already. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/09/09 at 03:54:05 Day 1 Brutus - 4 (karterfreak, oneshotbilly, Ariath, Howes) goose - 4 (Jabes, Brutus, Etch, In Hiding) No Lynch - 3 (SuperYoshi1, Extol, EnigmaticCam) Jabes - 1 (Clark) Lenny - 1 (K. McAteer) Syzygy - 1 (Brutus) nstinson - 1 (Goose) NStinson - 1 (syzygy) InHiding - 1 (nstinson) Not voting - dragondragon, Fababu, In Hiding, IsThatAGoodThing, Ivootjes, Lenny, nstinson, Sportsguy001, TJazZ Day 2 Goose - 11 (In Hiding, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, karterfreak, nstinson, Extol, Ivootjes, Brutus, Ariath, Sportsguy) dragondragon - 1 (Goose) Extol - 1 (Syzygy) Jabes - 1 (TJazZ) Not voting - Howes, K. McAteer, SuperYoshi1, Etch, oneshotbilly, Ariath, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny Day 3 Extol - 10 (Brutus, In Hiding, nstinson, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, TJazZ, Lenny, Etch, IsThatAGoodThing) K.McAteer - 2 (Sportsguy, Syzygy) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (Ivootjes, Ariath) karterfreak - 1 (oneshot) Sportsguy - 1 (K.McAteer) Not voting - Extol, Howes, karterfreak Day 4 Brutus - 9 (Jabes, TJazZ, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny, Howes, nstinson, dragondragon, K.McAteer, Brutus) K.McAteer - 1 (Syzygy) Not voting - In Hiding, Fababu, Sportsguy, Ivootjes, Ariath, oneshot, karterfreak |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/09/09 at 03:56:45 Yeah, i think we shouldn't quick lynch anymore, we've got 3 full days to make a lynch, why not use them a little better. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/09/09 at 03:58:21 I agree with Ben. And Scott can think it's me tag-teaming with him or whatever, but if I'm going to continue playing this game, I'm going to post my two-cents. Vote: Stinson You don't help the game at all, so why the fuck did you sign up? Subquestion: why did you get assigned a mafia role if you're not even going to fucking play? This game is bullshit. Get this fucking show on the road... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/09/09 at 04:02:40 3 full days is WAYYY too long for a mafia game this big. I understand that quicklynching isn't the best way to go, but some people have to work nights, and I can't exactly sit around a computer and read 25 pages worth of posts. At this point I don't care if I get lynched, because it gets me out of the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by In Hiding on 02/09/09 at 04:05:26 unvote vote Ariath That post from him was weak. He's maf. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/09/09 at 04:09:12 unvote Vote: In Hiding Hey, watch me vote and then not say anything useful! Remember how I used to post a lot with various explanations on why I did that?! Well, not anymore! Just imagine that I'm Frank Grimes from that Simpsons episode where he flips out because of Homer. That's me right now. That's me... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by In Hiding on 02/09/09 at 04:27:24 Jabes I told you i'm donkey kong. If you try to vote me off then i'll get you kicked off with my power role. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/09/09 at 04:32:33 See if I care. My vote still stands. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/09/09 at 04:58:45 I didn't even get a chance to get on the MB on day 4. Let me read the pages i missed before i vote. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/09/09 at 05:27:35 Vote Isthatagoodthing I voted scott because he voted to lynch brutus and extol who both turned out to be townies, but he didn't vote for goose who turned out to be mafia. Tjazz did the exact same thing, so he is my next suspect. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/09/09 at 05:27:55 Blah blah blah, i didnt get a chance to see the board. Its very intriguing to learn that once someone joins a game based on posting on a forum, they all of a sudden don't post on the forum. Reread, pretend to reread, i dont care, just keep in mind that i'm a forum moderator, and i can see who is viewing a topic when i'm viewing a topic... Unvote Vote: sportsguy |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/09/09 at 05:37:39 Vote: Joe That fucker is talking way too much |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/09/09 at 05:41:36 Unvote Vote: Kmacc He's gotta be mafia. EDIT - If i had two votes i'd go for Joe still - one of them is mafia guarenteed. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/09/09 at 05:43:30 Day 4 went from 8:20 pm to 1:05 am eastern time zone. Not sure what i was doing before 8:20, but at 10 i was watching Harold and Kumar and then i went to bed after that. Believe me or not, but i didn't expect the day to be over with when i checked it sunday morning |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/09/09 at 07:19:41 Well with less people in the game now, day's will probably go quicker, if we like it or not, because less votes are needed for a lynch. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/09/09 at 08:43:49 Quote:
What about dragondragon, lenny, Ivootjes, sportsguy, etc? I've posted more than them:-p One reason this has been so hard is because there aren't enough really active posters. Those who do post actively get lynched pretty fast. So, I'd assume that the people who don't post a lot are pretty smart:) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/09/09 at 09:30:53 Lenny can you elaborate on your reasoning for why I'm suspicious? I don't see how my posts are scummy or anything. That being said, I am once again suspicious of Lenny as I was on day one. For example, the post you said about being a mysterious role that does mysterious things at night. Lets assume you are telling the truth. If you were townie, you'd be more active, trying to persuade us in who to vote for because you may have some info on the mafia. Plus you wouldn't make your post sound so suspicious. If you were mafia, then it'd make sense for your post to seem suspicious. Plus you also said mafia is playing a very good game, which is obvious yes, and I guess that possibly means they may have some prior experience? Whether it be from the last mafia game, or maybe they played prior to playing it on this mb. But I know you said on day one while campaigning the no lynch that you've played on some other site before, so you have that experience. If you had such experience, and you were townie, you'd obviously be trying to help out much more than you already have. But with the mafia playing such a "good game", you being at least a moderately experience player, and your post about the role, I am definately quite suspicious of you. And no, this isn't out of spite for you feeling I am suspicious. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/09/09 at 11:15:14 Argh I just typed out a fucking monster post and my internet crashed. [smiley=chairshot.gif] Ffs, that was the first time I've had time to type for ages thanks to the retarded Brutus lynch yesterday. I'll sum up. 1) Brutus lynch was stupid. He clearly wasn't mafia and we lost Matt. 2) Dragondragon you have shit grammar. 3) Ariath that was poor, Tom had a legit reason and you didn't. Spite votes are for day one. 4) Lol @ people thinking me and Brutus were in league. Fail. 5) Finally some people are seeing the big picture. Benoit is a definite suspect, as is KMACC (I told you), as is Jabes and possibly Lenny. 6) I was partly to blame for the Extol lynch and for that I apologise. Brutus voted for the hell of it and I just followed suit and it seemed to spiral from there. I unvoted because I knew it was a mistake but by then it was too late. 7) Nathan you haven't contributed anything constructive all game. And wtf at your comment about me after Etch got lynched? What do you want me to do? Cry that we lost a power role? I just voted to get the game moving, what else was I going to say? Obviously I'm gutted about it but I'm not going to make a scene when I don't have anything to contribute about it. 8) LETS USE THE FULL THREE DAYS. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/09/09 at 11:29:35 Stinson, i wasn't part of the lynch on extol, plus i actually gave reasoning why i made my votes. Usually more than just one line. I think i would have voted brutus if i had been online yesterday but that was because he was pretty scummy. Can't blame you guys for that but getting rid of extol was just dumb. Besides, i want to post more but don't have that much time every day (on some days i have :D), that's why i asked not to instalynch within 20 hours so it's possible for everyone to post their analysys. People who have been part in the lynches made (day 2, day 3 and day 4) From triggerhappy speedlynchers to the people who never seem to agree with the mass or don't vote at all NStinson - 3 (goose, extol, brutus) Dragondragon - 3 (goose, extol, brutus) Jabes - 3 (goose, extol, brutus) Fababu - 2 (goose, extol) Lenny - 2 (extol, brutus) Inhiding - 2 (goose, extol) Isthatagoodthing - 2 (extol, brutus) Tjazz - 2 (extol, brutus) Howes - 1 (Brutus) Ariath - 1 (goose) Ivootjes - 1 (goose) K Mc.ateer - 1 (brutus) Sportsguy - 1 (goose) Oneshotbilly - 0 Syzygy - 0 |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/09/09 at 11:38:12 Vote count update TJazZ - 2 (IsThatAGoodThing, nstinson) Lenny - 1 (Ariath) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (Sportsguy) Sportsguy - 1 (Jabes) K.McAteer - 1 (oneshot) Not voting: Syzygy, TJazZ, Lenny, Howes, dragondragon, Fababu, Ivootjes, K.McAteer With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 58 hours, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/09/09 at 11:47:34 Today's lynch seems like its going to be a make-or-break day. As the day goes on, it looks like there's going to be two separate stances as to who should get lynched, and associations with those people are going to form. So if one group gets the lynch done and that person is mafia, then continuing going for the rest of the people who are being associated with them may work. If that person was a townie, we have to go after the ones egging on the lynch. Today is extremely crucial. Tim, I'm still trying to figure out why you think I'm mafia. I didn't go for extol because I knew he would be a townie, at least I tried stopping that. As for the Brutus lynch, nobody can be blamed for that but Brutus himself. Even the person starting that lynch cannot be blamed, Brutus' behavior was confusing and he was asking for it. Mafia didn't even have to start anything to get rid of Brutus, he did that to himself. We really need the quiet players to wake up and start giving input, especially if they have power roles. If they aren't going to do anything, then they are only making it ten times harder for us townies to have any leads and make correct moves. As people have said, we really need this day to last as long as possible; we need as much imput from as many people as we can get. People must talk up first though! If certain people continue to say absolutely nothing at this point, we're going to have no choice but to lynch them, because it just seems like they're trying to fly under the radar. As for now, besides mostly Lenny and slightly Tim, the only other suspicious people for me are the ones being too quiet. I could understand earlier in the game being quiet because you want things to develop a bit, or you're busy. I was busy as well and I was new to the game so I had to ease myself into it. But now I'm helping as much as I can to try and find stuff, so there's no reason the other townies who aren't talking shouldn't do the same. Right now its 10 townies vs 5 mafia, we need to find another mafia player or two asap or we're toast. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ariath on 02/09/09 at 12:04:52 To Inhiding, the reason I voted for Lenny is that his post seemed very odd. I wasn't simply voting for him out of spite, but more to get an explanation out of him. He never gave me an explanation though, so it obviously wasn't effective. Unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Fababu on 02/09/09 at 12:08:15 Wow, it seems that a lot have happened that the last time I see this. I couldn't post in Day 4 just for the reason that when I returned to ym house after all morning, the night has started. I must read all the posts, so I will show my opinion after that; but at the moment, I have taken a decission at my vote: Vote:IsThatAGoodThing Scott, you know I don't have nothing against you;but there was an act of you that seems suspicious to me; and this is the post where you quote Clark, Brutus and me speaking at IRC. If you look it with attention, you could see I didn't said any important info about the game; and the fact that Brutus and Clark are now dead and I'am the only one alive make me doubt about you. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ariath on 02/09/09 at 12:08:50 Also, some more thought. Why are so many of you suspicious of nate? If you recall, Goose wanted to vote him off with a fiery passion. If goose was mafia, then why would he desperately be trying to get rid of nate? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/09/09 at 12:13:00 The thing is, with the this game you never know. For all we may know, that could have been a planned skit in order to make us think that if one is mafia, the other isn't. So we can sit here and think hmm well Goose is gone and he hated Nathan and wanted him off, so Nathan must be townie. But it could have been completely planned for all we know to throw us off. I'm not actually suspicious of Nathan myself, but that's just my opinion on what could be possible with that situation. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/09/09 at 14:16:32 Yeah, I'm thinking Stinson and Ariath could be both mafia, why else would Ariath be providing his seemingly most-thought-out post of the game right here? 6B48574A4C4B5F4D41080809380 wrote:
How clear do I have to make it for you that I was not at the comptuer the day Goose died. By the time I loaded the forum, the last vote had just been cast to kill Goose. Here I will even tell you exactly what I was doing that day: Day 2 started at 1pm my time, on Monday. I was able to check the topic for a quick skim at 3:30 between school and practice. At that time I made a small post just to show I was reading it at least. Later that night I made only a couple more posts. At this time we still had about as much information as Day 1 had, so there wasn't much to go on. Right before I went to bed, Goose made a post about scanning someone, which I responded to, somewhat suspiciously. It seemed this post was out of line with his normal posting habits so far. I went to bed at that time. I woke up that morning and went to school at about 8:00am, and because I didn't wake up early enough I didn't even have time to check the computer. That night we had a wrestling meet, so I was occupied from after school until at least around 10pm.....the killing vote on Goose happened at around 7pm my time. So between when Goose made a suspicious comment, and him getting voted off, I had no way of going to the forum or seeing what was going on. I surely would've cast my vote in his direction if I wasn't at the wrestling meet that night, and had been able to see the forum before then. As far as my votes for Brutus and Extol go, I voted for Extol because it was already inevitable, and I decided we may as well get it over with. He was only one vote short of being killed, and no one else had more than just a couple. For Brutus, I really was somewhat suspicious of him until he had about half the required votes for a lynch. Earlier in the game he made comments like "Goose is not mafia" and "I am mafia" which seemed to be somewhat truthful. But eventually I realized the truth in reply #498 which I quoted earlier, saying the mafia is making Brutus look like he has too much power, when actually he is probably just a townie. Again, however.....there was no avoiding him getting voted off, and it would've looked silly for me to just remove my vote on him at that point in the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/09/09 at 14:31:47 6F6566657B651C0 wrote:
I try to do good grammer at school, so I'm still learning, but I'm getting better I think, but as long as I get my point across that's ok, and I'm gonna reread these posts tonight to see if I see anything I didn't the first time around, so I'll be home soon and do that, but I'll do it later, so now I can relax and go home. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/09/09 at 14:35:10 unvote Vote Tjazz Based on Isthatagoodthing's long explanation |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ariath on 02/09/09 at 15:52:48 Scott, I don't understand your reasoning at all. How is that my most thought out post of the game? Maybe you're thinking of somebody else, because if you look through my posts, most of them are in this topic, and are huge blocks of text. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/09/09 at 17:49:42 Well Scott, congrats you're probably going to get me lynched by going ape shit over me voting for Brutus despite the fact that a lot of people have said, and rightfully so, that he was almost asking for it by the way he was acting and creating confusion. I hope for your sake (if you are town) that you don't get caught into the same sand trap I was caught in. If I get lynched and people see that I am a Mii, LIKE I SAID A BUNCH OF TIMES BEFORE, people are going to turn toward the person who initiated my lynching, you. Although, I admit you are doing a good job trying to avoid that so far. All I can say in my defence is that I feel I have posted with reason and logic this whole game based on the information I was able to gather inside this topic in plain sight of everyone. I have always tried to explain why I have acted the ways I have. I still feel that most people at this point still think that I am actually town but I fear your overzealous reaction toward me has planted fear and a big "What if Scott's right?" tag on me, à la Fox News. I'd also like to note that Etch was fairly confident that I was town and he was the town scanner. Alas, if you are convinced that I'm mafia everything I say to you will seem suspect and will only further incriminate me in your eyes. Brutus was just trying to help his cause when he said that I was being mislead by the mafia however I was convinced that he was just trying to save his sorry ass. Now, I know the feeling of frustration he must have been feeling because of my clueless-ness. I admit that lynching Brutus was a mistake but in all honesty I was hoping to get some reactions the following day but when I woke up he was already lynched and it was looking terrible for me because Scott went off on me before the topic was closed. I will say this to all the townies reading this: I feel like I have posted with reasonable logic with little-to-no secretiveness to the best of my ability this whole time. It's up to you to decide if I have actually been trying to help us out this whole time or if I have been lying through me teeth this whole time and Scott's conspiracy theories are correct. Unfortunately for me, by defending myself like this, I only back up Scott's theories of me being persuasive and shit. So GG, Scott. Check Mate. At this point I don't have anything except hope that the Town come to their senses. With 10 town and 5 mafia left, I hope they make choose to keep me because at 7 vs 5 you only need 1 confused townie to loose the game. Personally, I think Scott kinda went too far and his suspicions toward me are speculative at best but that's just my opinion. I will admit that I see where he's coming from because I was in his seat the previous day. Unfortunately I was wrong and so is he. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/09/09 at 18:57:50 I really don't think either Scott or Benoit are mafia at all in my opinion. But if one gets lynched today and turns out to be townie, it'd seem like the one other would be getting the lynched the next day at this rate. Hopefully we don't lynch of any fellow townies today though.. imo Lenny and Tim are mafia, but they're just gonna come in eventually and say "spite vote since we voted for you kmacc you are mafia no doubt MAFIA MAFIA." |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/09/09 at 19:31:59 I still don't feel write about Scott... He seems so heated, trying to throw blame all over the place... I don't think I'm going to give the benefit of the doubt vote Scott p.s. why do people keep singling me out for contributing nothing when there are more people than me who have posted less and voted less? :-p but, like I said before... the people who post a lot are seemingly incriminating themselves, since they keep getting lynched, so there's got to be something to be said for that. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/09/09 at 19:55:46 Well Ben you make a good appeal. Maybe on the ropes a bit? Or maybe a true plea from the heart....the main reason I've suspected you so hardcore is that you're one of the brightest people here, and it wouldn't be hard for you to weasel your way into a good standing position among us. There aren't too many people left in the game that are townies, and the chance of anyone being a mafia is approaching 50% quickly. I'd like to take this time to summarize a bit in the topic myself, as Ivo has been doing. Maybe after this experience of rethinking the game I will see things differently. Currently there are 15 players in the game. I will post my thoughts on all of them. Ariath: Ariath has posted 21 times in this topic so far. This is around the average for most players in the game. I do not know too much about him, outside of what I've seen in this topic. Because of that I cannot provide special insight on him from previous knowledge. Early in the game, Ariath seemed to be very cautious as far as making votes. He was already putting a spin on Tim and Brutus on Day 1. At the same time he suggested a relationship between Ben and Lenny, due to a small scuffle they'd had that perhaps looked acted out. Interestingly, after making three posts advocating not to lynch anyone, Ariath voted for Brutus. Later on, he scolded an attempt at voting No Lynch on Day 2, after he had been so cautious on Day 1. On Day 2, Ariath voted for Goose after Ryan made his secession speech accompanied by a list of names. This vote seemed to be fine, because who WOULDN'T vote for Goose after that point? Of course, that is a great spot for a mafia to throw in a vote on one of their own, as it is going to be seen as a "no brainer." Ariath showed he had been paying careful attention to the topic, by knowing exactly which posts of Goose's (the lyrics) had been deleted after his death. On Day 3, Ariath pointed his finger at IsThatAGoodThing, claiming he was "in an attempt to stay low," and saw Scott's first vote in the whole topic as an important clue to his apparent guilt. Ariath was resistant to voting for Brutus, seeming to see beyond his facade the true Mii inside. Recently, Ariath strongly defended Stinson, somewhat disturbed by the fact that several people have it out for him even though he hasn't shown too much in the game. Overall, I think Ariath is knowledgeable about the game of mafia. Multiple times he worried about the power roles on the townie's side, and he hasn't been spilling the blame around too much. Most of his input seems pretty solid, and he could be a great asset if he's a townie. Drag: Eric has 19 posts in this topic, again a pretty average number. In his first post, he dissed those advocating No Lynch, saying that a kill made by the town would put them at an advantage over a No Lynch for sure. This is the same stance taken VERY strongly by Goose at the same time, maybe it points to a connection between these two? Eric is a pretty bright guy, and I think he could handle playing the part of a secret mafia man quite well. Most of Drag's posts are simple one liners throwing accusations at Goose early on, and various other players as the game progressed. When Drag cast a vote for Extol, he also brought up Ivo and Lenny as shady characters. Although he has 19 posts, only a handful of them have actual content, as if he's just posting for the sake of posting. I don't think he's been following the topic too closely, as he seems generally uninformed at points. After seeing what all Drag has written, I feel he is somewhat a suspect. His posts come in bunches and make you feel like he's saying something, while he's actually not really inputting anything at all. Drag is doing a great job of staying under the radar, I think....this could mean he has a special role for the town, or is a Mafia. I would like to hear quite a bit more out of Drag, or else he will remain a suspect in my book. Fababu: Fababu has posted 18 times in the topic, once again close to that "normal" number that most players have made. Early in the game, Fababu took the stand against the No Lynch vote also. The only person who was against the No Lynch who has gotten voted out was Goose, who was mafia. Fababu has seemed well-informed all game long and was critical of Goose, but not too many others. He hasn't just been dishing out accusations at everyone, and seems somewhat cautious. Most of what he said had good reasoning behind it, and I don't think he is capable of being a mafia and pulling it off without suspicion. Oddly enough, he voted for me in a recent post, because of a bit of my "telling" earlier in the game with the Clark situation. Perhaps he was just annoyed at being an innocent bystander. Right now I don't see any red flags associated with Fababu, but that may change after I've finished reading the posts of everyone else. (to be continued) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/09/09 at 20:02:32 Players killed: Brutus, Clark, Goose, Cam, Etch, Extol, SuperYoshi, Karterfreak.....The mafia killed both Karterfreak and Etch because they discovered their special roles. I think earlier in the game, they must've been scanning, and if it came up Mii, they voted for someone else at random (SuperYoshi), or had a specific target in mind (Cam). Cam was voted out early in the previous game also, because he seems to have a fair amount of experience in Mafia. He didn't seem to be out to a great start (accusing Brutus, Clark, Karterfreak), but he did mention Goose and Ariath, of which one is mafia and the other is still somewhat suspect. At the last minute, Cam changed his vote to No Lynch, showing his experience with the game before. This kill was a great one by the mafia, as his reputation would lead to suspicion of Matt and Brutus (and perhaps Ariath), even though he wasn't correct. The second night's kill of SuperYoshi must've just been a somewhat random vote. He hadn't contributed much to the topic yet. One thing to note AGAIN is that he voted for No Lynch in Day 1, something which seems to lead to death more than those who said No Lynch was a terrible play. Etch and Karterfreak were quite plainly targets because of their special roles. The mafia's scanner is doing a great job in recent days. I'm expecting him to be a great player (or someone else on the mafia great at giving advice). Of those that the town killed (Goose, Brutus, Extol), all three DID seem somewhat suspicious. Brutus had been closely tied to Goose by multiple posters in Day 1 already, so it was no surprise to see the suspicion on him not go away. Extol's killing maybe wasn't quite as justified, there may be something to look into as far as who got that started and why he was killed so quickly. I think the mafia must've been at work with that one. I'll put commentary on the rest of the players still alive later, I have a bit to do right now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Howes on 02/09/09 at 20:07:08 Umm :-? ... Scott ... Mafia doesn't hace a scanner role. Read Robin's first posts again. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/09/09 at 20:08:57 Oh my! :( Well, they've been doing a great job anyway! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/09/09 at 20:11:37 It would seem that mafia killed Etch and Matt because they are both smart and could be seen as threats in the sense that they have good logic and are very good at analyzing. Unfortunately, those happened to be some of our power roles. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/09/09 at 20:12:55 Yes, this reaffirms the thought that there are at least one, likely two, and maybe even three very experienced and intelligent players on the mafia. Perhaps someone else wants to complete the player reviews I started earlier? I am a bit sick tonight, and probably won't be able to finish that writeup until tomorrow afternoon. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/09/09 at 20:33:04 Vote count update TJazZ - 2 (IsThatAGoodThing, Sportsguy) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (Fababu, nstinson) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) Sportsguy - 1 (Jabes) K.McAteer - 1 (oneshot) Not voting: Ariath, Syzygy, TJazZ, Lenny, Howes, dragondragon, Ivootjes, K.McAteer With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 50 hours, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Lenny on 02/09/09 at 22:19:21 @Kmacc: First off, what you seem to be doing is either jumping on people for a lynch, and on the other end of the spectrum, every time someone gets suspicious of you, you're quick to defend yourself and ask why people are suspicious of you, like this. If you look back, you'll see that you always question why people vote for you. This is of course natural, especially when people don't back up things with reasoning, but it's become a habit of yours, which is why I'm suspicious of you. And yes, you were correct I have played mafia before. Although now that I went to reread some more, I saw your defenses, and they were pretty good, so I'm going to lay off you for now. :) @Ariath: I couldn't give you an explanation because I'm in the most different time zone when compared to everyone else, so I don't post until after a while when you guys have gone off and I get home from school. ;) And regarding the mysterious things at night, did none of you see the ::) after it? It was a joke, I'm a Mii :-/ I realise it was pretty stupid, but I figured that if the mafia thought I was a power role, they would try to kill me, a Mii. I was trying to protect the other power roles. I see why you were suspicous, but don't kill me for a play tactic. xD There are suspicious figures about, including myself I realise, but I have a bad feeling we're going to end up lynching another townie. :-X |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/09/09 at 23:55:04 unvote Vote: Tom, Tyler, and Stinson Because every one of them refuses to play, and I'm fairly confident that they're all mafia. If the game keeps going this painfully slow, consider me boycotting the rest of the game. Fucking kill me for all I care, but this is absolutely painful. The mafia gets assigned their roles and they don't talk at all, while the town actually tries to play and they get penalized for it. Modkill me. I'm fucking begging you... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by In Hiding on 02/10/09 at 01:24:18 Huh? I'm playing a fair bit, i'm continually reading and re-reading to see who to lynch both with my normal vote and my power vote. If i'm honest i'm voting differently (i.e one person on the board) and one in pm - they are different people. So pray my instincts are right.. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/10/09 at 04:06:16 Jabes: You don't get penalized for playing the game, you get penalized for making dumb decisions. One of them was Clarks mistake on day 1, that cost us a day where we could have lynched goose instead :( The other mistake was lynching extol so quikly. If you really think that all the inactive people are scum then the solution is to lynch them. i do agree that some of the inactive people could very well be mafia so i don't really see that much problems with it. The game is running slow with 23 people, you could have expected that, but now you're in the game at least try to find mafia. What's up with oneshot and sportsguy btw, i don't say that i contributed that much to the game, but at least i tried to add content to every post I made. They've barely posted anything at all. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/10/09 at 05:24:31 For joe because he doesn't think that i'm posting enough. My suspicious for mafia: Joe: because he keeps getting on my case Ivo: because he says all the right things. He seams to be too good of a townie. Lenny: because he doesn't post very much Tjazz: because he seems too adamant about being a mii |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 05:45:39 I like what sporstguy has to say there...sorry but I have to go to school now, and can't finish that writeup I was doing....maybe someone else can? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/10/09 at 10:05:32 Sure it's bad for the town to lose power roles, but it also have a positive aspect. Now that we know that Etch was Luigi, we can look more closely at what he said, since odds are he was telling the truth about his suspicions. Etch had the ability to scan one person per night, so he might've found out some of the mafia members. Day 3 613B606268606A3E3E0B0 wrote:
It's not much to go off of, but Etch didn't give us anything else useful as a scanner. I just wish he wouldn't said more, like someone he didn't "think" was mafia. At least we could go back in retrospect after his death to see who he scanned as town and who he scanned as mafia. Town is only up by 4 now, so we're gonna have to take some chances if we're to win. Vote: Kmacc |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/10/09 at 10:09:09 In case I wasn't clear in my logic last post, the goal of a scanner is to get as much info out there about what roles people are and stay alive as long as possible, so when he dies, we'll know exactly who is what. A scanner shouldn't make any accusations unless it's been a scan, because otherwise the source isn't as reliable. They shouldn't make it obvious that they know, but make it subtle, so they dont get killed by the mafia, but we can put the pieces together after their death. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/10/09 at 13:52:13 Wow. Such great information posted in the 10 hours I've been asleep. Way to get to the bottom of this game, town. I've officially lost interest, and wish to be killed. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/10/09 at 13:54:35 You should have been killed along time ago. If you are so smart then you help us out instead of crying about it. No wonder you are a suspect. Your strat is shit, I hope you do get modkilled. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/10/09 at 13:56:11 You, Stinson, Tyler, and Tom are all mafia. It's not my fault that the town doesn't play... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/10/09 at 14:02:06 I'm going to laugh in your face when this game ends and you see I'm not mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/10/09 at 14:03:26 I personally couldn't care less at this point. Scott is pretty much the only one playing the game right now, and I doubt he and I can take down the entire mafia... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/10/09 at 14:07:09 Nice constructive post there. That has helped the town deduce.... fuck all. If you want to complain at least do so without being hypocritical. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/10/09 at 14:11:20 He posted a list of people who haven't made many contributing posts, and I believe that there's a reason for it. -Tom was active the first day and a little in the second, and that's about it. So he's probably mafia. -Stinson never posts, and when he does he just goes along with whoever is being lynched. He's mafia. -Tyler does almost the same thing, only he offers a little bit of explanation, but it's never how he feels, it's always about someone else's posts and why he agrees. He's mafia. I'm done. I have received confirmation from Robin that I will be replaced. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/10/09 at 14:12:13 Adam_L has replaced Jabes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/10/09 at 14:13:28 YEAAAAAAAAAAAH BOIIIIIIIIII |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/10/09 at 14:14:15 Yhey [smiley=happy.gif] Ok I don't think Tom is mafia, but Nathan is IMO. He's too "consistent" in his posting style and never seems to change his gameplan. Just has suspicious written all over him. Don't know who Tyler is x] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/10/09 at 14:15:52 I say we kill the shit out of Stinson then, because a) he's ugly and b)he's wicked suspicious. Good plan syzygyzygyzy. vote: nstinson |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/10/09 at 14:18:38 Vote count update TJazZ - 2 (IsThatAGoodThing, Sportsguy) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (Fababu, nstinson) K.McAteer - 2 (oneshot, dragondragon) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) nstinson - 1 (Adam_L) Not voting: Ariath, Syzygy, TJazZ, Lenny, Howes, Ivootjes, K.McAteer With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 32 hours, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/10/09 at 14:29:19 212B282B352B520 wrote:
Me neither lol. So Adam, welcome aboard. I would be fine to get a fresh pair of eyes in here. What are your thoughts up till now? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Fababu on 02/10/09 at 14:32:49 Unvote Scott is making an awesome job. I've to put my ideas in order, but I don't think that he is mafia; at least at the moment. You don't bother me when you post the conversation, but I get shcoked when I see how fast you post it and when I see that Clark and Brutus where both townies. I don't know if I will have the opportunity to post something like this again, I hope that Day 5 will keep until the deadline; but I want to share my thought with you at this moment of the game: After Day 1, I prepaired a list of 7 suspiciuos guys, that seemed mafia to me. 3 of them are killed now: Goose, Cam and Extol. One of the others is Scott, but looking at the posts that he make during the last days I don't think that he could be mafia; but he's a clever guy and he could be owning us, so who knows. Lenny is also in my list. His decission of no lynch at the very beggining seems extremely suspicious to me, because it's a plan that I haven't used anytime before (being mafia or townie when I played with my friends). His posts doesn't show him like an aboslute mafia, but his role of townie isn't sure for me. TJazz is the third. In the last days he has tried to be a perfect townie, helping us with his deductions; but is hard to forget his strange behaviour at the beggining of the game. And the last one is Ariath. I don't know what to think about him, because I thought that his post were empty of sense as Extol's posts, but If Extol was a townie, he could be too a townie. In the recent days, two more names have been add to my list: Szygy and KMacc. Both are playing a silly game between them voting one to the other, but writing some posts empty of sense and guesses about who they think could be mafia. This behaviour seems quite suspicious to me, if you're a townie you shouldn't be afraid to post everything you thought about the others: maybe you could be wrong, but your deductions could be also correct and make that townies win. I will keep exposing my thoughts if I have the opportunity in the following days. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/10/09 at 14:32:56 Are you and adam in league? :S (Directed at TJazZ) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/10/09 at 14:34:28 Vote: Fababu I don't care if this is out of spite. I'm sick of people thinking I'm mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/10/09 at 14:40:48 Dudes, we seriously need to think about what to do with Oneshot, he hasn't added anything to the game at all, and it is really possible that it's part of the gameplan if he's mafia. And if he's not than he's really screwing it up for town :( Welcome to the game Adam :D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/10/09 at 14:58:00 6641515541524C200 wrote:
I don't understand what I'm doing wrong then.... I mean, it's not like anyone's going to confuse the mafia so I always figured I'd try to be 100% truthful all the time. It's not my fault people are getting paranoid and shit... whipping out conspiracy theories out of their you-know-what. 3F3536352B354C0 wrote:
How could I? He joined 30 minutes ago. I was fairly confident that I knew where Joe was at so I assume Adam is the same now. Joe's frustration didn't manifest because he was Mafia and they were pwning us too hard to the point where it was unbearable... I'm just sayin'... The only way I see Joe as potentially mafia is if the mafia purposefully killed Goose to label some mafia members are "obvious" townies. In this case, Joe (now Adam) and Tom would be on the hot seat. I'm not accusing anyone but I'm saying it would be a sick move... BTW, I take back accusing you of being mafia on Day 4 and I'm pretty sure you are town at this point to tell you the truth. I got the lovely messages you left me on IRC saying I was a dumbass and such. I didn't realized I had left it open lol. Since you said to Brutus that you were pretty sure I was mafia (or else I was an idiot), tells me that you are town. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Howes on 02/10/09 at 15:32:12 Okay, now I think I know enough to post. Scott is obviously not mafia. If he had been mafia, he wouldn't have thought that they had a scanner, because he would have been receiving info from that scanner. Oneshot and Stinson are my main ideas for mafia. Personally, I think that the mafia is watching us try to tear each other apart, and not jeopardizing their lives by interrupting. Of the two people that I named, I distrust stinson more. Oneshot is probably doing the same thing as last game, which hurts the town no matter what role he is, so he will be my vote tomorrow. Vote: nstinson I think that Adam has the right idea, especially since he is a fresh pair of eyes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/10/09 at 17:50:52 Vote count update K.McAteer - 2 (oneshot, dragondragon) nstinson - 2 (Adam_L, Howes) TJazZ - 1 (Sportsguy) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (nstinson) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) Fababu - 1 (Syzygy) Howes - 1 (IsThatAGoodThing) Not voting: Fababu, Ariath, TJazZ, Lenny, Ivootjes, K.McAteer With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 28 hours, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/10/09 at 17:57:39 That seem to be some pretty strong points, nice stuff He had been so quiet but even his name is quiet. :o Vote Howes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/10/09 at 18:00:39 But i still don't get what extol has to do with this, could you please point me to his supicious posts? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/10/09 at 18:21:27 btw, Adam's just voting against me because he hates me, same as Joe. Not because they think I'm a mafia. Just thought you might want to know:) Anyways, Scott has swayed my opinion, top notch stuff unvote vote Howes but, of course, if this ends up being wrong, then Scott goes back on the lynch pile tomorrow! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/10/09 at 18:21:33 I think you made a good choice, Scott and here's why: The only people who knows for a fact that I am telling the truth are, infornically, the Mafia. They know I'm Town but why not try to vote me out then? I think it's because they want to get a Role player instead of a regular Mii (which is what I am). That's why, IMO, I only ammased 3 votes and not any more. I think they were waiting in the shadows [although that doesn't clear SportsGuy btw] until another townie who they suspect is a Role player ammases 2 or 3 votes so they can act like it "naturally" climbed up to an seemingly insurmountable amout at 6 or 7 votes. Perhaps Howes was giving the green light to his fellow team-mates to vote for NStinson since a lot of people have expressed their uncertainty around him. Surely if the Mafia suspect NStinson to be a Role player and they see that Townies have expressed doubt toward him, it would be an ideal opportunity to try and lynch him. On the other hand, I have expressed personally some concern about NStinson so maybe Howes was just doing the same. For now, I will vote for Howes because I want to gather information off the people who agree/disagree. Vote: Howes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 18:24:19 I've got time for another writeup, so here goes.... Tom: Good friend Tom has made 17 posts in this topic. He's blending in well with that somewhat average number. Right from the start Tom was ready to "swear" he was a townie. He also wanted to hear what role everyone had. He plainly defended his mate Clark in that first post also...claiming he was probably still sleeping (which seems totally legit to me lol). After this, Joe hit him up with a HUGE bit of sarcasm, to which Tom replied TOTALLY UNAWARE of Joe's sarcastic tone. If there is a "best exchanges" award at the end of this game, this 6-post series between Jabes and Tom would be near the top of the list. I was laughing quite hard when reading this, as Tom is so oblivious, even calling Joe "simple." After that, Tom voted for Goose when the majority was still focused on Brutus (Day 1). This would be a somewhat silly move for a mafia, I think, as it brought Goose within one vote of Brutus at that point. A few posts later, Tom votes for Goose again, on Day 2. Up to this point, he had said "I'm a townie" quite plainly in EVERY message, lol. He's also been asking for people to straight up say "I'm a townie." Maybe Tom doesn't realize that the majority of the players are town at that point and it would be pointless to say "I'm town?" Regardless, Tom comes out as Donkey Kong soon after, claiming he voted to kill off Goose during the night, and was blocked. After that, Tom posts again after Goose's "list" post, claiming 100% that he's town (again....maybe getting a bit TOO repetitive?) and that he would use one of his power votes. Next, Tom hopped on the Extol train, after only TIM and an obviously joking Brutus had voted for him. After hopping on the Extol train, Tom claims originally he wanted to power vote out Extol, but changed that to Goose. Soon after that, tom calls out for "whoever is scanning" to come forward and tell the results they have gotten. Tom starts getting very confused after Extol was shown to be a dead Mii, then he votes for Ariath in a simple post, saying Ariath was "weak." Tom is still making it blatantly clear that he is "voting one in forum and one in PM" each night, and that he's Donkey Kong, in his most recent post. In review, Tom seems somewhat suspicious to me! It just does NOT seem RIGHT that someone would have to proclaim their status as a townie in 14+ out of 17 posts in this topic! He calls for townies to spill their roles at least twice in the topic. He claims to be voting to kill one person each night, but nothing has happened yet! He should be asking for advice if he's as confused as he is at this point. Perhaps he really did vote for Goose on the first night....was Tom roleblocked or was Goose protected by the guy who does protection? Maybe Tom can fill us in on that with info from his PM? Here is what I want from Tom, info on who he voted for on any night other than voting for Goose! Here is what I believe about Tom right now! I think he is likely BOWSER! Not Donkey Kong, but the biggest baddie of them all. Tom came out right off the bat claiming he was a townie. He can ask whatever questions he wants without fear of being killed at night by the true Donkey Kong (the status of Bowser gives him this freedom). We would wonder at this point WHY Tom hadn't been Killed? The Mafia managed to kill both Etch and Matt at night, but why would they not have killed an admitted Donkey Kong, who could kill TWO mafia in that time. I'm quite suspicious of this lack of activity related to the Donkey Kong and Bowser roles. Etch doesn't seem to even have scanned to confirm Tom's DK status. If he WAS a Bowser, we would see him as a town (which =/= DK). I don't believe the town has any more scanners left (do we?), and our DK wouldn't be able to take him out if he was Bowser. I have started formulating a CLEAR night plan for all our roles to perform, and I will post in detail about this later in my series of profiling posts. There will be no need to publicly proclaim your night role in the topic, for those of you who fear that (Mario maybe), and we will get great group input on everything. I think today we will be able to lynch one mafia, kill another at night, and hopefully confirm one more with Mario's scan ability. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 18:29:08 Oh my! Bunch of posts while I typed that one. Tom is trying to be an enigma, isn't he :) But guys PLEASE be careful, we do NOT want to kill Howes before the time is up. I think we should make this rule right now. The person who makes the kill vote on Howes before the time is up will be killed by Mario or DK in the night, OR lynched the next day. That person will be the automatic first target. Let me make very clear what I am saying. DO NOT KILL HOWES BEFORE THE TIME LIMIT IS UP. STOP when he gets to seven votes. Maybe even sit at six to make sure a tard doesn't come mess this up. WHOEVER kills Howes before the time is up will be mafia-suspected. Even though no one will kill him if we follow this plan, we will get a much longer time to review things. I may not be done with all my profile posts until the end of Day 5 tomorrow night, and I want to be SURE to get them all in so I repeat DO NOT lynch Howes by reaching a majority. Leave it at 6 or maybe 7 votes, and anyone who does the 8th vote is lynched that night automatically because any townie will now know that NOT to kill Howes. We want to take up the full time do you see what I say? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 18:30:22 Basically in my last post I'm trying to say TOWN WE NEED SOME STRATEGY HERE. This is a great strategy (in my opinion) of keeping Mafia from controlling the game like the doubtless have been doing in the past. I will like it if you please repeat how many votes on him there are when you make the 6th or 7th vote, and warn the next posters. And I will post it in every post this Day 5 not to Kill Howes so people will not be able to say "I didn't know." |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/10/09 at 18:40:59 Vote count update Howes - 4 (IsThatAGoodThing, Ivootjes, nstinson, TJazZ) K.McAteer - 2 (oneshot, dragondragon) nstinson - 2 (Adam_L, Howes) TJazZ - 1 (Sportsguy) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) Fababu - 1 (Syzygy) Not voting: Fababu, Ariath, Lenny, K.McAteer With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 27 hours, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/10/09 at 18:47:50 @drag: If you couldn't read Etch's post already, he says it's a spite vote. He wouldn't say it was a spite vote if he had scanned me and saw I was mafia. What Scott (I think it was him) said was correct, how we were joking around. @Fababu: Me and Tim have been arguing possibly, but we haven't even voted back and forth at each other. I'm pretty sure I have put sense into at least some of my posts, explaining why I thought what I did. As people are saying now, I'm starting to also see Howes as very suspicious. Scott said that Howes may not have posted as much or something because he's inexperienced. This is only my first game of mafia ever, and I think for my first time I'd like to say I'm doing an at least "okay" job. If I can contribute to an extent, then Howes should be able to contribute much more than he has. Also I feel oneshot is suspicious, and no this isn't a spite vote. He posted very little, and his posts are basically just voting and that's it. I know in the first game he didn't post much or at all and he got lynched because of it, but that was on day one. This is now day five in this game, and he still has contributed absolutely nothing. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/10/09 at 18:51:04 KMacc made the 666th post in this topic, he's mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/10/09 at 18:53:42 It's actually the 666th reply, which is the 667th post. The post above mine is the 666th post. Honko is mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/10/09 at 18:56:25 It's true. I'm Evil Toad, Mafia Instawin. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 19:04:30 Well the next one should be easy so whatever I guess I'll do one on myself... IsThatAGoodThing: I won't go back and read every post I've made, as there are way too many of them. I know at the beginning of the game I felt uncomfortable, Goose and Brutus were in a battle, and people wouldn't stop talking about the game in IRC. I missed out on most of Day 2, causing people to suspect me of being a Goose supporter. In Day 3 I voted for Extol because I really had no idea who else to try to get rid of, and it was inevitable that he would be killed. In Day 4 I voted for Brutus for basically the same reason, the general opinion placed the blame right on him. In Days 3 and 4 I made probably 30 posts that were mostly nonsense, throwing blame in every direction possible. At that point in the game I literally posted every single thought that came into my head. I'm not completely sure, but I think it would be hard to get anything of value out of my masses of nonsense. After that point, I realized how badly we were getting owned, and that the town needed to be THOUGHTFUL, CALM, AND CAREFUL. That's when I started making these profile posts after carefully reviewing every bit of info each player still alive has contributed. I don't know how much more to say about myself..... I'll be working on at least one and hopefully more of these tonight. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 19:06:16 Note: I am doing these in alphabetical order, following Honko's list on the first post of the topic. I'm not doing them in a special order to get those names out of the way first. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/10/09 at 19:08:12 484E424040230 wrote:
I understand that it looks like a spite vote, but if it's not a real clue, Etch gave us No Info as a scanner, which is pretty sad. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Howes on 02/10/09 at 19:10:27 * hates having to talk about himself So you have something to work with, here are some basics about me: I am a military child. Moving to many different places has coupled with my shyness to create a very quiet, calculated person. Even IRL, I am extremely quiet, except with very close friends. My last move this year was easily the worst, even though I have nothing against where I live. As a student in my senior year in high school, I am one of the smarter ones in my class, especially in math and science. However, I rarely use my intellect because doing so has often had negative consequences in the past. In this mafia game in particular, I hide the true extent of my knowledge, because being too smart can get you killed. Why should I do something that will get me killed? Also during this game, I am completely stumped. People are being more careful than in the last game, and there have been no overwhelmingly obvious mistakes. In total, if the town is against me, there is no point in fighting back and trying to influence people's opinions of me, no matter what my role is. I will accept whatever consensus is reached, and await the final results of the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/10/09 at 19:18:50 Not contributing much eh? I suggest that you are a mafia boss! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/10/09 at 19:22:15 drag: I understand that it looks like a spite vote, but if it's not a real clue, Etch gave us No Info as a scanner, which is pretty sad. Well I can tell you right now it isn't a real clue. Maybe Etch wasn't able to tell us anything because he scanned people who eventually died or something, or maybe he was busy, idk. howes: I hide the true extent of my knowledge, because being too smart can get you killed. Why should I do something that will get me killed? If you aren't posting anything at all, then there is no point of even being alive in this game. It'd be smarter for you to post what you think and post smartly, even if it gets you killed, because then maybe we can get some leads or have some ideas. Sometimes you have to take one for the team I guess you could say. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/10/09 at 19:23:27 Not contributing much eh? I suggest that you are a mafia boss! You suggest incorrectly. Do you have any excuse for not posting much, or do you just not care? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Howes on 02/10/09 at 19:24:38 Or maybe you are the mafia boss, Oneshot? unvote Vote: Oneshot |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 19:25:09 Quote:
I hope this isn't true, for my own sake (haha). |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 19:55:14 Well, I guess I'll keep on trucking along. Good thing the recent players have seemed quite full of information, else I might be getting tired of this by now. Ivo: Ivo has made 13 posts in the topic so far. He was very quiet for the first half or so of what has been played so far, and more active lately. He gave a pretty good reason as to why he hadn't posted much, so I'm going to say he falls right into the "average" as far as post amount goes (previous posters have commonly been between 18 and 22). In his first post, Ivo made the third Brutus vote on Day 1. At that point Brutus was a pretty large target so I don't know if we can gain much by analyzing that particular action. Not too much later, he unvoted for Brutus and complied with Tom's demand for everyone to post their role by saying he was a townie. I think it's important to note that he is basically the only person who did this at that time. In his next revelation, Ivo calls Clark dumb for violating the rules of the game, the town dumb in general for not following the topic very closely at all (just as in the previous game), and votes on Oneshot for being generally useless and confusing. I agree with most of what he says here, as the town does seem like a bunch of knuckleheads at times. Ivo was the 8th person to hop on the Goose train, when it was already quite clear he would be voted out, his reasoning being that Goose is useless as a townie. Ivo's next post puts a vote on IsThatAGoodThing, for making his first vote on Extol and seeming to follow a bandwagon that was currently rolling. He also puts forth a good stance that Extol is probably not mafia, warning that he had made good game decisions up to that point. He went on to reaffirm that post by saying the bandwagon on Extol was quite pointless, and there were many other suspects to be looked at more closely. Ivo quickly scolded Lenny for making his "I have a role to do funny things at night" post, giving a pretty solid breakdown of why it was a bad move. In his next post, Ivo did something great, he copy/pasted Honko's "vote results" from each night into one easy to read post. This let us see who had voted for whom on which nights. At that point he also advocated waiting longer before making each lynch, because we had been lynching too quickly the whole game. Next, Ivo again says not to quickly lynch people, giving everyone a shot to comment. This post is accompanied by a nice breakdown of the stats from the previous copy/paste job. We can see who voted for the person who got killed on each night. After Joe seemed to start getting fed up with the game, Ivo was quickly there to console him and warn against "dumb decisions." He throws out a call to Oneshot and Sportsguy, both for being much too quiet in the game. In his most recent post, he again scolded the lack of effort by Oneshot. Here are my thoughts on Ivo. He will be regarded as a very solid mafia player by the majority of the people in the topic, because he hosted the first mafia topic and seemed very filled-in on the game. I'd say he's one of the more experienced mafia players in here. A general trend I have felt in his posts is that he is saying the same things I have been saying, only a bit earlier. He first called for the game to slow down and the quiet people to be looked at. Almost everything he's posted has been solid, even though there's not a ton of it. I really think his status is hard to determine. If he were a mafia he would have NO problem acting out one of the best townie roles he could. He hasn't seemed to go out on a limb too often, however. I think my judgment of him may change as I make the other eight remaining profile posts in the coming 26 or whatever hours. We always have to be careful of Ivo since he's so experienced, and it's odd he wasn't one of the first people voted out by the mafia. The mafia did vote out Cam right away, because of his apparent experience. This fact alone means the mafia think Ivo is total shit at this game or doesn't have a special role. With 15 players left we have 5 mafia, 5 Miis, and 5 town special roles. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/10/09 at 21:15:48 Well if Ivo dies then we know to thank you for pointing out that he's good at the game Cheers |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 21:18:19 Here we go again! I'm on a roll right now. Joe (including Adam now I guess....): Joe is well known as a mod so his words have great value (and he has a yellow name :) ). He makes 50 posts before being replaced, which is significant because he seems to really care about the game. Right off the bat, Joe does a hilarious comedy skit with Tom that I've already mentioned. If they are both mafia they would be able to pull this off easily, and if just one of them is, it's twice as funny. Joe hits up Tom with some blatant sarcasm, which Tom seems to miss completely, and reformats his question. If this was scripted, it was done by a master of comedy, or one of these two is as dumb as a box of rocks. I think this 6 post exchange (seven counting the only other person, Ivo, to "admit" their status at this point) actually has great value. After that, guess what his vote was at that point....NO LYNCH! He was a no lyncher! This is odd to see someone who had voted No Lynch still alive, as those who had campaigned for it have been mostly silenced. Amazingly enough, in his next post, Joe was the FIRST person to start the vote on Goose. He quite clearly stated that he was annoyed at what Ryan had been doing, and didn't care if he was mafia or town. Soon after that, Joe was called in as a suspect in our mini-scandal of Day 1. It appears he had an IM conversation with Clark (the two are great friends) where Clark basically begged on his knees to find Joe's role. In the quotation he posted, Clark was the only one to talk, but Chris came back and posted a "complete" version of the conversation which was deleted by Robin as soon as he saw it. In that other convo, Joe admitted to being mafia to Clark right where the one Joe posted ended. After that passed, he started pointing fingers at both Goose and Karterfreak, putting his vote on Matt at that point. Only 5 minutes later, he made what amounts to an edit, basically, saying he meant to say Matt and Brutus instead of Matt and Goose (hmmmmmmmmmmmmm, look who was mafia and got the finger pointed away from him as soon as a mistake was realized). Matt is simply mafia "because he points his finger" and Brutus joins him because he agreed with Matt too much. In his next post, Joe quickly flips over to the Goose vote, only the fourth person to do so. In his first comment after Goose's death, Joe brings up the fact that we have to look at people who were against the lynching of Goose, and that those who voted for him are probably not mafia (protecting himself, perhaps?). The beginning of this post also had a great line that I think holds a lot of value. Joe says we need to focus on those who first tried to get the vote off of Goose. The spree on him was so fast and complete that really only three people avoided the Goose issue. First, BENOIT made a clean sidestep, by voting for Joe himself. Next, Brutus and his supposed teammate Tim made a double vote on Extol for no apparent reason. I think this was just Brutus being Brutus, and I'll comment on Tim's involvement in his own profile post. Back to Joe, however.....I find this point in the game very suspicious! He is clearly making light of the fact that "no mafia would vote for Goose" and "the first people to vote away are big targets" if Ben is a townie, and Brutus has already been shown to be townie, then Joe becomes a GIGANTIC suspect right here already. I am surprised no one picked up on this and pointed it out before. There was no reason to drop TWO hints of that nature right at that moment in the game. Of course, it could mean he's being a great townie, is super suspicious of Tjazz at this point, and knows what's going on. In his next post, Joe comes out with his "list" of "trusted" people. This list was Tom, Mark, and Scott. In the same post he puts suspicion on Tjazz by plainly saying what he alluded to in his previous post. I have no idea why he made this list, but the other person to do it was Tjazz....After being attacked for making such a list, he claims he never realized what negatives it could have, and that he hoped to be more "welcomed" by the town by making such a post. He also apologizes for naming people that could easily be picked off. Right away after that, Joe voted on Extol once he already had 6 votes. The swing was totally on him already at this point, so his vote could easily have been just going along for the ride. Joe moves on to say something very interesting at this point. He brings back the "Townies reveal your roles" idea that Tom had mentioned (along with Joe) right at the start! I cannot believe he did that at this point in the game! Joe keeps leaving little hints that Tyler is suspicious, also. They are subtle but definitely there. Joe then claims not to be the cop, and says he doesn't want to give away his role in case the mafia want to kill him for having a role. I'm running out of space in this post because Joe is so interesting, haha....well he ends up being the first to cast a vote on Brutus in Day 4, this is also around the time he starts to get "depressed" about the game (perhaps a total act). Joe seemed VERY sure of Brutus being mafia, calling for a sacrifice of himself if Brutus was not mafia. He also got in a scuffle with me on that subject. At the end of his life with us, Joe accuses Stinson Tom and Sportsguy in separate posts and is super pissed about everything. He then asks to be replaced and is, by Adam L. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 21:27:20 (ran out of characters in the last post, 5500 is somewhat restrictive!) Adam L: Adam made 3 joke posts before he was even in the game. All were votes, and he was pretty funny about it. Adam did a good job in the last game, and definitely has mafia experience. He is probably a better player than Joe, and I feel he will be able to blend into whatever Joe was doing very well. All he has done since entering the game is voted for Stinson because......he's ugly and suspicious (lol?). I'll comment on them as "Joe" even though Adam is playing the role now. It's basically a complete fact that Joe is a power role. Whether it's for the townies or for the mafia is hard to tell. I'm leaning toward him having a pretty important role...but it could be just a good old mafia player. His skit with Tom early on almost HAD to be planned, because it was just too perfect. When he re-brought up the "tell your roles" thing later in the game I became suspicious again. Joe's huge act of "depression" about the game may seem too good to be true (what I originally thought), but I'm thinking now that he is probably really a townie. He truly gives a great feeling of desperation in his posts. OMG NVM JUST THOUGHT OF SOMETHING Joe graduated from college in English. He is well-educated and could easily be fooling with us the whole time. Even though he may sometimes post like a non-caring person who doesn't know a lot, he definitely has the ability to mess with us by carefully wording what he says. This makes me think a lot more like he could be a strong mafia. On the other hand, he hasn't mentioned playing mafia before ever, so maybe he wouldn't even know what do do in that case. If the mafia were the quiets: Joe would seem odd for pointing out the quiet people all the time nonstop. If the mafia were the loud ones: Joe would seem like a suspect for pointing out the quiet ones. Since most of who has died so far were actives, I think we can call Joe a townie with a special role. Joe is safe for now, IMO I mean Adam L of course. He probably has a nifty role for us! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Jabes on 02/10/09 at 21:31:59 If i may say one last thing, its that i never saw the post by clark with the supposed "real" conversation between us, but i can tell you for a fact that the one that i posted is the real conversation, as clark said that entire convo while i was asleep. Ive done nothing but tell the truth, and i hope the rest of you guys have a good finish to the game... |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/10/09 at 22:09:27 Dear Mario(or whoever drew that role), FIND A MAFIA TONIGHT, NO BULLSHIT. IF YOU DO, REPORT IT. THAT IS ALL. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/10/09 at 22:18:18 0926332F262914332E29342829470 wrote:
I don't like this post. At all. Yeah, I hate you, but there's one person I hate more in this thread, and that's Scott. Seriously, I hate his guts. But I'm willing to work with him because he's proven his merit and is on the right track. You, however, have been nothing but scummy. Allow me to try to point this out. He's quick to defer not just MY vote but also Joe's vote, trying to make it seem more plausible then it actually is. I'll agree, Joe's playstyle in the game before I took over was a bit erratic towards the end(mafia itself is a frustrating game, when coupled with somewhat inactive players it becomes a chore), but that's not to say he was pointing his finger blindly(all the time at least). Also, "Scott has swayed my opinion, top notch stuff"? What the fuck? This stands out to me so hard for no apparent reason, the only thing I can think of is that you're trying to flatter Scott to try to keep him off of you too hard. I really don't know. You're mafia. Convince me why you aren't, if you will. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/10/09 at 22:19:47 Okay, for tonight I will not be able to make any more of these profiling posts. I have seven left to complete tomorrow night. I will not be able to do them until about 14 to 18 hours from now, depending on my afternoon. Left to go are Kmacc, Lenny, Stinson, Oneshot, Tyler, Tim, and Ben. I will kind of try to show you what I plan to be able to show tomorrow night before the Day ends. I will try to put people into the three categories: 5 in mafia, 5 in town (special role), and 5 in town (mii). I think after doing the remaining seven of these people I will be able to get this filled out quite nicely. I think I will try to make a preliminary version of that list now, even though I haven't clearly and carefully read every single post by the other 7 players. Mafia: Kmacc, Fababu, Oneshot, Tyler, Tom Special role: Adam L, Ivo, Drag, Ariath, Howes Mii: Scott, Tim, Lenny, Stinson, Ben Don't put TOO much value in this list, but here are a few things since some of my posts earlier. I think Howes made a great redemption post. I probably had him pegged wrongly in my "He's the most suspicious" post. At least we won't be voting him out until the whole time limit is up. Since there are only four votes on him, and ONESHOT seems to be a larger target, because he is even MORE useless, let's just do the same as we were going to do for Howes, but on Sean instead? Because howes could get quite a bit done for us if he helps like he could! unvote vote Oneshot Not saying howes is off the hook but you know what I mean. Someone please link to all the "profile" stuff I've already made so everyone that hasn't been reading will be able to see all those posts. They're great if you missed anything. Don't take that set of roles that I just posted super seriously, again, as there are probably about 4 errors in it at least. Summary: If town wants to win let's do this right! During the remainder of Day 5 (about 24 hours) we need to do specific things! First: We need 7 (or 6) votes on Oneshotbilly! Earlier this plan was for Howes but I now see that Oneshot is much less useful even if he is a town special role, and Howes can stay around a bit longer. Second: We must NOT end the day early by getting to 8 votes on Oneshot. Doing so will result in catastrophe. WHOEVER MAKES THE EIGHTH VOTE ON ONESHOT SHOULD BE LYNCHED, NO QUESTIONS ASKED, RIGHT AWAY ON DAY 6. It's as simple as that. We want to use up the entire time of the Day 5 and anyone who does not agree to this will be killed. I would not be surprised if Stinson is the one who would do something that stupid, from ignorance. If oneshot gets to 6 or 7 votes make it widely known that people should not vote on him any more. Third: We need to have a plan for the night. I have most of this plan already worked out. I propose that we will lynch a mafia in this Day 5, giving them 4 remaining to our 10. I am not afraid that I have called out the townies as to who has special roles etc etc etc, because we are able to dominate at our current position, I think. I will post a complete plan for all the remaining special roles to do in the night, and they will all reveal their role in the morning of Day 6 and exactly what they did. By following the plan we should be able to nail one mafia for sure and then the game will be 9-3 or even 10-3 if we're super lucky. I feel at this point I am the most-informed player out there. Fourth: I will have to finish the remaining 7 player profiles. This is the main reason we must not end the day early. By letting me finish these everyone will be able to quickly review basically the whole game, and nothing will be able to happen with the mafia to stop me from posting the last of these. I think after doing the remaining 7 I will be able to make a 90% confidence chart like the one I made up above a bit. Am I pretty clear on this? No one else seems to want to take the initiative so I'll do it for you guys. I just put like 4 hours of effort into this tonight so you better damn well appreciate it. I think I can plan our way right into a win, and if this works you will love me! If not, you can't say I wasnt trying. VOTE ONESHOT! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/10/09 at 22:27:27 Vote count update Howes - 3 (Ivootjes, nstinson, TJazZ) K.McAteer - 2 (oneshot, dragondragon) oneshot - 2 (Howes, IsThatAGoodThing) nstinson - 1 (Adam_L) TJazZ - 1 (Sportsguy) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) Fababu - 1 (Syzygy) Not voting: Fababu, Ariath, Lenny, K.McAteer With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 23 hours, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Fababu on 02/10/09 at 23:00:25 Ok, it's time to deffense myself. @KMacc/Szygy: I've read again your posts and KMacc answer; and I don't think both or you will be Mafia. BTW, Tim, sorry If my point of view have offensed you. @Scott: Am I appear in your mafia list? C'mon guy, don't joke me, I'm just a regular Mii. If I have got an important role I would have said something about it and I would try to be less offensive/critic in my posts; the same that if I have been mafia; but I can sure you 100% i'm a townie. Time to go to school, I will popst againb later. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by In Hiding on 02/11/09 at 02:44:17 by law of averages I would say that one of the mods is mafia... doing alot of finger pointing eh? (spose i've done my fair share, i did think extol was sus but i also started the goose campaign). My feeling still is with Ariath. I know least about him and he's not said that much. Its not much more than a hunch in my hungover state. Honko, please pm me and let me know if i have any more special kills? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/11/09 at 05:20:49 I'm not mafia so don't vote for me. Unvote Vote: scott Talking way too much breeze. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/11/09 at 06:46:51 Oneshot, I don't understand that vote at all. Scott, even if he was mafia, is providing us with a hell of a lot of analysis which is likely to help the town make informed decision. Even if you are a mii you don't seem to care and should be lynched :/ Unvote Vote: OneShot |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/11/09 at 07:05:03 WTF, oneshot, how can you possibly talk too much in this thread, it's part of the game. At least try to play it when you participate :( I will Unvote for now Oh what the heck, i've said that oneshot should be lynched several times already and scott has basicly confirmed that he's a townie, i trust him on this Vote Oneshot |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 07:16:04 556F48747D685D5B737378487475727B1C0 wrote:
Most of that list seems correct for Mafia members, but I'll have to go back again and examine further before I jump on a lynch train. For now, I'll stick with Kmacc, since he's on the list. However if needed I can switch to Oneshot later on. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 07:39:41 vote: oneshot He is doing absolute nothing to help. He is most likely mafia it seems, but if he's townie then he was absolutely no help at all throughout the entire game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 07:42:12 Oh and oneshot voting for Scott is just stupid imo. As Tim said, Scott is putting in so much analysis for us, he's coming up with more stuff than everyone combined it seems. For scott to be mafia after doing that, he'd either have to be a) crazy or b) willing to spend THAT much time on doing that stuff while risking his mafia members lives in order to preserve his if it comes down to a close one at the end of the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/11/09 at 07:43:48 I'll go with option A :D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 07:43:55 Mmk, so that settles it, Oneshot is mafia and so is Kevin, so that's two of them out of the way. THERE ARE SIX VOTES FOR ONESHOT, DO NOT GO TO 8 OR YOU WILL GET FUCKED |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/11/09 at 07:47:20 Vote count update oneshot - 5 (Howes, IsThatAGoodThing, Syzygy, Ivootjes, Kmacc) Howes - 2 (nstinson, TJazZ) Kmacc - 1 (dragondragon) nstinson - 1 (Adam_L) TJazZ - 1 (Sportsguy) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (oneshot) Not voting: Fababu, Ariath, Lenny With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 14 hours, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 08:12:23 Meant to say unvote vote: Oneshot |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/11/09 at 08:22:57 Unvote For respect to Howes. Vote Fababu To make him talk some more. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/11/09 at 08:22:58 Ah good, you can count. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/11/09 at 08:29:55 Well i'm fucked now. I'm Yoshi the Jailkeeper btw. i was trying to find out some information on the sly but some cunts have ruined that. At least a few of them are mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 09:21:05 I don't know if we should believe you |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/11/09 at 09:23:11 Well Oneshot, I'm sure if you list and explain your night actions so far that people would fairly evaluate what you have to say. Just because Scott went on a crazy rampage doesn't mean he's 100% correct (although I agree with most of it). |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/11/09 at 09:27:40 How could you possible get information by swallowing these guys This message was editted because this messageboard sucks -_- Didn't remove any gamecontaining info btw. Plz don't kill me honko |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 09:46:02 That just sounds wrong, Ivo ;D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 09:47:06 What file did you try to attach, Ivo? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/11/09 at 10:06:28 Nothing, i just pressed "post" and it only posted half of my message :-? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/11/09 at 10:36:06 Quote:
This doesn't make a lot of sense, you can either vote for someone because he's suspicious or because he doesn't talk enough. But telling him that the pressure vote is for pressure kinda takes the pressure away as he knows you don't find him that supicious anyway. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ivootjes on 02/11/09 at 10:51:05 And about oneshot, it could very well be that he speaks the truth, but it could also mean that he's lying. Saying that he was getting information on the sly is a bullshit argument indeed, as there has died someone every night until now If he speaks the truth: At least tell us what you've done in the night actions, so we know who didnt make night kills. Not that this tells us much but it's better than nothing. If he lies: Than he's basicly mafia trying to convince us that we shouldn't vote for him, and even worse, he could be trying to let the real yoshi openclaim so the mafia could kill him at night. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 11:10:56 voting for fababu a lot won't make him talk.. if you get lynched, you can't really talk:) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/11/09 at 11:17:26 I don't think we should be voting for oneshot to be lynched. I have some doubt that he is mafia and we are in bad shape if we don't lynch one of the mafia today or role block the right mafia member in the night. I believe Oneshot is telling the truth about being yoshi, but it would really help us if he would divulge what actions he has done before he gets killed. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 11:33:41 Yeah, that's why we're giving him a chance to tell us what he knows, Tyler. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Goose on 02/11/09 at 12:03:20 13383F233E510 wrote:
and YOU can count... on ME, waiting for YOU in the parking lot. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/11/09 at 12:04:19 7F7A454459486A42425E482D0 wrote:
and YOU can count... on ME, waiting for YOU in the parking lot.[/quote] That will always be funny. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/11/09 at 12:10:48 Lol, Happy Gilmore :3 Anyhow, for now I'm keeping my vote for Oneshot unless he proves his innocence... I'm not really sure who to vote for. TJazZ, that last post has made me suspicious of you again. I just don't understand how that is constructive in any way :S Also, Sportsguy's last post is fishy [smiley=ninja.gif] I still think Nathan could be mafia as well, his post style hasn't changed one bit throughout the game which is odd. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 12:13:28 242E2D2E302E570 wrote:
1. WOW we can quote the last 2 posts now :-/ 2. I notice that nearly EVERYONE has changed their posting in the game so far, over the course of many days which we have been playing. I think this could mean something. Good news: I have 10 hours to get everything set up. Tonight the townies will rock the show! Please check in as often as possible ALL you townies, and post so we know you've read the latest stuff. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 12:49:29 I don't see how not changing my posting style could mean anything. The way I see it, I would not want to do anything even somewhat suspicious, whether I was mafia or not. it's better to lay low in this game, IMO. If I, all of a sudden, started changing my "posting style", what would everyone say? I'd think that would be suspicious. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Ariath on 02/11/09 at 13:07:24 Ugh, I haven't been online for a little while, and I have a couple of things to say. 1. As far as the oneshot case goes, I don't think that he is mafia. A little while ago he admitted he was yoshi, and I am inclined to believe this, as nobody has openly come out and said that they are the real yoshi and he is lying. I am going to assume that whoever is the real yoshi isn't actually somebody else who is too afraid to admit that they have a power role (If this is the case, then it makes things more difficult.) I believe Oneshot for now though, as I think that somebody would have said by now that he was lying. 2. In hiding: I'm rather confused as to why you see me suspicious. You've given very little reason as to why you voted for me, and the little information that you did give doesn't make sense. You said that I've posted very little, and that you hardly know anything about me. How is this a legit explanation for voting for me, considering that I have not only made more posts than you, but nearly all of them have been blocks of text? I know that you stated that your suspicion of me is just a hunch, but I find it to be rather stupid, because you have little to no reason, and I will state one more time: I am a townie, and I promise you that. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/11/09 at 13:08:23 464C4F4C524C350 wrote:
If you want me to spell it out, I didn't really peg Fababu to be mafia so I wanted to hear what he had to say. I was hoping he would write something in his defense for the simple fact that I accused him and I was hoping to subtly judge him based on the kinda of arguments he was going to use. But now since many people have questioned my vote he probably doesn't feel compelled to post anything anymore. I guess after reading Ivo's thoughts on my move, I realize I could have worded it better or not post it at all. I was on my lunch break so I guess it shows I posted in a hurry and didn't think thoroughly. Anyway I see he's reading the topic now (along with like 12 of you) so the suitability is pretty much gone. Unvote Stinson, don't edit you posts. ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 13:11:26 6D4A4140465B706D405A4B5D4A4E5A2F0 wrote:
Is not editing a rule? I can spam the topic with new posts whenever I think of something if you'd rather *shrugs* I don't edit my posts if they aren't the very last reply to a topic anyways |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 13:14:29 Yes, it's one of the main rules Robin has asked us to follow :). That's why I sometimes have quad posted on accident, because I'm so used to being able to edit more things that aren't in the current frame of thought. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Fababu on 02/11/09 at 13:15:13 Everytime who someone votes for me I'm oblied to answer, and If you want me to talk, I will do it. As I said before, I'm a regular Mii. When I made my post naming the persons I knew that some people could feel bothered about it; but my intention was only try to show you my point of view. I also know that at this point of the game is hard to believe the words of the other ones, because the possibility of being mafia is higher. In other terms, I won't vote for Oneshot at the moment. He has remained quite all the game until now, when he has come saying that he is Yoshi. No one has posted saying that he's the real Yoshi and Oneshot was a liar; but I don't find it as an argument that proof 100% his innocence as townie. Today I will try to go to sleep as late as I can trying to read new posts and talk about them. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 13:19:30 If I wanted, I could say I was Mario. If no one stepped up and said, "No, I'm Mario", you may or may not believe me. It would make me much more likely to get killed during the night, if I wasn't protected by someone like Toad. I say let's let Oneshot go on saying he's Yoshi and see if he gets killed tonight. If he didn't, then either he was telling the truth, and someone died protecting him (like Toad), or he was telling the truth and the mafia was stupid for not taking a chance of taking out another role player. Or, he was a mafia, and of course wasn't going to get killed |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 13:20:21 332536303839332536303839570 wrote:
I've never "removed" information, though, which is what I would think the spirit of the rule is. I just added more information to my original post. Ah, whatever though. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 13:22:49 Yeah, I know Nate. I'm just stating the rule :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 13:24:18 Here we go, I'm going to nail these next few, as things have been falling into place nicely. Kmacc: Kmacc is one of the several players in this game with mod status on the forums. This different colored name may give all these players an illusion of comfort for the town, as we think what they say is more trustworthy and powerful. Kmacc has made 31 posts in the topic so far. That is a fair amount more than the "average" posters have had, but not as many as spammy Brutus or Scott have had. Kmacc starts off simple with a joke shot at Etch, probably because they're friends. In his first serious post, Kevin voted for Lenny, claiming his No Lynch advocacy was getting the heat off him and switching it to a townie. He then goes back to his joking manner, by laughing at a MKDS news title which pinned Etch as mafia. Kevin had the same excuse as me for not voting Goose on Day 2. His next accusation is a vote at Sporstguy, because Tyler had made an unexplained vote at him. This brought to my mind something I read in here by a person who said vote retaliation by the townies is pointless, they have to work as a team....this is an example of that. After this, Kevin explains his point of view on Goose's "list," saying we should try to put it out of our minds until someone on it is killed and proven to be mafia. This was the same thing I personally thought about right when the list came out, then I thought: The mafia will be able to kill three or more of the people on the list without getting themselves, and after that we will forget about the list or try to kill the people not on it. This would be a good stance for the mafia to take. But at this point that post seems great to me, as that's what I thought right there. In at least two posts here, Kevin claims he doesn't think Extol is mafia (but still votes on him), and Tyler claims the same thing to reason out the vote he made on Kevin. Kevin's next claim is that he's not mafia because he didn't vote to kill Extol. This seems a bit odd, could easily have just not voted to plan to say that (Kevin seems like he could plan ahead). He continues this defense for two or three posts. At this point in my review of Kevin, I feel his posts have almost ALL had a slanted feeling of him either saying "i'm not mafia" or showing why he isn't. He's dealing almost exclusively with any sort of attack on himself. The feeling I'm getting is kind of like one or two other posters who seemed obsessed with saying they were not mafia. By Day 4, Kmacc changed a bit, bringing forth Tim and Brutus as his two main targets, and backing up his Brutus point with some evidence from a Goose post. As soon as a small call toward lynching the quiet people was brought up, Kevin was very quick to DEFEND the quiet people, saying they may be townies with special roles trying to hide. Right here a big light goes off in my head. Then he is like making a post about what other people with similar roles should be doing, and supporting that stance....while not doing it himself? Kevin was then the 8th person to hop on the Brutus-vote, a great time for a possible mafia member to do so. After Brutus was revealed a Mii, Kevin seemed exasperated and gave up hopes on Tim being mafia either, since they seemed to be in league. Up to this point Kevin had changed his posting quite a bit since Day 1, but now someone else (Lenny) has accused Kevin in Day 5. Kmacc makes it quite clear that he thinks Lenny is a mafia and should be gone, but he doesn't even place a vote on him. Kevin goes on in Day 5 to scold the quiet townies, which was a quite popular view at the time (still is). Kevin does the most odd thing I have seen all game, and at this point I realize it's his trend: HE SAYS WHO HE DOESNT SUSPECT. In back to back posts, he first unsuspects Nstinson, then Benoit and Scott in the next one. No one else goes on rides like this, which he has done at multiple points in the game. In his latest posts, Kevin has started voting for and reasoning why Oneshot should go. This also seems like "new" behavior for Kevin, this late in the game? After now reading all Kevin has contributed I think he is NOT a regular Mii. I think he is mafia! He has often NOT voted for or called against votes on people who were lynched or close to lynched. Oneshot is basically the only person he's campaigning to kill, and this is when Sean has claimed to be a Horse. I think Kevin is doing the perfect "setup" on us. He did this already by saying "Oh look, I didn't vote for Extol there's no way I am mafia" more than once. He will do it AGAIN when Oneshot is voted out and proves to be a mafia. I think Kevin is just setting himself up too well. Let's see how the last 6 reviews go. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 13:45:28 I honestly don't remeber saying "I am not a Mii. I am not mafia" at all, can you quote the post or something? I guess I'm quick to defend myself which looks bad but whatever. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 13:48:42 I'm feel right now both Ariath and Tyler are suspicious for backing up oneshot, but at the same time I could see their understanding. If oneshot isn't the real yoshi, then the real yoshi should come out and say something!!! But if oneshot is the one who gets lynched and he's mafia, then I'm going to be very suspicious of both Ariath and Tyler. I've already been suspicious of Tyler earlier in the game too. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 13:54:10 Here's my third one of these for the day. Lenny: Lenny is Australian. He has big hair. This guy could be anything! Lenny has only made 14 posts in this game so far. This seems quite low to me. Lenny wanted the No Lynch right from the start, which was something I felt was a great move at that point. He also made a mention at getting information from people. He posted five times on Day 1, mostly just defending the No Lynch and saying that anyone we kill that day would likely be a negative effect on us. By Day 3 Lenny has only posted a couple more times, and he's still quite adamantly and proudly defending his stance on WAITING to vote, and keeping the No Lynch in mind as a town tool. Eventually he goes for the inevitable and votes off Extol. Next, he quickly votes for Brutus in Day 4. By Day 5 he is annoyed we've lost Matt, and thinks Kmacc is suspicious. Tom straight up asks Lenny if he is mafia, and Lenny responds with a funny "what are you doing?" line, and gives his very odd line "i do mysterious things at night." This is an odd spot in Lenny's game so far, as he seemed really calm and thoughtful until that line made him look like a fool. Lenny has been quiet the last couple days now, which I find surprising and frustrating. I'd like to hear what he has to say about my thoughts in here so far. I really truly do not believe Lenny to be a mafia. Even though he has great experience with the game before, perhaps the most experienced one of us involved in the game, I do not think he could've played a mafia role in this manner. Everything he's said seems to be great and well-thought. I would not recommend voting for Lenny at this time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 13:59:03 090F030101620 wrote:
Yeah that was actually Tim and I knew it was Tim....I don't quite know why it popped into your post like that. I will edit that post simply to take out that line which seems like I accidentally put it there between two unrelated lines. Must be part of Tim's writeup. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 14:00:55 Quick Analysis of who has been killed by the mafia, and who that person voted for the day before: Night One Killed: EnigmaticCam (mii) Voted: No Lynch Night Two Killed: SuperYoshi1 (mii) Voted: No Vote Night Three Killed: Etch (Luigi) Voted: Extol Night Four Killed: karterfreak (Peach) Voted: No Vote Very interesting. The mafia has been lynching the people not voting 3 of 4 days so far. They want to be as unsuspious as possible, by not giving us leads based on who they kill. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 14:04:26 This leads me to believe that the only reason they varied their killing on day 3, was that they scanned Etch as a power role. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 14:05:02 is there any thread between all of those who were killed? Did they attack someone during their days? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 14:06:36 @drag: Mafia has no scanner, someone already thought that earlier was well and had to be clarified. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 14:08:25 Drag....mafia do not have a scanner. I thought the same thing until Howes told me differently lol. Good point, anyway, with that little stat bit. Stinson: SuperYoshi basically did nothing, but he was on Goose's list. Cam was known as a strong player, but hadn't even had time to do anything other than say to slow the game down. Etch had joked around with Kmacc a little, and defended Benoit in one of his later posts. Matt had been accusing and questioning many people the whole game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 14:09:25 Ok, I just briefly scanned the roles, and saw the word scan under Bowser. Hmmm, then there must be some link to something Etch said on day 3, since they killed him despite voting to lynch a mii. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 14:09:43 Drag that mistake is too "obvious" Might easily mean you are trying to show you are not mafia by making a blunder like that. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 14:13:13 I have some commentary on what you say about looking at what Etch says on Day 3. This could be a perfect play by the Mafia. Etch called Benoit safe in one of his last 2 or 3 posts alive. Benoit is Bowser. Etch scanned Ben and came back negative, then they killed etch who proved to be Scanner, and then it clearly shows that Ben is town. If this is not the amazing mafia play we would expect out of an educated mafia, then what else is? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/11/09 at 14:15:52 Vote count update oneshot - 6 (Howes, IsThatAGoodThing, Syzygy, Ivootjes, Kmacc, Adam_L) Howes - 1 (nstinson) Kmacc - 1 (dragondragon) TJazZ - 1 (Sportsguy) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (oneshot) Not voting: TJazZ, Fababu, Ariath, Lenny With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 8 hours, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/11/09 at 14:18:31 Fababu Howes In Hiding Isthatagoodthing Jabes K. Alteer oneshotbilly Sportsguy001 TJaZZ If this list is true then mafia (imo) are Howes, Jabes (now Adam), Sportsguy, KMacc and TJazZ. It's difficult to know whether to try to get a lynch on one of them. Any thought? :/ |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 14:23:33 For those wondering why Scott made such a bad post Howes Oneshot Sportsguy Kmacc TJazz |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/11/09 at 14:24:44 I'm coming round about Oneshot. In the last game he was never really active and it just seemed like he wasn't too bothered and ended up getting lynched early. I think that's just his "play style", and there isn't much need to lynch him. It could turn out to be a lynch like Brutus, where the town get played into voting for a "suspicious" townie. For now, I am going with Howes, as he seems fishy and Scott reckons so too (I think it's fair to go in Scott's direction somewhat at this point). Also, the day is soon over and I am hoping I won't have to change my vote again. Unvote Vote: Howes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Fababu on 02/11/09 at 14:26:18 0F35122E27320701292922122E2F2821460 wrote:
That's an interesting point to take into account. It's a pity that we have lost Luigi so soon. I'm afraid that tomorrow when I will wake up, Night 5 would have arrived and I won't have the opportunity to post; so I will ask for a favour for the people who will be awake until the end: try to find a post where someone said something like: "if you don't believe me, scan me and you will see i'm a mii". Bowser is the hardest role to kill, but if we found a mistake like that, we will be getting closer to him. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/11/09 at 14:26:33 7A40675B524772745C5C57675B5A5D54330 wrote:
I disagree. Surely they would want to kill those who contributed more to finding out things. That would leave the town silenced. Which brings me to the question.... why haven't they lynched you? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 14:28:50 Syzygy, he just started going off on his rampage when Day 5 started, at least that's how it feels to me. Whoever Yoshi is should definitely eat Scott tonight so the mafia can't kill him. As to suspicion about me, I can't really prove how I'm not mafia, but I'm sure Scott's plan will help me prove what I need to. Trust me through tonight and you'll find out the next day. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/11/09 at 14:30:44 Oh I see. Voting patterns. Gotcha. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 14:33:42 Well mafia kill patterns. But now that the information is public, the future of that trend won't be worth following. Only what happened before my post. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 14:37:55 However in the towns interest, everyone should be voting. It doesn't have to be to the same person, because we don't need a majority for a lynch. But the more information we can gather from votes, the better. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 14:42:11 I believe there were a few who said they'd submit to a scan, unless I am misremembering something? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 14:43:18 Go quote them Nate! :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 14:43:58 If you scan an inno, it's not worth reporting because you're just putting a target on your head. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 14:47:21 It is until you die. Once you're dead and we see that they are a scanner, we'll know the people that are for sure town. These would probably be good targets for the mafia to take down first, but at least it would make it easier to not lose two townies in one day. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 14:49:43 Yes, but without a bodyguard/doctor we can't risk Mario coming out and saying "I scanned four people and they were all innocent, sorry guys". What we'd have to do then is have Yoshi eat him, which keeps Mario from being able to scan/roleblock/kill/whatever for that night. Useless. Noone knows who Mario is right now, we should keep it that way. The odds are good that he won't get killed tonight. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 14:52:18 I'll be around. Also, we should take a look at who voted to kill Goose. In previous experience with him, I think it'd be right up his alley to tell his mafia-mates to vote for him first so he could put that list out there and confuse the shit out of us. Give me a few minutes and I'll pull it up. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 14:53:43 I should be around, Scott. Today is certainly a crucial day, and we can't afford to make many more mistakes. Every extra hour will help. We have a little over 7 hours remaining. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 14:55:04 Make sure to grab the days before he got lynched as well, Adam. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:03:09 "Nathan is actually trying here" Am I really?:-p actually I haven't been trying at all until today I'm actually starting to pay closer attention... just wish I had earlier on! I'll start scanning for "scan" and see if I can find anymore references about it. Right now, the really active ones seem to be scott, drag, adam, and ben... haven't seen Joe post today |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/11/09 at 15:04:35 Final Day 2 Vote Tally. Goose - 11 (In Hiding, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, karterfreak, nstinson, Extol, Ivootjes, Sportsguy001, Ariath, Howes) dragondragon - 1 (Goose) Extol - 1 (Syzygy) Jabes - 1 (TJazZ) Not voting - Brutus, K. McAteer, SuperYoshi1, Etch, oneshotbilly, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny From page 13, if it helps. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 15:08:40 There are only 6 people alive who were not on Goose's list. I do not believe Goose just put a random list. It was either all on or all off the list are the mafia. The mafia have killed people both on and off the list. They killed SuperYoshi because he was on the list and would be good for a listie to die. They also killed Extol (in day) who was on the list. If the whole mafia is OFF the list, then Stinson has to be one of them, and the rest is Lenny Tim Ariath Ivo and Drag, all of whom have VERY low suspicion. Also Stinson names 3 of those right here in this post below which would be very odd to name 3 of your mafia friends right like that. Quote:
Basically also....Goose seemed totally legit when he posted that. And all the people on there are the suspicious ones anyway. Maf did a good job of making the list look unimportant. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:09:25 here are all mentions of the word scan so far that I found from the thread: By Fababu: Quote:
By Drag: Quote:
Quote:
By Ellis: Quote:
By Etch: Quote:
Quote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:10:42 Do we assume that Goose was acting under the orders of someone else in the mafia? Or did he go rogue, posting the list? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 15:11:09 Nathan etch was our scanner and he is now dead. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Syzygy on 02/11/09 at 15:11:22 Wait... The last four voters for Goose were Ariath, Sportsguy, Howes and Ivo, with Goose's "submission" right in between. I wonder if this has any significance. Is it too much of a coincidence that these suspected (some more than others) would post in this way? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 15:12:54 The last etch quote that nathan quoted is probably why etch was found to be scanner and killed by mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:20:10 More scanning quotes: a post made by drag still rings true to me: Sure it's bad for the town to lose power roles, but it also have a positive aspect. Now that we know that Etch was Luigi, we can look more closely at what he said, since odds are he was telling the truth about his suspicions. Etch had the ability to scan one person per night, so he might've found out some of the mafia members. maybe we should be searching all of Etch's past posts and analyze them since he WAS one of our scanners? Also, would it be worth it for our last scanner (Mario) to sacrifice himself? If he came out and said the name of Wario, then we'd have a target to kill. Toad would try to protect Mario and die (if he'd agree to it), unless Wario could figure out who toad was and roleblock him, then there'd be trouble. We could have more than one person try to kill Wario, if he didn't get lynched. Baby could roleblock wario from now on, to keep him detained...... as Wario can only roleblock one member at a time. Of course, Toad would then die, and, if they got peach, Mario'd be a goner. At least we'd be able to kill someone instead of slowly being picked off. Just an idea *shrugs* Also, apparently, Mario hasn't used his kill ability yet, and neither has DK... either that, or they've been roleblocked.... or the mafia mysteriously hasn't killed anyone on a night |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:21:10 79436458514471775F5F546458595E57300 wrote:
Mario has one scan to his power... of course he'd have to get really lucky to hit a mafia with his one scan |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by karterfreak on 02/11/09 at 15:29:58 Stinson, I'm just gonna point out that both Me (Peach) and Etch (Luigi) are dead. *goes back to watching the game from the afterlife* |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:36:10 Some referrals to or by Etch KMacc: Quote:
By Etch: Quote:
I say we just lynch the people who talk too much. Mafia or Town, I don't give a fuck. Watch you guys lynch Brutus and it turns out he isn't mafia. It's just because he gives you shit but hey, some bridges need to be burnt. [/quote] Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Here is a good post by Etch, that also rings true to an extent, but its opposite of what I previously have said: Quote:
That seemed to be Etch's strategy, he did not say much, and just chimed in when he felt it was needed, but they still got him. EDITED to fix quotations, they were bolded, instead of quoted |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:37:32 373D2E28392E033A2E393D375C0 wrote:
eh, when I was typing that, I had posted peach originally, then remembered he was dead, but I guess I forgot to take out all the peach references, like I meant to |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:40:12 More etch stalking; TJazz said that he trusted Etch By Etch: Quote:
By Drag: Quote:
By Etch: Quote:
D'OH. did he do this on purpose? Or did he actually have a slip here? Also, Etch's first vote after the first night was KMacc... who is still alive |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:48:28 One more thing: I don't buy the whole "oneshot must be telling the truth because no one has spoken up" If you really WERE who oneshot said he was, why would you speak up? That would paint a target for the mafia saying "Here I am, come and kill me". If I were a mafia, and I was on the verge of being lynched, I would claim to be an important character. If the townies believed me, they would not vote to lynch me. If the real one stuck his head up, they'd lynch me, but we'd have taken out an important character. This, of course, would work best if oneshot wasn't Bowser or Wario, since they don't want to lose them |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 15:49:20 5B61467A736653557D7D76467A7B7C75120 wrote:
SCOTT MAKE ME :lol anyways, I'm off for now. I'll check back later tonight to see who gets lynched |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/11/09 at 15:49:56 Ok these are my actions during nights 1-4 1- Scott 2- Brutus 3- Tom 4- Joe Hasn't rly helped me tbh thats why i haven't been posting. If I live until the next night i can at least protect someone, and you mite acutally lynch someone that is mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 15:53:15 Imo, Mario should NOT say he is Mario unless he has used all 4 abilities (hopefully including something useful). Once he has used all 4, he is just like a regular mii. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 15:55:31 Thanks oneshot. That will prove to be useful if you get lynched or if you dont. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/11/09 at 16:33:27 Are you as confident about all your other analysis as you are about mine? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/11/09 at 18:03:00 Vote count update oneshot - 5 (Howes, IsThatAGoodThing, Ivootjes, Kmacc, Adam_L) Howes - 2 (nstinson, Syzygy) Kmacc - 1 (dragondragon) TJazZ - 1 (Sportsguy) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (oneshot) Not voting: TJazZ, Fababu, Ariath, Lenny With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 4 hours, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/11/09 at 18:16:50 After i criticized Scott's "over" analysis someone in return critized my opinion. Perhaps a back up - mafia duo? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 18:43:51 Sounds good to me, not that we have a real team plan. Vote: Benoit |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 18:44:30 Scott, if you're mafia you've done one hell of a job rigging this game. unvote vote: Benoit |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 18:46:53 If mario kills me tonight you guys will lose another townie, which is me. Anyway, that's a bit of a crazy plan you got there scott. This obviously can't all work out correctly, because you will be killing off townies and possibly blocking others. This night could end up being a massive townie massacre. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 18:50:12 Quote:
Here is the roles again on this page so you will all see it in case you missed it on the last page. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 18:50:31 I'm just following everyone else here, I have nothing against youu Benoit. unvote vote: Benoit If Ben is townie and this plan of scott's works out, that will be at least two townies gone in me and ben, and possibly other townies dead as well. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/11/09 at 18:50:22 Scott you are looking sketchier by the minute, you have to be mafia. This mutherfuckers swallowing himself. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 18:51:04 (Btw guys Kmacc just showed he is mafia by not voting for Benoit) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 18:51:49 Oneshot you cannot swallow yourself. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 18:53:20 Umm I did vote for Benoit. Maybe you guys should just vote for me instead at the rate you're going cause you want the town to lose it seems. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 18:54:19 Yeah good cover up there, I saw you voted for Ben after I had already made that post. But sadly we are killing Ben right now. Do not try to cover up for your Bowser. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 18:54:30 Oh boy, this is going to be a tense night coming up. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 18:56:55 I hope Benoit is a townie for the sake of Scott looking like a jerk right now to be honest. If he is mafia though I'm gonna die anyway soon then and you'll find out I'm a Mii and feel stupid for being a bad analyst. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Howes on 02/11/09 at 18:57:09 unvote Vote: Benoit |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/11/09 at 19:11:21 Can whoever is toad announce so we can protect each other, because i'm a sitting duck out here - this play could win us the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/11/09 at 19:13:48 Since I'm a townie I must do as Scott says. Vote Benoit GG Mafia. It seems you have played one hell of a game. I'm ashamed to have said this statement and I take it back: 07202B2A2C311A072A302137202430450 wrote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Howes on 02/11/09 at 19:15:55 1B061D11520 wrote:
Oneshot, that would not be an excellent idea. Toad would be blocked by you, and can't protect you. You would both be sitting ducks, and it helps nobody, except the mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/11/09 at 19:16:43 BTW, Scott, you're not going to feel very good about your analytical skills tomorrow. ::) If you are Mafia you are playing one hell of a risky game and it's working. Good Job. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 19:17:53 Shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 19:22:37 Scott, how does this make you feel about your plan? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by TJazZ on 02/11/09 at 19:26:14 I'll just quote myself before I leave. 0C2B2021273A110C213B2A3C2B2F3B4E0 wrote:
Good luck tomorrow, Scott! :D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 19:47:04 unvote I really don't think Benoit is mafia but whatever. You guys are probably gonna kill him anyway. I voted before out of frustration I guess to be honest but I really don't know, I think this is a stupid move. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 19:48:32 If Benoit ends up mafia then you can lynch me next if I don't die during the night if you really think I'm mafia. You shouldn't because I'm town, but you all seem to be controlled by Scott now so you'll do as he says anyway. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 20:14:01 vote: Lenny Just because I will forever think he is mafia, even though he is going to get away with it if he is. How everyone is letting Lenny get away with his actions and say he is a prefectly normal townie is crazy. He is one of the most, if not, the most experienced player here. He can psych us all out probably. I'm sorry if I sound like a jerk Lenny, but this is just what my gut instinct is telling me to do. You would be playing a very good mafia role right now, being that nobody suspects you, and if any person could do it, it'd be you. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 20:31:24 I'm personally suspicious of joe and kmacc more than ben, but... I also personally think that Scott has a better chance of being Bowser than a Mii:-p Anyways. I say this. We listen to Scott tonight. If it turns out on the next day that Ben was a townie, we lynch Scott. Sounds fair to me:D unvote vote Ben |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 20:43:40 I said a long time ago that we should lynch the quiet people:-p |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 20:45:14 Quote:
considering that you talked to me in elite chat and told me to do what you said, I thought you had an idea:-p well fine then, I'm just going to go with my gut on this one. unvote vote Lenny |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 20:45:46 Unvote Vote: Scott |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 20:48:18 hey now Scott, be fair here! You can't bang on Adam L for talking out of game! [22:08] isthatagoodt: Goose if you want to have a LOL [22:08] isthatagoodt: check the mafia thred [22:08] isthatagoodt: I sabotaged it :) plus the chat that I didn't save where you basically laid out your plan for tonight! I think I agree with drag! unvote vote Scott p.s. no hard feelings:) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 20:48:19 I"m not really voting for Scott :). I just figured comment back quick. Back to my original suspiciion. Unvote: Vote: Kmacc |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 20:48:21 I highly highly highly doubt Adam is mafia. He took Joe's spot. Joe left the game cause he was annoyed over how it was going, and how the town was acting because it wasn't working out. If Joe was mafia, he wouldn't have been unhappy, therefore he wouldn't have left the game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 20:49:39 Yes Stinson is correct we talked in elite chat, but it was a pretty silly one where we both did a joke followed by a smiley face. It was not a serious chat but haha it was funny. Then I said like "check this topic later I will have a post where the town should all follow" Basically, Nathan seemed to fall right into what I was trying to make all the townies believe. Good thing I'm town and I'm stopping this nonsense right now, instead of letting all those night players make terrible moves. Now, I should try to get a solid thought in on the people I think are mafia, at least one of them which we can lynch now! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 20:50:45 85 minutes left of day 5. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 20:52:51 That is a little late to retract your post, Scott. Many people that switched over to Ben are probably off the boards until day 5 is done. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 20:52:54 Okay Kevin I see what you say there but the content of these IMs was just getting so....personal almost....between both of them, that I just started to feel uncomfortable. In real life I am EXTREMELY naive. Basically, I take people at face value, how I have seen them act is how I think they ARE and I always see the good in people before the bad. Often I hear of something a person has done that I have talked to a lot and I will be surprised that person could've done that, maybe just a simple violation of the law, but because that is not my nature I figure most of the people I see as 'good' also will be like that. However I know this is not the case....just can't do anything about it and I'll probably always think like this. I am very weak when people try to appeal to me on my emotions. Regardless, I felt this was just going too far with Adam and Joe BOTH messaging me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 20:53:49 Well that's the point Drag, people should be CARING when the day is ending. People shouldn't just have voted for Ben and left. There are sitll MANY other players in the game who haven't voted for Ben or checked in since the Ben vote started. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 20:55:03 I do agree that we will get a lot of information from tonight, but hopefully we don't fall into a big hole tonight. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 20:56:16 Robin, you should give us a vote update if you're around 8-) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:00:05 couldn't the game be over "tomorrow" if we lynch a townie and one gets killed? Especially if Mario kills one:-p |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:00:47 I hope you plan on voting Scott! Remember you unvoted :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:01:21 gah, I'm so conflicted. I really want to get Scott, because he has too much influence, and he talks a lot of trash:-p OTOH, I still think some quiet guys are mafia. unvote vote Lenny |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:01:30 Town is still alive until townies <= mafia |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:03:11 The only problem with spreading out our votes thin is that the mafia can get 2-3 together to jump on townie with only 1 or 2 votes and then they could still get lynched. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 21:05:10 This day has been extremely hectic (as if that wasn't obvious), and stuff has gotten so crazy that you can't be definite about anything anymore. Lenny is just a strong suspicion of mine, I just have a gut feeling about him. But that's just me too, I don't have 100% proof that he is mafia, and nobody ever will have that of anyone because that is how this works. In my opinion I feel he is mafia, but you also have to take it upon yourself to look into the situation and see how you feel about it, and if you think he's suspicious. We should analyze everything we can in this next hour or so to make sure we have the best pick possible for who we are going to lynch. We need to lynch a mafia member badly. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:20:24 Kmacc, why did you say you know for sure that Etch was mafia? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:21:47 That's one reason I semi-suspect KMacc.. he says that really early, then, after the first night, our scanner makes his very first vote against Kmacc possibly coincidence? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:23:06 I'm sticking with that vote, unless Kmacc convinces me otherwise. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Goose on 02/11/09 at 21:25:36 isthatagoodt (12:22:29 AM): it's adam L isthatagoodt (12:22:31 AM): he's a stoner isthatagoodt (12:22:33 AM): form kart NathanStinson (12:22:36 AM): who doesn't have matis on the mind? isthatagoodt (12:22:39 AM): dont worry hes a dumby will be in prison or something soon isthatagoodt (12:22:45 AM): nathan we need to get EVERYONE TALKING in the topic NOW NathanStinson (12:22:52 AM): where's drag? NathanStinson (12:23:38 AM): btw, wasn't tom in this game? NathanStinson (12:23:47 AM): oh nvm isthatagoodt (12:24:24 AM): yeah he is isthatagoodt (12:24:27 AM): I bet he's mafia NathanStinson (12:24:33 AM): he hasn't posted in forever isthatagoodt (12:24:33 AM): he claims to be Donkey Kong like 10 times isthatagoodt (12:24:37 AM): but never gets killed isthatagoodt (12:24:41 AM): do you think thats suspicous isthatagoodt (12:24:42 AM): ? NathanStinson (12:24:46 AM): probably isthatagoodt (12:24:52 AM): because DK can kill 2 mafias by himself isthatagoodt (12:24:53 AM): its his role isthatagoodt (12:24:55 AM): night kills |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:26:06 Here are those still alive, from the first post: 2. Ariath 4. dragondragon 8. Fababu 10. Howes 11. In Hiding (Tom) 12. IsThatAGoodThing (Scott) 13. Ivootjes 14. Adam_L 15. K. McAteer 17. Lenny 18. nstinson 19. oneshotbilly 20. Sportsguy (Tyler) 22. syzygy (Tim) 23. TJazZ (Benoit) some random questions: What on earth happened to the Gaff, Lenny, syzygy, and Sportsguy? Haven't seen them post in a long time Who on earth is Ariath, Howes, and Lenny? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:26:55 lol Goose has posted two times so far after he's been dead. I believe that is against the rules:) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:28:41 Talking about Mafia Club outside of this thread is also against the rules, nate. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:28:49 I wouldn't mention it if I didn't think it were so. I'd use the same reasoning I used for Oneshot saying he was Yoshi |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Goose on 02/11/09 at 21:29:35 Talking outside of this topic is also against the rules... I have nothing to lose. I can't die further. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:30:06 Talking about Mafia Club outside of this thread is also against the rules, nate. I posted my post about Tom at the same time I said it in chat. I was asking in Chat because I couldn't remember if Tom had been in the game or not, because I didn't see his name in the list on the first page as I was typing it up |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:31:06 I guess if "NathanStinson (12:23:38 AM): btw, wasn't tom in this game?" constitutes talking out of the game. :-? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 21:31:44 He goes by Inhiding on the forum, Nate. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 21:32:06 5D4B585E56575D4B585E5657390 wrote:
If you couldn't tell by now, it was obviously a joke. As you could also see in last week's MKDS news title, I joke about Etch being mafia there as well. Me and Etch obviously go way back since near the beginning of mkds and basically are the two that do the most updating and such on the site, and because of that we talk a lot and are good friends. From that you can deduct that it is a joke vote. Etch even says his vote for me is a spite vote, because we were joking around about it. If Etch had scanned me and it came up mafia (which it wouldn't because I'm townie, don't say I'm Bowser), he wouldn't have posted that his vote for me was out of spite. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:34:01 peh, who checks the MKDS news?:-p |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 21:34:28 I agree there, Kmacc....for some reason you have completely won my trust in the last half hour. I still don't know if Lenny is a good vote here. I just counted and it looks like Benoit reached 7 votes TWICE in that hour where my "vote ben" post was up. We nearly killed him. If we want to kill someone other than ben We better get on it NOW |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:35:55 I say let's just let the night go as it will, as we obviously have no idea who is what |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/11/09 at 21:37:20 Vote count update TJazZ - 4 (Sportsguy, Adam_L, Howes, TJazZ) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (oneshot) Howes - 1 (Syzygy) oneshot - 1 (Ivootjes) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) Kmacc - 1 (dragondragon) Lenny - 1 (nstinson) Not voting: IsThatAGoodThing, Kmacc, Fababu, Ariath, Lenny With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 20 minutes, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 21:38:10 We can't just give up on the day now, after waiting out the WHOLE three days to decide. I'd rather make a thoughtful guess at this than just let everything finish out by itself and hope for the best. Can we get a vote count/amount of time left anytime soon? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:38:44 4D515654584A5E4108390 wrote:
I know you're probably asleep by now, but I'd like to know if you've attempted your second kill yet. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:38:53 64626E6C6C0F0 wrote:
This is the last message where I saw KMac vote. I never saw him vote for drag? :-? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 21:39:05 Ahh scratch that, we got what I asked for. We need to act fast, only twenty minutes! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:40:22 Any reason for voting on Howes? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/11/09 at 21:40:48 The day ends on the hour to be precise. Posts after X:59 will be ignored. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 21:40:53 That's because drag voted me, not me voting him. vote: Lenny Didn't bold it earlier I realized. This may change though, we gotta hurry though. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:41:08 615B7C40495C696F47474C7C4041464F280 wrote:
The only problem with this logic is that Adam L isn't even around, checking the topic, is he? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:42:24 IMO, If Tom really WAS blocked trying to kill someone. It would seem to stand that the person he was trying to kill was Bowser or Wario? nvm, scratch that thought |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:43:37 Why should I let you boss me around?:-p |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 21:44:08 But if we get a tie at 4 Ben vs 4 Howes, won't Ben still get lynched? Is there anybody else around to vote? Should Howes be our definite decision? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:44:39 Whoever reached 4 first will be lynched |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:45:15 I'm just too torn. I don't really *trust* anyone in the game right now |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:46:41 78535448553A0 wrote:
Don't think there's any way you can get the 4 Ben votes to switch. Of those who haven't voted... Scott and KMacc could vote Howes. If drag and I switched, that'd give him 5 and ben 4 |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:47:39 I'll go ahead and unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 21:47:40 unvote vote: Howes No idea what the fuck is going on, just got back from watching some TV and Scott's yelling at me for not posting. Whatever. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:48:42 Scott, I don't like how you rallied votes about 1.5 hours before the end of the day, retracted with an hour left, and then rerallied for someone new with 20 minutes to go. Just seems VERY suspicious, especially since you said you have no power role. Unvote: Vote: Scott |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 21:50:44 Yeahhhh Scott narcing on me is going to get your shit ruined Unvote Fuck your life, fuck the town, fuck the mafia, I'm Baby Daisy, I don't care about you faggots anymore, this shit's about to get rough. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 21:50:52 TEN MINUTES LEFT. We need ONE more Howes vote to secure his lynching. He has done MUCH less than Benoit or anyone here. Even if he is a townie there isn't much reason to keep him around. Perhaps he's Toad or something lame like that. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Lenny on 02/11/09 at 21:51:04 Whoa. I get back from school and I see no more than SEVEN GODDAMN FUCKING pages to read through. Took me forever, but I finally read through them. I'm sorry that I can't post that much, but at the very least, I think I've made up for that by having considerable/ok content in my posts. @Kmacc/Stinson: If you've got a gut feeling that I'm mafia, then I don't think there's really much I can do to convince you that I'm not. I still assure you that I am town, but think what you want. btw, Stinson, my name IS Lenny. xD There's not much to say at this point in my opinion, nothing is going to change now, so I'm going to say more tomorrow, when I have more time to post. ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 21:51:06 The only thing is the only thing I find suspicious about Howes is his little activity, and how he's trying to lay low under the radar. Which is weird, cause I also have that same suspicion towards Lenny, but I my feelings of suspicion towards Lenny are far greater, I guess that's because of my previous reasons though as well. But I don't think Benoit is mafia at all. The only thing for me that would be worse in switching my vote would be if Howes ends up being a power role for the town, or if in the end Ben is mafia, but we won't know that until later. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:51:39 this game sounds like serious business ;D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/11/09 at 21:51:48 COME ON We need to get HOWES out of the game right now. He now has 2 votes, to Tjazz's three. PLEASE SOMEONE HELP ME GET HOWES OUT. I HAVE THIS HUGE FEELING SO BAD RIGHT NOW. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/11/09 at 21:51:49 Vote count update TJazZ - 3 (Sportsguy, Howes, TJazZ) Howes - 2 (Syzygy, IsThatAGoodThing) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (oneshot, dragondragon) Lenny - 1 (Kmacc) oneshot - 1 (Ivootjes) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) Not voting: Adam_L, nstinson, Fababu, Ariath, Lenny With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 8 minutes, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:52:33 meh, Ben's a goner. Not going to get enough people to switch votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Lenny on 02/11/09 at 21:52:42 Oh, Scott, if you want that one more vote, then I can give it to you, I'm not too certain who could be mafia, so I'll have to trust you on this one. Vote: Howes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:53:17 If this ends up being wrong, then I'm definitely voting Scott next day vote Howes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 21:53:19 vote: Benoit |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:53:44 426D78646D625F7865627F63620C0 wrote:
Still feel that way, nate? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:54:27 I just don't get why you'd rally to get Ben killed, then rally to save him as well. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/11/09 at 21:55:08 Vote count update Howes - 4 (Syzygy, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny, nstinson) TJazZ - 4 (Sportsguy, Howes, TJazZ, Adam_L) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (oneshot, dragondragon) Lenny - 1 (Kmacc) oneshot - 1 (Ivootjes) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) Not voting: Fababu, Ariath With 15 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. The day will end in 4 minutes, or when someone reaches 8 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Lenny on 02/11/09 at 21:55:37 At this point in time, the people most suspicous to me are constantly changing, varying almost on one post. One post for me could make it or break it for you in my eyes, so I'm going to be watching everyone more carefully now, especially what they say. I'm just going to pray that 7 pages don't come up the next time I read the thread. :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by K. McAteer on 02/11/09 at 21:55:53 Since Howes reached four votes first and nobody else is around to vote, there's really no need for me to vote.. I am just so confused right now, this is extremely crazy. Not much time to figure out what I wanna do. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 21:56:02 DragonDragon, cool people vote for Benoit. Come on. Do it. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by dragondragon on 02/11/09 at 21:58:11 THis is probably gonna get me killed, but I don't feel right about Scott now. Unvote: Vote: TJazz |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:58:12 either way this works, I say we should all jump on scott tomorrow and lynch him in the first hour:) (that is, of course, unless Ben or Howes ends up being mafia after they get lynched. Then Scott will be vindicated) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Adam L on 02/11/09 at 21:58:17 KMacc, Scott is a dick and should be treated as such. We have no proof Benoit or Howes are mafia, but Benoit being Bowser actually makes sense(with the whole Etch scan thing). We're riding blind suspicion through this lynch and lynching Howes makes no sense. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:59:04 Quote:
hmmm, I may have to rethink things. Drag sure seems to be trying hard to save his... fellow mafia member, Howes? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by nstinson on 02/11/09 at 21:59:54 Quote:
I don't thinkl lynching anyone makes much sense, personally:-p |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Lenny on 02/11/09 at 22:00:17 ^If Howes is mafia, I'm going to be REALLY sus of drag. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 5] Post by Honko on 02/11/09 at 22:22:14 As the karters continued to search for the killers, they thought back to what Luigi had told them earlier. Luigi had said TJazZ was a good guy, and Luigi was always right. So obviously, TJazZ needed to die!! They grabbed their handy lynch stapleguns and made a big mess. TJazZ has been lynched. He was a Mii. Final Day 5 Vote Count TJazZ - 5 (Sportsguy, Howes, TJazZ, Adam_L, dragondragon) Howes - 4 (Syzygy, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny, nstinson) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (oneshot) Lenny - 1 (Kmacc) oneshot - 1 (Ivootjes) Ariath - 1 (In Hiding) Not voting - Fababu, Ariath It is now Night 5. No more talking. Send me your night actions via PM by 10:00pm Pacific time tomorrow. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Honko on 02/12/09 at 15:28:23 Another new day, another new dead body. The remaining players were used to this routine by now. So when they noticed Fababu was missing at the breakfast table, they weren't too surprised. Fababu has been killed. He was a Mii. After a quick funeral they went back to their breakfast. But then they realized someone else was missing. Two deaths in one night?? Who could it be this time? Ariath has been killed. He was Wario, Mafia Roleblocker. "We killed a bad man! We killed a bad man!" The survivors celebrated for several hours. But they knew they weren't done yet. There must still be some killers among them. Time to get back to accusing each other randomly! Day 6 begins now. With 12 players alive, 7 votes are needed to lynch. The deadline for the day is Sunday at 3:30pm Pacific time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 15:36:48 68434458452A0 wrote:
There are now five people left who were NOT on Goose's list. I think these are now the suspects, as Ariath was NOT on Goose's list. Do you think he had the balls to make a list of entirely NOT mafia candidates? Lenny, Tim, Drag, and Ivo would seem the perfect group here. I have no reason at ALL to believe Stinson was mafia. Drag voted for Ben last night as the final vote instead of Howes because Ben is more dangerous than Howes (or so it seems). |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 15:39:22 Scott, personally I felt they were both innocent last night, so I had to choose one. You left too much confusion to the last 15 minutes of the day. We need to be voting with confidence, because the Mafia won't get confused. They know who they are. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 15:40:50 Drag, both you and Ivo fall into another similar category, suddenly. Both of you have been copying and "compiling" stats from the votes that have happened so far in the game. Isn't it convenient for you both to fall into both of these categories? (For example Ivo kept posting where each person had voted, and you posted who the mafia killed at night) I think Ivo and Lenny and Tim are owning us and they know what to have Drag do. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 15:41:43 It felt like you were tricking us into sway at the very end, since there were only minutes to react. If you want to go Howes tonight, I will, but don't make it last minute again :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 15:43:41 Howes isn't on my list. I am targeting you, Ivo, Tim, and Lenny. This seems crystal clear to me that at LEAST Drag/Ivo are Mafia. The reason they keep bringing up previous vote counts is that those stats MEAN NOTHING AT ALL. This is the most clearly I have seen the game up to this point. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 15:43:52 At the moment, it seems like you layed a trap last night, forcing one townie or the other to get killed. No matter what, a townie would die, and whoever voted for them would be a perfect coverup to be mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 15:45:25 I think Lenny is the most dangerous, but Lenny/Ivo/Tim all seem to be able to create a great work of Mafia hidden-ness. Let's get rid of the Australian before he knows what hit him. We will only need 7 votes to lynch him, and here's the first. vote Lenny You guys that will say I am a tard and did bad things last Day, realize this: Through it all I was probably wrong at everything I "analyzed" which I don't care, as I didn't think I'd be right....but right now I DO feel I'm right on this vote! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 15:46:36 Drag, I freaked out like shit last night, but yes they are probably both Town. You right now are not doing a very good job of arguing with me at all. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 15:46:42 Also, when's the last time a rally has led to a Mafia kill? I didn't want that trend to continue, since you like rallying the folks up. Vote: Scott I feel that Scott or Kmacc is Bowser. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 15:48:47 Dragon I am not bowser you fag. If the mafia needed someone to waste hours upon hours to make profile posts, just to get ONE vote, you are sadly mistaken. This only goes to show that you are mafia. I think Kmacc hit it RIGHT on the head last night when he felt suspicious of Lenny near the end. Stinson was ready and willing to also vote on Lenny, and I wish I had also. You would not have supported it, however. Right now I feel like I have totally figured this out, and that you mafia guys are going to lose starting here. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 15:48:58 The reason I voted for Ben last night, was because you guys let Ben get 1 away from being lynched twice. It seemed like a perfect diversion to not let us think that he was Mafia. You gave zero legit reasons of why to vote for Howes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 15:50:04 I would've voted Lenny. He was suspicious for being quieter this game than the last. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 15:51:17 Okay, even though what I say in my "profile" posts probably shouldn't be valued very highly I will say this: When I read the posts of Drag, Ivo, Lenny, Tim, they all give me a little bit of a "feeling" that is not present. Each poster, by reading 20-30 of their posts all in one shot, gave me a different "feeling" as I typed and read and typed and read. I can really remember the "safety" feeling I got off all these guys, and I think that is because they are just SO adept at playing a masterful game. Maybe Goose made his list about 1/2 and 1/2, mafia and town...but Drag and Lenny are just seeming so suspicious here. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 15:56:40 774D6A565F4A7F7951515A6A565750593E0 wrote:
So if you don't think Howes is Mafia, why would I appear Mafia by voting for Ben? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 15:58:52 Drag: You and Lenny voted for Howes there because it's a great setup. This way Lenny can say you would be suspicious if Howes ended up being mafia (Which he knows neither is). This is why I know Howes is no longer a suspect at all. Drag we are talking about Lenny in multiple posts last night in the last hour but you didn't mention LENNY one time in your posts. You just posted about other stuff..... Lenny hopped on by voting for Benoit, and he did it so easily and claiming not to know who the mafia is. Lenny is a GREAT Mafia player and he would NEVER say that. He would have a HUGE idea who the mafia is by this time. Right now: Everyone needs to see this clearly. I will prepare the most important posts and it should be very clear! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 16:01:26 I have a different proposition for everyone tonight. You should vote for me, and if I'm town, then vote for Scott tommorrow. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 16:02:32 Here is how Lenny votes for Howes. A player as well-schooled as he is in mafia should NOT have made such a silly vote claim at this point. This is where he messed up. Kmacc saw Lenny's guilt much before, so I congratulate him for that. He is a much better mafia player than I. 2223252A3D4E0 wrote:
I think this is the first time in the game we can REALLY see what the mafia have been doing, and now we are able to finally get them knocked off one by one! First it's Lenny, as Drag cannot function without his crutch. It's so easy to see this when he is posting now, doesn't know HOW to defend his mafia, but that he should. Earlier he had a plan of action that Lenny had obviously given to him, which was show them things from the past that have no value at all. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 16:03:03 I have a VERY strong feeling Scott and I are opposite sides after the events of last night. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ariath on 02/12/09 at 16:03:23 Eh, that sucks xD I thought that I had played a pretty good game. Props to |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 16:03:29 Okay maybe Drag isn't mafia, but Lenny for sure must be. Look at this guy. He is mafia. I think I have made it very clear. I WISH Kmacc, me, and Stinson would've just went with Lenny last night, but the votes weren't going to line up to kill him anyway. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 16:06:09 Are you sure you don't want to chance leading the troops against me, with my claim, Scott? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 16:07:24 Eric I do not want to lead the topic against you because you are worthless when Lenny dies. Lenny is for sure a mafia, in my mind. Dragon are you ever going to let it go? You are now defending and trying to get votes off of Lenny. That looks suspicious to me even more. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 16:11:12 I didn't make my claim to get votes off of me, since there are none yet. That is the last I will say of that today. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 16:11:42 By the way someone else just fell completely off my radar and that is Sporstguy, maybe we SHOULDNT forget about those on the list. Just that I think Lenny for now is the most clear mafia. Okay here is something I said in IRC to Robin and he wanted me to post it here lol [18:09:36] <IsThatAGoodThing> And I guess if you spend 10 hours making profile posts you are bowser [18:09:44] <IsThatAGoodThing> Since he is so weak and needs to try so hard to figure everything out [18:09:53] <IsThatAGoodThing> Drag's either a mafia or a moron But sorry Drag if you are a town because haha....but I hope you are not a moron! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 16:13:45 Why would Araith say who Mario was since he's Mafia? They have no scanner, so Mafia can't know for sure. I only see it as to keep the heat off of Scott, so people won't suspect him. He still wants the Mafia to win. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 16:14:52 67544F47524E260 wrote:
Forgot to quote it. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/12/09 at 16:15:54 The mafia plays games with their final post, first goose and now ariath. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 16:15:56 Drag, he wasn't saying I'm mario, he was obviously mocking the fact that I am sucky as shit at telling stuff in mafia on Day 5. But overall the contribution is positive: we have caught you and Lenny! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 16:16:53 Glad to see you are around Sporstguy. Haven't seen you posting lately, what do you think of everything, who are you suspicious of at the moment? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 16:18:18 Lol, did you just IM Tim to come check the topic? ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 16:20:24 No? Tim was in IRC but he left before it was opened again. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/12/09 at 16:28:41 I'm suspicious of Tom because he hasn't posted in a while. However, one of his last posts he questioned Ariath. So it could have been him kill Ariath in the night. I'm doubting scott would be mafia simply because he posted all those profiles even though i think he almost single handily got Ben lynched who was a mii. I don't know what to think about dragon and lenny. Ivo is someone to keep an eye on. I think he is mafia or a special role more than likely mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by In Hiding on 02/12/09 at 16:34:49 1) From day 1 i've said i'm a townie 2) I early on questioned goose and if you read back it was me that said he was mafia and voted for him - he was. 3) I owned up and said I was donkey - I have the ability to kill two people at night 4) I suspected Ariath and I voted him last night, i knew no one else could see it cause he wasn't posting much but if you re-read his posts they're not convincing so i took a chance (sorry guys but not much else was clearer - alot of shit talking) and voted him. He was a bad guy. 5) I'm in big fucking trouble now as no doubt mafia will vote me off next - this is the one round where i need to make a big impact - both in terms of my normal vote and my night vote. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by K. McAteer on 02/12/09 at 16:51:50 Can't say much because I'm at my friend's house right now, but damn good job to knock out Ariath. We still stand a chance guys! :D As for my suspicious, it's still on lenny, because that's my gut feeling. I've explained my reasoning earlier as well if anyone is wanting more in that department. vote: Lenny |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 17:00:00 Scott, once I was willing to die to sacrifice myself to get you killed, you backed off. To be that important, you must be 1) a power role 2) mafia You told us last night that you were just a mii, so what's the harm in a 1 for 1 trade? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 17:02:33 If I'm mafia, then you'll live. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ariath on 02/12/09 at 17:08:46 Eh, I'm probably not allowed to talk anymore, but I'll make one final post. 1. No, I wasn't saying that Scott. You are mario and all should know that. 2. In hiding is lying. I roleblocked him last night, so it is impossible for him to have killed me unless Robin fucked up. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Almost Started] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 17:11:14 6A41465A47280 wrote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ariath on 02/12/09 at 17:15:14 :P *dies for good now* |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 17:16:33 Thank you Ariath :P |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 17:17:55 Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] (Read 10000 times) 10,000'd |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Honko on 02/12/09 at 17:18:17 Yeah Ariath, don't post information after you are dead. I did not make a mistake with the night actions. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Howes on 02/12/09 at 17:25:36 362A2D2F2331253A73420 wrote:
So either Tom is lying, Ariath is lying, or one of two things happened. 1. The roleblocker from our side (Adam L) blocked Ariath, or 2. Mario killed Ariath. Adam, since you claim to be roleblocker, and no one else has come forward claiming it, did you block Ariath last night? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 17:26:08 I'm going where I was lat night, before Scott freaked out and tried getting a lynchmob for Howes together again vote Lenny |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 17:28:05 08232438254A0 wrote:
Goose posted several times after being dead, IMO |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 17:29:12 Lenny better be a mafia, but I'm still not changing my vote. My instinct hasn't changed from last night. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Honko on 02/12/09 at 17:30:21 Goose did not post information that might affect people's decisions. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ivootjes on 02/12/09 at 17:54:03 That was one hell of a read, through 10 pages :o And it's pretty nice, no more ariath mafia talk in this topic from now on, this topic is actually improving ;D Quote:
Did somebody else notice that this dead mafiosi actually told us that Tom is a confirmed townie? 8-) Besides, i won't jump on another Scott bandwagon too soon today, look what happened yesterday :o I'll analyze more tomorrow, it's bed time now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ivootjes on 02/12/09 at 17:57:08 And yeah, ariath shouldn't have made that post, but i don't care as he's actually helping town now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Etch on 02/12/09 at 18:27:26 I told you so! Goes back to heaven. [smiley=engel017.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Extol on 02/12/09 at 18:35:25 man, its gettin crazy down here, im glad i died... follows etch [smiley=engel017.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 18:40:08 Through page 25: Scott defends Nate 467C5B676E7B4E4860606B5B676661680F0 wrote:
Ariath accuses Brutus, Tim, Ben, and Lenny 093A21293C20480 wrote:
Ariath doesn't defend Howes 7F4C575F4A563E0 wrote:
Ariath accuses Scott without explanation 1B28333B2E325A0 wrote:
Ariath accues Kmacc 794A51594C50380 wrote:
Just a thought, but perhaps these two quotes from etch are actually both correct? In the first, he seemed pretty sure that Benoit was a townie, so I'll continue to trust him. In the second post though, he stated that his vote for Kmacc was a 'spite' vote. Maybe he scanned kmacc and he actually is mafia; Etch could have been giving subtle hints as to who's who.[/quote] Ariath accuses Lenny 6C5F444C59452D0 wrote:
Ariath defends Nate 417269617468000 wrote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 18:47:36 The rest before Ariath's death Ariath defends OneShot 112239312438500 wrote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 18:50:04 From those posts, I am inclined to make a short list. Keep in mind, that it's only based on that, but these people should most likely be where I put them Town: Lenny Howes Scott Kmacc Mafia: Nate Oneshot |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 18:50:57 Unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 18:52:00 The only thing that confuses me though, is that Scott defends Nate. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 18:57:52 Nate wants Lenny and Howes dead 7A55405C555A67405D5A475B5A340 wrote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/12/09 at 18:59:30 Nate, you were defended by Ariath and now you want to kill 2 people Ariath wanted killed. You are now enemy number 1 in my eyes. Vote: Nate |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Adam L on 02/12/09 at 19:24:43 6864716D6864627076353632050 wrote:
I blocked drag because I had no idea what to do about Scott's "plan", and I was suspicious of him being mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 19:37:32 Eric that seems like a well-thought posting section there, I don't quite know what to think of it yet. Ivo and Ariath both had a little exchange there, of Ivo saying "Did he say this is a confirmed townie" THIS could have been true but if Ivo is a mafia then you know that has no meaning at all. So this post I think we CANNOT give any value at this time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 19:38:00 I'm suspicious because Araith defended me?:-p Perhaps he analyzed me, saw I was a Mii, and didn't want us to waste time on killing me:-p |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 19:39:46 392F3C3A3233392F3C3A32335D0 wrote:
I don't understand what you are referencing here? If you have prior mafia experience then good for you, but I don't have a clue what this post is meaning. Also when you say I defended Nate...that was on Day ONE, right at the start. Goose was making fun of Stinson hardcore and I just thought he was being a little mean to him. I have seen Goose post things like that about Nate before so :-/ .....but well at that point in the game I didn't even have my head on straight at all! (As if I do now haha!) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 19:41:48 Nathan: Ariath can't analyze anyone LOL! Okay and as to Ariath calling me Mario twice....first off this shouldn't even be legal and Robin should've deleted those posts! He's trying to contribute to the game. Second off....no I am not Mario. If I was Mario I would not have called myself a Mii. Mario has four special night powers of Killing, Protecting, Roleblocking, and one more, and I don't have these. If I did I would've killed Howes last night (lol!) because at that moment I was sad to see Ben get killed and I thought Howes was still supposed to be dead after Drag had voted the wrong way. But no haha I am not Mario. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 19:42:52 Goose just bangs on me all the time, Scott usually does also:-p Heck, most people do! hmmm, I'm assuming its Mario or DK that killed their Wario... How did they know? If it was Mario, we've got to assume that he scanned him first, and found out. Yet, we haven't heard anything from anyone regarding that. If it really WAS Tom, and he was telling the truth, I don't know why Tom isn't dead yet (he claimed to be DK yesterday). He most definitely will be tonight (unless a roleblocking happens hardcore or he is protected by Toad) If it WAS Tom... how did he know? Did he just take a wild shot in the dark? If so, that seems very suspicious to me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 19:45:28 you're right, for some reason I kept thinking that Wario was a scanner, not a roleblocker. Now, however, that we've got their roleblocker down... We can almost get them! If Mario had a good scan of a Mafia he could pass along to us, then either he or DK could wack the guy (if either of them has a kill left), and we'd be down to... I think one Koopa Troopa and Bowser? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 19:55:35 Good idea, Nate...I think Tom does seem a bit suspicious. I just realize right now that what me and Nate are doing looks almost scripted LOL! Also for now I am uncomfortable voting for Lenny at this moment and I think we should slow the day down again, as this discussion is seeming good. unvote But this doesn't mean you're off the hook, you big-haired goomba-looking Aussie! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by K. McAteer on 02/12/09 at 19:58:01 Maybe both Tom and Ariath are telling the truth. Maybe Ariath got roleblocked so his roleblock failed, meaning Tom was able to get the kill? Idk random analysis lol. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 20:12:44 Who roleblocked Ariath? Mario? EDIT: Btw 1000th post :)! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by K. McAteer on 02/12/09 at 20:22:51 ^Actually that is the 1000th reply, my post was the 1000th post. Honko is mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 20:36:05 I'll keep my vote Lenny for now |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 20:40:45 I wonder what will happen when the rest of the crew reads this. If we go the whole next 20 hours or so with not much posting I will be very sad. It's now been the same 5 guys for the last 2 days haha. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 21:39:49 time to lynch the guys who don't ever respond! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Lenny on 02/12/09 at 22:42:28 And, as per normal, I get back from school to find 4 pages to read through. Definitely not as much as the other days, but still quite a read. ;D OK... Probably the time to defend myself. So Scott, let me get this straight. You think I'm mafia, because A: I said I wasn't too certain of who was mafia, and this I think this is the first time in the game we can REALLY see what the mafia have been doing, and now we are able to finally get them knocked off one by one! First it's Lenny, as Drag cannot function without his crutch. It's so easy to see this when he is posting now, doesn't know HOW to defend his mafia, but that he should. Earlier he had a plan of action that Lenny had obviously given to him, which was show them things from the past that have no value at all. You say that I am well-schooled in mafia, which, I admit freely, I am. However, if I was, then how could I not know how to defend myself if I'm mafia, which I keep telling you, I am not. A major flaw in the plot I think. I can see that for sure, you are not mafia, it's very clear. Then there's this Drag: You and Lenny voted for Howes there because it's a great setup. This way Lenny can say you would be suspicious if Howes ended up being mafia (Which he knows neither is). This is why I know Howes is no longer a suspect at all. Drag we are talking about Lenny in multiple posts last night in the last hour but you didn't mention LENNY one time in your posts. You just posted about other stuff..... Lenny hopped on by voting for Benoit, and he did it so easily and claiming not to know who the mafia is. Lenny is a GREAT Mafia player and he would NEVER say that. He would have a HUGE idea who the mafia is by this time. First off, if me and drag voted against Howes because it was a great setup, then why the hell did drag change his vote at the last moment? I'm not sure, but I think this is something which I am very suspicous of, take note of this, I will mention it a little later. The second part, I will also mention a little later. The third. The third. I assure you, at the time of that post, I only had suspicions of people, but no clear mafiosos, which I will mention in conjunction with the above parts in a moment. NOW is the time when I have a huge idea who is mafia. Also, if I was mafia, then I would have had a huge idea who mafia was from the start, wouldn't I now? Now is when it is far more clear, better than the confusion that was yesterday. Now, this is where I will tell you who I'm suspicious of. I think some people may say that I'm trying to take the pressure off of myself, but anyone in my position would do that, especially when a lynch on me would make it easier for a mafia win. First, I quote drag 697F6C6A6263697F6C6A62630D0 wrote:
This guy is way too suspicious for me after this, especially after Benoit turned out to be town. He's also suspicous of Scott, who is either an idiot or town. He also defended Howes, who I'm also suspicous of. For once, maybe I may be able to formulate a plan, despite my being untrustworthy. I say we lynch Howes, like we were going to yesterday. If Howes is mafia, drag is in my eyes 100% mafia, I don't care what happens. That's just a suggestion, and I guess that was my 'defense'. Make what you want of it. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 22:43:30 the only thing is, we'll never know if Howes was mafia or not... because we'd have to waste a day to find out. I said last night that I suspected drag because of the last second switch |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 22:44:56 it's going to suck if someone like sports guy is bowser, because he never talks |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/12/09 at 22:47:04 side note last mafia took app 10 days and 15 pages this one has taken 13+ days and 41+ pages and counting... about 15 of those pages by Scott himself:D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/12/09 at 22:49:45 Lenny what do you propose we do now? Also the part you bolded was me saying DRAG doesn't know how to defend. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Fababu on 02/12/09 at 22:51:22 Oh man, I get killed when the game starts to be interesting. Good luck townies. P.D: At least I'm happy knowing that my guess about Ariath was correct xD. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Lenny on 02/12/09 at 23:07:25 Oh right Scott, sorry about that. If that's the case then dw about that part. My proposal: I am next to certain now that at least one of Drag or Howes is mafia, if not both. My proposal is to lynch Howes, because Drag seemed to defend him with that last minute vote. Another few people who go up on my list are Sportsguy and OneShot for their silence-ness. I can't really elaborate here, I have to go in a minute, but we should really lynch Howes today, just as we planned yesterday. IF, he IS mafia, then drag is practically guaranteed to be mafia, and we should definitely lynch him the next day. That'll whittle things down to two mafia, who I suspect of above. That's all for now. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by In Hiding on 02/13/09 at 01:59:20 I think dragon could be mafia, mafia are doing a good job of talking loads, its putting me off, i am better at spotting the mafia when they say less. All this constant waffle. ffs. If you're a townie then post you are, I want to know who owns up. Btw - people are asking why, if i'm dk i've not been killed yet - i imagine it will happen tonight. So make sure you role block me if you can. I've contributed to kill 2 mafia so far, one indirectly and one directly, try to save me if you want to win. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ivootjes on 02/13/09 at 02:50:18 I think we should either lynch howes or drag at this point. It al started with our favorite cop telling us that Tjazz was innocent [smiley=dankk2.gif] Then scott started with the plan to try to get several players to vote for multiple players on one day. And he made a point there, the votes gathered way more quikly on Tjazz and Oneshot than they did on Howes. The problem is that he included Tjazz VERY late in the day. I know that it could have been a possibility that Tjazz was the bowser, it's just unlike that he was, and even if he was the bowser than their would still be 3 more mafia members to look out for. Why would you take the risk of lynching an almost confirmed townie so early. You might want to rethink such things when your with 3-5 man left, but for now it wasn't the best idea. That's why i think that the players who voted for Tjazz are more suspicious than the other players (as a reminder, this are Sportsguy, Howes, Adam and Dragondragon) Besides, i can't believe that Tjazz made this vote for himself, such a dumb move to vote for yourself. I'll probably vote for drag or howes later on in the day depending on who you guys think we should lynch or if someone can convince me to vote else. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by In Hiding on 02/13/09 at 02:56:14 why do you think howes is dodgy? howes, defend yourself or i might be swayed.. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/13/09 at 03:53:38 Vote: dragondragon I said numerous times that I am Yoshi. Trying to accuse me of being mafia looks like he trying to shift attention from himself. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ivootjes on 02/13/09 at 04:10:18 0C36112D243104022A2A21112D2C2B22450 wrote:
I'm only analyzing what's said, i don't post my personal opinion there. Or do you think that ariath's frustrated post was part of a plan with in hiding while he didn't even know that he was going to die in the first place? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by In Hiding on 02/13/09 at 04:13:32 thats ridiculous, i voted him, knew he wasn't going to get the most votes so i used one of my night kills to get rid of him. Its simple! Ask Honko. There's no elaborate plan. And for the record - I know sean personally and from the way he is writing I honestly believe he is yoshi. * *i'm wrong i'll look a mug [smiley=lolk.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/13/09 at 06:37:37 Ok I'm back. Few things. 1) Can't believe TJazZ got voted last night. I was reading through the topic and it looked like it was swaying in Howes direction and I was glad I chose to leave my vote with him, only for Dragondragon to confirm the kill on Ben -___- I know Ben was suspected, but I thought he did a good job (or at least he did with me) of convincing us he was also a townie. Dragondragon, I know Scott was talking a lot of shit last night but that was a bad move, Howes has barely done anything all game and now I think it's even more likely he is mafia with fewer players left in the game. What I'm annoyed at though is how your post to kill was quickly after someone mentioned that KMacc need to vote to CONFIRM the kill on Howes (reach 5 first) and for that you now have a very big ?????????? over your head. 2) GG Mario, we really needed that one. 3) Scott, don't know wtf you've been smoking, you went a bit insane last night but at least you wanted Howes dead which was how it should have been. If you are mafia then you are playing a crazy strat. I'm keeping an eye on you. 4) Lenny is not mafia (IMO). He has a strange post style for this game, nearly always incorporating ;) or ;D or :P into one of his posts. I don't think he should be doing this though. He did it in the last game and was targeted by me (Mark Jones in game) as I thought he was mafia for the strangeness. Therefore, I think Lenny is truthful. 5) I don't know where all the Tom suspicion came from :S Yes he hasn' posted an awful lot so far but he's always seemed to correct in his guesses/assumptions. 6) Now my suspicion lies with Howes, Ivo and Sportsguy, but I'm not sure about the fourth. :/ |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Adam L on 02/13/09 at 07:08:58 I've already claimed that I'm Baby Daisy, but I guess I'll say it again(mafia, don't see this thanks). I'm Baby Daisy. As for why I voted drag, Scott is a fucking narc and I hated his guts and I had to make sure his night was ruined. Sorry to the rest of the townies that I fucked over(esp. you Benoit), but goddamn I hate Scott. It's over now and I'm back to playing the game the right way, so let's get this shit over with. At the moment I like how everything is playing out, especially the Howes/Drag suspicion. I've already said that I'm suspicious of drag(I roleblocked him last night to no avail, or at least we think to no avail), and Howes is suspicious because he just hasn't been active lately, and I feel like he's trying to avoid talking and giving himself away until the last second. Mark my words, he'll post when he has four or five votes on him pleading you not to vote. Though after reading this you'll probably post, won't you Howes? Please do, I'd love to analyze everything you have to say. As for a vote, well, I'm voting for dragondragon. Not trying to get a bandwagon going, so don't just hop on kiddies, think about who you're voting for. We need to make a mafia lynch today, and I think we're on a good path. vote: dragondragon |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 07:45:23 Just remember that Scott led the charge to lynch Ben first. He also said that he believed Ben and Howes were both NOT mafia. I said that I figured neither were as well, but I didn't have the power to eliminate someone else by myself. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 07:46:23 Sender: Adam L To: dragondragon Subject: please god Date: Feb 11th, 2009, 11:57pm For the love of God please vote Benoit at 00:58 You would make my life complete by ruining Scott's life I am Baby Daisy and can prove it if need be PLEASE GOD DO THIS FOR ME AND I WILL OWE YOU EVERYTHING |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 07:47:33 People really need to quit talking out of game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/13/09 at 07:55:35 You should have voted Howes >=( |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 07:58:34 I'm not worried about putting pressure on myself dying, because I'd rather keep a probable power role alive. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Adam L on 02/13/09 at 08:01:40 lo fucking l, ok, I quit the game. Modkill me Honko, the level of narcing running rampant through the forum is amazing. Congrats kiddies, you just lost Baby Daisy, one of your townie power roles! Oh yeah, there's no doubt in my mind dragondragon is mafia now, so make sure you kill him ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 08:03:48 I wouldnt have narced if you didn't say I was guilty for voting late. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 08:04:56 But rules are rules, and you're not the only one who has contacted me about the game, via IM, PM, or phone call. I have not given any info to people, because it is against the rules. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Adam L on 02/13/09 at 08:05:14 YOU ARE MAFIA YOU FUCKING SCUM I DON'T EVEN KNOW YOU, THERE WOULD BE NO REASON FOR YOU TO SWITCH YOUR VOTE TO BENOIT THAT LATE IN THE GAME UNLESS YOU SHARE A HATRED FOR SCOTT WITH ME. YOU ARE MAFIA, HOWES IS MAFIA, YOU KNEW BENOIT WASN'T MAFIA. CONGRATS ON GIVING YOURSELF AWAY DOUCHEBAG. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Adam L on 02/13/09 at 08:06:19 Dragondragon is mafia and if you don't vote for him you are borderline retarded. If he is not mafia then you can lynch me because I will most certainly somehow be mafia if he isn't. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 08:07:01 Ben and Howes aren't mafia in my opinion. But I'm still led to believe that Scott is. So if you guys kill me and find out I'm town, you should kill Scott next. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ivootjes on 02/13/09 at 08:08:52 Vote Dragondragon for reasons explained in my earlier posts. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Adam L on 02/13/09 at 08:10:42 What the fuck are you on dragon? "Ben and Howes aren't mafia in my opinion." BENOIT IS DEAD. BENOIT IS PROVEN TO BE TOWN. YOU ARE MAFIA. GIVE UP. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 08:11:11 I know, but I said that before either were dead. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Adam L on 02/13/09 at 08:13:17 Find the quote and link to it for me, thanks. It doesn't clear you of anything, considering you're mafia, and you would know who the mafia is. Of course you know Benoit isn't mafia, and it's easy to say that. Howes IS mafia with you, so you had to clear his name. You hoped that people would see you thinking "Benoit isn't mafia", Benoit dies, we find out he was town, people believe you and start to trust you. CLEARING YOURSELF AND HOWES AT THE SAME TIME, YOU MAFIA FAGGOTS. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 08:18:33 I didn't switch to eliminate Ben. I switched because I don't trust Scott. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 08:25:02 Please eliminate the following once I am lynched. Mafia: Scott Nate Kmacc Oneshot Someone finally needed to strike back to vote away from the trend. We've eliminated a Townie too many times in a row, and Scott is always leading the charge. All 4 of these are linked with Ariath in my quote posts a few pages ago. I want you to kill me, so we can finally take down the Mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 08:26:14 However, please start by voting Scott. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by TJazZ on 02/13/09 at 08:31:46 [smiley=engel017.gif] I know I'm not supposed to talk but... 132C35352E303F295A0 wrote:
How was I supposed to guess that Scott was going to try to pull some retarded antics at 1:30 am? I went to bed immediately after I posted my last message since I've been doing 14 hour days at work since Monday and it was already ~11:30. I was so frustrated that people were actually following his ridiculously unfounded and speculative "analysis" that I figured there was not hope for the townies at that point. To give you an idea, Scott's just lucky I didn't mod-kill myself and end the night right then and there by posting a screenshot of Robin's PM. THAT's how frustrated I was. In hindsight I do wish I had unvoted before I left but IMO a last minute rush is a bad idea because there's no way to know who's going to be there at the time (and look what happened). I'm not about to say up until 2 am to play a silly internet game if I have to get up 4 hours later. I just wanted to defend myself. I won't post again until the game is over now. :-X [smiley=engel017.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 08:33:57 That's why Scott picked the time that he did. I wanted to keep my vote for Scott instead, but I know he was trying to pull something by leading a charge that late into the day (we had like 20 minutes before the end of the day). Sorry Ben, but you were just in the crossfire. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 2] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 09:41:59 0A21263A27480 wrote:
3 of 4 on my list did NOT vote Goose on Day 2. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 09:45:20 Nate has been the wildcard and the least suspicious in my mind. However, that leads me more to believe that he could be Bowser. Bowser is the most critical of the Mafia, because the only way he can die is by lynch. He tends to follow everyone's votes to keep the suspicions off. Even when scanned, Bowser will show up as a mii. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by K. McAteer on 02/13/09 at 10:43:53 drag: imo that's a terrible list. If scott were mafia and wasted ALL of that time writing stuff, then he is out of his mind. I do believe now that oneshot is yoshi, just by the way he's posted since then (even if only a few times) and plus Tom thinks he's yoshi too by the way he's talking. I myself know I am a townie so obviously I know it would be retarded to lynch me. Nate I'm not 100% he's townie, but I'm not suspicious of him. And if you read back to the Goose lynching, you could see that me and scott were not back in time. We both came on the forums a bit after night had started. If you are going to say we were mafia because we didn't vote because we didn't have access to the forum then you are mentally disabled. unvote vote: dragondragon |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Honko on 02/13/09 at 10:59:11 Vote count update dragondragon - 4 (oneshot, Adam_L, Ivootjes, Kmacc) Lenny - 1 (nstinson) nstinson - 1 (dragondragon) Not voting: Syzygy, Lenny, Sportsguy, Howes, In Hiding, IsThatAGoodThing With 12 players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch. The day will end in 53 hours, or when someone reaches 7 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/13/09 at 11:23:29 Vote dragondragon Because he is against Adam L and Scott who seem very much town. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 11:41:15 I'm not against Adam. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 11:42:53 Hmmm, I could've sworn I switched my vote to Scott. Unvote Vote: Scott |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/13/09 at 11:43:26 ^ Ok, maybe i just assumed you were because Adam L is so very much against you. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 11:44:15 Nope :). Just Scott, Nate, Kmacc, and Oneshot. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 11:45:12 Adam tried to set me up, but I don't think he's Mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/13/09 at 11:46:58 Oh my lord. Dragon, stop using this thread as an excuse to increase your post count. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 12:29:02 687473717D6F7B642D1C0 wrote:
I want to know how you knew who wario was, unless it was a dumb luck guess? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 12:33:17 3E283B3D35343E283B3D35345A0 wrote:
thanks for the support, drag!:D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ivootjes on 02/13/09 at 12:33:30 And i'm off, probably for about 14 hours again (party+sleep) I expect a full write up by scott when i wake up tomorrow ^^ Don't lynch dragondragon yet, we've still got time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 12:41:15 btw, I'm probably letting my personal biases into the game a bit, since I've only actually met drag in person out of everyone in the game, so would be more inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt. I probably should switch my Lenny vote, I just said I was keeping it there until I decided on a concrete one, instead of letting Scott way my opinion all day, like yesterday:-p I really think Scott is one of the bad guys, but I'm never going to vote him, because I know that we'd never get enough to vote him off. So, if he is, I'll just have the vindication of knowing that I was right in the end (even though I'm dead:-p) ok, we need a gameplan for tonight.... IF Tom is really DK... I don't see *how* mafia could be stupid enough to not kill Tom yet in the night. They killed Etch based on an off-comment by fababu, when fababu said (stupidly) that Etch could scan. So, Etch dead just from an off handed comment... yet, Tom says EARLY that he is DK.. and is not dead yet... either mafia is stupid.. or Tom is suspicious. I don't know, I'm just not buying it yet. (Only because the mafia has seemed really smart so far. Sorry Tom) (on second thought, I guess Peach could have protected Tom early... but that still wouldn't say why Tom is still alive) (p.s.s. We still don't know for sure DK made the kill last night) (p.s.s.s. HOW did Tom know ariath was foul? That seems way to lucky IMO:)) and that leaves another point of suspicion for me... why would they leave Oneshot alive? Oneshot has been claiming to be yoshi for a day now... There's no Peach to protect him (unless Mario uses his one protect).... Toad hasn't died yet, so he hasn't protected someone who's been killed... and this goes back to the "why kill etch so early, and not one of these others?"... I guess Adam L would be included in this, since he claimed yesterday to be Baby. I mean, come on... what would it hurt a mafia to kill one of those guys claiming to be something if you KNOW they aren't mafia? What's the worst you can do? Kill a Mii? Maybe kill Toad trying to protect that guy? (if toad died trying to protect the guy, then that guys a goner the next night almost guaranteed). Last night they killed FABABU, for some odd reason. Were they just being ignorant? Stupid? Trying to mislead us? too many loose ends IMO |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 12:44:08 " really think Scott is one of the bad guys, but I'm never going to vote him, because I know that we'd never get enough to vote him off. So, if he is, I'll just have the vindication of knowing that I was right in the end (even though I'm dead:-p)" Thanks Nate. Finally someone sees things my way. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/13/09 at 12:45:20 To pick up what you say about Scott, I think he has been getting very carried away. What may have been perceived as "help" has caused a whole lot of confusion through the town and I'm not sure what to make of him :/ |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 12:47:15 And also Nate, I've also said you're the one i'm unsure about. The other 3 are really obvious to me, and you may just be an innocent follower. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 12:49:52 I guess you'll just have to make your own decision on whether or not I am:) Lay out your evidence against me and we'll see if they hold water |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 12:53:13 One comment I have just thought about, referring to Goose's list. We know that all 5 mafia weren't on there. I believe that he wouldn't put Bowser on that list, to keep the most important mafia member more safe. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by In Hiding on 02/13/09 at 12:55:09 stinson just shot up on my dodgy list. I think he's going to the be one i kill tonight with my power role. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 12:56:58 So... I shoot up on Tom's list because I find something fishy about whats been happening with him? hmmmmmm |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by In Hiding on 02/13/09 at 13:02:45 yes, 100%, if you think i'm a mafia after everything i've said then it increminates you. To some degree, it matters not, if i choose to kill you then I do, unless you have a power-role, you'll be screwed. What i'm saying is, its in your court to convince me you're a townie, not the other way around. 8-) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/13/09 at 13:02:58 That means you got roleblocked Tom? So it was Mario who killed Ariath? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/13/09 at 13:04:27 My bad, didn't realise DK got two kills. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by K. McAteer on 02/13/09 at 13:04:27 drag, if you think it's pretty obvious that I'm mafia, then you suck at analyzing. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 13:07:45 if Tom thinks I am, then he sucks at analyzing also 8-) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/13/09 at 13:14:14 Stinson shut up. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 13:17:45 That's probably a good idea, since the quiet guys don't get lynched |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 13:20:44 Only ways Scott can be alive after all these huge analysis posts: 1) He's a townie and is correct with his analyzing. He is getting protected every night by Toad. We haven't seen any kill fails yet, but I'm not sure if that goes public. 2) He's incorrect with his analyzing, so the Mafia sees him as not a threat. He is safe because they like an innocent townie leading the lynches with no risk to themselves. 3) He's Mafia. He is the ploy to take the heat off of all of the Mafia. No one suspects him, because he's posting so much analysis. The town listens to what he says, so the Mafia can just sit back and watch. This is the perfect role for one of the Mafia members. No one wants to boot him off, because he thinks for everyone else, and they believe he's good. However, he has said he's a normal mii, so everything is just an educated guess. They would rather listen to him than someone with a power role. Take from it what you want, but choose wisely. Let me know if I left out any probably scenarios of Scott's role. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 13:23:34 Thats how I analyze it also, Drag. He could be almost telling the truth if he says he's a Mii... Bowser scans as a Mii, so, technically, for intents and purposes.. Bowser is a Mii:) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 13:26:13 People who claim power roles and people who provide correct analysis against the mafia should be their main targets. There has to be a reason why they're sticking around. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Adam L on 02/13/09 at 13:31:00 Stinson and Drag are mafia. This conversation is a ploy to make people people who've claimed(like me) and people who are posting a lot(Scott) seem more suspicious when we don't die at night. So kill us Stinson, and let your plan be ruined when people see we were telling the truth about you. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/13/09 at 13:32:22 Or they are just kissing ass for fun. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 13:33:02 Adam, I didn't say I was suspicious of everyone that follows that mold. Just that we should keep a close eye on them. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 13:42:21 I just said I was suspicious why people claiming roles didn't die at night :-\ I don't see where it would hurt the mafia to kill those people. worst case scenario for them is that they kill a Mii (unless they want to sow confusion by letting them live) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 14:11:52 243221272F2E243221272F2E400 wrote:
Scott first, then Kmacc, then Oneshot. Nate I'm not sure, so wait until last for him in case you see someone better. Good luck town :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Honko on 02/13/09 at 14:13:55 Vote count update dragondragon - 6 (oneshot, Adam_L, Ivootjes, Kmacc, Sportsguy, IsThatAGoodThing) Lenny - 1 (nstinson) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (dragondragon) Not voting: Syzygy, Lenny, Howes, In Hiding With 12 players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch. The day will end in 49 hours, or when someone reaches 7 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 14:15:00 I'm too conflicted on you. You seem very innocent, and non-threatening, like the blundering professor type (kind of like myself)... and yet... and yet.... I can't help but shake that the ultimate mafia player could do what you do... so, either you're the ultimate mafioso (spending 10 hours writing profiles and then flexing your muscles by leading everyone on a goose chase) or just an ignorant townie (like myself). There's a part deep down that believes the latter, but, not strong enough to vote against you. If that makes sense:) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 14:16:04 6C56714D445164624A4A41714D4C4B42250 wrote:
so you're saying that yours is a spite vote? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 14:23:56 725D48545D526F4855524F53523C0 wrote:
Makes perfect sense. Scott's type is the most difficult to eliminate, because of how much influence he brings to the table. If he's Bowser, he'd appear like a mii too, just like he's claimed. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/13/09 at 14:35:29 What do you want me to say Scott? I think you are wrong on almost all your predictions. I voted with the group for drag because everyone jump on me if i didn't. Like everyone jumped on drag today because he wouldn't vote for Benoit last night. Unvote Vote Isthatagoodthing |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 14:38:26 Nate, now is a great time for your vote to be heard :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 14:38:57 we were? Also, Scott, I think you'd do better if you just suggested someone, and then didn't make anymore comments (you made sportsguy change because of you throwing notice to him:-p) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 14:39:39 Quote:
Why would I try to vote if I don't have a good guess? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 14:40:32 Fair enough. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 14:42:07 He's saying it makes you look suspicious, Scott. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 14:42:17 170B0C0E0210041B52630 wrote:
If I do have a power role, then we'll all be screwed. I think its even more suspicious the way you're so blatant about "I can kill you and you can't do anything about it. I will kill you, even though you're a Mii, just to satisfy my power" :) Anyways, if you've already used your two kills, then you can't kill me anyways, and this all doesn't matter |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 14:43:24 7E44635F56437670585853635F5E5950370 wrote:
you'd be better off. i.e. if you really want someone to get lynched, you shouldn't go saying stuff about people to make them spitevote you (like you did to adam l last night, and sportsguy earlier) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/13/09 at 14:44:28 Well we know he has only killed one, Ariath. That means he has one left. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 14:51:09 did he not say he got roleblocked earlier? SOmeone said he said that at least |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/13/09 at 14:53:19 If Tom is DK and killed ariath then he has 1 kill left. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 15:04:37 Etch was a profit: Code:
Ariath rarely posted = Wario. Of course, this idea takes a slight hit with fababu being a Mii, but not all non-talkers can be mafia Quote:
Etch seemed to be right on his predictions a lot. I just wish he'd thrown out more votes than just the one he made of KMacc... btw, this was one of his last posts before his death. btwbtw, what power role did tim admit to having? I don't recall this. If he claimed to have one and didn't get killed off, I guess that adds to my suspicion list;) Quote:
This too, is still true it seems:) So much for going back through the Etch post retrospective, since he didn't really say much.. he followed his own advice to the end of power roles not posting much. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 15:40:55 Scott loves leading townies to the gallows. Follow my list after my death. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Honko on 02/13/09 at 15:49:59 Vote count update dragondragon - 5 (oneshot, Adam_L, Ivootjes, Kmacc, IsThatAGoodThing) IsThatAGoodThing - 2 (dragondragon, Sportsguy) Lenny - 1 (nstinson) Not voting: Syzygy, Lenny, Howes, In Hiding With 12 players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch. The day will end in 48 hours, or when someone reaches 7 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 16:02:00 One more thing I just thought about that night Scott acted weird. What if some power roles didn't read back on the part where he retracted what he said. Did he want the potential slip that the townies would say who they were? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 16:06:26 774D6A565F4A7F7951515A6A565750593E0 wrote:
I like you how you said the two NOT on my list. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Lenny on 02/13/09 at 19:03:11 This topic may have set a record for the most replies in the shortest time. xD I've already explained myself in previous posts, Drag is suspicious, but it seems that everyone has forgotten about Howes also. Now, I'm not about to stupidly place my vote on Howes, seeing as there's next to no chance that Drag will survive today. IF Drag is town, our theory will be thrown out the window. Oneshot is still being suspicious and untrustworthy, posting wayyy less than he should be. Sportsguy, also may or may not be mafia, it's hard to say. Remember what happened in the last game, it may just be his posting style. I'm going to remain on neutral ground on him for now, and see what happens tomorrow and make a judgment then if possible. Then there's Tom. I'm not sure what to believe about him here either, I can't make a judgment on his status until tomorrow depending on who dies. In essence, what I'm trying to say is, a lot hinges on the actions of tonight. I'm voting for drag now, explained before. Vote: Drag |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by AlexPenev on 02/13/09 at 19:52:37 5976637F767944637E79647879170 wrote:
There are situations where it makes sense. Suppose a power role publicly said they'll use their power against another townie, to the deficit of the town and benefit of the mafia. The mafia may let them survive that night in hope that they screw up the townies, and the mafia then gets their free kill at night. Double win for the mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 20:08:28 Tom hadn't said he was going to kill anyone except for me now, though (that I can recall) Oneshot hasn't said who he's going to rollblock (although it doesn't really matter since wario is done) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by AlexPenev on 02/13/09 at 21:09:30 It sort of matters who Yoshi roleblocks because he might roleblock a townie power. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 21:56:41 why would he block anyone now though? Can a roleblock keep the mafia from offing someone? If not, then the mafia doesn't have any more special powers |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by nstinson on 02/13/09 at 23:17:15 ah, I thought yoshi was a roleblocker |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Honko on 02/13/09 at 23:23:58 He's a roleblocker+protector at the same time. Whoever he swallows can't do anything, and also can't have anything done to them. Kills count as night actions, so if any of the roleblockers (Baby Daisy, Yoshi, Mario once) target the mafia member doing that night's mafia kill, the kill will fail. So even with Wario dead, Yoshi could still be useful in multiple ways. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/13/09 at 23:59:43 Nope. I'm willing to die for what I believe in. It's the only way I see the momentum switching. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/14/09 at 00:06:46 People are afraid of having differing opinions from the mob. We haven't eliminated a Mafia via lynch since day 2, so the people currently leading the charge are 1) regular miis that are going off of pure deduction, but are afraid that original thinking is a sign of a mafia member taking focus off themselves 2) mafia and trying to steer us towards seemingly guility townies We have been incorrect for 3 days in a row now, and we'd be in dire straights if not for a power role kill last night. We are only behind 8-4, but with only a 4 Townie lead, that could disappear quickly. I may not be correct in my assumptions, but I know lately we haven't been effective in our lynches. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/14/09 at 00:15:47 Yeah I meant ahead. I hate not being able to edit :). I just want people to start doing their own reasoning as well, instead of being a pure follower. Mafia should be pure followers so they aren't suspicious, but Townies should be the ones doing the challenging. When we see a differing opinion, we should analyze it and not necessarily condemn then. We SHOULD be taking as much of the 3 days to vote each time, because not everyone is on the boards 24/7. We need plenty of time for debate, and make sure we're all on the same page to vote. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/14/09 at 00:22:34 Right, that's why I have Scott listed as a wildcard. He could be 1) trying to stay under the radar while still posting as a townie 2) trying to stay under the radar while still posting as a mafia I'm leaning more towards #2, which is why he's still on my list, but I'm still unsure. He's always following someone different. I'm pretty sure he's followed more people then there are Mafia remaining, but maybe someone could look that up for me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/14/09 at 00:31:03 I may think that Scott is still Mafia, but if we can have more open dialogue as a group, that will lead to more information obtained. Having multiple sources of differing info can be both bad and good. As a whole we need to extract the best information from each, and come with a general concensus as a group. If something looks wrong or is inaccurate, it needs to be brought up. We can't let ONE person lead the charge. We need individuals to step forward and discuss what's really going on, so we can make the best decision TOGETHER. Townies still outweigh the Mafia 8-4, so we're still very much in this thing. I just think we've been jumping on the lynch train too often, so people are afraid to speak up. I hope this can help us make more informed decisions. The three day timeline restricts us, because some people won't be there throughout the discussion. Most of the information should be out in the first day or two, so the final day can be for final analysis. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/14/09 at 00:41:55 I'll continually keep a close eye on Scott, but I'll put my weapon down for now, to show unhostility. People just need to step forward and say when they think an idea is BS, and we'll decide as a group if we think it is or not. The more analysis that can be provided, the better, but we need to make sure we still filter it out between multiple sources and have the best educated hypothesis of each day's situation. I don't mind keeping Scott around for the analysis, but I'm just concerned that he has all the say. We need to not let this become an autocracy. That's the danger I'm worried about the most. Unvote |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by dragondragon on 02/14/09 at 00:44:23 Townies, don't say your role. There's nothing stopping the Mafia from making up what role they are. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by In Hiding on 02/14/09 at 00:45:53 vote dragon |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/14/09 at 03:47:02 Hmm, back and is that the final vote? Is Honko sleeping? :/ W/e, I know it means nothing but Vote: Howes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Syzygy on 02/14/09 at 03:48:33 .... also, I don't think dragon is mafia -___- |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Ivootjes on 02/14/09 at 03:56:01 Seems like he's dead. Can a mod please close this topic? Oh, scott, everytime i'm asleep or away this topic gets like 4 pages. It's not my fault i'm not american ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by Lenny on 02/14/09 at 04:33:09 ^Same thing with me, except worse. xD |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 6] Post by TJazZ on 02/14/09 at 05:04:56 I'm closing this topic until robin gets here. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 6] Post by Honko on 02/14/09 at 10:31:45 Thanks Benoit. The accusations continued, and today most of them were falling on dragondragon. "Hey look, the whole top half of the player list is dead except for this guy! Let's get him!" "No, don't kill me, I'm a Mii!" "Psh, yeah right, we've killed like 13 Miis in a row, there can't be any left. Kill him!" They grabbed their handy lynch basilisk fangs and silenced him. dragondragon has been lynched. He was a Mii. Final Day 6 Vote count dragondragon - 7 (oneshot, Adam_L, Ivootjes, Kmacc, IsThatAGoodThing, Lenny, In Hiding) IsThatAGoodThing - 1 (Sportsguy) Lenny - 1 (nstinson) Not voting - Syzygy, Howes, dragondragon It is now Night 6. Send me your night actions via PM by 10:00am Pacific time tomorrow. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 6] Post by Honko on 02/15/09 at 11:48:59 For the second day in a row, the karters woke to find 2 dead bodies. What an intense game! Howes has been killed. He was a Koopa Troopa, one of the Mafia. oneshot has been killed. He was Yoshi, Town Jailkeeper. Day 7 begins now. With 9 players alive, 5 votes are needed to lynch. The deadline for the day is Wednesday at 12 noon Pacific time. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 11:56:54 Holy CRAP! Whoever is doing night kills for town is doing an amazing job. Two days in a row, they have managed to kill a mafia. OMG Damnit! The night when Drag voted for BENOIT at the last second REALLY killed us :( Guess I was right when I first put it on Howes in Day 5, LOL! Shame I didn't stop there, had to make too big of an example :( Okay so now we see Ariath and Howes were both mafia, and they were both really quiet guys. Who do you think we should go after next? I think people like IVO and SPORSTGUY might be a bit suspicious now, after seeing how those mafia had been playing. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Honko on 02/15/09 at 11:58:17 Remaining Players Adam L In Hiding (Tom) IsThatAGoodThing (Scott) Ivootjes K. McAteer Lenny nstinson Sportsguy (Tyler) Syzygy (Tim) Remaining Roles (probably not in the same order as the remaining players :P) Mario Donkey Kong Toad Baby Daisy Mii x2 --- Bowser Koopa Troopa x2 |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 11:59:10 Seems it's now 6-3, townies to mafia. We keep losing two townies each day, and one mafia. If we can finally lynch a mafia in the day, then we will be to about 5-2 which would be AWESOME. Good thing, it seems we still have one night kill left. Either Mario or DK still has the ability to kill one more person. Also, it seems whoever is doing the good nightkills for town must be a pretty good mafia player, so maybe this eliminates our suspicion on one of the "good" players who seem to know a lot about the game. I don't know what to think yet, and since everything I seem to think is wrong, maybe I'll let someone else throw the first accusations of Day 7 (LOL!) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Syzygy on 02/15/09 at 11:59:34 Fucking told you Howes was. Fags. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 12:02:13 Tim, he would've died at the end of Day 5 if it weren't for Drag doing some retarded move that got him killed. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Adam L on 02/15/09 at 12:06:04 Scott is Bowser. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 12:07:37 WTF is your deal, Adam? I am not Bowser. Why do you keep saying I am Bowser. This is pissing me off that people keep calling me Bowser. What else can I do to prove to you that I'm a lowly Mii. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/15/09 at 12:08:17 I like the quiet person theory. vote sportsguy IMO |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Syzygy on 02/15/09 at 12:14:57 Ok 9 left, 3 mafia. Here's my breakdown. Adam L - Not mafia, due to the whole Jabes incident. In Hiding (Tom) - Not mafia, he's too cool for that. If he was I'd be thoroughly pissed. IsThatAGoodThing (Scott) - Not mafia. Not entirely sure, but his strat would have been ridiculous if he is in fact mafia. Ivootjes - Suspect. I think he's mafia. In the same way I thought Ariath and Howes were, who were. K. McAteer - Undecided. Lenny - Undecided. nstinson - Undecided. Sportsguy (Tyler) - Mafia. Syzygy (Tim) - Not mafia, already said this 1000 times. Therefore it's Ivo, Tyler and Lenny/KMacc for me (don't think Stindon is cut out for mafia ;D ) Vote: Sportsguy |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Adam L on 02/15/09 at 12:48:56 Scott, there's nothing you can do to prove you're a Mii, and there's nothing I can do to prove you're not a Mii. It's frustrating. I guess the quiet person theory is smart, we've gotten two so far and they've both posted far less then they should be. Maybe the mafia as a group is doing this? I guess we should go with it until Sportsguy talks. So Mr Tyler, what's up with you? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Howes on 02/15/09 at 13:02:08 Good game, and good luck to all. [smiley=engel017.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/15/09 at 13:11:34 TRUST ME you don't want to vote for me. I have a special role in this game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 13:24:35 I think Tyler is something good. I nearly posted that before he posted there, but I really believe it. Ivo you are now on my list. Vote: Ivo Tyler, I hope saying that doesn't get you killed, then you can't do anything with your power tonight anyway |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by K. McAteer on 02/15/09 at 14:08:23 Sorry I haven't been around lately guys. Was only home yesterday in the morning, and I'm gonna be gone again tonight until tomorrow afternoon. Good job getting another mafia though, whoever is making those kills! I'm starting to agree with Scott that Ivo seems suspicious, and I already have felt Lenny was suspicious for a long time now. vote: Lenny My gut still says so. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 14:37:38 Oh! Almost forgot about the big haired Aussie noobus from IRC called Lenny. He is nice guy but sadly, mafia are mafia! I think he's more dangerous than Ivo anyway. unvote vote LENNY |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Honko on 02/15/09 at 14:42:19 Vote count update Sportsguy - 2 (nstinson, Syzygy) Lenny - 2 (Kmacc, IsThatAGoodThing) Not voting: Lenny, In Hiding, Adam_L, Ivootjes, Sportsguy With 9 players alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch. The day will end in 69 hours, or when someone reaches 5 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Adam L on 02/15/09 at 15:23:33 Tyler, you've already revealed your power role, why not claim it so we can see if anyone else will claim? Nothing like good ol' contorversy to ferret out a liar. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 15:35:00 If he's Mario or DK and has a killvote left, it is made useless by revealing his role. If he's Toad, then it would be FINE (IMO) to reveal his role, (actually better) since they won't want to attack him, they'd want to attack whoever he is not protecting. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by In Hiding on 02/15/09 at 15:49:34 ok, so i day voted the wrong person but i voted for howes as my special role kill. I've got one more vote, because i was roleblocked on my ariath kill, not sure how the fuck he was killed now.. i'll have to check the roles. either way, two out of two. I will get voted off soon, need to work out who the fuck is mafia. If you're a townie, tell me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Syzygy on 02/15/09 at 15:54:49 Hmm, if you still have a kill then Mario must have used up his. I'm still at a loss as to who has the role, but surely he would have used his scan by now so would that warrant owning up? :/ |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by In Hiding on 02/15/09 at 15:58:01 i think mario was going to save me, good he did cause i got the right mafia kill. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Ivootjes on 02/15/09 at 16:02:17 Wow, nice job guys :o I didn't suspect howes that much anymore after dragondragon was lynched. Lol, it seems like some people think i'm suspicious. :D I haven't been that quiet the last few days btw, made several posts a day. Tomorrow time for a reread. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Syzygy on 02/15/09 at 16:09:44 Ivo are you mafia? Admit it now or I'll chop off your testicles. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Ivootjes on 02/15/09 at 16:26:23 I'm not mafia. Are you mafia? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Syzygy on 02/15/09 at 16:29:03 Don't lie to me Ivo >:( |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 17:30:18 unvote Vote: TOM Tom this makes no sense. First you claimed to kill Ariath, then you admit you got roleblocked as Ariath claimed. If you are really DK why would they have killed oneshot last night instead of you? Yeah I am not buying this any longer. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by K. McAteer on 02/15/09 at 17:42:04 The thing is, nobody else has claimed to be DK besides him. There have been two night kills by the town so far, which means we have one left (Mario gets one and DK gets two). So if Dk is the one with a kill left, he should come out and say he's the real DK tomorrow at the very latest, and try and get a mafia kill tonight. Because then DK wouldn't have anymore kills, and he has no other roles so it would be like a normal townie down rather than a power role. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 17:55:54 So if Tom is NOT DK, this is his last day of being alive. I agree I guess it makes sense not to kill him now. The real DK will come forth tomorrow then. I guess it is smart of the real DK (if Tom is faking) not to come forth, as he would have been killed right away. unvote Vote: Lenny |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/15/09 at 21:10:51 Stinson's been online and not posting, looks like he's mafia with Lenny. He's just waiting for Lenny to come to computer how he usually does in an hour or so. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Adam L on 02/15/09 at 22:02:46 So someone's on the computer and not satisfying their OCD by posting every thought they have in this thread, that makes them mafia? Shit boys, I guess you should lynch me. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by In Hiding on 02/16/09 at 02:09:36 Ummm, whats confusing? Let me put it simply. I used one special power to kill Ariath. However he was blocked by someone. Someone else (one of us) also used their special power on him - completely by chance and we did get the kill on Ariath. I didn't know that it wasn't my special power that killed him as honko only told me the other night. I suppose it doesn't matter either way does it? Unless the role blocker said "block Tom's secret kill" cause either way it could've been mine or the other mii's special which killed him? (need to check the roles again). Then I just voted Howes and killed him. For some reason, because it was the other mii who killed Ariath and not me, it means i have one more kill. So who wants the chop? vote Isthatagoodthing purely because anyone who still accuses me at this stage in the game must be mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by AlexPenev on 02/16/09 at 02:28:55 1B21063A332613153D3D36063A3B3C35520 wrote:
If Tom was mafia, the mafia could spare him automatically. If he was townie, they could still easily have avoided him last night because of fear he was being protected. The town had 3 protectors! Each could have defended Tom if they believed he was useful to the town as was in danger. Whichever way, the mafia's action makes sense. Another logical explanation is that they considered oneshot to be the most dangerous role they were confident about :). Not as crazy as it sounds. IMO Yoshi was the most dangerous townie role after Mario at this point in the game. @Robin: how did you pick these roles' powers? Are they standard? I think Toad is a little underpowered and Yoshi is overpowered because Yoshi can do what Toad can do, except as many times as he wants. ;D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Lenny on 02/16/09 at 02:31:50 ^That wasn't very simple. ::) Anyway, you guys are voting me on a gut suspicion that I'm mafia, as far as I can see. At this stage in the game I suppose you would do something like this if you were mafia, but you accused me on a gut suspicion earlier. I think the mafia are keeping me in play because I'm a 'suspicious' character, in an attempt to frame you. It may sound like a 'lame' defence, but it's true. I can't really sway a 'gut feeling', so you make whatever decision you feel is right. I feel that for the town, lynching me isn't exactly the best option. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Ivootjes on 02/16/09 at 02:37:34 Tom, i don't think that you can kill another player if you've send in two nightchoices already. That is, if your story is true. Honko, can DK get 2 kills for sure or make 2 targets at night? Quote:
Lies, i don't believe that Honko actually gives you information about other peoples night choices. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Honko on 02/16/09 at 02:53:32 DK and Mario can re-use their abilities if they fail. If they are roleblocked/swallowed/whatever then it doesn't count as using their ability. If they fail, I tell them they can use it again. So in the possible scenario where DK targets someone but is blocked, and someone else kills the same person DK tried to kill, I would indeed tell DK his kill failed even though the target died. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Ivootjes on 02/16/09 at 03:15:22 Ok, thanks for the explanation. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by %hat on 02/16/09 at 03:34:48 Why are all the mafia getting killed at night? Are they just not talking to each other or something? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by In Hiding on 02/16/09 at 04:54:12 they're getting killed because they can't fool the gaff. And btw - anyone who doesn't see that honko has basically confirmed my story is a mug. I expect the vote for me to be removed :) so who is mafia.. who's left? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Syzygy on 02/16/09 at 05:09:33 Sportsguy, nstinson, Syzygy Lenny, Kmacc, IsThatAGoodThing In Hiding, Adam_L, Ivootjes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/16/09 at 05:22:15 200B0C100D620 wrote:
Ok what if DK wants to kill bowser in the night. He can't kill him, but does he get his kill back or what. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by In Hiding on 02/16/09 at 05:37:10 its stinson, i knew it all along, just taken me to tune into my hunch to be correct. unvote vote stinson |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/16/09 at 05:47:58 Yeah DK would get his kill back, it seems, Tyler. unvote Vote: Stinson Tom seems to be doing well. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 08:56:10 So the vote for me is just because I'm not post whoring like Scott?:-p Great deduction there. I'll keep my vote for now, because everyone is still just voting based on hunches |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by In Hiding on 02/16/09 at 09:18:08 My hunches have been more right than wrong so far :) stinson is mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Honko on 02/16/09 at 13:29:37 DK/Mario would get their kill back in any case where they failed to kill anyone, whether they were roleblocked, their target was protected, their target was Bowser, or any other situation, and they won't find out the specific reason why it failed. The only time they wouldn't get their kill back is if Toad protected their target. Since Toad would die instead of the target, it still counts as a kill. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Honko on 02/16/09 at 13:33:38 Vote count update Sportsguy - 2 (nstinson, Syzygy) nstinson - 2 (In Hiding, IsThatAGoodThing) Lenny - 1 (Kmacc) Not voting: Lenny, Adam_L, Ivootjes, Sportsguy With 9 players alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch. The day will end in 46 hours, or when someone reaches 5 votes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Honko on 02/16/09 at 13:46:53 @Alex: Most of the roles are standard (Yoshi is not quite a standard Jailkeeper, but it actually makes him less helpful to town the way I have him here). They don't really have to be balanced with each other. All that matters is that the two teams are balanced against each other. Even though Toad's role kind of sucks for him, since he dies doing something once that Peach or Yoshi could have done many times safely, he still has a part to play in helping his team win. There are some roles that I didn't use here that are actually bad for their team, like Miller or Beloved Princess. You just have to try to help your team as best as you can with what you've got. I got the roles from here. http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Roles After the game ends I'd like to hear from any experienced players about whether I did an OK job balancing the teams, since this is my first time hosting a game like this. :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/16/09 at 13:51:23 Okay... WHAT IN THE HECK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! TOWNIES UNITE! WHERE IS EVERYONE??? What a quiet and pitiful waste of nearly 24 hours. NO ONE is posting, what in the world has happened? Either the people left in it that were quiet are town, and don't care anymore, or the quiet ones are mafia and the town are just being quiet for some dumb reason. This doesn't make any sense. unvote Vote: Stinson Tom seems pretty smart and informed. Let's get this GOING! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 13:58:17 you already voted for me, Scott:) Also, your hunches have been wrong almost unequivocally (especially lately, with Ben and Drag) I can only say that voting for me would not be in the best interests of the team:) Tom, I believe you are DK. Can you tell us what prompted you to try to kill Ariath and Howes? Your reasoning? Also, what reasoning leads you to believe I am mafia? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 13:59:15 I only ask because Scott hasn't given any good reason to vote for me today |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Sportsguy001 on 02/16/09 at 14:29:28 Vote Stinson Tom has been right lately and if thinks stinson is mafia then he must be. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 14:33:33 and now Sportsguy, who is most likely a mafia, tries to make a vote to off me (a townie) to save his own hide. :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 14:34:47 When you guys vote me off, make sure you get Tom tomorrow. Because, if he thinks I am a mafia, then he must be a liar (unless he has some proof) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by In Hiding on 02/16/09 at 14:36:06 stinson, who are you then? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 14:50:39 I have been doing my job quietly every night (or I may very well be lying). IMO, you'd be worse off to kill me. You've tried killing quiet players before today... I just want to know why me? Did you use the same logic to nail down Ariath and Howes? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by In Hiding on 02/16/09 at 14:55:18 my logic was based on their text.. reading between the lines. Its a skill. To be completely honest, it could be you, lenny or sportguy right now.. thats my bet. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 15:00:55 I voted sportsguy, he voted me, lenny hasn't voted. What does that tell you? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/16/09 at 15:02:44 Okay, I'm easily swayed. Tom tried appealing to me in an MSN message, with "are you mafia" which I didnt' respond to. I think he knows I am easily swayed by emotional connections to people, since i seem to like you all. lol unvote vote: Howes |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 15:04:28 Quote:
|
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by K. McAteer on 02/16/09 at 15:04:57 I just skimmed through most of the topic, reading Goose's, Ariath's and Howes' posts. I looked at who they saw as suspicious and were going for a lynch at, to see if they discluded anybody. From that, there were two people who never seemed to come up at all out of their suspicions, and that was Ivo and Tyler. Right now I feel Tyler is more suspicious, and it seems I'm not the only one that feels that way. unvote vote: Sportsguy |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by K. McAteer on 02/16/09 at 15:07:28 Also something I noticed: Goose - 11 (In Hiding, Fababu, dragondragon, Jabes, karterfreak, nstinson, Extol, Ivootjes, Sportsguy001, Ariath, Howes) On the lynch for Goose, the last two voters were Ariath and Howes, both mafia. So as you can see, they were jumping on the bandwagon late in order to not look very suspicious. Right before them are Ivo and Tyler, who could very well be doing the same thing. Also I noticed that on Day 3 with Extol's lynching, none of those four voted to lynch him at all, because they saw that the town was self-destructing on extol and saw they wouldn't have to do anything for the lynch to go through. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Syzygy on 02/16/09 at 15:13:57 I covered that point already, why do you think I think Ivo and Tyler are mafia? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 15:14:24 That's very good detective work, KMacc! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/16/09 at 15:15:08 Good work, Kmacc. I have thought those two for about 2 days now (real life days). I was obv joking voting for Howes there unvote Vote: Ivo Ivo is more dangerous and more suspicious than sportsguy, however. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by K. McAteer on 02/16/09 at 15:16:32 Sorr Tim, must have missed when you covered it lol. But yeah then I completely agree with you from what I've inspected. I'm pretty close to saying that those two are definite mafias. Can't pick out the last one though. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 15:19:27 so, most agree that ivo and sportsguy are mafia, and some people add in me. Any specifics on who we think Bowser may be? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Adam L on 02/16/09 at 15:19:43 Scott, you're starting to fall off a bit in my books. Ivo being more dangerous and suspicious then Tyler? That's borderline retarded. Now we know guys, if Tyler is mafia, which I'm starting to get the feeling he is, Scott is as well. Let's get down to the bottom of this. vote: Sportsguy |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Adam L on 02/16/09 at 15:20:25 Nate, Scott is Bowser. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by K. McAteer on 02/16/09 at 15:20:50 I don't know, I don't know if there's any reasoning that could used to differentiate the roles of each mafia member. You can just figure out if they're mafia basically, which is enough. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by K. McAteer on 02/16/09 at 15:22:44 Well I understand where Scott comes from in saying that Ivo could be more dangerous because I'm pretty sure he's an experienced mafia player. But suspicion wise, I feel Tyler is more suspicious. That could also be because if Ivo is more dangerous, he would have an easier time swaying our votes, making him not as suspicious of him. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Adam L on 02/16/09 at 15:25:22 Scott played the Bowser role perfectly. He only turns up as a townie(which he claimed, saying he was a Mii) and can't get killed at night. The townie's only hope is to lynch him during the day, and as long as Scott keeps active and keeps putting out "valuable information", the townies won't lynch him. Not for long though Scott, not for long. Think about it, as long as he's active and throwing the finger of suspicion around without drawing too much attention to himself, he's safe. Think about who he's started the lynch kills on, damned near everyone lately. None of them have turned out to be mafia, why are we so lenient? He's pretty much instigated at least three lynchings for random townies and gotten them all killed. This needs to stop, and we need to stop listening to Scott until we find out he isn't Bowser. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 15:26:21 me and drag both thought so also... but I haven't voted him, because I know that I wouldn't be able to get enough votes... yet |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by K. McAteer on 02/16/09 at 15:35:13 I see what you mean Adam. He could very well be psyching us out completely, but for now I feel we should go for the ones who seem like they are nearly definite mafias, which is how I personally feel Ivo and Tyler are. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by nstinson on 02/16/09 at 15:37:12 agreed. Let's get scott last:D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/16/09 at 15:57:27 Get that fuck. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/16/09 at 15:59:32 If you get me last it'll be a sad day to see a Mii go :) That is funny that you think I'm Bowser. Why do you keep bringing up the scanning bit? Do you realize our scanner Etch died after making only 2 scans (I think).....and Mario only gets one scan all time. I doubt anyone has even scanned me lol! So haha. But okay I will vote Tyler since you all seem so set on it. But one particular post of his made me think he was MARIO. If he turns out Mario, I will tan your hides! unvote Vote: Tyler |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/16/09 at 16:01:06 Btw, that is the killing vote on Tyler. If he is town you will all be sad, and don't come after me, lol! But if he is mafia we will be happy! I think you need to realize that you should not be following someone who has never played mafia before kartforums! Why in the world would you be doing that. Don't blame it on me that you followed my incorrect guesses! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 7] Post by Ivootjes on 02/16/09 at 16:01:31 So now i'm suspicious because i voted mafia out at L-3? o_0 Am i also suspicious because i was a part of other lynches? And yeah, i do agree that today was a wasted day, haven't been online all day. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 7] Post by Honko on 02/16/09 at 18:24:39 With only 9 people left, things were getting intense. So when the karters started suspecting Sportsguy, they decided to be extra sure he was the right guy to kill. They used their special goodguy scanning machine to check out what he could be. "It says he's a Mii." "AWESOME, LET'S KILL HIM!" "No no, we're supposed to kill mafia. Miis are good guys." "No, that's stupid. Just look at the past 5 days. Obviously we're supposed to lynch Miis." "Oh, good point." They grabbed their handy lynch potato guns and popped some taters in Sportsguy's ass. But when he was dead, they realized their scanning machine had been wrong. "What's that big ugly dinosaur thing? That doesn't look like a Mii." "Dammit, we killed Bowser. Now our Mii streak is ruined." Sportsguy has been lynched. He was Bowser, Mafia Godfather. Final Day 7 Vote Count Sportsguy - 5 (nstinson, Syzygy, Kmacc, Adam_L, IsThatAGoodThing) nstinson - 2 (In Hiding, Sportsguy) Not voting - Lenny, Ivootjes It is now Night 7. Send me your night actions via PM by 6:00pm Pacific time tomorrow. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Night 7] Post by Honko on 02/17/09 at 14:30:02 In case you're wondering what's up, I accidentally started the day early without getting all the night actions. For some reason when I woke up I thought I was really late opening the day, so I did it quickly without checking everything. Day 8 will start at 6:00pm Pacific (3.5 hours). |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Honko on 02/17/09 at 18:06:34 OK, this time for real. The karters awoke to find yet another bad man dead. Lenny has been killed. He was a Koopa Troopa, one of the Mafia. But this time, there was no innocent body to go with it. No good guys died last night. What could it mean? Day 8 begins now. With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch. The deadline for the day is Friday at 6:00pm Pacific time. There is 1 mafia left. If he is lynched today, Town wins. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Adam L on 02/17/09 at 18:07:14 I roleblocked Ivo last night. Did anyone else roleblock someone? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Ivootjes on 02/17/09 at 18:08:41 Well, i don't have an ability so roleblocking me doesn't make a lot of sense ::) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Adam L on 02/17/09 at 18:09:57 Roleblock explains the lack of a mafia kill. If noone else roleblocked, you look guilty as all hell. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Ivootjes on 02/17/09 at 18:11:35 Might be a mafia trick? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/17/09 at 18:12:38 Yeah, roleblocking me would be dumb too. Why didn't mafia kill? Probably because it's someone who isn't paying attention? *checks who hasn't posted lately* Btw raise your hand as to what role you have right now. There is only one person of each role, and whatever role has doubles is the mafia one, in 2 kills we'd kill the real one and the fake one, and it's over. There should be no problems at this point winning. I am a Mii |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Adam L on 02/17/09 at 18:12:44 Which is why I said you look guilty as all hell, not definitely mafia. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Ivootjes on 02/17/09 at 18:14:17 I'm a mii, and there are 2 mii's btw. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Ivootjes on 02/17/09 at 18:15:02 oh wait, there aren't Vote Ivo GG town. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/17/09 at 18:16:12 vote: Ivo GG, mates...had Ivo pinned as a mafia FOR EVER! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Adam L on 02/17/09 at 18:16:55 I'm Baby Daisy, and I think I've said that enough so that noone will forget it. Make your claim people. The only other option, besides Ivo being mafia or mafia not making a kill last night, would be Mario roleblocking someone. Come out and say it Mario, it's safe. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Adam L on 02/17/09 at 18:17:38 Finally. vote: Ivo |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Ivootjes on 02/17/09 at 18:20:39 Oh wait, there were 2 mii's. Well, doesn't matter as adam would have roleblocked me again tonight even if i could have talked me out of this. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Ivootjes on 02/17/09 at 18:25:43 And another reason why i couldn't win this anymore: 4 townies plus 3 mii's (i could only claim mii this day) would work out like this kill one mii, kill one special role 3-2, kill one mii kill one special role 2-1 last day and i would have gotten lynched. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Honko on 02/17/09 at 18:27:17 Vote: Ivootjes Pwned! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Ivootjes on 02/17/09 at 18:28:57 [22:14] <Ivootjes>wtf, why did you give only 16 hours? [22:15] <Honko>16? [22:15] <Ivootjes>according to the forum clock [22:18] <Honko>hmmmmmm [22:18] <Ivootjes>tyler was killed 11.59 pm [22:18] <Honko>v_v [22:18] <Honko>fuck [22:18] <Ivootjes>this screws up my game to get me out of this shit as adam blocked me [22:18] <Honko>i was looking at night 6 [22:19] <Honko>i woke up and thought the deadline was already passed [22:19] <Ivootjes>now they'll now i'm mafia for sure -_- (though they probably would have gotten me out of this anyway) [22:19] <Ivootjes>otherwise tom would have died btw [22:19] <Ivootjes>mafia kill > toms kill or do they both go at the same time? [22:19] <Honko>lol i just ruined my game >_< [22:19] <Honko>they both go [22:20] <Honko>so lenny and tom would be both dead [22:20] <Ivootjes>i do have proof that i told lenny to make the kill :P [22:20] <Honko>and that the target was tom? [22:20] <Ivootjes>yup [22:21] <Honko>ok........ [22:21] <Honko>what do you recommend i do thats fair [22:21] <Honko>relock topic and wait till real deadline? [22:21] <Ivootjes>well, lenny was supposed to make the kill, i already knew i was going to get roleblocked :P [22:22] <Ivootjes>so i say tom still dies anyway [22:23] <Honko>ok, i'm going to relock it and say i started day too early [22:23] <Ivootjes>if you dont do that and i send it in and adam roleblocks me than they'll know i'm mafia anyway [22:24] <Ivootjes>not that it matters that much cause i can't kill adam anymore in this game as he'll roleblock me tomorrow xD [22:24] <Ivootjes>basicly we've lost the game :P [22:26] <Ivootjes>meh, i should lenny kill adam instead now, way more strategic xD [22:34] <Honko>show me the proof of you telling lenny to kill [22:38] <Ivootjes>how [22:38] <Ivootjes>screenshot? [22:40] <Ivootjes>btw, i thought that mafia kill > dk kill so this obviously changes our strategy xD [22:42] <Ivootjes>not that it matters that much, we've lost anyway :P [22:44] <Ivootjes>http://img516.imageshack.us/img516/7121/mafiabx0.png [23:55] <Honko>make sure lenny sends that kill in the next 3 hours [02:13] <Honko>.... [02:24] <Ivootjes>he hasn't been online :( [02:59] <Ivootjes>damnit lenny -_- [03:03] <Honko>lol [03:03] <Honko>oh well [03:05] <Ivootjes>meh, i give up, it's impossible to win this now |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Honko on 02/17/09 at 18:46:55 Ivootjes has been lynched. He was a Koopa Troopa, the last of the ancient race of evil killers known as "Mafia." Town wins! The end. Final Player List Clark - Mii - Modkilled Day 1 EnigmaticCam - Mii - Killed Night 1 Goose - Koopa Troopa - Lynched Day 2 SuperYoshi - Mii - Killed Night 2 Extol - Mii - Lynched Day 3 Etch - Luigi - Killed Night 3 Brutus - Mii - Lynched Day 4 karterfreak - Peach - Killed Night 4 TJazZ - Mii - Lynched Day 5 Fababu - Mii - Killed Night 5 Ariath - Wario - Killed Night 5 dragondragon - Mii - Lynched Day 6 oneshot - Yoshi - Killed Night 6 Howes - Koopa Troopa - Killed Night 6 Sportsguy - Bowser - Lynched Day 7 Lenny - Koopa Troopa - Killed Night 7 Ivootjes - Koopa Troopa - Lynched Day 8 In Hiding - Donkey Kong - Survived to finish IsThatAGoodThing - Mii - Survived to finish Jabes/Adam - Baby Daisy - Survived to finish Kmacc - Mii - Survived to finish Stinson - Toad - Survived to finish Syzygy - Mario - Survived to finish |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Honko on 02/17/09 at 18:49:08 Here were all the night actions. NIGHT 1 Syzygy (Mario) does nothing. Etch (Luigi) scans TJazZ (Mii). karterfreak (Peach) protects Scott (Mii). oneshot (Yoshi) swallows Scott (Mii). Tom (Donkey Kong) kills Goose (Koopa Troopa). Fails - Tom is roleblocked by Joe. Stinson (Toad) does nothing. Joe (Baby Daisy) roleblocks Tom (Donkey Kong). Ariath (Wario) roleblocks SuperYoshi (Mii). Ivootjes (Koopa Troopa) kills EnigmaticCam (Mii). NIGHT 2 Syzygy (Mario) does nothing. Etch (Luigi) scans karterfreak (Peach). karterfreak (Peach) protects Brutus (Mii). oneshot (Yoshi) swallows Brutus (Mii). Tom (Donkey Kong) does nothing. Stinson (Toad) protects dragondragon (Mii). Joe (Baby Daisy) roleblocks TJazZ (Mii). Ariath (Wario) roleblocks Fababu (Mii). Ariath (Wario) kills SuperYoshi (Mii). NIGHT 3 Syzygy (Mario) scans Kmacc (Mii). Fails - Syzygy is roleblocked by Ariath. Etch (Luigi) scans Scott (Mii). karterfreak (Peach) protects Tom (Donkey Kong). oneshot (Yoshi) swallows Tom (Donkey Kong). Tom (Donkey Kong) does nothing. Stinson (Toad) protects Scott (Mii). Joe (Baby Daisy) roleblocks Brutus (Mii). Ariath (Wario) roleblocks Syzygy (Mario). Ariath (Wario) kills Etch (Luigi). NIGHT 4 Syzygy (Mario) kills Joe (Baby Daisy). Fails - Syzygy is roleblocked by Ariath. karterfreak (Peach) protects Scott (Mii). oneshot (Yoshi) swallows Joe (Baby Daisy). Tom (Donkey Kong) does nothing. Stinson (Toad) does nothing. Joe (Baby Daisy) roleblocks Syzygy (Mario). Fails - Joe is swallowed by Oneshot. Ariath (Wario) roleblocks Syzygy (Mario). Ariath (Wario) kills karterfreak (Peach). NIGHT 5 Syzygy (Mario) kills Ariath (Wario). oneshot (Yoshi) swallows Adam (Baby Daisy). Tom (Donkey Kong) kills Ariath (Wario). Fails - Tom is roleblocked by Ariath. Stinson (Toad) protects Tom (Donkey Kong). Adam (Baby Daisy) roleblocks dragondragon (Mii). Fails - Adam is swallowed by Oneshot. Ariath (Wario) roleblocks Tom (Donkey Kong). Ariath (Wario) kills Fababu (Mii). NIGHT 6 Syzygy (Mario) scans Scott (Mii). Fails - Scott is swallowed by Oneshot. oneshot (Yoshi) swallows Scott (Mii). Tom (Donkey Kong) kills Howes (Koopa Troopa). Stinson (Toad) protects Tom (Donkey Kong). Adam (Baby Daisy) roleblocks Scott (Mii). Lenny (Koopa Troopa) kills oneshot (Yoshi). NIGHT 7 Syzygy (Mario) scans Lenny (Koopa Troopa). Tom (Donkey Kong) kills Lenny (Koopa Troopa). Stinson (Toad) protects Kmacc (Mii). Adam (Baby Daisy) roleblocks Ivootjes (Koopa Troopa). Mafia does nothing. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Extol on 02/17/09 at 18:51:29 nice job town [smiley=thumbsup.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Day 8] Post by Ivootjes on 02/17/09 at 18:52:57 I'd like to thank Honko for the game anyway as his mistake didn't matter in the end. :D It was a pretty cool and exciting game. I would have done less special roles in the game myself or i would have made it a closed set up. I think both town and mafia have made their share in mistakes but in the end Tom was the deciding factor for town to win this game. We all (the mafia) though that he would be killing mii's at night but he didn't. Tim also did pretty good as mario i guess. As for hosting another game, i won't be hosting nor will i be playing in a game in the next two weeks, as i'll be going on holidays. :) I hope that someone else is willing to step it up and host an interesting game, if not then i'll host when i'm back. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/17/09 at 19:04:20 Tom is totally the man, and our savior...he only targeted mafias, FFS! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Extol on 02/17/09 at 19:10:12 id like to play another game, i dont really know enough or am as acquainted with the game to host one yet, but i think someone should :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Honko on 02/17/09 at 19:13:21 I'll host another in a month or two. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Howes on 02/17/09 at 19:28:21 Excellent game, Robin. I especially liked the storyline... best part of the game 8-) Reflections: I really should have been dead after day 2, I completely messed up voting for Goose. Being mafia is hard! I have no idea, besides dumb luck, as to how I survived days 5 and 6 either. My longest post was supposed to be me giving up, but it turned into another two days of not being dead :-? Good job to the townies for finally figuring the mafia out, and good game to all. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Jabes on 02/17/09 at 20:18:46 The truth came ALIGHT (ariath, lenny, ivootjes, goose, howes, tyler). When i left the game i talked with matt about who i strongly thought was mafia, and the only one i got right was tyler. Funny thing about that was that i spent all day a couple saturdays ago arguing with scott on the board and i could see that tyler was watching nearly the whole time, so i knew he was pretty suspicious. I got fed up and left the game when i saw that people would frequently watch the boards but would never post. It was fun and id definitely play again whenever it comes up! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by karterfreak on 02/17/09 at 20:22:18 Lawl @ Oneshot protecting the same person I did 3 times in a row. And yeah, the truth was to come ALIGHT eventually, me and Joe both knew it ;) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by nstinson on 02/17/09 at 20:23:21 Someone needs to host another asap:) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/17/09 at 20:38:06 You guys need to get in for some IRC mafia. The night we DID play it was amazing, and it only takes THIRTY MINUTES or less. In 30 minutes, we could do two games probably. It's really amazing and fast paced and fun. All of you who are interested, let's do it! Robin is still up for (i'm pretty sure) hosting these IRC bashes, and we could do it at a lot of different times of the day/night. Some people would post when they're available, and we could get a group set up. I think 7, 9, 11, 13 ppl would be good sizes. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by K. McAteer on 02/17/09 at 21:06:22 Good job townies! We pwned them. ;D I am quite happy with my performance, especially since I had no powers, meaning I had to rely on reading stuff and instincts to figure things out. Good job especially to Tom getting those kills was extremely important and you were clutch. Well I guess I played rather well for my first mafia game. :) AND I knew Lenny would be mafia ffs! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Lenny on 02/17/09 at 21:21:09 lol gg guys, I think I played ok. I'm sorry Ivo, as I mentioned before, my time zone is completely out of whack when compared with everyone else's, such that when night ended I was at school. xD I'd be happy to host if anyone wants, I know some good roles [smiley=happy.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/17/09 at 22:37:07 Btw me and Joe talked about this. Mafia was super lucky to get 3 people who are unknown to the majority of the group (kart specific players who don't post in general a ton): Ariath, Howes, Tyler. Mafia was ALSO lucky to get Ivo and Lenny who are really good at mafia lol. And Mafia got Goose who was new here so no one knew what to think about him haha! And after reviewing the ENTIRE topic, we came to the conclusion that Ivo and Lenny played really solid games as mafia, but it was apparent they were mafia when their games were too solid haha! And Ariath/Howes/Tyler were just too quiet to be legit! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Fababu on 02/17/09 at 22:58:29 Wow, excellent game town. I thought we will lose when we started killing Mii's; but Tom has made an awesome work as DK. At least I'm happy knowing that 1/3 of my list was correct. I wait with expectation the start of a new game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by AlexPenev on 02/17/09 at 23:27:09 1E312438313E0324393E233F3E500 wrote:
Nooo, too much forum traffic ::) Maybe we should first discuss the roles used in this mafia game, and which roles you would like to be used in the next mafia game. I think a good time to wait before starting the next game would be 2+ weeks. Toad - I think he should be upgraded a little. Perhaps give him 2 lives and allow him to protect 2 people per night (if he loses 1 of those lifes, then he can only protect 1 person). Yoshi - I think he should be downgraded a little. He has only a small downside, but 2x the chance of preventing a townie death at night compared to any other role. Maybe he should not be allowed to swallow the same player twice. The rest were fairly balanced. Both teams had a roleblocker and the 3:1 ratio of super roles was close to the 17:6 ratio of mafia/town. The mafia wiki had some funny roles that would make the next game great. A nice role for the mafia would be a Wobuffett with Destiny Bond who takes you down with him if you kill him. Hmm, yes, make the next mafia revolve around pokemon :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/17/09 at 23:31:39 *Agrees with the above poster* I'm so shot from playing this and trying to think through everything. I think we need to give those of us (seems to be maybe half) who are new to mafia some time to sort through the facts of this game, and realize more about the game. Maybe we could keep this going as a monthly deal, like starting a new game on the first of each month or something, from now on. Moderation is okay here haha! But I was talking to someone who will admit it if he likes to, and we decided that there should probably be a rule after what happened in this game. People who sign up and aren't going to play should not be allowed to play again, as this hurts the town so badly it's not possible for them to compete. Maybe not letting the bottom 5 posters from this topic play in the next game, or the most USELESS 5 posters, or maybe there's no good way to do it, but people need to PARTICIPATE more, there was a huge problem of this at one point in the game. I think it would be much more fun if everyone participated. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Honko on 02/18/09 at 00:15:52 @Penev: I was actually thinking next time I do one I would probably make it Pokemon themed. There aren't many things I know more about than Mario Kart and Pokemon ::) You should play next time. @Scott: I don't like the idea of picking out a specific number of people to be banned from the next game or whatever. On the other hand, next time I host there are certain people who I may pass over even if they sign up, but that should be left up to the host, not some constant arbitrary rule of mafia activeness. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Jabes on 02/18/09 at 02:13:04 Well, i think its pretty obvious who youre talking about, scott, as i cited that as my reason for exiting the game. I agree with you to an extent, because i dont feel as though they should be banned per se, but given a penalty during the game. I dont know what would be a good penalty, but to literally watch people viewing the board but not posting made my blood boil. I had a great time this round through and have learned so much from this single game. I even got to know other people from the board that i normally wouldnt have talked to, so that in itself was worth the experience. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by In Hiding on 02/18/09 at 02:22:31 How about compulsory voting? If someone ends up not voting then they are modkilled? You could include/exclude no lynching. I must say, this was the most fun I've had in ages. Only my 2nd game but I think i'm getting the hang of this. Townie is more fun than mafia :) I really want to reveal my tactics and strats but I think its in my interest to keep them to myself so I can stay an effective player. I think I did ok.. some people here are very good at this though. I can't say I was 100% about some of the townies! lol I would really like to play again soon. I dont want to play in IRC because I prefer the slower pace of the game. I was lying when I said I might re-read the whole topic etc.. I was lying because trust me, I would be very suprised if anyone else re-read from start to finish everyones posts more than me :) hehe. Maybe we could set another game up after a weeks break? Also its worth noting that I have watched every episode of Columbo ever 8-) [edit] - A huge thank you to Honko who set this up and managed it - legend :) [smiley=beer.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Syzygy on 02/18/09 at 02:44:38 Thanks Honko for such a fun game x] We won convincingly in the end, lucky we had a few good players :3 Scott, looking back, you were almost totally useless :P Mario for the win. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Darius on 02/18/09 at 02:50:44 I've been watching this and it's been very entertaining so I'd love to play next time around. I've never played before but I think I've picked up a few things from watching. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by TJazZ on 02/18/09 at 02:57:13 I sent this message to Honko the same night I was lynched. Quote:
Pretty close! :D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Lenny on 02/18/09 at 03:41:10 http://www.epicmafia.com/instruction/characters There, some awesome roles, convert them to pokemon however you like Robin. :) I recommend these roles: Insane Cop - nice twist on cop Tracker - nice way to know what's going on Watcher - same as above Miller - screws with people's minds a bit Bulletproof - useful Fool - PUT THIS IN IT'LL STOP PEOPLE MAKING USELESS LYNCHES Granny - LOL UNSTOPPABLE Amnesiac - pretty nice, can choose to join the mafia or town There also a lot more roles, but these are some of my favourites. There also a lot of good mafia roles, I recommend choosing some as well to balance it out. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Jabes on 02/18/09 at 03:42:33 Probably should have spoken up about your suspicions, because you nailed em! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Syzygy on 02/18/09 at 03:42:39 Brutus had the idea of "Yellow and black bomb" where when you die you can comeback and blow someone up [smiley=lolk.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Ariath on 02/18/09 at 03:51:04 Nice job town! Many are saying to me that they suspected me because I was too quiet, but I don't come to the boards that often, so I only posted when I came on. I wouldn't be quiet just to stay low, because that would be stupid xD |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by SuperYoshi1 on 02/18/09 at 04:39:15 Quote:
ROFL ! [smiley=roll.gif] Btw I know I wasn't too active in this game, cos I was in busy in school and each time I came to the computer, it was night... furthermore I got killed early so couldn't post my opinions and even vote :3 (I wanted to vote Kmacc on day 2 since he was too quiet ::)) Dunno if I'll play the next one, but I would like though... I will be more aggressive [smiley=evil.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Syzygy on 02/18/09 at 04:48:44 Joe was annoying me which is why I went for him. Lucky I was roleblocked. I cracked it after the Ariath lynch, then it was obvious who was mafia. The scan on Scott was just precautionary because he was annoying me [smiley=lolk.gif] |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Jabes on 02/18/09 at 04:52:33 Yes, kill the people who advance the game the most. Makes perfect sense. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Syzygy on 02/18/09 at 04:57:47 You advanced the game how exactly? [smiley=lolk.gif] Quitter. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Jabes on 02/18/09 at 05:04:02 I quit because it was only Scott and me posting for an entire day. How much fun is it when 23 people sign up and 8 people participate? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by In Hiding on 02/18/09 at 06:27:14 I got more out of that day with just you two posting at eachother than I did from almost all of the other days. Purely because it was just you two and what you both said. If people want to keep quiet then fine but thats sus in my mind. The time difference does play a part in some people not being able to post/talk as much as others. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Extol on 02/18/09 at 07:10:18 i like the idea of IRC mafia personally, everyone should go to the irc so we can get a game set up, we need several people who want to play, and with the number of people that visit the forum it shouldnt be that hard to get enough people in irc for a game. If nothing else, it could hold people who like playing over until the next forum game is made :) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by oneshotbillyII on 02/18/09 at 07:11:44 Good game, good game. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by In Hiding on 02/18/09 at 07:26:41 I carried your ass billy boy! yeah! yeah!!! YEAH!!! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by AlexPenev on 02/18/09 at 08:01:07 I don't think we should introduce too many new roles, otherwise it will be confusing. It's probably better to keep most existing roles and introduce only a couple of new ones. I like the idea of Masons. Masons are townies who can talk to each other at night (like mafia) and they have the benefit of knowing that they're townies. They recruit others into becoming Masons as the game goes on. There are a few twists to apply to them. One is that if they accidentally recruit a mafia, then all Masons die. Another is that if they accidentally recruit a townie power role, that townie becomes a regular townie Mason and loses their power. Quote:
Townie = Weedle Mafia = Pidgey Doctor = Chansey Bodyguard = Machoke Cop = Growlithe Insane/Naive/Paranoid Cop = Psyduck Tracker/Watcher = Gengar/Kecleon Vigilante = Vigoroth Town Drunk = Spinda Miller = Voltorb Bulletproof = Geodude Bomb = Wobbuffet Paranoid Gun Owner = Blastoise Hunter = Haunter Masons = Digletts Jailer = Lickitung Fool = Bidoof Amnesiac = Slowpoke Yakuza = Hariyama Godfather = Slaking/Snorlax Hooker = Smoochum Most of the other roles won't work well for us. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Honko on 02/18/09 at 08:24:11 lol bidoof |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Ivootjes on 02/18/09 at 08:29:22 I personally like to see a game with a closed set up, where the roles are only known to the mod. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by nstinson on 02/18/09 at 08:44:17 Quote:
Agreed, being Toad wasn't too great:D Also, the Mafia really pwned itself when Ariath role blocked Syzygy. Lastly, it seems that the "quiet people are mafia" strategy was golden, except for Goose:) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by In Hiding on 02/18/09 at 09:05:51 stinson, btw, i knew you weren't mafia but it was a ploy to avoid being killed off for putting to much heat onto the real mafia. Had votes started going your way i'd have removed mine and defended you. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by nstinson on 02/18/09 at 09:21:44 I kind of got that feeling, thanks:) I also wasn't *too* suspicious of you. I just had to say something to get the heat off myself. I did protect you that night, though:) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Adam L on 02/18/09 at 09:42:18 Undefeated in forum Mafia 8-) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Honko on 02/18/09 at 11:56:51 1A253C3C27393620530 wrote:
Yeah, my next one will be like this, so I'm not gonna post which Pokemon I think should have which role because that will be secret ;) And as I said earlier in the topic, I don't think the roles need to all be balanced with each other. If you want to think like that, then all the Miis were pretty underpowered :P IMO all that matters is that when the powers are all added up, the two sides have a pretty even chance of winning. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Ariath on 02/18/09 at 11:57:56 lol, even if I hadn't role blocked tim on night 4, joe still wouldn't have been killed xD Quote: oneshot (Yoshi) swallows Joe (Baby Daisy). Joe was swallowed anyway, so he wouldn't have died :p |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/18/09 at 14:07:54 7A4C5F5951506178514C5D5B3E0 wrote:
0-1 in MK IRC mafia 8-) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Etch on 02/18/09 at 14:52:28 I thought town was going to lose at the rate it was going, good to see you guys pull off the win. After all that bullshit, Benoit got lynched. [smiley=lolk.gif] gg |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by AlexPenev on 02/18/09 at 15:40:13 Benoit got tied for a lynch. He lynched himself! @Ivo: how does closed mafia work? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Honko on 02/18/09 at 16:35:46 I think Closed means you don't know the roles that are in the game. It changes how you look at night actions (you don't know what kind of killing or blocking roles there are) and claims people make (mafia has to be more creative, and townies have to be convincing), and it allows some more interesting roles too. If people know there's an insane cop in the game, they know to be careful trusting scans, and if they know there's a bomb they'll be scared to cast the final vote, so those roles don't work well in open games. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by dragondragon on 02/18/09 at 17:00:19 *takes notes* don't trust scans don't be last lyncher Ok, I'm all set Robin! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by AlexPenev on 02/18/09 at 17:04:26 If the roles are secret, is it then better to play with roles that can reveal others' roles? For insane, nobody except the Mod knows he's insane. It's his job to figure out he's getting dodgy scans. Bomb does sound better as a secret role if it explodes during a lynch, but it could be useful for both mafia and town. I think mafia should get some extra roles next time because they only had a roleblock this game. What do you think of a mafia protector that can cast Mirror Coat? |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Honko on 02/18/09 at 18:03:57 Quote:
They can work, but that could easily be overpowered. I think Detective does this, but it reveals 3 options of what the role could be, because knowing for sure a person's role is a very powerful thing. For some reason I'm acting like I know what I'm talking about even though I've only played like 3 games. ;D I haven't seen a game with a Mafia Protector, but it could be interesting. I wouldn't want to give away what roles I might use though! :P Everyone's a Jester! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Ivootjes on 02/18/09 at 18:07:48 Closed game is more fun as you actually have to think about what roles there are in the game and wether to trust roleclaims. In an open game it's easy to roleclaim some strong town role and get protected by the doc. In this case mafia members can't counterroleclaim or they'll be lynched the day this happens or the next day. If the claimed townie is lynched first and the mafia member after that it's not that bad, (just a fair trade, one cop for one mafiosi) but if the mafia member gets lynched first In this game Etch could have openclaimed cop first day. with such a big amount of protectors (toad, mario, daisy) he could have easily made 4 or 5 searches at night without any risk, (just tell them to protect you, day 1->toad, day2 ->daisy, etc.) while mafia were trying to shoot them all. This results in a follow-the-cop mentality. (meh, i just realize that we had a mafia roleblocker, but there are other examples when an open set up is fucked, look at how i got lamed out of the game as remaining mafia member, i had 0% chance thanks to the open set up) But in a closed game, a cop claim can mean anything. Has he been trustworthy? Are there role blockers? Are there doctors? Is there a cop at all? Is he the only cop? etc. In the end i think that open setup is good to learn the basics, see how this stuff works out in practice, but after that it's more fun/balanced to use a closed set up. If the mod actually balances it out good enough. Edit: Jesters suck in a closed set up btw, way too easy to get yourself lynched when none knows that there's actually a jester. Though i've seen games with some great teamwork between town and mafia to kill the jester at night :D Edit2: post 777 ;D Let's go the casino Edit3: shit, i'm not allowed to edit my posts! :o |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by AlexPenev on 02/18/09 at 18:42:02 Quote:
That way the Vigilante or Jack-of-trades need to be careful about who they nightkill, because a certain mafia might try to act mafia-like to attract their attention, but he is really poison bait. In our game Tom could kill anyone and the downside (killing a townie) wasn't so bad for him (he was already expected to kill a townie; the mafia let him alive for that reason) Also, I don't think we should have any roles that win "for themselves", like Jester and Serial Killer. It sounds more interesting for a whole team to win, not for one person. PS. I initially read your jester smallprint as "everyone's a Jailer". Tempting! |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Etch on 02/18/09 at 20:35:19 Make everyone town or mafia. That would be amusing to see play out. ;D |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Lenny on 02/18/09 at 21:43:01 Everyone being town is better than everyone being maf because maf know who each other are. ::) Anyway, I don't like the idea of a closed game. If Robin starts a closed game, I'll start an open game. [smiley=lolk.gif] I know what I'm doing anyway, It'll be fine. 8-) |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Honko on 02/18/09 at 21:50:44 I'm not doing mine for a while. If you want to host one, I'll wait till you're done. Having two games running at once would probably be a bad idea. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by IsThatAGoodThing on 02/18/09 at 21:55:49 Definitely give us at LEAST 7 days break from now...maybe more. |
|
Title: Re: Mario Kart X Mafia! [Town Wins] Post by Lenny on 02/18/09 at 22:11:55 ^Yeah sure, it'll give me time to think of a good setup. [smiley=evil.gif] Actually, I'll start a new sign up topic now so that I can get a general idea of how many people are going to play. :) |
|
Mario Kart MB » Powered by YaBB 2.2! YaBB © 2000-2007. All Rights Reserved. |